Potential Role of Bioactive Compounds: In Vitro Evaluation of the Antioxidant and Antimicrobial Activity of Fermented Milk Thistle

: The group of innovative ingredients in cosmetic preparations includes bio-ferments (Bs), which are characterized by high bioactivity and biocompatibility, and one of the plants rich in bioactive compounds that has a beneficial effect on the skin and the body is Silybum marianum . Bio-ferments obtained from this plant are becoming increasingly useful as active ingredients in cosmetics. In the present study, four different bio-ferments were obtained by fermentation of pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle. Their biodegradability (%B), total polyphenols content (Folin–Ciocalteu method), and antimicrobial, antioxidant (DPPH, ABTS, and FRAP methods), chelating (Fe 2+ ions), and reduction (Cu 2+ and Fe 3+ ions) properties, as well as the acidity, were evaluated. The contact angle using the sessile drop method was assessed to investigate bio-ferments’ impact on skin wettability. Finally, the content of selected phenolic acids in the Bs was evaluated using the HPLC method, while the lactic acid (LA) content was assessed using the GC-MS method. All bio-ferments were characterized by high polyphenols content (13.56 ± 0.10–15.28 ± 0.12 mmol GA/L B), chelating (0.08 ± 0.01–0.17 ± 0.01 mmol Fe 2+ /L B) and antioxidant activity (DPPH method, 2.41 ± 0.01–3.53 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L B), and reducing Cu 2+ and Fe 3+ ions. Gallic acid, protocate-chuic acid, caffeic acid, neochlorogenic acid, coumaric acid, and LA were identified in Bs. The most increased antibacterial activity for B-P was observed for a strain of Staphylococcus aureus (MIC = 250 µ L/mL) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (MIC = 250 µ L/mL). Simultaneously, B-S demonstrated the highest inhibitory effects against Escherichia coli (MIC = 125 µ L/mL), emphasizing the varied antimicrobial profiles of these bio-ferments against different bacterial strains. Research on aerobic biodegradation demonstrated a high level of degradation (%B = 60 ± 1–65 ± 3), and all Bs were categorized as readily degradable according to the OECD classification.


Introduction
The skin, the largest organ in the human body, acts as a protective barrier against external threats and is essential during vitamin D production.The skin consists of three layers: the epidermis, the dermis, and the deepest subcutaneous tissue.The outermost layer of the epidermis is the Stratum corneum (SC).The SC contains intercellular cement, which includes, among other things, ceramides, cholesterol, fatty acids, cholesterol ester, and trace amounts of phospholipids [1].Natural moisturizing factors (NMFs) found in the skin are chemical compounds that increase the skin's ability to retain moisture.The absence of NMFs or abnormalities in their composition is directly linked to dry skin [2].Lactic acid (LA) is a metabolite produced by milk fermentation bacteria.The primary raw material lactic acid bacteria use is carbohydrates, or more specifically, sugars made up of six-carbon residues (glucose or sucrose) [3].The most desirable in industrial production are the enantiomers L(+) of lactic acid, which are produced mainly by the homofermentative lactic fermentation bacteria of the genus Lactobacillus.The characteristic effect of LA is to acidify the environment because a low pH inhibits the development of undesirable microflora in food and cosmetic products [4][5][6].In addition to lactic acid, the metabolic products of Gram-positive lactic fermentation bacteria are bacteriocins, which are hydrolyzed by enzymes in the digestive tract into easily digestible and harmless amino acids [7].The main producers of bacteriocins on an industrial scale are bacteria of the genera Lactobacillus, Lactococcus, and Leuconostoc [8].
Silymarin (Silybum marianum), a non-toxic complex extracted from seeds and fruits from milk thistles, significantly protects against harmful UV radiation by inhibiting radical chain reactions [9].One of the leading causes of premature skin aging is oxidative stress [10].It is caused by, among other things, prolonged skin exposure to UV radiation, where the skin is exposed to the harmful effects of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [11].This ultimately leads to tissue degeneration, inflammation, and cancerous changes.It is widely believed that oxidative stress is closely linked to many diseases that occur in old age (e.g., Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, hypertension, and diabetes) [12,13].
Bio-ferments are innovative cosmetic raw materials obtained mainly from plant raw materials through a fermentation process involving appropriate strains of bacteria [14].The applications of bio-ferments include their antioxidant and antimicrobial properties, and anti-ageing, hydrating, and anti-allergic effects.The wide spectrum of biological properties makes bio-ferments an innovative cosmetic raw material with great biocompatibility [2,[14][15][16].The fermentation process increases the bioactivity of fermented plant materials by breaking down or converting unwanted substrates into compatible products.Fermentation significantly increases the content of phenols and anthocyanins, resulting in fermented products with stronger antioxidant activity compared to non-fermented plants [17].Bacteria and fungi have great potential to produce antioxidants through the enzymatic hydrolysis of phenolic glycosides to free polyphenols [18].Fermented plant extracts are obtained by the fermentation of plant raw materials in the presence of appropriate microorganisms (mainly bacteria and fungi).Microorganisms decompose plant components contained in plant materials, increasing the biological activity of the substrate by converting high-molecular compounds into low-molecular structures, resulting in increased compatibility of fermented raw materials compared to non-fermented raw materials [18].The structural breakdown of the cell walls of plant raw materials and the hydrolysis activity of microorganisms during the fermentation carried out affect the increase in the content of polyphenols, flavonoids, organic acids, proteins, ceramides, amino acids, biological enzymes, and antioxidants in the fermentation medium [19].As a result, the product obtained after the fermentation of plant raw materials shows increased biological efficacy and bioavailability with reduced cytotoxicity [18].Fermentation of plant extracts (blueberry fruit in the presence of the lactic acid bacteria Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus fermentum and black tea with kombucha) confirms the presence of phenolic compounds in the fermentation medium [20].The fermentation medium with kombucha yerba mate extract showed that polyphenols such as chlorogenic acid and caffeoyl derivatives, as well as flavonoids and xanthine, may indicate the biological potential of the fermented plant extract for dermatological applications [21].Polyphenolic compounds have gained attention due to their possible beneficial implications for human health, such as the treat-ment and prevention of cancer, cardiovascular disease, mental deterioration associated with aging, and neurodegeneration [18,22].The fermented plant extract obtained from Magnolia denudata flowers in the presence of Pediococcus acidilactici KCCM 11614 had higher anticancer activity than the unfermented plant extract against human gastric adenocarcinoma (AGS) cells and human colon cancer (LoVo) cells [23].Plant extracts obtained by fermentation of Rhus verniciflua bark exhibited anticancer activity against the colon cancer cell line HCT-116 and showed the ability to induce apoptosis and inhibit the hedgehog pathway [24].Dual fermentation of Ophiopogon japonicas extract against Cordyceps militaris, Bifidobacterium longum, Lactobacillus plantarum, and Enterococcus faecium yielded a fermented extract that can prevent cardiovascular disease associated with vascular smooth muscle cell (VSMC) proliferation and migration [25].Moreover, the fermented plant extract obtained from ginseng in the presence of Aspergillus usamii showed higher anticancer activity against human hepatoma cells (HepG2) and the human colon cancer cell line (DLD-1) compared to the unfermented ginseng extract [22,26].
In our previous study, the extract and bio-ferment were obtained from ground and defatted seeds of spotted thistle Silybum marianum.Their antioxidant activity was evaluated using DPPH, ABTS, and FRAP techniques, while total polyphenol content was measured using the Folin-Ciocalteu method.High antioxidant activity was found for both the extract (0.91 mmol Trolox/L ± 0.2) and the bio-ferment (1.19 mmol Trolox/L ± 0.2), which was evaluated by the DPPH technique.The resulting cosmetic raw materials were incorporated into hydrogel (H) and organogel (O) vehicles to obtain cosmetic formulations with antioxidant activity.We then evaluated the in vitro permeation through porcine skin of the main components contained in the obtained cosmetic raw materials, such as silibinin and taxifolin, which are part of the silymarin complex.For comparison, we also used pure silymarin (S).Of the formulations tested, H-S showed the most significant penetration of taxifolin, with a cumulative permeation of 87.739 ± 7.457 µg/cm 2 .Finally, biodegradation tests of prepared formulations containing cosmetic raw materials and silymarin were also conducted.Tests on the effect of cosmetic formulations on aerobic biodegradation showed a good level of degradation of the prepared formulations, some of which (O-B and O-S) were classified as readily degradable (OECD) [14].
For this article, we focused on identifying polyphenolic compounds and lactic acid contained in the obtained bio-ferments.Phenolic acids, as antioxidants, can mitigate the harmful effects of UV radiation and oxidative stress [27].These compounds can act as antioxidants by scavenging free radicals and inhibiting the production of reactive oxygen species.In addition, they participate in many metabolic processes and pathways in the body [28].As a result, they are increasingly used in cosmetic preparations with photoprotective and anti-aging effects.While there are a few current studies of the antioxidant activity of bio-ferments in the literature, most of them only concentrate on the analysis of compounds contained in fermented plant raw materials.This study offers a comprehensive analysis of the active compounds in bio-ferments, which may be achieved through the fermentation of seeds, extract, oil, and pomace (waste after oil pressing).It emphasizes the added advantage of a circular economy.This also affects technical and environmental factors, such as lowering carbon footprints, using plant biomass wastes, and developing new raw material extraction technologies.

Materials
The research plant material consisting of milk thistle seeds was purchased from Slodkie Zdrowie (Bialystok, Poland).
All reagents were of analytical grade.

Extract Preparation
The extraction of milk thistle was carried out using an ultrasonic method.First, 22.5 g of spotted thistle seeds were introduced into a conical flask, and then 300 mL of distilled water was added.After that, the extraction was carried out with the use of an ultrasound bath at a frequency of 40 kHz (for 1 h at 60 • C), and then the extract (E) obtained was subjected to filtration on a pressure funnel through a Whatman paper filter (codified EEA03).The obtained extract was used to prepare bio-ferment (B-E) and was a substitute for distilled water.

Oil Preparation
A Camry Premium Oil Press Cr 4001 (Adler Europe Group, München, Germany) was used to obtain oil from the milk thistle seeds.The oil was centrifuged in a centrifuge (5 min, 166 Hz, 10,000× g).The obtained oil was used to prepare bio-ferment (B-O).Moreover, the residue (pomace) was also used to prepare bio-ferment (W-O).

Preparations of Bio-Ferment
Four new bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) were derived from milk thistle by fermentation of 22.5 g of pomace (P), extract (E), 22.5 g of cold-pressed oil (O), and 22.5 g of seeds (S).In our research, as a raw material for lactic acid production, we used molasses, a sugar industry waste product.The total content of 6-carbon sugars (Brix) in the certified molasses was determined using a refractometer method (KRUSS Optronic DR301-95, A. Kruss Optronic GmbH).The fermentation of milk thistle pomace (P), extract (E), coldpressed oil (O), and seeds (S) was carried out using 7 individual strains of lactic acid bacteria: 1. L. reuteri MI_0168, 2. L. salivarius LY_0652, 3. L. brevis LY_1120, 4. L. acidophilus MI-0078, 5. L. rhamnosus MI-0272, 6. L. plantarum MI-0102, and 7. L. rhamnosus LY-0457.In addition, fermentation of spotted thistle P, E, O, and S was also carried out using a mixture of the listed lactic acid bacterial strains.The preparation of the inoculum (in the amount of 10 mL) was performed by a previously used procedure [14].The following raw materials were introduced into a 500 mL conical flask: molasses (in the amount of 18.00 g), distilled water (in the amount of 300.00 g), mineral salts such as (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 (in the amount of 2 g), CaCl 2 (in the amount of 1 g), and KH 2 PO 4 (in the amount of 1 g), the P, O, and S of milk thistle (in the amount of 22.5 g), and inoculum (in the amount of 10 mL).When fermentation of E was carried out (to obtain bio-ferment B-E), the previously obtained extract (according to the procedure described in Section 2.2 "Extract Preparation") was used as a substitute for distilled water.The contents of the flask were agitated until the raw ingredients added were wholly dissolved; subsequently, the fermentation process commenced (at a temperature of 37.5 • C) for an appropriate time.During the fermentation process, daily samples were collected and examined for lactic acid content (whose concentration was determined by GC-MS) and polyphenols (whose levels were determined by the spectrophotometric method using the Folin-Ciocalteu technique).The fermentation was carried out until the maximum level of lactic acid was reached.
Finally, fermentations were completed on the 14th day, and two independent experiments were performed.After the process was completed, lipase was added to hydrolyze the bacterial cell walls.The obtained bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) were subjected to 3-stage filtration: 1. initially, the bio-ferment underwent filtration using a glass funnel; 2. subsequently, the bio-ferment underwent centrifugation using a centrifuge (5 min, 166 Hz, 10,000× g); and 3. ultimately, the bio-ferment that had undergone extra filtration and centrifugation was further filtered using sterile syringe filters with a pore size of 0.45 µm (intended for sterilizing filtration of aqueous solutions).In this way, the bio-ferments were free of microorganisms.The amount of bio-ferments obtained and filtered was approximately 100-110 mL.The bio-ferments were kept in a freezer at a temperature of −15 • C (Figure S1).

Antimicrobial Activity
The bio-ferments were tested against Staphylococcus aureus ATCC6538, Escherichia coli ATCC25922, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC27853 using a modified broth microdilution method based on the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) guidelines [31].Two-fold dilutions in Mueller-Hinton broth (MHB, Sigma-Aldrich, Darmstadt, Germany) were prepared, starting with a well containing 200 µL of the tested bio-ferment.Next, 2-fold dilutions of the starting solution were prepared in MHB.The final concentration of bacterial cells was 10 6 CFU/mL.All tests were carried out in triplicate.The results, expressed in µL/mL, were determined using known densities of the bio-ferments.The Folin-Ciocalteu modified method was employed to determine the total polyphenols content of bio-ferments [32].These studies used the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 instrument (Waltham, MA, USA) at the wavelength λ = 750 nm.Gallic acid (GA) was used as a reference substance.
The total polyphenol content of the bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was quantified in the following manner: 2000 µL of Folin-Ciocalteu reagent, 100 µL of bio-ferment, and 1000 µL of aqueous Na 2 CO 3 (saturated solution) were introduced into volumetric 10 mL flasks.The contents of the flasks were made up to the mark with distilled water, the flasks were closed tightly with a stopper, and they were incubated at an ambient temperature for 15 min, after which the absorbance of the test solutions was measured using a spectrophotometer at a wavelength of λ = 750 nm.Blank samples of the absent bio-ferment were prepared in the same way, using distilled water in an amount of 100 µL.Three independent experiments were performed.TPC was expressed as mg GA/L of the bio-ferment, based on the resulting calibration curve of gallic acid y = 0.0075x, R 2 = 0.997, with concentration range 0-100 mg GA.

DPPH Method
The DPPH technique was employed to assess the antioxidant capability of the acquired bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) [32].These studies were conducted using the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 instrument at the wavelength λ = 517 nm.Trolox (Tx) was used as a reference substance.
The antioxidant activity of the obtained bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was measured as follows: 2850 µL ethanolic solution of the DPPH radical (concentration of 0.3 mmol/L), with absorbance about 1.000 ± 0.020 (at λ = 517 nm), was placed in the tube, and 150 µL of bio-ferment was added.Blank samples without bio-ferment were prepared the same way, using distilled water (150 µL).The tubes were enveloped in aluminum foil, sealed with a stopper, and then incubated for 10 min at ambient temperature.Three independent experiments were performed.The antioxidant activity was expressed in mmol Tx/L bio-ferment, based on the obtained calibration curve y = −1.2463x+ 1.0546, R 2 = 0.999, with concentration range 0-20 mmol Tx.

ABTS Method
The ABTS technique assessed the antioxidant capability of the bio-ferments obtained (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) [32].These studies were conducted using the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 instrument at the wavelength λ = 734 nm.Trolox (Tx) was used as a reference substance.
The antioxidant activity of the bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was determined using the following method: 2500 µL solution of the ABTS (absorbance about 1.000 ± 0.020 at λ = 734 nm) was placed in the tube, and 25 µL of bio-ferment was added.Blank samples without bio-ferment were prepared the same way, using distilled water (25 µL).The tubes were enveloped in aluminum foil and sealed with a stopper, followed by incubation at room temperature for 6 min.Three independent experiments were performed.The antioxidant activity was expressed as mmol Tx/L of bio-ferment based on the resulting calibration curve y = −1.2718x+ 0.9924, R 2 = 0.999, with concentration range 0-50 mmol Tx.

FRAP Method
The FRAP technique assessed the antioxidant activity of the bio-ferments obtained (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) [33].These studies used the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 instrument at the wavelength λ = 593 nm.Iron II sulfate VI (FeSO 4 ) was used as a reference substance.
To prepare the reagent, 25 mL of sodium acetate buffer (3 M solution, pH = 3.6) was mixed with 2500 µL of 2,4,6-tripyridyl-s-triazine solution (0.01 M solution TPTZ) in HCl (0.04 M solution HCl) and with 2500 µL of iron (III) chloride (0.02 M solution).The antioxidant activity of the bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was measured in the following manner: 2900 µL solution of the TPTZ, with absorbance about 1.000 ± 0.020 at λ = 593 nm, was placed in the tube, and 100 µL of bio-ferment was added.Blank samples without bio-ferment were prepared in the same way, using distilled water in an amount of 100 µL.The tubes were enveloped in aluminum foil and sealed with a stopper; thereafter, they were subjected to incubation for 15 min at ambient temperature.Three independent experiments were performed.The antioxidant activity was expressed as mmol FeSO 4 /L of bio-ferment, based on the resulting calibration curve y = 0.6747x + 0.0218, R 2 = 0.998, with concentration range 0-50 mmol FeSO 4 .

Reducing Fe 3+
First, a calibration curve of Fe 2+ ions was prepared using aqueous VI iron II sulfate (FeSO 4 ) solutions.For this purpose, the following were introduced into 100 mL volumetric flasks: appropriate amounts of FeSO 4 (so that the resulting concentrations of Fe 2+ ions were in the range of 0.5 to 5 mg/L) and 1 mg of ascorbic acid, in order to reduce any Fe 3+ ions present in the test sample.The contents of the flasks were filled with distilled water to the mark, and the flasks were closed tightly with a stopper and stirred to obtain homogeneous solutions.
In the next stage of the test, 1000 µL of aqueous FeSO 4 solution with ascorbic acid and 1000 µL of aqueous ferrozine solution (with a concentration of 1 g/L) were introduced into glass test tubes.The tubes were closed tightly with a stopper and incubated at room temperature for 10 min.Then, the absorbance of the test solutions was measured using a spectrophotometer at a wavelength of λ = 562 nm.Spectrophotometric analyses were carried out in triplicate using a Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 instrument, obtaining a calibration curve for Fe 2+ ions (y = 0.4888x + 0.0064; R 2 = 0.999), with concentration range 0-100 mmol Fe 3+ .
Assessment of the ability to reduce iron III ions to iron II by the ferrozine method was carried out as follows: 1000 µL of aqueous FeCl 3 solution (with a Fe 3+ concentration of 0.5 g/L), 1 µL of bio-ferment, and 1000 µL of aqueous ferrozine solution (with a concentration of 1 g/L) were introduced into glass tubes.The tubes were closed tightly with a stopper and incubated at room temperature for 10 min, and then the absorbance of the test solutions (λ = 562 nm) was measured using a spectrophotometer.First, the instrument was zeroed using 1000 µL of aqueous FeCl 3 solution, 1 µL of distilled water, and 1000 µL of aqueous ferrozine solution as a reference.
The ability to reduce Fe 3+ to Fe 2+ was calculated according to the following formula: where The ability to reduce copper II ions was evaluated according to the method described by Roman et al. [34].The analyses were performed on the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 apparatus at the wavelength λ = 450 nm.The ability to reduce copper II ions was measured as follows: 1000 µL of 0.01 M aqueous CuCl 2 solution, 1000 µL of 7.5 mM neocuproine solution in 96% ethanol, 1000 µL of 1 M acetate buffer (pH 7), 600 µL of distilled water, and 500 µL of the corresponding bio-ferment were introduced into a test tube.The tubes were wrapped in aluminum foil, sealed with a stopper, and incubated for 30 min at room temperature, and then the absorbance was measured at 450 nm.Blank samples without bio-ferment were prepared the same way, using distilled water (500 µL).Three independent experiments were performed.The result was expressed as mmol Tx/L of bio-ferment, based on the resulting calibration curve y = 0.30961x + 1.2004, R 2 = 0.996.

Chelating Activity Fe 2+
The chelating ability for Fe 2+ was assessed using a ferrozine technique [35].The metal ion chelation process significantly prevents reactive oxygen species formation [36].A calibration curve was prepared by utilizing aqueous solutions of FeSO 4 to measure Fe 2+ ions.First, an initial FeSO 4 solution with a Fe 2+ concentration of 0.53 mmol/L was prepared.Next, a ferrozine initial solution (concentration of 3.2 mmol/L) was prepared.Then, 1000 µL of the initial FeSO 4 solution (final Fe concentrations of 3, 1.2, 0.6, and 0.3 mg/L) and 1000 µL of ferrozine were introduced into 10, 25, 50, and 100 mL volumetric flasks.The flasks were filled with distilled water, sealed snugly with a stopper, and then kept at room temperature for 10 min.The absorbance of the test solutions was measured (using the Thermo Scientific GENESYS 50 apparatus at the wavelength λ = 562 nm), obtaining a calibration curve for Fe 2+ ions y = 0.4888x + 0.0064, R 2 = 0.999.
In the next stage, 1000 µL of the initial FeSO 4 solution, 100 µL of bio-ferment, and 1000 µL of ferrozine were introduced into 10 mL volumetric flasks.The flasks were filled with distilled water, sealed snugly with a stopper, and incubated at room temperature for 10 min.Then, the absorbance of the solutions was measured using a spectrophotometer at a wavelength of λ = 562 nm.Three separate tests were conducted.
The assessment of the chelating activity for Fe 2+ ions was computed using the following formula: where: ChA-chelating activity for Fe 2+  Acidity testing [14] of appropriate bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was carried out by titration with a standard sodium hydroxide solution and phenolphthalein as an indicator.In a ground conical flask, 10 mL of distilled water, 2 mL of the corresponding bioferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S), and 3 drops of an ethanolic solution of phenolphthalein were introduced.The flask was closed with a stopper, and its contents were mixed and then titrated with NaOH solution until the solution turned slightly pink.Blank analyses were performed in parallel.
The acidity (A) of the tested bio-ferments was determined as the number of sodium hydroxides that are required to neutralize the test sample with the equivalent of carboxyl groups according to the following equation:

HPLC Analysis
The concentration of gallic acid, protocatechuic acid, caffeic acid, neochlorogenic acid, and coumaric acid in the bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) was determined by highperformance liquid chromatography (HPLC-UV) using the HPLC system from Knauer, Berlin, Germany.The tested components were separated on a 125 mm × 4 mm C18 column containing Eurospher 100, particle size 5 µm.The mobile phase consisted of 1% acetic acid and MeOH (93:7 by vol.), flow rate was 1 mL/min, and 20 µL of the sample was injected into the column.Individual peaks were identified based on reference substances.

GC-MS Analysis
The gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis was performed using a Shimadzu GCMS-QP2020 NX with a Shimadzu SH-I-5MS column (30 m × 0.25 mm × 0.25 µm) (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan).The column temperature was kept at 40 • C for 2 min and programmed to 280 • C at a rate of 15 • C/min.The flow rate of helium as a carrier gas was 35 cm/s (1 µL/min).MS was performed at 70 eV, using split 10.The total analysis time was 17 min, while the sample volume was 1 µL.Identification of lactic acid which formed during the fermentation process was made by comparison of mass spectra located in the spectra library (NIST2020) with the LA benchmark used.Lactic acid concentration in bio-ferments was calculated based on the obtained calibration curve: C LA = (1.518× S LA + 1568)/S O (including concentration range of lactic acid 0-350 mmol LA), R 2 = 0.9971, using the internal standard method (octane), where A-slope, B-intercept, C LA -lactic acid concentration [%], and S LA and S O -lactic acid and octane peak areas.All samples were analyzed three times.Results are presented as the mean ± standard deviation (SD).

Wettability
To study the effect of bio-ferments (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) on wettability, the Drop Shape Analyzer, Kruss 165 DSA100 (Filderstadt, Germany), was used.One drop of bioferment (4 µL) was placed on the STRAT-M ® membrane (Sigma-Aldrich, Darmstadt, Germany) (which is a substitute for human skin) [37].The contact angle using the sessile drop method was measured using DSA4 software.The contact angle analysis was performed 5 s after placing the drop on the membrane.Measurements were made on the surface of the membrane (with a layer thickness of 320 µm) from ten different places, and the results were averaged (c.a.av. ).

Biodegradation Studies
Analysis of the bio-ferments' biodegradation was performed following a previously used procedure based on the general method for determining aerobic biodegradation potential in a mineral medium by carbon dioxide production as recommended by the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development).Moreover, the experimental conditions used (carbon content and inoculum volume) were chosen according to the OECD guidelines.The samples of active sludge were taken from the aeration chamber of the Pomorzany sewage treatment plant in Szczecin, Poland.A microbiological test (Schulke Mikrocount Duo) was used to measure the concentration of active sludge suspensions to calculate the total number of microorganisms (CFU/1 mL of active sludge).A microbiological test containing medium and TTC agar with Tergitol-7 was submerged in active sludge for 10 s.The number of bacteria was determined by comparing the test's appearance to that of a standard test after 96 h at room temperature (Figure S2) [26].
The system for measuring CO 2 produced by microorganisms during the 28-day process was described in the last study [14]-Figure S3.The only sources of carbon and energy were bio-ferments ( B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S Two tests were conducted independently (in two measuring vessels).The amount of produced CO 2 was determined using a total organic carbon analysis (TOC-LCSH/CSN, Shimadzu Corporation, Kyoto, Japan).Utilizing the calibration curve y = 4.1187x + 7.1718, R 2 = 0.999, the inorganic carbon (IC) content in the test specimens was determined.The biodegradation degree of the test bio-ferments was determined according to the following formula [14]: where: %B-degree of biodegradation; C IC -concentration of inorganic carbon in the test vessel 1.4, obtained by TOC analysis of the test sample corrected by blank (mg/L); R-dilution of the sample collected from the test vessel 1.4 (2.5); V 0 -initial volume of NaOH solution in the test vessel 1.4 (0.25 L); i-sample number; V p -volume of sample taken from the test vessel 1.4 (0.01 L); m-mass of test bio-ferment injected into the test vessel 1.3 (mg); U-the proportion of carbon in the test bio-ferment introduced into the test vessel 1.3 (-).

Statistical Analysis
The statistical computations were performed using the Statistica 13 PL software (Stat-Soft, Kraków, Poland).The ultimate data are shown as the average standard deviation (±SD).A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed.The Tukey's test (with a significance level of α < 0.05) was employed to assess the significance of variations across distinct groups in the findings obtained from the biodegradation experiments and antioxidant activity investigations.

Antimicrobial Activity
The quantitative results, expressed as minimum inhibitory concentrations, are detailed in Table 1, which presents the results for the antimicrobial activity of bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle.The bio-ferments B-P and B-S exhibited the most robust antimicrobial properties, consistently demonstrating effectiveness across all tested strains.In contrast, the B-E and B-O bio-ferments did not display significant antimicrobial activity-Table 1.

Antioxidant Activity and Total Polyphenols Content
Table 2 presents the results for the antioxidant activity and total polyphenols content of bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle.
Table 2 shows the antioxidant activity (DPPH, ABTS, and FRAP methods) and total polyphenols content (the Folin-Ciocalteu method) of the bio-ferments.The highest degree of DPPH radical scavenging was shown by the bio-ferment from pomace (B-P) of milk thistle at 3.21 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L.The DPPH radical scavenging rate of bioferments from extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle was, respectively, 3.01 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L, 3.53 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L, and 2.41 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L.The test results, presented in Table 2, show that all bio-ferments were characterized by antioxidant activity as evaluated with ABTS and FRAP.The bio-ferment from pomace (B-P) showed the highest antioxidant activity: 22.43 ± 2.01 mmol Tx/L (ABTS method) and 16.68 ± 2.50 mmol FeSO 4 /L (FRAP method).The other bio-ferments (B-E, B-O, and B-S) had lower activity as assessed by ABTS and FRAP techniques.At the same time, the total polyphenol content assessed by the Folin-Ciocalteu method for all the bio-ferments tested was high, amounting to 2546.69 ± 0.09 mg GA/L (for B-P), 2439.52 ± 0.11 mg GA/L (for B-E), 2599.43 ± 0.12 mg GA/L (for B-O), and 2306.82 ± 0.10 mg GA/L (for B-S)-Tables 2 and S1.Mean ± SD (n = 3); a,b,c,d -different letters: values differ significantly between the analyzed bio-ferments.
Table 3 shows the results of chelating Fe 2+ and the reducing activity for Cu 2+ (CUPRAC method) and Fe 3+ , as well as the acidity of bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle.Mean ± SD (n = 3); a,b,c,d -values differ significantly between the analyzed bio-ferments.

Chelating and Reducing Activity, and Acidity
Chelating activity tests in the ferrozine assay showed that the bio-ferment from pomace (B-P) had the highest ability to chelate Fe 2+ ions (0.17 ± 0.01 mmol Fe 2+ /L).For the other bioferments, a slightly lower ability to chelate iron ions was observed.In addition, the reduction ability of copper II ions and iron III ions by the bio-ferments can be ranked as follows: B-P (12.82 ± 0.18 mmol Tx/L and 40.02 ± 0.19 mmol Fe 3+ /L) > B-E (10.35 ± 0.16 mmol Tx/L and 27.39 ± 0.23 mmol Fe 3+ /L) > B-O (11.12 ± 0.37 mmol Tx/L and 31.67 ± 0.17 mmol Fe 3+ /L) > B-S (7.94 ± 0.32 mmol Tx/L and 25.57 ± 0.21 mmol Fe 3+ /L).On the other hand, the acidity of the tested bio-ferments was 360 ± 5 mmol COOH/L (in the case of B-P), 410 ± 5 mmol COOH/L (in the case of B-E), 310 ± 5 mmol COOH/L (in the case of B-O), and 420 ± 5 mmol COOH/L (in the case of B-S)-Table 3.

HPLC Analysis
Table 4 shows the content of selected phenolic acids in the analyzed bio-ferments; Figure S4 shows an example chromatogram of a bio-ferment.Mean (±standard deviation) (n = 3); a,b,c -indicate significant differences between the tested bio-ferments; α = 0.05; n.d.-not detected.
The bio-ferment from pomace (B-P) of milk thistle had the highest significant content of phenolic acids.This bio-ferment contained the highest amounts of gallic acid (44.25 ± 3.29 mg/L) and caffeic acid (41.42 ± 2.81 mg/L).The bio-ferment from seeds (B-S) was also characterized by a high gallic acid content (34.26 ± 2.01 mg/L), which differed significantly from the B-E and B-O bio-ferments.However, the contents of caffeic acid in the cases of B-E, B-O, and B-S were at comparable levels and ranged from 15.98 ± 0.83 mg/L for B-S to 23.29 ± 1.34 mg/L for B-O.The contents of protocatechuic and of neochlorogenic acids were also statistically higher in B-P and amounted to 16.44 ± 2.46 mg/L and 7.12 ± 1.25 mg/L, respectively.It was also observed that B-O does not contain coumaric acid, while all other bio-ferments contain it in amounts ranging from 7.15 ± 0.20 mg/L for B-E to 10.97 ± 0.62 mg/L for B-P (Table 4 and Table S2).

Elemental Analysis
Before starting the biodegradation experiments, the organic carbon (C) content was confirmed through elemental analysis.The results for the carbon content of the tested bioferments B-P, B-E, B-O, B-S, and reference compound were, respectively, 48.02%, 49.86%,

Elemental Analysis
Before starting the biodegradation experiments, the organic carbon (C) content was confirmed through elemental analysis.The results for the carbon content of the tested bio-ferments B-P, B-E, B-O, B-S, and reference compound were, respectively, 48.02%, 49.86%, 47.32%, 50.24%, and 49.09%.

Biodegradation Studies
Table 5 shows the biodegradation of the tested bio-ferments B-P, B-E, B-O, B-S, and SDS by bacterial cultures.* Mean ± SD (n = 6)-for each bio-ferment, two independent experiments were performed, during each of which the collected samples were analyzed three times.** Categories: "•"-Readily biodegradable, degree of biodegradation: ≥60%.
After 28 days, the highest percentages of biodegradation were 60% ± 1 (B-O), 61% ± 2 (B-P), 62% ± 3 (B-E), 65% ± 3 (B-S), and 85% ± 3 (sodium dodecyl sulfate), which classify these bio-ferments and the reference compound as readily degradable.This suggests that bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle containing lactic acid as a product of the main fermentation process are readily biodegradable [38].The biodegradable LA in these cosmetic preparations likely enhances their susceptibility to microbial degradation.The presence of lactic acid in bio-ferments may make them more appealing to the biodegrading microorganisms, leading to higher degradation rates-Table 5 [39].
The half-life of the bio-ferments' degradation by bacterial cultures is shown in Table 6.The half-life of the bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle was 23 days.Furthermore, SDS was characterized by a half-life of 13 days-Table 6.
The phases of degradation of the bio-ferments are shown in Table 7.The bio-ferments from pomace (B-P) and SDS reached 10% degradation after 2 days, and the bio-ferment from seeds (B-S) reached 10% degradation after 4 days, while B-E and B-O took longer than 4 days (5 days), which may be related to the adaptation of microorganisms during the lag phase [29].The degradation phase of B-P, B-E, and B-N-E is 26 days.In contrast, for B-O and SDS, the degradation phase is the shortest (22 and 24 days)-Table 7.

Discussion
Recently, there has been a growing interest in exploring safe cosmetic raw materials with antioxidant, anti-aging, and antimicrobial properties.All the bio-ferments obtained from milk thistle showed antimicrobial activity against Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.Among the bio-ferments, B-P exhibits the most potent antimicrobial properties, with minimum inhibitory concentrations of 250 µL/mL, 125 µL/mL, and 250 µL/mL against Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, respectively.B-S follows closely with concentrations of 250 µL/mL, 125 µL/mL,

Discussion
Recently, there has been a growing interest in exploring safe cosmetic raw materials with antioxidant, anti-aging, and antimicrobial properties.All the bio-ferments obtained from milk thistle showed antimicrobial activity against Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.Among the bio-ferments, B-P exhibits the most potent antimicrobial properties, with minimum inhibitory concentrations of 250 µL/mL, 125 µL/mL, and 250 µL/mL against Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, respectively.B-S follows closely with concentrations of 250 µL/mL, 125 µL/mL, and 500 µL/mL against those respective strains.Notably, B-P also demonstrates the highest inhibitory effects against Escherichia coli.In contrast, B-E and B-O show comparatively lower antimicrobial activity, with concentrations of 500 µL/mL and 750 µL/mL (against Staphylococcus aureus), 750 µL/mL and 750 µL/mL (against Escherichia coli), and 750 µL/mL and 750 µL/mL (against Pseudomonas aeruginosa)-Table 1.
Plants are widely used to treat microbial infections.Recently, it has been discovered that plant extracts containing phenolic compounds have the ability to enhance the antibacterial effect of certain antibiotics, reverse antimicrobial resistance, and have a synergistic effect when combined with commonly used chemotherapeutics [40,41].The antimicrobial potential of extracts obtained from many medicinal plant species has made it possible to evaluate their antimicrobial activity by determining the IC 50 parameter [42].However, the IC 50 parameter is not the optimal relevance parameter, and most of the reported data are the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) values.Therefore, the antimicrobial activity of the tested extracts was set at the following levels: significant (MIC < 100 µg/mL), moderate (100 < MIC ≤ 625 µg/mL), or weak (MIC > 625 µg/mL) [42].
The mechanisms of action of phenolic compounds contained in plant extracts on the bacterial cell have been attributed in part to damage to the bacterial membrane, inhibition of virulence factors (such as enzymes and toxins), and inhibition of bacterial biofilm formation [43,44].Numerous reports in the literature have shown that polyphenolic compounds isolated from plants, in combination with commonly used antibiotics, may represent a new strategy against infections caused by multidrug-resistant bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, or Pseudomonas aeruginosa) [44][45][46].
An important aspect of the antibacterial properties of phenolic acids isolated from plant extracts is their interaction with antibiotics [47].Studying the antibacterial activity of protocatechuic acid ethyl ester (EDHB) and caffeic acid (CA) alone and in antibioticphenolic combination against reference and clinical strains of Staphylococcus aureus, it was shown that EDHB exhibited antimicrobial activity against clinical strains of S. aureus (MIC = 64-1024 µg/mL), while CA activity against S. aureus isolates ranged from MIC = 256 µg/mL to MIC = 1024 µg/mL.However, the interaction of caffeic acid with antibiotics (erythromycin, clindamycin, and cefoxitin) increased the antibacterial activity of the antibiotic-phenol combination [44,48].
The initial caffeic acid has been shown to exhibit antimicrobial activity against methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus (MSSA) and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) strains, and the mechanism of CA action is related to cell membrane damage and changes in the oxygen metabolism of S. aureus cells [49].This polyphenolic compound is characterized by strong nucleophilic properties, which enable it to donate electron pairs to electrophilic functional groups of proteins and lipids in the cell membrane, leading to dysfunction of this membrane and inhibiting α-hemolysin secretion by S. aureus.Studies of the antimicrobial activity of CA, EDHB, and catechin hydrate (CH) showed that caffeic acid exhibited stronger antitumor activity than EDHB and CH and a greater synergistic effect with antibiotics than the compounds.The high antimicrobial activity of caffeic acid is due to a propene side chain, which reduces its polarity compared to the hydroxybenzoic structure of protocatechuic acid [50].
The authors of the work [51] evaluated the antibacterial activity of extracts obtained from sugarcane bagasse.The main components of the obtained extracts were phenolic acids, such as gallic acid, ferulic acid, coumaric acid, and chlorogenic acid.The tested extracts were characterized by antibacterial activity against S. aureus strains (MIC = 0.625 mg/mL) [51].
The study of plant extracts' antibacterial activity has been focused so far.The antibacterial activity of bio-ferments obtained by the fermentation of pomace, extract, cold-pressed oil, and seeds from milk thistles containing polyphenolic compounds, among others, has not been analyzed.Therefore, preliminary studies were carried out in the present study to evaluate the antibacterial activity of new bio-ferments.The presence of phenolic hydroxyl groups in the structure of polyphenols makes them have a high affinity for binding to proteins and lipids in the cell membrane [52].As a result, phenolic compounds contained in bio-ferments can inhibit microbial enzymes and, at the same time, increase their affinity for cytoplasmic membranes, thus increasing antimicrobial activity against the strains tested.The present study demonstrates that bio-ferments containing polyphenols are a promising source of effective, safe, and inexpensive antimicrobial compounds.The antimicrobial potential of fermented plant materials opens up a wide range of possibilities for new antimicrobial therapies.Because the bio-ferments had higher MIC values than antibiotics, they cannot be used in antimicrobial monotherapy due to their insufficient therapeutic effect.The antimicrobial activity of the tested bio-ferments was established at the following levels: moderate (B-S and B-P) or weak (B-E and B-O).However, implementing combination therapy with antibiotics can improve their pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties and reduce the dose of antibiotic intake.Studies by other authors have shown that the strain of Staphylococcus aureus was sensitive to most of the drugs used and resistant to doxycycline (MIC = 32 µg/mL) and florfenicol (MIC = 64 µg/mL) [53,54].Escherichia coli was susceptible to ceftiofur (MIC = 0.125 µg/mL), kanamycin (MIC = 2 µg/mL), colistin sulfate (MIC = 0.125 µg/mL), florfenicol (MIC = 2 µg/mL), and rifampicin (MIC = 4 µg/mL), while resistant to amoxicillin and doxycycline (MIC = 32 µg/MG), acetylisovaleryltylosin tartrate (MIC = 128 µg/mL), sulfadimidine and enrofloxacin (MIC = 16 µg/mL), and lincomycin (MIC = 512 µg/mL) [53,55].The MIC values of the antibiotics against Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853 were within the CLSI accuracy range throughout those studies: ceftazidime (MIC = 1-4 mg/L), tobramycin (MIC = 0.25-16 mg/L), piperacillin (MIC = 4-128 mg/L), ciprofloxacin, and colistin (MIC = 0.25-2 mg/L) [56,57].
The antimicrobial activity of the obtained bio-ferments may be due to the presence of phenolic compounds (Table 2), especially caffeic acid [58] and gallic acid [59].Polyphenol caffeic acid is a compound found in many species of plants that has proven antimicrobial activity.Caffeic acid is one of the ingredients in cosmetic (dermatological) preparations that enhances the antimicrobial effect of these preparations, even if they do not have a direct antibacterial and antifungal effect [58].Caffeic acid has significantly been employed as an alternative strategy to combat microbial pathogenesis and chronic infection induced by microbes such as bacteria, fungi, and viruses [60].Gallic acid (3,4,5-trihydroxybenzoic acid) is a bioactive phytochemical, and its derivatives are often present in cosmetic formulations and can be considered "safe" and "natural" in the context of cosmetic production [61].Studies have found that gallic acid killed Salmonella strains by permeabilizing the outer membrane by chelating divalent cations, leading to subsequent cell lysis.Gallic acid has been shown to have antimicrobial activity against Escherichia coli, Campylobacter jejuni, and Staphylococcus aureus [62,63].
All the bio-ferments obtained showed high antioxidant activity by the DPPH (from 2.41 ± 0.01 to 3.21 ± 0.01 mmol Tx/L), ABTS (from 6.52 ± 2.06 to 22.43 ± 2.01 mmol Tx/L), and FRAP (from 10.77 ± 0.59 to 16.68 ± 2.50 mmol FeSO 4 /L) methods, and had a high content of polyphenolic compounds as assessed by the Folin-Ciocalteu method (from 2306.82 ± 0.10 to 2599.43 mg GA/L).However, the bio-ferment derived from milk thistle pomace (B-P) showed the most effective DPPH radical scavenging activity, with a Tx equivalent antioxidant capacity of 3.21 ± 0.01 mmol/L.In addition, B-P showed the most potent antioxidant activity at 22.43 ± 2.01 mmol Tx/L using the ABTS method and 16.68 ± 2.50 mmol FeSO 4 /L using the FRAP method-Table 2. The bio-ferment from pomace (B-P) exhibited the highest ability to chelate Fe 2+ ions in the ferrozine assay and also had the highest ability to reduce Cu 2+ and Fe 3+ ions.However, O-S bio-ferments had a lower capacity to reduce copper II ions than B-E and B-O (Table 3).
The results confirm that the analyzed by-products are a good source of many biological functional substances with a significant content of phenolic compounds [14].A more than 2-fold increase in activity was observed.The antioxidant capacity of extracts obtained from vegetable oil by-products (flour, meal, and groats) was also confirmed by Multescu et al. [64].The extracts contain significant amounts of phenolic compounds, ranging from 1.54 to 74.85 mg GA/g byproduct.DPPH values ranged from 7.58 to 7182.53 mg Tx/g byproduct.ABTS test values of the analyzed samples ranged from 0 to 3500.52 mg Tx/g byproduct.The highest values for the FRAP method were represented by grape seed flour (4716.75mg Tx/g).For the CUPRAC test, grape seed flour (5936.76mg Tx/g) showed the highest antioxidant activity [64].
Our study showed that a bio-ferment from pomace had the highest significant content of phenolic acids, which contained the highest amounts of gallic acid (44.25 ± 3.29 mg/L) and caffeine acid (41.42 ± 2.81 mg/L)-Table 4. Data in the literature show that pomace has a rich composition of phenolic compounds and high antioxidant activity.Moreover, using pomace in the fermentation process highlights an additional advantage, that of a closed-loop economy.It also has implications for technical and environmental factors, such as lowering the carbon footprint when using plant biomass waste [65,[68][69][70][71].
The acidity of the tested bio-ferments was found to be 360 ± 5 mmol COOH/L for B-P, 410 ± 5 mmol COOH/L for B-E, 310 ± 5 mmol COOH/L for B-O, and 420 ± 5 mmol COOH/L for B-S (Table 3).The acidity of bio-ferments (which is due to the presence of carboxyl groups) is mainly influenced by lactic acid content (Figure 1) and carboxyl derivatives of phenolic compounds (Table 4).The acidity results obtained (Table 1) correlate with the results of lactic acid determination by GC-MS (Figure 1).The GC-MS analysis revealed that the highest lactic acid efficiency was achieved on the 14th day of fermenting milk thistle seeds (B-S: LA efficiency = 59%).The maximum yields of lactic acid were also observed on the 14th day of fermentation for the extract, oil, and pomace, and the yield values of LA were, respectively, B-E (53%), B-O (51%), and B-P (50%).By the 14th day of fermentation, the lactic acid contents were as follows: B-P: 240 mmol LA/L, B-E: 254 mmol LA/L, B-O: 248 mmol LA/L, and B-S: 287 mmol LA/L-as shown in Figure 1.Later, a gradual decrease in LA was observed in the bio-ferments.Lactic acid bacteria are microorganisms of industrial importance, known for their fermentation abilities, mainly for probiotic benefits, as well as lactic acid production.When conducting fermentation, inhibition of LA production often occurs, and a gradual decrease in the growth rate of lactic acid bacteria cells is observed [72].Therefore, a gradual decrease in lactic acid concentration is observed as the process is prolonged (Figure 1).The inhibition of lactic acid is caused by the ability of the undissociated lactic acid to dissolve in the cytoplasmic membrane, while the dissociated lactate remains insoluble.This leads to acidification of the cytoplasm and the disruption of proton motive forces.This event impacts the pH gradient across the cell membrane and reduces the cellular energy available for growth [72].
The hydrophilicity of all investigated bio-ferments (Figure 2) and distilled water (Figure S6) was determined (B-P c.a. av .= 66.7 • ± 1.5; B-E c.a. av .= 78.5 • ± 2.6; B-O c.a. av .= 74.8• ± 3.5; B-S c.a. av .= 75.4• ± 3.0; and control sample c.a. av.= 57.8• ± 1.0).This characteristic is mainly attributed to phenolic compounds (TPC) and lactic acid [26].The higher contact angle possesses higher hydrophilicity for all bio-ferments due to the phenolic acids and lactic acid in these cosmetic raw materials [36].Thus, these bio-ferments can only be used in lipid bilayers in the aqueous core of liposomes, not in the lipid envelope.Liposomes are spherical vesicles consisting of one or more lipid bilayers arranged concentrically.The core of liposomes is a droplet of water.Wettability studies showed that all bio-ferments are highly hydrophilic and can accumulate in lipid bilayers in the aqueous core of liposomes [33].
Our study showed that all the bio-ferments obtained from S. marianum were classified as readily degradable (Table 5).The biological activity results and the biodegradation findings provide a comprehensive understanding of the tested bio-ferments' environmental impact and cosmetic (dermatological) efficacy.Tio-ferments demonstrated both high biodegradability and significant antioxidant activity.This suggests that bio-ferments containing active compounds with antioxidant potential may offer effective active substance delivery (with desired antioxidant activity) and beneficial environmental influences.

Conclusions
Fermentation of pomace (P), extract (E), oil (O), and seeds (S) of milk thistle in the presence of lactic acid bacteria affected the production of phenolic compounds (Table S1) by enzymatic hydrolysis of phenolic glycosides contained in the plant material to free polyphenols (Figure S7).Bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle have high antioxidant and polyphenols content (Table 2) and high reducing activity for Cu 2+ and Fe 3+ ions (Table 3).All bio-ferments obtained from milk thistle can be used as cosmetic raw materials included in the composition of cosmetic formulations with antimicrobial activity (Table 1) due to the presence of phenolic acids, especially caffeic acid and gallic acid (Table 4).Moreover, the biologic activity of fermented plant raw materials can be used in dermatological and cosmetic products applied to the skin, including those with anti-aging, depigmenting, moisturizing, and regenerating properties.
After assessing the bio-ferments' biodegradability, all were classified according to the OECD as easily biodegradable (Table 5).Integration of the activity and biodegradability of the obtained cosmetic raw materials allows a comprehensive evaluation of the environmental and cosmetic aspects of bio-ferments.Considering environmental sustainability, this information is crucial for making informed decisions about obtaining biodegradable cosmetic formulations with antioxidant and antimicrobial potential.

Supplementary Materials:
The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https: //www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/app14104287/s1, Figure S1 S1. Results of the monitoring of the total polyphenols content production of the tested bio-ferments; Table S2.Results of the monitoring of the phenolic compound production of the tested bio-ferments from pomace (B-P), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and seeds (B-S) of milk thistle; Figure S6.Contact angle (c.a.av. ) of the control samples (distilled water): c.a. av.= 57.8• ± 1.0; Figure S7.The structure of identifying individual phenolic acids and lactic acid in bio-ferments from seeds (B-S), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and pomace (B-P) of milk thistle: A-gallic acid, B-protocatechuic acid, C-caffeic acid, D-neochlorogenic acid, E-coumaric acid, and F-lactic acid.

2. 6 .
Total Polyphenols Content and Antioxidant Activity 2.6.1.Total Polyphenol Content (TPC) A-acidity [mmol COOH/L]; V-volume of NaOH solution [L]; V 0 -volume of NaOH solution used for titration of the blank [L]; V b -volume of NaOH solution used for titration of the sample of bio-ferment [L]; N-normality of the NaOH solution used for the titration [0.1 N].
) and reference compounds (SDS) in 40 mg/L organic carbon concentrations.The starting concentrations for the obtained bioferments and reference compound were as follows: B-P = 83.30mg/L, B-E = 80.22 mg/L, B-O = 84.53mg/L, B-S = 79.62 mg/L, and SDS = 81.48mg/L.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Lactic acid content in bio-ferments B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S (left); lactic acid efficiency in bioferments B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S (right).Based on the results obtained by GC-MS, it was found that the highest lactic acid efficiency was obtained on the 14th day of conducting the fermentation of pomace (B-P: LA efficiency = 50%), extract (B-E: LA efficiency = 53%), oil (B-O: LA efficiency = 51%), and seeds (B-S: LA efficiency = 59%) of milk thistle.During the process, a gradual increase in lactic acid content was observed (i.e., by the 14th day of conducting the fermentation): B-P: LA content 0-240 mmol LA/L; B-E: LA content 0-254 mmol LA/L; B-O: LA content 0-248 mmol LA/L; and B-S: LA content 0-287 mmol LA/L-Figures 1 and S5.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Lactic acid content in bio-ferments B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S (left); lactic acid efficiency in bio-ferments B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S (right).Based on the results obtained by GC-MS, it was found that the highest lactic acid efficiency was obtained on the 14th day of conducting the fermentation of pomace (B-P: LA efficiency = 50%), extract (B-E: LA efficiency = 53%), oil (B-O: LA efficiency = 51%), and seeds (B-S: LA efficiency = 59%) of milk thistle.During the process, a gradual increase in lactic acid content was observed (i.e., by the 14th day of conducting the fermentation): B-P: LA content 0-240 mmol LA/L; B-E: LA content 0-254 mmol LA/L; B-O: LA content 0-248 mmol LA/L; and B-S: LA content 0-287 mmol LA/L-Figures 1 and S5.

Figure 2
Figure 2 shows photographs of bio-fermented (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) droplets on the surface of the STRAT-M ® membrane, which is a substitute for human skin.

Figure 2
Figure 2 shows photographs of bio-fermented (B-P, B-E, B-O, and B-S) droplets on the surface of the STRAT-M ® membrane, which is a substitute for human skin.
. A scheme for obtaining bio-ferments from seeds (B-S), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and pomace (B-P) of milk thistle; Figure S2.The appearance of the test obtained after immersion of the insert in the active sludge-right; the appearance of the reference test-left; Figure S3.The carbon dioxide measurement method; Figure S4.Representative chromatographs identifying individual phenolic acids in bio-ferments from seeds (B-S), extract (B-E), oil (B-O), and pomace (B-P) of milk thistle: A-gallic acid, RT = 6.455 min; B-protocatechuic acid, RT = 14.525 min; C-caffeic acid, RT = 16.673min; D-neochlorogenic acid, RT = 21.027min; and E-coumaric acid, RT = 28.209min; Figure S5.A representative chromatogram of a bio-ferment containing internal standard (octane RT = 4.73 min) and lactic acid (RT = and 5.92 min); Table

Table 1 .
Results for the antimicrobial activity of the tested bio-ferments presented as discrete numbers.

Table 2 .
Results for the antioxidant activity and total polyphenols content of the tested bio-ferments.

Table 3 .
Results for the chelating and reducing activity, as well as the acidity, of the tested bio-ferments.

Table 6 .
The half-life of bio-ferments' degradation by bacterial cultures.

Table 7 .
The phases of degradation of bio-ferments.