Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga Strains Cohabit in Olive Knots

Two bacteria belonging to the Pseudomonas and Pantoea genera were isolated from olive knots. Both bacterial strains were omnipresent in this study’s olive orchard with high susceptibility of the autochthonous olive genotypes indicating coevolution of bacteria with host plants. Genomes of two endemic bacteria show conserved core genomes and genome plasticity. The Pseudomonas ST1 genome has conserved virulence-related genes including genes for quorum sensing, pilus, and flagella biosynthesis, two copies of indole acetic acid biosynthesis (IAA) operons, type I-VI secretions systems, and genes for alginate and levan biosynthesis. Development of knots depends only on the presence of the Pseudomonas ST1 strain which then allows Pantoea paga strain co-infection and cohabitation in developed knots. The two bacteria are sensitive to a large number of antimicrobials, antibiotics, H2O2, and Cu (II) salts that can be efficiently used in propagation of bacterial free olive cultivars.


Introduction
Olive knot disease caused by the Gram-negative bacterium Pseudomonas savastanoi pv. savastanoi is recognized as one of the most important diseases that affect olive trees (Olea europaea L.) throughout various regions of the world, in particular the Mediterranean region [1]. Pseudomonas savastanoi belongs to the Pseudomonas syringae complex and includes three pathogenic lineages that cause tumorous overgrowths (tumorous galls or knots) in diverse trees and shrubs of economic relevance. In addition to Pseudomonas savastanoi pv. savastanoi, other pathovars such as P. savastanoi pv. nerii and P. savastanoi pv. fraxini have been isolated from oleander and ash, respectively.
Pseudomonas savastanoi pv. savastanoi (Psv, according to [2]) lives mainly as an epiphyte on the surface of olive organs [3]. Under favorable weather conditions, its population increases and the bacteria may enter into olive tissues and survive as an endophyte. Psv may experience uncontrolled proliferation at the site of infection and form knots trig-gered by phytohormones synthesized by the bacterium [1,4,5]. The knots occur mainly on the stems and branches of the host plants, and more rarely on leaves and fruits [6]. However, there is limited information on the impacts of this disease on tree vigor and yield [7].
At short distances, the bacterium can spread by rain, windblown aerosols, insects and agricultural practices. Processes such as the falling of leaves, budding, harvesting and pruning create wounds on the plant through which infection occurs [8]. Weather conditions favorable for both bacterium epiphytic development and its entry into the host determine the extent of damages caused by Psv. Olive knots are optimal niches for Psv growth and also for other bacteria. For example, many bacterial species reside inside the knots together with Pseudomonas savastanoi pv. savastanoi, commonly of the genera Pantoea, Pectobacterium, Erwinia and Curtobacterium [9]. Previous studies have reported that the microbe interactions can result in enhanced or decreased pathogenicity of one bacterium towards their plant host. Likewise, the interaction of Psv with other bacterial species has shown to mediate the disease potential [10,11]. Several non-pathogenic bacterial species, namely Erwinia toletana, Pantoea agglomerans, and Erwinia oleae, can form a stable bacterial consortium with the pathogen Psv and increase disease severity by boosting the proliferation of olive tissues [9,12,13]. The structure of plant-associated microbiota is genotype dependent [14,15] and may lead to different pathobiomes [16].
The pathogenicity and virulence of bacteria from the Pseudomonas syringae group and olive isolates of P. savastanoi are dependent on a type III secretion system (T3SS) that has been identified as a key virulence determinant among many Gram-negative plant and animal pathogenic bacteria [17][18][19][20]. Bacteria of the P. syringae group cause disease by suppressing plant defense responses after delivering effector proteins into the host cell cytoplasm using a type III secretion system (T3SS) [21]. Sisto et al. [17] reported that T3SS is encoded by hrp/hrc gene clusters. The T3SS is required for the hypersensitive response and for pathogenicity [22]. In addition to effector proteins, phytotoxins and hormones are recognized as molecules that increase virulence or microbial fitness [18,[23][24][25][26]. The phytohormones indoleacetic acid (IAA) and cytokinins (CK) are the first and best-characterized Psv determinants that have been shown to be involved in olive knot formation [5,27].
Due to the economic impact of olive knot disease, growers need effective control methods to overcome its negative effects on plant growth and fruit yield [28]. Traditional control strategies are mainly based on reducing the endophytic and epiphytic P. savastanoi populations with practices that include pruning of affected branches and treating with copper compounds [28]. The use of resistant olive cultivars is considered one of the most efficient methods of disease control but limited information is available from these comparative studies [29][30][31]. Although different olive cultivars have shown different susceptibility to olive knot disease, there exists no report of olive tree genotypes completely resistant to disease [11]. To avoid the spread of P. savastanoi or other pathogens, sanitary certification programs for olive propagation materials and mother plants have been already launched worldwide [32]. However, the measures for the production of certified olive plants are sometimes based on the visual inspection of the knots, without considering the possible asymptomatic presence of P. savastanoi.
The plant genotype has been increasingly recognized to be a key determinant of phyllosphere microbiota composition [14]. The aim of this work was to evaluate the susceptibility of olive germplasm to olive knot disease caused by Pseudomonas and Pantoea, including isolation of the causative agent of knot formation and confirmation of pathogenicity by inoculation of healthy plants with isolated bacterial strains.
The genus Pantoea is a member of the Enterobacteriaceae and includes several species [33]. Most of them are associated with many plants living as a part of plants epiphyte or endophyte microbiome. Some strains are considered as plant growth promoting bacteria (PGPB). Pantoea aglomerans strains evolved into pathogens that cause gall formation on various plants [34,35] and another prevents root development in pruned cuttings as a limiting factor in plant propagation [36]. In this work we describe the effects of two bacteria in forming galls on olive plants and determine the genomic potential, phylogeny, and virulence of each strain.
In November 2019, the symptoms caused by olive knot in different olive cultivars were evaluated, five months after a hailstorm caused great damage to the trees of all cultivars in the collection. The evaluation of the symptoms was carried out according to the proposed methodology for the secondary characterization of olive varieties held in collections. The incidence of the disease was assessed by visual inspection of at least four trees per cultivar. The percentage of area in which symptoms appear was evaluated and cultivars were classified into six different categories of tolerance corresponding to percentages (1. Nil: 0; 2. Very low: 1-20%; 3. Low: 20-40%; 4. Medium: 40-60%; 5. High: 60-80%; 6. Very high: 80-100%).

Genetic and Phylogenetic Analysis of Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga
Two genomes, Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea paga strains have been sequenced earlier and deposited under the accession numbers VKOF00000000.1 [37] and VLTF00000000 [38], respectively. Genomes of Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea paga strains were analyzed on the Mage platform [39] to compute clusters of orthologous genes (COGs) [40]. Using antiSMASH [41] genes clusters involved in the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites and virulence factors [42] were identified.
Using GBDP distances calculated from 16S rDNA gene sequences, phylogenetic trees were created with FastME 2.1.6.1. The branch lengths are scaled in terms of GBDP distance formula d5. The numbers above branches are GBDP pseudo-bootstrap support values > 60% from 100 replications, with an average branch support of 52.6%. The tree was rooted at the midpoint [43,44].

Confirmation of Pathogenicity of Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga Isolated from the Trees in a Collection Orchard
The experiment was performed in an unshaded greenhouse at the Institute for Adriatic Crops and Karst Reclamation, Split in October 2020. Two olive cultivars Oblica and Lastovka that showed significantly different susceptibilities to olive knot disease in the first experiment were included in the study. Plants were planted in 5 L pots with a mixture of substrates including "Brill TYPical 4" and eutric brown soil (pH 5.5-6.8; 2-6% humus content). With a sterile scalpel, lateral wounds, approximately 5 to 10 mm in diameter, were introduced to the shoots of the two-year-old plants. The cambial tissue was exposed to artificial infection performed by inoculation with Pseudomonas ST1 strain [37], Pantoea paga strain [38], and combination of these two bacteria. Replicates of five plants per cultivar with ten lateral wounds was used (in total, fifty wounds per treatment condition and cultivar). In control plants no inoculation with bacterial strains was performed. Olive trees were assessed 6 months after inoculation and the percentage of knot formation was calculated for each treatment (number of wounds with symptoms/total number of wounds × 100). Treatments were evaluated based on the incidence of disease. The data for knot formation in different treatments were subjected to an analysis of variance using generalised linear models in SAS software (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). Differences between groups were determined by the LSD test at p ≤ 0.05.
To confirm the presence of bacteria in lateral wounds, bacteria from the olive knots and plant tissue around the wounds were cultured from the plants that showed symptoms of infection as well as from the plants that did not develop symptoms including control plants. The samples were sterilized using 75% ethanol, sliced with a sterile scalpel, and put onto King's medium agar plates, kept in the dark [45]. The bacterial cells developed on medium were transferred onto a new King's medium agar plates and kept at 37 • C. An isolated single colony from each treatment was transferred into 5 ml of liquid lysogeny broth (LB) medium and grown at 28 • C. DNA was isolated from bacterial cells in the precipitate using a microbial DNA kit (Macherey-Nagel, Hoerdt, France). 16S RNA gene was amplified in each sample using PCR reaction and sequenced.

Bacteria Strains
The strains of two bacterial species used in this study were from our culture collection. Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea paga cells were isolated from olive knots from olive plants grown in the central region of Dalmatia, Croatia. The complete genome sequence was described and has been deposited in NCBI/GenBank [37,38].

Growth Media, Antibiotics and Chemical Agents
King's A media for a single-disc diffusion technique was prepared according to King et al. [45]. The medium was used for antibiotic and chemical agents' susceptibility testing. A single-disc diffusion technique was used for determination of the antibiotic susceptibility of bacteria. Eighteen antibiotics were tested including: Ciprofloxacin, Novobiocin, Streptomycin, Hygromycin, Chloramphenicol, Tetracycline, Trimethoprim, Carbenicillin, G418, Neomycin, Ampicillin, Vancomycin, Geneticin, Rifampicin, Spectinomycin, Apramycin, Ticarcillin and Kanamycin.
Antibiotics and chemical agents were diluted in sterile distilled water to prepare the solutions at the specified working concentrations. The antibiotics (Sigma Aldrich, Saint-Quentin-Fallavier, France) were used at the working concentrations of the following ranges: Ciprofloxacin (from 0.05 to 2.5 mg/mL), Novobiocin (from 0.748 to 37.4 mg/mL), Streptomycin (from 0.6 to 30 mg/mL), Hygromycin, Carbenicillin, G418, Neomycin, Ampicillin (from 2 to 100 mg/mL), Chloramphenicol (from 0.4 to 20 mg/mL), Tetracycline, Trimethoprim (from 0.5 to 25 mg/mL), Vancomycin (from 0.58 to 28.86 mg/mL), Geneticin, Kanamycin (from 0.8 to 40 mg/mL), Rifampicin (from 1.8 to 90 mg/mL), Spectinomycin (from 6 to 300 mg/mL), Apramycin (from 1 to 50 mg/mL) and Ticarcillin (250 mg/mL  26 ), mineral oil, and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS; C 12 H 25 NaO 4 S). Solutions of different chemical agents were prepared at the concentrations from 1 mg/ml to 50 mg/ml with the exception of hydrogen peroxide and dodecyl sulfate, which were used at the concentration from 0.6 to 30% and 0.004 to 20%, respectively. Antibiotic and chemical agents were added on the discs. The discs were placed on the King's A media with growing bacterial cultures. To determine the efficiency of an individual antibiotic and chemical agent and their effective concentrations, the zone diameters were measured after overnight incubation at 37 • C. We measured the diameter of the growth inhibition zone [circular zone around an antibiotic disc with no visible bacterial growth ( Figure S1)]. The diameter of the zone of inhibition of the test isolates were recorded. Some strains exhibited an inner area of light growth immediately around the antibiotic disc with an obvious area of inhibition outside this hazy growth. In these instances, the outer zone of inhibition was measured. The most obvious zone of inhibition was measured in those instances when several concentric zones were observed around an antibiotic disc.

Susceptibility of Different Olive Cultivars to Olive Knot Disease
Different cultivars showed diverse intensities of symptoms for olive knot disease and were classified in six categories according to percentage of area affected (Table 1). We found no symptoms of disease in three Italian cultivars, Coratina, Favarol, and Leccino. The highest percentages of area covered by tumorous overgrowths ranging from 60-80% (category 5) and from 80-100% (category 6) were found for Frantoio, Lastovka, Santa Catarina and Chemlali. The Tunisian cultivar Chemlali was the most affected cultivar with the highest incidence of symptoms (category 6). Together with cultivars Fasolina, Grignan, Moraiolo and Sigoise, trees of Oblica, which is the most widespread cultivar in Croatia, showed very low percentage of area covered by symptoms ranging from 1-20% (category 2).

Genome Analysis of the Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga
Plants of Lastovka and Oblica, the most representative olive cultivars grown along the eastern coast of the Adriatic area were used to isolate and identify causal agent of gall formation that could coevolve with olive plants. Fresh galls from different plants where surface sterilized in ethanol, sliced by sterile scalpel and placed on King's agar plates. We cultured two visually different types of colonies after two days of incubation at room temperature. Total DNA was isolated from twelve colonies and part of the 16sRNA gene was amplified and sequenced. Blast results of sequence analysis of the 16sRNA genes from twelve random isolated colonies show presence of two groups of bacteria belonging to Pseudomonas and Pantoea genera.
Genomes of Pantoea paga and Pseudomonas ST1 isolates were sequenced using ilumina NGS technology end each genome was assembled for genome analysis [37,38].
The genome of Pseudomonas ST1 has 6.1 Mbps, genome coding for 6271 genomic objects and 58% of GC contents (Figure 1). Phylogenetic analysis of the whole genome and 16S rRNA gene sequence of Pseudomonas ST1 show that this strain belongs to known species Pseudomonas amygdali (Figure 2A,B).

Genome Analysis of the Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga
Plants of Lastovka and Oblica, the most representative olive cultivars grown along the eastern coast of the Adriatic area were used to isolate and identify causal agent of gall formation that could coevolve with olive plants. Fresh galls from different plants where surface sterilized in ethanol, sliced by sterile scalpel and placed on King's agar plates. We cultured two visually different types of colonies after two days of incubation at room temperature. Total DNA was isolated from twelve colonies and part of the 16sRNA gene was amplified and sequenced. Blast results of sequence analysis of the 16sRNA genes from twelve random isolated colonies show presence of two groups of bacteria belonging to Pseudomonas and Pantoea genera.
Genomes of Pantoea paga and Pseudomonas ST1 isolates were sequenced using ilumina NGS technology end each genome was assembled for genome analysis [37,38].
The genome of Pseudomonas ST1 has 6.1 Mbps, genome coding for 6271 genomic objects and 58% of GC contents (Figure 1). Phylogenetic analysis of the whole genome and 16S rRNA gene sequence of Pseudomonas ST1 show that this strain belongs to known species Pseudomonas amygdali (Figure 2A,B).  Pseudomonas ST1 is a motile bacterium as confirmed under light microscopy observation and presence of flagellum and pili biosynthesis genes in the genome. Genome analysis shows presence of six secretion systems, from TSS1 to TSS6, and an alginate biosynthesis operon related to production of extracellular polysaccharides necessary to host attachment and virulence. The global activator, two component system gacS is also present in the genome and could regulate not only alginate production but also homo serine lactone production, toxin production and other virulence related genes and operons ( Figure  3 and Table S1). Presence of two operons with genes (iaaM1, iaaH1, iaaM2, and iaaH2) involved in indole acetic acid (IAA) biosynthesis indicates potential for the strain to produce plant hormone. Eight genome clusters coding for secondary metabolites are present in the genome. Most of them are nonribosomal peptides synthetases (NRPS) involved in biosynthesis of secondary metabolites. Based on homology searches, these clusters can be involved in biosynthesis of antibiotics, signaling molecules, siderophores, toxins, and storage materials (Table S2). Pseudomonas ST1 is a motile bacterium as confirmed under light microscopy observation and presence of flagellum and pili biosynthesis genes in the genome. Genome analysis shows presence of six secretion systems, from TSS1 to TSS6, and an alginate biosynthesis operon related to production of extracellular polysaccharides necessary to host attachment and virulence. The global activator, two component system gacS is also present in the genome and could regulate not only alginate production but also homo serine lactone production, toxin production and other virulence related genes and operons ( Figure 3 and Table S1). Presence of two operons with genes (iaaM1, iaaH1, iaaM2, and iaaH2) involved in indole acetic acid (IAA) biosynthesis indicates potential for the strain to produce plant hormone. Eight genome clusters coding for secondary metabolites are present in the genome. Most of them are nonribosomal peptides synthetases (NRPS) involved in biosynthesis of secondary metabolites. Based on homology searches, these clusters can be involved in biosynthesis of antibiotics, signaling molecules, siderophores, toxins, and storage materials (Table S2) Table S1.
Whole genome homology searches show similarity of Pseudomonas ST1 isolates to the Pseudomonas savastanoi ICMP. Two strains share 5442 common genes and each strain has strain-specific genes. Pseudomonas ST1 has 568 strain-specific genes in comparison and Pseudomonas savastanoi that has 434 specific genes (Table S3; Figure S2).
The genome has T1SS, T3SS, and T5SS genes for secretion systems, focA gene for pilin biosynthesis, hlyF gene for hemolysin, and only one hopD1 gene related to pathogenicity. Seven genome regions contain genes for secondary metabolite biosynthesis such as carotenoids, zeaxantinins, siderophores, and homoserine lactone. The Pantoea paga strain has mcb bacteriocin biosynthesis operon containing genes involved in biosynthesis, maturation, modification, and secretion of antimicrobial peptide.
Phylogenetic analysis of the whole genome and 16S rRNA gene sequence of Pantoea paga shows that this strain belongs to the known species Pantoea agglomerans ( Figure  5A,B).  Table S1.
Whole genome homology searches show similarity of Pseudomonas ST1 isolates to the Pseudomonas savastanoi ICMP. Two strains share 5442 common genes and each strain has strain-specific genes. Pseudomonas ST1 has 568 strain-specific genes in comparison and Pseudomonas savastanoi that has 434 specific genes (Table S3 and Figure S2).
The genome has T1SS, T3SS, and T5SS genes for secretion systems, focA gene for pilin biosynthesis, hlyF gene for hemolysin, and only one hopD1 gene related to pathogenicity. Seven genome regions contain genes for secondary metabolite biosynthesis such as carotenoids, zeaxantinins, siderophores, and homoserine lactone. The Pantoea paga strain has mcb bacteriocin biosynthesis operon containing genes involved in biosynthesis, maturation, modification, and secretion of antimicrobial peptide.
Phylogenetic analysis of the whole genome and 16S rRNA gene sequence of Pantoea paga shows that this strain belongs to the known species Pantoea agglomerans ( Figure 5A,B).
The statistic distribution of the protein coding genes of the two genomes within the clusters of orthologous groups of functional categories is shown in Figure 6 [40].    The statistic distribution of the protein coding genes of the two genomes within the clusters of orthologous groups of functional categories is shown in Figure 6 [40]. T-signal transduction mechanisms; U-intracellular trafficking, secretion, and vesicular transport; V-defense mechanisms; W-extracellular structures; Z-cytoskeleton; A-RNA processing and modification; Bchromatin structure and dynamics; J-translation, ribosomal structure, and biogenesis; K-transcription; L-replication, recombination, and repair; C-energy production and conversion; Eamino acid transport and metabolism; F-nucleotide transport and metabolism; G-carbohydrate transport and metabolism; H-coenzyme transport and metabolism; I-lipid transport and metabolism; P-inorganic ion transport and metabolism; Q-secondary metabolites biosynthesis, transport and catabolism; R-general function prediction only; and S-function unknown. The statistic distribution of the protein coding genes of the two genomes within the clusters of orthologous groups of functional categories is shown in Figure 6 [40]. T-signal transduction mechanisms; U-intracellular trafficking, secretion, and vesicular transport; V-defense mechanisms; W-extracellular structures; Z-cytoskeleton; A-RNA processing and modification; Bchromatin structure and dynamics; J-translation, ribosomal structure, and biogenesis; K-transcription; L-replication, recombination, and repair; C-energy production and conversion; Eamino acid transport and metabolism; F-nucleotide transport and metabolism; G-carbohydrate transport and metabolism; H-coenzyme transport and metabolism; I-lipid transport and metabolism; P-inorganic ion transport and metabolism; Q-secondary metabolites biosynthesis, transport and catabolism; R-general function prediction only; and S-function unknown. T-signal transduction mechanisms; U-intracellular trafficking, secretion, and vesicular transport; V-defense mechanisms; W-extracellular structures; Z-cytoskeleton; A-RNA processing and modification; B-chromatin structure and dynamics; J-translation, ribosomal structure, and biogenesis; K-transcription; L -replication, recombination, and repair; C-energy production and conversion; E-amino acid transport and metabolism; F-nucleotide transport and metabolism; G -carbohydrate transport and metabolism; H-coenzyme transport and metabolism; I-lipid transport and metabolism; P-inorganic ion transport and metabolism; Q-secondary metabolites biosynthesis, transport and catabolism; R-general function prediction only; and S-function unknown.

Pathogenicity of Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga
To verify the causative agent of knot formation we inoculated healthy olive plants with isolated bacterial species alone and in a mixture of the two bacterial isolates. Pure culture of two strains were mixed and inoculated on healthy olive plants. Six months post inoculation of bacteria we observed formation of galls on plants tissues and compared symptoms with control plants (Figure 7A-D). We observed formation of galls when Pseudomonas ST1 strain was used as inoculant either alone or in a mixture with Pantoea sp. paga strain ( Figure 7C,D). There was no gall formation on the plants where Pantoea paga strain was applied alone ( Figure 7B).

Pathogenicity of Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea Paga
To verify the causative agent of knot formation we inoculated healthy olive plants with isolated bacterial species alone and in a mixture of the two bacterial isolates. Pure culture of two strains were mixed and inoculated on healthy olive plants. Six months post inoculation of bacteria we observed formation of galls on plants tissues and compared symptoms with control plants (Figure 7A-D). We observed formation of galls when Pseudomonas ST1 strain was used as inoculant either alone or in a mixture with Pantoea sp. paga strain ( Figure 7C,D). There was no gall formation on the plants where Pantoea paga strain was applied alone ( Figure 7B). Total DNA was isolated from infected areas of plant tissues. Presence of two bacteria was confirmed by PCR amplification of 16s rDNA genes and PCR amplification of strain specific genes using specific pairs of primers followed by amplicon sequencing. Formation of knots and presence of Pseudomonas ST1 strain was confirmed in all tested knots. We conclude that the isolate of Pseudomonas sp. alone is the causative agent of knot formation on olive plants (Figure 8). Pantoea sp. cells inoculated alone on olive plants did not induce formation of galls. Lastovka showed higher level of knot formation compared to Oblica when inoculated with Pseudomonas ST1 strain (Figure 8). A mixture of two bacteria enhanced the development of knots as observed in Oblica. Total DNA was isolated from infected areas of plant tissues. Presence of two bacteria was confirmed by PCR amplification of 16s rDNA genes and PCR amplification of strain specific genes using specific pairs of primers followed by amplicon sequencing. Formation of knots and presence of Pseudomonas ST1 strain was confirmed in all tested knots. We conclude that the isolate of Pseudomonas sp. alone is the causative agent of knot formation on olive plants (

Susceptibility of Two Bacteria to Various Chemical Agents and Antibiotics
The antibacterial activities of the antibiotics and chemical agents in different concentrations against the Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea paga strains were examined for the presence or absence of the inhibition zones by the agar disc diffusion method. Sensitivity values of each antibiotic and chemical agent used for antibacterial activity are shown in Table   Figure 8. Percentage of knots formation on Oblica and Lastovka cultivars inoculated with Pantoea paga or Pseudomonas ST1 strains used alone or with mixture of two strains compared to non-inoculated control plants. The results are expressed as the means ± SE. Different lowercase letters indicate significant differences according to the least significant difference test at p < 0.05.

Susceptibility of Two Bacteria to Various Chemical Agents and Antibiotics
The antibacterial activities of the antibiotics and chemical agents in different concentrations against the Pseudomonas ST1 and Pantoea paga strains were examined for the presence or absence of the inhibition zones by the agar disc diffusion method. Sensitivity values of each antibiotic and chemical agent used for antibacterial activity are shown in Table 2. Pseudomonas ST1 strain showed the highest susceptibility to all of the used antibiotics, while Pantoea paga strain showed reduced sensitivity to hygromycin and vancomycin. Both strains were resistant to iron (II) citrate, magnesium carbonate, mineral oil, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, polyoxyethylenesorbitan monolaurate, potassium iodide, and potassium sulfate. The sodium molybdate was not effective against Pantoea paga. The high efficiency of sodium dodecyl sulfate on Pseudomonas ST1 was confirmed. Both bacterial strains were very susceptible to copper salts. Hydrogen peroxide showed the highest activity against both bacteria and it is one of the best candidates in the protection of olive plants from the bacteria causing olive knot.
The occurrence and intensity of symptoms in olive cultivars was assessed in the Olive Germplasm Bank of Croatia. In earlier studies, the two most common bacterial species associated with the olive-knot microbiome were isolated from the knots of olive trees grown in Croatia and their genomes have been sequenced [37,38]. Two bacterial strains of Pseudomonas [52] and Pantoea [53] are known as causative agents of knot formation on plants. In silico analysis of Pseudomonas ST1 genome shows presence of all virulence genes necessary for infection such as type T3SS secretion system, protected polymers production, alginate, levan, and production of the phytohormone IAA [54,55]. The strain has two putative operons for production of IAA that could be related to high infectivity of this endemic strain in knot formation. This strain shares a high proportion of genes in common with other Pseudomonas strains. However, strain ST1 has 568 specific genes with unknown function. These genes may contribute to its specific ecological niche. It possesses three gene clusters coding non-ribosomal peptide synthetase that could synthetize bicornutin, rhizomide, and mangotoxin. According to phylogenetic analyses the Pseudomonas ST1 strain belongs to the Pseudomonas amygdali species.
In contrast, Pantoea paga has no panel of virulence genes in its genome. This strain belongs to the Pantoea agglomerans species and probably uses Pseudomonas ST1 to invade plant tissue. It contains antimicrobial genes involved in microcin biosynthesis that is known as antibacterial peptide inhibiting DNA gyrase [56]. Therefore, the presence of Pantoea paga can affect the growth of other bacteria.
The genomes were further analyzed in the present study to determine differences between the two bacteria. These two bacteria were used in the new experiment to determine whether their co-infection intensifies the symptoms of olive knot disease in two olive cultivars Lastovka and Oblica and to determine whether each of them is sufficient to cause the symptoms. Pseudomonas ST1 is the causative agent of knot formation as it was shown in the experiment where the healthy olive plants were inoculated with two bacteria. Inoculation with the Pantoea strain did not induce knot formation when inoculated alone; however, join inoculation with Pseudomonas ST1 strain increased the percentage of knot formation in Oblica cultivar. The differences in occurrence and intensity of symptoms in cultivars Oblica and Lastovka were less pronounced in the greenhouse experiment, where the young plants were artificially infected compared to the evaluation carried out in the collection orchard, where the knots were formed over the longer period before the assessment and without our interference.
To avoid the spread of P. savastanoi or other pathogens, it is important to develop strain specific identification. Here we successfully used strain specific PCR oligonucleotide primers for the detection of two bacteria. Furthermore, in order to improve measures to control the spread of this disease in the process of propagation of olive plant material, the efficiency of antibiotics and other chemical agents in control of pathogens has been investigated. Our results provide new insights on the epidemiology of this disease and enable Pseudomonas and Pantoea control.
Supplementary Materials: The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https:// www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/microorganisms10081529/s1. Figure S1: Disc diffusion method for antibiotic and chemical agent's susceptibility testing. Figure S2: Venn diagram showing two genomes (Pseudomonas ST1 and Pseudomonas savastanoi pv. savastanoi PVFi1) with core genome and strain specific genes (Table S3). Table S1: Conserved Pseudomonas ST1 virulence genes. Table S2: Cluster of genes for biosynthesis of secondary metabolites; Table S3: Strain specific and common genes in Pseudomonas ST1.