ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 and ZnO–Malachite as Effective Photocatalysts for the Removal of Enteropathogenic Bacteria, Dyestuffs, and Heavy Metals from Municipal and Industrial Wastewater

: Different composites based on ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 and ZnO–malachite (Cu 2 (OH) 2 CO 3 ) were synthesized in order to determine their effectiveness in the treatment of municipal and industrial wastewaters (mainly polluted by enteropathogenic bacteria, dyes, and heavy metals). The addition of Ag 3 PO 4 and malachite did not signiﬁcantly modify the physicochemical properties of ZnO; however, the optical properties of this oxide were modiﬁed as a result of its coupling with the modiﬁers. The modiﬁcation of ZnO led to an improvement in its effectiveness in the treatment of municipal and industrial wastewater. In general, the amount of malachite or silver phosphate and the efﬂuent to be treated were the determining factors in the effectiveness of the wastewater treatment. The highest degree of elimination of bacteria from municipal wastewater and discoloration of textile staining wastewater were achieved by using ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%), but an increase in the phosphate content had a detrimental effect on the treatment. Likewise, the highest Fe and Cu photoreduction from coal mining wastewater was observed by using ZnO–malachite (2.5%) and ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (10%), respectively. Some of the results of this work were presented at the fourth Congreso Colombiano de Procesos Avanzados de Oxidaci ó n (4CCPAOx).


Introduction
Municipal effluents, textile staining wastewater, and coal mining wastewater currently represent important pollution problems in Latin-American countries. A clear example of this reality can be found in Colombia, where municipal and industrial wastewaters have a detrimental effect on the quality of natural water sources that significantly impacts animal and human health.
Different techniques for contaminant removal from wastewater have been evaluated around the world [1]. Adsorbents are the main materials employed for the removal of dyes and heavy metals. These materials present excellent performance; however, by using adsorption, the pollutants are transferred to a new phase, so this treatment is not a definitive solution for the environmental problem represented by the abovementioned contaminants [2]. Ozonization has also been successfully improved for water purification [3]; however, this process is only effective for the degradation of organic compounds, and heavy metals still remain in the liquid phase.
Combinations of advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have also been studied for the treatment of organic pollutants. For example, D. Yu et al. have deeply studied combinations of AOPs. They have reported the successful degradation and mineralization of 4-nitrophenol (4-NP) by using photocatalysis combined with ozonation and Fe-based metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) [4]. These authors have also reported the degradation of 4-NP by using Fenton-like processes based on Fe-MOFs [5]. Tetracycline (TC) degradation has also been successfully performed by different authors. For example, O. Alani et al. have reported the treatment of this compound with a heterogeneous photo-Fenton process based on bio-templated Fe 3 O 4 /CuO/C [6]. On the other hand, H. Ari et al. [7] have combined a UV-assisted Fenton process with nanostructured biomimetic α-Fe 2 O 3 , thus showing efficient UV-Fenton degradation for TC. This catalyst can also be reused in up to five consecutive cycles without a significant loss in activity.
The current research simultaneously addresses the serious environmental problems represented by enteropathogenic bacteria, dyestuffs, and heavy metals by means of photocatalytic processes. In this study, different composites based on ZnO and modified with the addition of Ag 3 PO 4 or Cu 2 (OH) 2 CO 3 were tested in the photocatalytic treatment of real effluents from domestic and industrial activities. The evaluated photocatalysts were found to be very effective at eliminating pollutants from the tested wastewaters and improve on the efficiency of the photocatalysts that our research group studied previously [8][9][10][11][12].
The main objective of this study was to improve ZnO's photoactivity by modifying it with ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 and ZnO-Cu 2 (OH) 2 CO 3 and evaluating the effects of these composites in real wastewater samples. Authors have reported that Ag 3 PO 4 can help ZnO improve its optical response in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum [13,14]. Likewise, it has also been reported that malachite (Cu 2 CO 3 (OH) 2 ) is an effective modifier of TiO 2 , leading to an improvement in the effectiveness of this semiconductor in photocatalytic hydrogen production [15].
In the current study, the efficiency of ZnO modified by Ag 3 PO 4 or Cu 2 CO 3 (OH) 2 addition was studied in the treatment of wastewater by photocatalysis. This research makes a beneficial contribution to the use of photocatalysis to treat real wastewaters, such as municipal, handicraft factory, and coal mining effluents.
ZnO-malachite composites were prepared by the dispersion of the pure ZnO obtained previously in an aqueous solution of CuSO 4 under continuous stirring for 1 h. Afterwards, an aqueous solution of Na 2 CO 3 was added drop by drop in amounts such to obtain nominal malachite contents of 0.5% and 2.5% (molar percentages). These materials were labeled ZnO-M (0.5%) and ZnO-M (2.5%), respectively.

Physicochemical Properties Analysis
The physicochemical properties of the composites were evaluated by using different analytical techniques and pieces of equipment, which are described below.
The chemical composition of the materials was estimated by X-ray fluorescence (XRF). Measurements were performed on pressed pellets in which samples were fixed in 10 wt.% wax. The analyses used a Panalytical Axios sequential spectrophotometer equipped with a Rh tube as the source of radiation.
BET specific surface areas were determined by N 2 adsorption at 77 K in a Micromeritics ASAP 2010 instrument. Degassing of the samples was performed at 150 • C for 30 min under a helium flow.
UV-Vis diffuse reflectance spectrophotometry was used to study the optical properties of the materials. Spectra were recorded in the range between 200 nm and 800 nm in absorption mode using a Varian spectrometer (model: Cary100) equipped with an integrating sphere and using BaSO 4 as a 100% absorption reference material. Band-gap values were calculated from the Kubelka-Munk functions F (R∞), which are proportional to the absorption of radiation, by plotting (F (R∞) × hυ) 1/2 against hυ.
X-ray diffraction analyses used a X' PertPro PANalytical instrument equipped with a Cu Kα1 radiation source (λ = 0.15406 nm) (45 kV, 40 mA). The 2θ range was between 10 • and 80 • . A step size of 0.05 • and a step time of 80 s were used.
Finally, the morphology of the samples was observed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) in a Hitachi S 4800 microscope and by transmission scanning microscopy (S/TEM) in a Talos™ F200S FEI microscope.

Wastewater Sampling
The water samples selected for this study corresponded to municipal and industrial wastewater from three different sources. Water samples from three Colombian towns highly influenced by domestic and industrial activities were included in this study. Firstly, municipal wastewater was collected from a highly polluted river in the city of Tunja (geographical coordinates: Latitude: 5.553583; Longitude: −73.350694). Handmade textile wastewater was also obtained at the exit of the staining tanks of factories located in the town of Nobsa (Latitude: 5.77333; Longitude: −72.94833). Finally, coal mining wastewater was taken from the town of Samacá (Latitude: 5.49444, Longitude: −73.48833). The wastewater samples were collected by following the procedure described in the Standard Methods for Examination of Water and Wastewater (SMEWW) [16].

Photocatalytic Wastewater Treatment
ZnO nanocomposites were prepared according to the methods described in Section 2.1 and were tested in the photocatalytic treatment of the municipal and industrial wastewater samples. A detailed description of the procedure employed in each of the photocatalytic tests conducted is presented below.
All the experiments were carried out twice in a 400 mL Pyrex reactor wrapped in aluminum foil with a 250 mL sample of wastewater and 1 g/L of photocatalyst loading. A total reaction time of 240 min was used along with an Osram Ultra-Vitalux lamp (300 W) as the light source with a sun-like radiation spectrum, a UVA range at 365 nm, and an intensity of 30 W/m 2 . The adsorption-desorption equilibrium was achieved by stirring for 10 min in the dark before switching on the lamp. Magnetic stirring and a constant natural oxygen flow of 35 L/h coming from a bubbler tank were maintained throughout the photocatalytic treatment time. Photocatalyst recovery was carried out by filtration with Sartorius Biolab filters with a pore size of 0.45 µm. Photolysis tests (without photocatalyst) were also carried out.
A complete physicochemical analysis of the wastewater samples before and after treatment was carried out by double testing. These measurements included pH, alkalinity, and chloride content determination. The pH was measured with an SI analytics Lab 850 pH-meter. Alkalinity and chloride content were calculated by using the 2320 B-1995 APHA and 4500 Cl-B-1995 APHA methods, respectively [16].
Total organic carbon (TOC) was also determined by using a TOC/TNb analyzer (multi N/C 2100 Analytik Jena). Method 5310B from the SMEWW was employed [16].
In order to evaluate the effectiveness of the treatment in the removal of enteropathogenic bacteria from municipal and handmade textile factory wastewater, all samples were analyzed before and after the photocatalytic reaction by using the Merck membrane filtration method (method 9222) [16]. Coliforms Chromocult ® agar was used as the culture medium. The results obtained are reported as colony forming units (CFU)/100 mL of wastewater sample.
In the case of the stained wastewater from the textile factories, discoloration was also analyzed by UV-Vis spectrophotometry with a Thermo Scientific Evolution 300 spectrophotometer. The main absorption signal presented in these effluents was observed at 450 nm. Samples were collected after 30, 60, 120, 180, and 240 min. The percentage of discoloration was calculated by using Equation (1).
where: A = absorbance value of the starting sample at 450 nm; and B = absorbance value of the sample after a determined reaction time.
Considering the complex composition of the coal mining wastewater samples, only photocatalysts showing promising results in the treatment of municipal and stained wastewater were selected to be evaluated in the treatment of the acidic mining drainage. In this case, the effectiveness of the photocatalysts employed was determined by the removal of heavy metals. Thus, the concentration of these pollutants was evaluated using atomic absorption spectroscopy in a Shimadzu AA-7000 spectrophotometer. All samples (from the liquid phase or solid catalysts) were subjected to acidic digestion by the addition of 3 mL of HNO 3 (c) at 180 • C for 30 min (method 3010 from the SMEWW) [16].
In order to ensure the reproducibility and reliability of the obtained results, selected photocatalytic reactions and all of the physicochemical analyses were carried out twice. Herein, we report the values from the arithmetic average obtained for all the results, and the standard deviation was also calculated.

Characterization of the ZnO-Based Composites
Compositional, structural, and spectroscopic analysis of the ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 and ZnOmalachite composites showed the different properties of the photocatalysts. The results for ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 have been previously reported [14]; therefore, the current study provides only an overview.
As shown in Table 1, the chemical composition of the analyzed materials determined by XRF agrees with the theoretical values, thus indicating a good incorporation of Ag 3 PO 4 and Cu 2 (OH) 2 CO 3 in the ZnO matrix. Table 1 also shows the specific surface area values for all the samples. The value for ZnO is 30.20 m 2 /g and decreases with the incorporation of Ag 3 PO 4 and malachite in the composites due to the much lower surface area of the phosphate and malachite (2.7 m 2 /g in both cases). This effect is more evident as the phosphate content increases; the surface area of the composite with 50% phosphate addition decreased to 17.27 m 2 /g. N 2 adsorption-desorption curves are presented as supplementary material in Figures S1 and S2. As can be seen in these figures, no significant differences were observed after Ag 3 PO 4 or malachite incorporation into the ZnO matrix. However, it is evident that all materials present a type III isotherm with the H1 hysteresis loop [17], and the behavior of the N 2 adsorption-desorption isotherms is the same regardless of the type and amount of dopant used. The band-gap values for selected composites were determined by UV-Vis DRS spectrophotometry (Table 1). It can be observed that after the coupling of ZnO and Ag 3 PO 4 , the ZnO band-gap value decreased. It is worth noting that the lowest value was obtained with the addition of less Ag 3 PO 4 (5%); the value then increased as the phosphate content increased. Figure 1 shows the UV-Vis DR spectra for ZnO and the composites. In this figure, the absorption for ZnO, Ag 3 PO 4 , and malachite located between 200 and 450 nm is very high. When ZnO was coupled with the modifying agents, its absorption increased significantly in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum. This absorption in the visible region increased as the Ag 3 PO 4 or malachite content increased. Regarding the ZnO-M materials, no significant differences were observed with DRS, which may be because malachite is found in low concentrations in ZnO. A high absorption shoulder was observed in the visible range, which may be indicative of the presence of this material because the spectrum of the precursor material also presents a high absorption value in the visible range. This characteristic can be assigned to the Cu(II) d-d transition [18].
Water 2021, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 14 and the behavior of the N2 adsorption-desorption isotherms is the same regardless of the type and amount of dopant used. The band-gap values for selected composites were determined by UV-Vis DRS spectrophotometry (Table 1). It can be observed that after the coupling of ZnO and Ag3PO4, the ZnO band-gap value decreased. It is worth noting that the lowest value was obtained with the addition of less Ag3PO4 (5%); the value then increased as the phosphate content increased.  Figure 1 shows the UV-Vis DR spectra for ZnO and the composites. In this figure, the absorption for ZnO, Ag3PO4, and malachite located between 200 and 450 nm is very high. When ZnO was coupled with the modifying agents, its absorption increased significantly in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum. This absorption in the visible region increased as the Ag3PO4 or malachite content increased. Regarding the ZnO-M materials, no significant differences were observed with DRS, which may be because malachite is found in low concentrations in ZnO. A high absorption shoulder was observed in the visible range, which may be indicative of the presence of this material because the spectrum of the precursor material also presents a high absorption value in the visible range. This characteristic can be assigned to the Cu(II) d-d transition [18].    XRD patterns of the different samples are depicted in Figure 2. For the ZnO/Ag3PO4 composites (Figure 2a), the characteristic peaks for Ag3PO4 and ZnO can be observed with a cubic phase and Wurtzite structure, respectively. The increase in Ag3PO4 content leads to a gradual increase in the intensity of the signal (200) corresponding to phosphate, while the intensity of the signals for ZnO decreases.   Only peaks corresponding to ZnO Wurtzite can be observed. Even for the sample with the highest malachite content, no peaks associated with this mineral can be seen. This is probably due to the low amount and good dispersion of malachite on the ZnO matrix; however, the XRF results show that in the ZnO-M materials there are different Cu concentrations, which are dependent on the nominal amount added during synthesis.
The morphology and composition of the studied materials were analyzed by SEM and selected images are presented in Figures 3 and 4. As can be seen in Figure 3, Ag 3 PO 4 is heterogeneously dispersed in ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%) and ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (10%). On the other side, the ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (50%) material is present as a homogeneous dispersion of aggregates with a diameter of 50 nm on the ZnO particles (25 nm).
The morphology and composition of the studied materials were analyzed by SEM and selected images are presented in Figures 3 and 4. As can be seen in Figure 3, Ag3PO4 is heterogeneously dispersed in ZnO/Ag3PO4 (5%) and ZnO/Ag3PO4 (10%). On the other side, the ZnO/Ag3PO4 (50%) material is present as a homogeneous dispersion of aggregates with a diameter of 50 nm on the ZnO particles (25 nm). Figure 4 shows images of ZnO-M composites. Here, it is possible to identify ZnO particles with a shape like rice grains. In the case of malachite, the morphology of this mineral is more regular with round structures and a flower shape.

Municipal Wastewater
Citrobacter spp., E. coli, Salmonella sp., and coliforms were the main species of bacteria present in the studied municipal wastewater samples (samples taken from a river). During the photocatalytic tests, samples from the reactor were taken at different times: 30, 60, 120, 180, and 240 min. For all the photocatalysts tested, the number of bacteria of all of these species decreased as the photoreaction time increased.
The results obtained from the removal of bacteria after 240 min of photocatalytic treatment are presented in Table 2. As expected, the bacteria were sensitive to UV-Vis light, leading to a decrease in their number during the photolysis tests performed under illumination without a catalyst.   Figure 4 shows images of ZnO-M composites. Here, it is possible to identify ZnO particles with a shape like rice grains. In the case of malachite, the morphology of this mineral is more regular with round structures and a flower shape.

Municipal Wastewater
Citrobacter spp., E. coli, Salmonella sp., and coliforms were the main species of bacteria present in the studied municipal wastewater samples (samples taken from a river). During the photocatalytic tests, samples from the reactor were taken at different times: 30, 60, 120, 180, and 240 min. For all the photocatalysts tested, the number of bacteria of all of these species decreased as the photoreaction time increased.
The results obtained from the removal of bacteria after 240 min of photocatalytic treatment are presented in Table 2. As expected, the bacteria were sensitive to UV-Vis light, leading to a decrease in their number during the photolysis tests performed under illumination without a catalyst. When ZnO or any of the composites were added to the reactor, the elimination of bacteria increased significantly, thus showing the bactericidal effect of the photocatalytic process. This effect is mainly caused by the generation of radical oxygen species, which are responsible for the breakup of the plasma membrane [19][20][21]. Malachite was also observed to be less effective than ZnO in the elimination of coliforms, but it also had a bactericidal effect conferred by the presence of Cu in its structure.
In order to improve the photocatalytic performance of ZnO, this semiconductor was combined with malachite. The addition of 2.5% of malachite resulted in the complete elimination of Citrobacter spp. and E. coli after 240 min of treatment; however, other species were still detected in the sample. In both cases, malachite can act as an electron sink that can facilitate charge transfer, leading to a better gap-electron separation [15].
It can also be observed that in the ZnO-M materials there is a synergistic effect between the zinc oxide and the malachite in the elimination of bacteria that is directly proportional to the malachite content. This significantly exceeds the effect caused by the bare materials. Ag 3 PO 4 was also tested as a modifying agent for ZnO as shown in Table 2. This compound is more effective in the removal of bacteria than ZnO and malachite. As a result, the ZnO-Ag 3 PO 4 combination significantly improves the effectiveness of the semiconductor in the elimination of bacteria. The complete elimination of all enteropathogenic species from the municipal wastewater was achieved after 300 min of total reaction time by using the photocatalyst prepared by the addition of 5% of Ag 3 PO 4 to ZnO (i.e., ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%)).
An increase in the content of Ag 3 PO 4 above 5% had a detrimental effect on the photocatalytic activity of ZnO, which may have been due to the possible obstruction of active sites on the ZnO surface.
Besides the microbiological analysis, a complete physicochemical analysis of the wastewater samples was also carried out. A comparative presentation of the TOC analysis results is included in Figure 5. As shown in the figure, the highest TOC removal value was achieved by using the photocatalyst labeled ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%), with a final TOC value of 6.5 mg/L. Parameters such as pH, alkalinity, hardness, and chloride content, which are presented in Table 3, remained almost constant after the photocatalytic treatment. These results show that photocatalytic phenomena have priority over the adsorption processes for ionic species, such as chlorides and carbonates, on the photocatalysts' surface.
tocatalytic activity of ZnO, which may have been due to the possible obstruction of active sites on the ZnO surface.
Besides the microbiological analysis, a complete physicochemical analysis of the wastewater samples was also carried out. A comparative presentation of the TOC analysis results is included in Figure 5. As shown in the figure, the highest TOC removal value was achieved by using the photocatalyst labeled ZnO/Ag3PO4 (5%), with a final TOC value of 6.5 mg/L.

Handmade Textile Factory Wastewater
Citrobacter spp. were not detected in the handmade textile staining wastewater samples. For the rest of studied bacteria species, a similar behavior to that observed in the municipal wastewater treatment was found (Section 3.2.1); i.e., it was also determined that the highest bactericidal efficiency was obtained by using ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%) as a photocatalyst (Table 4). The addition of malachite to ZnO increased the effectiveness of ZnO in removing bacteria. The sample with 2.5% of malachite was the best photocatalyst in this series. The addition of Ag 3 PO 4 also considerably increased the effectiveness of ZnO in removing bacteria. This resulted in the sample with the lowest content of phosphate (5%) being the one with the best photocatalytic activity. An increase in the silver phosphate content had a detrimental effect on the overall effectiveness of the photocatalytic treatment, probably due to a screening effect of the phosphate on the surface-active sites of ZnO.
On the other hand, the TOC analyses ( Figure 6) showed that the handmade textile staining effluents had a higher TOC content than that observed in the municipal wastewater samples due to the high content of organic dyestuffs present in these effluents. In this case, ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (10%) yielded the lowest TOC value after 240 min of treatment; however, all photocatalytic tests achieved TOC values lower than 800 mg/L. The addition of malachite to ZnO increased the effectiveness of ZnO in removing bacteria. The sample with 2.5% of malachite was the best photocatalyst in this series. The addition of Ag3PO4 also considerably increased the effectiveness of ZnO in removing bacteria. This resulted in the sample with the lowest content of phosphate (5%) being the one with the best photocatalytic activity. An increase in the silver phosphate content had a detrimental effect on the overall effectiveness of the photocatalytic treatment, probably due to a screening effect of the phosphate on the surface-active sites of ZnO. On the other hand, the TOC analyses ( Figure 6) showed that the handmade textile staining effluents had a higher TOC content than that observed in the municipal wastewater samples due to the high content of organic dyestuffs present in these effluents. In this case, ZnO/Ag3PO4 (10%) yielded the lowest TOC value after 240 min of treatment; however, all photocatalytic tests achieved TOC values lower than 800 mg/L. Photodegradation of dyestuffs in the handmade textile staining wastewater samples during the photocatalytic treatment was evaluated by measuring the percentage of discoloration after the treatment ( Table 5). The highest dyestuffs removal value (73.63%) was obtained by using the ZnO/Ag3PO4 (5%) photocatalyst. This result is consistent with the TOC analysis results (Figure 6). Photodegradation of dyestuffs in the handmade textile staining wastewater samples during the photocatalytic treatment was evaluated by measuring the percentage of discoloration after the treatment ( Table 5). The highest dyestuffs removal value (73.63%) was obtained by using the ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%) photocatalyst. This result is consistent with the TOC analysis results ( Figure 6).

Coal Mining Wastewater
The acid mining drainage (AMD) evaluated in this study was primarily composed of iron and copper. Other metals were not detected in the analyzed samples; however, they could be present in amounts lower than the detection limit of the atomic absorption spectroscopy technique.
The Fe and Cu concentrations present in the AMD before and after photocatalytic treatment using ZnO and the composite catalysts are reported in Table 6. The Colombian regulations indicate a maximum amount of 2 mg/L of total iron in AMD; however, as shown in this table, the content of this metal significantly exceeds the maximum level (9 mg/L). For this reason, it is very important to find strategies for the treatment of AMD that are focused on the removal of the metals in these effluents before they are poured into the drain or natural water sources. According to Colombia's national regulations for Cu content in AMD, the maximum permissible level is 1 mg/L. In the studied samples, the value of this parameter was under the maximum value (0.20 mg/L); however, it is also important to try to decrease the content of this metal in the wastewater. Table 6 shows the degree of iron and copper removal from the coal mine wastewater after 120 min of photocatalytic treatment using the different photocatalysts. Metals present in the wastewater, such as Cu and iron, can be photocatalytically reduced on the catalyst's surface [9,[22][23][24][25][26] and thus removed from the water. The catalysts were analyzed after each reaction, and it was found that the content of metals removed from the liquid phase passed to the catalyst's surface. The photocatalyst ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (10%) had estimated concentrations of Fe and Cu of 6.43 mg/L and 0.08 mg/mL, respectively. On the other hand, ZnO-M (2.5%) had an Fe concentration of 6.39 mg/mL and no result was obtained for Cu since it was below the limit of detection using this technique.
The highest Fe and Cu removal value was achieved by using ZnO-M (2.5%) and ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (10%). With these materials, it was possible to decrease the Fe and Cu content in the liquid phase to values lower than those permitted by Colombian regulations. As can also be seen in Table 6, the iron content decreased during the blank test (under UV-Vis light and without photocatalyst). This may have been due to the reduction of this metal on the reactor's surface as evidenced by the change in the color of that element after the photoreaction. In the case of Cu, the reduction in the metal content was negligible.

Conclusions
Enteropathogenic bacteria, dyestuffs, and metals were detected in the municipal and industrial wastewater studied and their removal was attempted by photocatalytic treatment using ZnO and ZnO-malachite and ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 composites.
In order to improve the effectiveness of the photocatalytic treatment, ZnO was modified by the addition of different concentrations of silver phosphate and malachite. Using physicochemical characterization, it was possible to observe that the addition of these compounds did not significantly change the starting properties of the zinc oxide. However, the addition of phosphate or malachite to ZnO considerably improved its photocatalytic efficiency in the overall effectiveness of the treatment.
In general, throughout all the photocatalytic tests performed, the greatest effectiveness in the removal of pollutants (bacteria, dyestuffs, and metals) was achieved by using the ZnO/Ag 3 PO 4 (5%) and ZnO-malachite (2.5%) composites. This led to final values of contaminants within the values allowed by Colombian regulations for treated waters. As a consequence of these results, the photocatalysts studied could allow for wastewater to be recycled for uses such as irrigation and industrial activities according to the amounts of enteropathogenic bacteria, discoloration levels, and Fe and Cu concentrations. Further studies remain necessary to gain a deeper understanding of all the parameters considered in Colombia's regulations.