Catalytic Performance of Calcium Titanate for Catalytic Decomposition of Waste Polypropylene to Carbon Nanotubes in a Single-Stage CVD Reactor

: Calcium titanate mixed metal oxides with di ﬀ erent contents were used as supports for NiMo catalyst prepared by the sol–gel method. The activities of these catalysts were tested in the catalytic decomposition of waste polypropylene (PP) for the synthesis of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) using a single-stage chemical vapor deposition technique. The physico-chemical properties of the catalysts and deposited carbon over the catalysts were checked by X-ray di ﬀ raction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), temperature-programmed reduction (TPR), N 2 physisorption, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Raman spectroscopy, and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA). The TEM and XRD results presented a high dispersion of the active metal species on the surface of the support materials. The result showed that increasing the support content led to an increased crystallite size of the catalysts and a resultant reduction in CNTs yield from 44% to 35%. NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalyst displayed good catalytic activity and stability toward CNTs growth. Furthermore, the e ﬀ ect of calcination temperature on the morphology, yield, and quality of CNTs was also studied, and it was observed that thermal treatment up to 700 ◦ C could produce well graphitized, high-quality, and high-yield CNTs from the waste PP.

Considering the enormous global demand and application of CNTs, it is plausible that the cost of production is minimized while yield and quality are maximized. Accordingly, 'sleeping treasure' waste active metal, leading to reduced catalytic activity [42,50,51]. For example, Yahya and co-workers [52] studied and compared the catalytic activities of CaTiO 3 and commercial CaO as catalysts during the catalytic production of biodiesel from waste cooking oil. They found that for 1 wt % CaTiO 3 catalyst loading calcined at 400 • C, high biodiesel yield up to 80% was produced compared to commercial CaO catalyst with 60% biodiesel yield under the same reaction conditions of methanol to oil ratio of 15:1 at 65 • C for 60 min. In a patented study by Baker and Summit [53], the catalytic activity of CaO-TiO 2 was compared with fresh commercial silica-alumina (SiO 2 -Al 2 O 3 ) catalyst containing about 13% alumina during the catalytic cracking of light gas oil (East Texas) feed in a fixed bed reactor at a boiling range of 490-700 • F under atmospheric pressure. Their result showed that CaO-TiO 2 catalyst produced a higher yield (24.4 wt %) of more olefinic C 5 -430 • F gasoline with better performance (with bromine number of about 81 cg./mL) than C 5 -430 • F gasoline yield of 23.0 wt % and 40 cg/mL bromine number obtained with SiO 2 -Al 2 O 3 catalyst. Similarly, in the same invention by Baker and Summit, 5% NiO supported on 95% CaO-TiO 2 catalyst was also utilized as a reforming catalyst in the dehydrogenation of methylcyclopentene feed into the aromatic hydrocarbon containing benzene and its activity was compared with the conventional reforming catalyst 90% Al 2 O 3 -10% MoO 3 under 2/1 H 2 to hydrocarbon dilution at 200 p.s.i.g. (pounds per square in gauge) and 975 • F; their result showed that more aromatic hydrocarbons at about 28% of feed were produced with 5% NiO-95% CaO-TiO 2 catalyst relative to the conventional reforming 90% Al 2 O 3 -10% MoO 3 catalyst [53].
Although several studies have investigated the activity of NiMo-based catalyst to catalyze the decomposition of hydrocarbons for CNTs production from single pure and waste polymers, available studies on NiMo catalysts for the pyrolysis of waste PP using a single-stage CVD technique are rather limited. Additionally, the yield and quality of as-produced carbon deposited over NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalyst using waste PP have not been systematically investigated. Therefore, this study explored the use of bimetallic NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalysts in the valorization of waste PP into CNTs using a single-stage chemical vapor deposition method. The effect of catalyst support loading and catalyst thermal treatment condition on the yield, quality, and morphology of deposited carbon were also studied.

Catalyst Synthesis and Characterization
The XRD patterns of NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalysts with different CaTiO 3 content (NMC412 and NMC414) are shown in Figure 1. The XRD patterns of both NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalysts reveal characteristic diffraction peaks of NiO at 2θ = 37.2 • , 43.2 • , 62.9 • , 75.3 • and 79.4 • that correspond to the (1 1 1), (2 0 0), (2 2 0), (3 1 1), and (2 2 2) planes, respectively, were observed [30,54]. Six resolved peaks attributed to CaTiO 3 at 2θ = 33.0 • , 47 [45,55]. For both catalysts, NiO and CaTiO 3 crystals could be identified on the catalyst surface. However, the XRD pattern of NMC414 catalyst show more sharp diffraction peaks for CaTiO 3 (2θ = 33.2 • ), signifying the degree of increase in the crystallite size of the catalyst. Similarly, NiO of large particle size was produced by the NMC414 catalyst. The corresponding average crystallite size of the main phases present in both catalysts is 9.2 nm and 10.1 nm for NMC412 and 11.4 nm and 14.8 nm for NMC414. The above result is in support of Scherrer's equation, which links large metal crystallite sizes to sharp and intense diffraction peaks, while broad peaks are associated with smaller crystallite-sized particles [56]. For both catalysts, several overlaps were observed: the diffraction peaks at 2θ = 59.  [55], where an anatase TiO 2 phase was observed at 2θ = 24.5 • . The morphology of both catalysts (NMC412 and NMC414) obtained from TEM are depicted in Figure 2. The NMC414 catalyst showed a random irregular structure with an estimated mean average particle diameter of about 16.7 nm, while the NMC412 catalyst displayed an almost well-rounded platelet-like structure with an estimated mean diameter of about 9 nm; they also depict a good dispersion of particles on the surface of the support. These results are consistent with the XRD patterns for the samples. Liu et al. [32] reported similar smaller Ni particle sizes between 8 and 13 nm for Ni-based catalysts. Therefore, TEM images showed that by increasing the support content in the catalyst, the diameter of Ni particles also increases; hence, large particle size distribution was observed on the NMC414 catalyst compared to the NMC412 catalyst. The morphology of both catalysts (NMC412 and NMC414) obtained from TEM are depicted in Figure 2. The NMC414 catalyst showed a random irregular structure with an estimated mean average particle diameter of about 16.7 nm, while the NMC412 catalyst displayed an almost well-rounded platelet-like structure with an estimated mean diameter of about 9 nm; they also depict a good dispersion of particles on the surface of the support. These results are consistent with the XRD patterns for the samples. Liu et al. [32] reported similar smaller Ni particle sizes between 8 and 13 nm for Ni-based catalysts. Therefore, TEM images showed that by increasing the support content in the catalyst, the diameter of Ni particles also increases; hence, large particle size distribution was observed on the NMC414 catalyst compared to the NMC412 catalyst.
Temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) investigation was carried out to study the reducibility of both catalysts in order to deduce their interaction between the metal oxide (NiO) species and the CaTiO 3 support. The TPR profile of two catalysts under study is shown in Figure 3. Distinct and broad reduction peaks were observed for both catalysts with different CaTiO 3 compositions. For the NMC414 catalyst, the first reduction peak in the range of 350-427 • C with two well-defined divisions, with maximum at 380 • C and 403 • C, were attributed to the reduction of Ni 2+ in the crystalline NiO phase [30] and the reduction of TiO 2 phases (whose single phase was detected by XRD), respectively [55]. It has been reported that the reduction of unsupported NiO to atomic Ni occurs around 200 • C, while supported NiO is reduced at a rather higher temperature range [57]. For the NMC412 catalyst, the first reduction peak appeared at the range of 420-538 • C with a maximum at 480 • C, which was attributed to the reduction of NiO. This higher reduction temperature could be due to the smaller NiO particle size for the NMC412 catalyst compared to the NMC414 catalyst, since it was reported that catalysts with small metal oxide particles require high temperature to be reduced to their metallic stable forms [32]. Temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) investigation was carried out to study the reducibility of both catalysts in order to deduce their interaction between the metal oxide (NiO) species and the CaTiO3 support. The TPR profile of two catalysts under study is shown in Figure 3. Distinct and broad reduction peaks were observed for both catalysts with different CaTiO3 compositions. For the NMC414 catalyst, the first reduction peak in the range of 350-427 °C with two well-defined divisions, with maximum at 380 °C and 403 °C, were attributed to the reduction of Ni 2+ in the crystalline NiO phase [30] and the reduction of TiO2 phases (whose single phase was detected by XRD), respectively [55]. It has been reported that the reduction of unsupported NiO to atomic Ni occurs around 200 °C, while supported NiO is reduced at a rather higher temperature range [57]. For the NMC412 catalyst, the first reduction peak appeared at the range of 420-538 °C with a maximum Another broad peak that appeared as a shoulder at 576 • C was observed for the NMC412 catalyst, and the similar peak slightly disappears for the NMC414 catalyst due to the appearance of segregated phases. The broad peak in the range of 570-610 • C with a maximum at 576 • C could be attributed to the reduction of less thermally stable NiO-CaTiO 3 compounds as well as the reduction of Mo species as confirmed by XRD [57]. The interaction between NiO and CaTiO 3 resulted in the incorporation of Ca 2+ into NiO crystallites, which poses difficulty in the disruption of the Ni-O bond [58]. begin at a temperature above 700 °C [55]. By increasing the support content in the bulk catalyst (i.e., NMC414), the reduction peak at 650-782 °C has a maximum at 710 °C, which was lower than the observed peak for the NMC412 catalyst, signifying a reduced interaction between the catalyst metal oxide species and the support. Hence, strong and more interaction was observed for the NMC412 catalyst (that is, between the metal oxide species) than for the NMC414 catalyst. The morphology of the two catalysts with different support content was determined by SEM analysis, as shown in Figure 4. These results showed almost dissimilar aggregates of catalyst particles for both catalysts. The NMC412 catalyst depicts more porous, more defined morphology and smoother particle than the NMC414 catalyst. The NMC414 catalyst displayed a compacted-stack structure, which could be due to the presence of more CaTiO3 content in the catalyst resulting in different aggregated degrees of the catalyst particles. A larger and stronger peak was observed at a high reduction temperature for the NMC412 catalyst in the temperature range of 712-802 • C with a maximum at 748 • C; this peak could be related to the complete reduction of the MoO 2 phase as shown in the XRD pattern due to its metallic form and could be associated to the reduction of the Ni-Mo-O phase. This could also be attributed to the reduction of the thermally stable calcium compound CaMoO 4 , whose reduction has been reported to begin at a temperature above 700 • C [55]. By increasing the support content in the bulk catalyst (i.e., NMC414), the reduction peak at 650-782 • C has a maximum at 710 • C, which was lower than the observed peak for the NMC412 catalyst, signifying a reduced interaction between the catalyst metal oxide species and the support. Hence, strong and more interaction was observed for the NMC412 catalyst (that is, between the metal oxide species) than for the NMC414 catalyst.
The morphology of the two catalysts with different support content was determined by SEM analysis, as shown in Figure 4. These results showed almost dissimilar aggregates of catalyst particles for both catalysts. The NMC412 catalyst depicts more porous, more defined morphology and smoother particle than the NMC414 catalyst. The NMC414 catalyst displayed a compacted-stack structure, which could be due to the presence of more CaTiO 3 content in the catalyst resulting in different aggregated degrees of the catalyst particles. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) analysis was used to determine the elements present on some spots on the catalyst surface, as shown in Figure 5. Analysis of EDXS result peaks in keV showed that all elements of interest in the catalyst mix were all found. Table S3 disclosed the composition of elements in NMC412 and NMC414 catalysts, respectively. This also revealed that the stoichiometric ratio of CaTiO3 present in Figure 5B is higher than that in Figure 5A.  Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) analysis was used to determine the elements present on some spots on the catalyst surface, as shown in Figure 5. Analysis of EDXS result peaks in keV showed that all elements of interest in the catalyst mix were all found. Table S3 disclosed the composition of elements in NMC412 and NMC414 catalysts, respectively. This also revealed that the stoichiometric ratio of CaTiO 3 present in Figure 5B is higher than that in Figure 5A. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) analysis was used to determine the elements present on some spots on the catalyst surface, as shown in Figure 5. Analysis of EDXS result peaks in keV showed that all elements of interest in the catalyst mix were all found. Table S3 disclosed the composition of elements in NMC412 and NMC414 catalysts, respectively. This also revealed that the stoichiometric ratio of CaTiO3 present in Figure 5B is higher than that in Figure 5A.

Effect of Support Composition and Content on the Microstructure, Yield, and Quality of CNTs
The microstructure of the carbon nanomaterial deposited on the surface of catalysts is shown in Figure 6. The carbon deposits were majorly a filamentous type of carbon in the tubular-like form identified as multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) with their length up to a few micrometers. The numbers of the walls were mainly in the range of 10-15 (see high-resolution TEM images in Figure 6a,b). The absence of radial breathing mode (RBM), a characteristic of SWCNT [59], was confirmed in Figure S1 for all as-grown CNTs over both catalysts. A very small proportion of amorphous and disordered carbon was also detected. It is noteworthy to mention that amongst the MWCNTs deposited on the surface of the NMC414 catalyst, carbon nanofibers (CNFs) with few broken and deformed nanotubes were also deposited. The diameter distribution of MWCNTs obtained from the two different catalysts of diverse support content is shown in Figure 6. Long, smooth, and twisted MWCNTs with outer diameters ranging from 5 to 35 nm were obtained from MWCNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst; this correlates with the XRD and TEM particle size results. Rough-edged and larger diameter MWCNTs with an outer diameter in the range of 12 to 36 nm were produced over the NMC414 catalyst. It could be suggested that a smaller particle-sized catalyst yielded long, smoother, and small diameter MWCNTs. This result agrees with what is reported in the literature: the size of active metal particles controls the diameter as well as growth of CNTs [60,61]. confirmed in Figure S1 for all as-grown CNTs over both catalysts. A very small proportion of amorphous and disordered carbon was also detected. It is noteworthy to mention that amongst the MWCNTs deposited on the surface of the NMC414 catalyst, carbon nanofibers (CNFs) with few broken and deformed nanotubes were also deposited. The diameter distribution of MWCNTs obtained from the two different catalysts of diverse support content is shown in Figure 6. Long, smooth, and twisted MWCNTs with outer diameters ranging from 5 to 35 nm were obtained from MWCNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst; this correlates with the XRD and TEM particle size results. Rough-edged and larger diameter MWCNTs with an outer diameter in the range of 12 to 36 nm were produced over the NMC414 catalyst. It could be suggested that a smaller particle-sized catalyst yielded long, smoother, and small diameter MWCNTs. This result agrees with what is reported in the literature: the size of active metal particles controls the diameter as well as growth of CNTs [60,61].
The yield of CNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst was obtained to be 44%, while the NMC414 catalyst yielded about 35% CNTs. The above result also reveals that support material composition and content is significant and has a noticeable influence on the catalytic performance toward CNTs yield. Similarly, the above result could be due to the smaller metal particle size of the NMC412 catalyst relative to the NMC414 catalyst, as confirmed from XRD and TEM results. According to the study by Yao et al. [56] they reported that Ni/α-Al2O3 catalyst with a smaller metal particle size produced higher CNTs yield (26.1 wt. %) than Ni/γ-Al2O3 catalyst (21.1 wt. %). The authors suggested this could probably be due to smaller metal particles on the catalyst surface, which facilitated carbon atom diffusion, nucleation, and nanotubes growth at the interface, ultimately resulting in higher CNTs yield. It could be confirmed that there is a connection among CNTs yield, the crystallite size of NiO, and the CaTiO3 content in the catalyst, which resulted in a higher CNTs yield. Accordingly, smaller crystallite-sized active sites (in this case NiO) result in high carbon yield [61]. The yield of CNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst was obtained to be 44%, while the NMC414 catalyst yielded about 35% CNTs. The above result also reveals that support material composition and content is significant and has a noticeable influence on the catalytic performance toward CNTs yield. Similarly, the above result could be due to the smaller metal particle size of the NMC412 catalyst relative to the NMC414 catalyst, as confirmed from XRD and TEM results. According to the study by Yao et al. [56] they reported that Ni/α-Al 2 O 3 catalyst with a smaller metal particle size produced higher CNTs yield (26.1 wt. %) than Ni/γ-Al 2 O 3 catalyst (21.1 wt. %). The authors suggested this could probably be due to smaller metal particles on the catalyst surface, which facilitated carbon atom diffusion, nucleation, and nanotubes growth at the interface, ultimately resulting in higher CNTs yield. It could be confirmed that there is a connection among CNTs yield, the crystallite size of NiO, and the CaTiO 3 content in the catalyst, which resulted in a higher CNTs yield. Accordingly, smaller crystallite-sized active sites (in this case NiO) result in high carbon yield [61].
To study the quality and graphitization degree of as-produced CNTs, Raman analysis was conducted. The Raman spectra of MWCNTs produced over the two catalysts under study are illustrated in Figure S1. Three different bands are seen on the spectrum for each CNTs; the G-band at about 1580 cm −1 is an indication of the presence of ordered and graphitized carbon. The D-band around 1352 cm −1 is attributed to the presence of amorphous or disordered carbon atoms in the CNTs [62], while the G ' band (2D-band) obtained at 2691 cm −1 is linked to the second-order two-photon process. It indicates the presence of parallel graphitic layers in CNTs [63]. The peak intensity ratios I G /I D and I G' /I G are used to investigate the quality and degree of graphitization of CNTs; it is also an indication of defects in the graphitic structure [22]. Therefore, a higher I G /I D ratio suggests high-quality and well-graphitized CNTs, while a high I G' /I G ratio also suggests high-purity CNTs [64]. A very distinctive 2D-band (G' band) appeared in all CNTs deposited over both catalysts, indicating that CNTs formed from both catalysts are of high purity and possess more parallel graphitic layers. For the MWCNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst, an I G /I D ratio of 1.15 and I G' /I G ratio of 0.80 were obtained; while the produced MWCNTs over the NMC414 catalyst have an I G /I D ratio of 0.96 and an I G' /I G ratio of 0.84. The above results suggest the presence of defects on the CNTs obtained from both catalysts, but the CNTs deposited over the NMC412 catalyst possess fewer defects and have higher quality and a higher degree of structural ordering than those obtained over the NMC414 catalyst. Therefore, it could be concluded that the microstructure, yield, and quality of MWCNTs obtained are strongly affected by the CaTiO 3 content in the parent catalyst because of the optimum interaction between the support and the Ni-active metal. It is worthwhile comparing this work with other studies in the literature that employed the use of waste PP as a carbon source for CNTs synthesis with respect to the quality and yield of CNTs obtained. Mishra et al. [65] also utilized a single-stage CVD reactor in their study; waste PP was the used carbon precursor in the presence of unsupported Ni catalyst. They reported a good graphitic CNTs yield of 19% with their outer diameter in the range of 10-20 nm. Bajad and co-workers [66] also synthesized CNTs from waste PP in a batch reactor using NiMo-supported MgO catalyst; their obtained yield was 3.2 g CNTs/6 g PP with 40-60 nm outer diameter CNTs of lower quality reported.
It could be concluded that CaTiO 3 support in the NiMo catalyst mix resulted in small diameter and a high yield of CNTs of good quality.

The Effect of Calcination Temperatures on the Yield and Quality of CNTs
The effect of variation in calcination temperature (600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C) on NiMo/CaTiO3 catalyst prepared at molar ratios of 4:1:2 (designated as NMC412) was studied to evaluate its influence on the yield, microstructure, and quality of as-produced CNTs. The investigation was carried out on NMC412 catalyst calcined at 600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C.
The textural property of the NMC412 catalyst at different calcination temperatures was obtained via N 2 physisorption at −196 • C (see Table 1 for the results). It could be observed that there is a progressive decrease in the specific surface area and pore volume of the catalysts as the calcination temperature increases from 600 to 800 • C. This result is expected based on what was reported in the literature: at high calcination temperature, the wall porous structures of materials collapse, and this leads to their lower total surface area [41,58]. Furthermore, the low BET (Brunauer-Emmett-Teller) surface area for all the catalyst calcined from 600 to 800 • C could be due to the agglomeration of metal particles at elevated temperature or due to catalyst precursor (additive) composition and/or catalyst preparation technique [37]. Although no direct comparison could be obtained from the literature, studies by Pfaff [50] and Liu and co-workers [67] presented similar reductions in surface and pore volume with increasing calcination temperature. The structural changes in the phases of NMC412 catalysts calcined at different temperatures were evaluated using XRD analysis, as depicted in Figure 7. The individual peaks corresponding to different phases were identified and labeled in the XRD spectra, as shown in Figure 7. It could be observed that as the calcination temperature increases, the identified peaks become sharper and more elongated, indicating an increased crystallite size of the catalysts [56] with increasing calcination temperature, while broader and shortened peaks disclose smaller crystallite size (600 • C < 700 • C < 800 • C), as shown in Table 2. A major change was identified with the 800 • C calcined catalyst with the appearance of additional metal stable phases of NiMoO 4 , CaMoO 4 , and tricalcium dititanium oxide (Ca 3 Ti 2 O 7 ) phases (the Ca 3 Ti 2 O 7 compound is a double perovskite sheet interwoven with CaO) [50]. The presence of thermally stable compounds inhibits catalyst deactivation and the agglomeration of NiO particles on the catalyst surface, disallowing the formation of excessive larger NiO particles [61]. This confirms that high calcination temperatures result in the emergence of thermally stable compounds in the catalysts, which builds up a strong interaction between the catalyst-active metal and the support. In addition, it was also observed that the crystallite size of all the phases of interest-that is, NiO and CaTiO 3 (Ca 3 Ti 2 O 7 )-increased as the thermal treatment temperature increased from 600 to 800 • C, as shown in Table 2. The structural changes in the phases of NMC412 catalysts calcined at different temperatures were evaluated using XRD analysis, as depicted in Figure 7. The individual peaks corresponding to different phases were identified and labeled in the XRD spectra, as shown in Figure 7. It could be observed that as the calcination temperature increases, the identified peaks become sharper and more elongated, indicating an increased crystallite size of the catalysts [56] with increasing calcination temperature, while broader and shortened peaks disclose smaller crystallite size (600 ℃ ˂ 700 ℃ ˂ 800 ℃), as shown in Table 2. A major change was identified with the 800 °C calcined catalyst with the appearance of additional metal stable phases of NiMoO4, CaMoO4, and tricalcium dititanium oxide (Ca3Ti2O7) phases (the Ca3Ti2O7 compound is a double perovskite sheet interwoven with CaO) [50]. The presence of thermally stable compounds inhibits catalyst deactivation and the agglomeration of NiO particles on the catalyst surface, disallowing the formation of excessive larger NiO particles [61]. This confirms that high calcination temperatures result in the emergence of thermally stable compounds in the catalysts, which builds up a strong interaction between the catalyst-active metal and the support. In addition, it was also observed that the crystallite size of all the phases of interest-that is, NiO and CaTiO3 (Ca3Ti2O7)-increased as the thermal treatment temperature increased from 600 to 800 °C, as shown in Table 2.    TPR was used to study the interaction between the Ni active phase and the support material of the catalysts prepared at different calcination temperatures, as illustrated in Figure 8. From the TPR profile, the peaks at 460 • C, 480 • C, and 484 • C for 600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C calcined catalysts respectively, could be attributed to the high-temperature reduction of the NiO species to Ni 0 due to its interaction with the support material. Again, the small crystallite size of the metal oxide could be the reason also for its high reduction temperature. It is also necessary to recall that crystallites with small size require high temperature to be reduced to their metallic form [32,68]. The profile for the 800 • C calcined catalyst shows somehow a shift to more complex peaks and a shoulder (plateau) at 631 • C, 691 • C, and 776 • C. This could be due to the presence of the larger amount of thermally stable phases present, as shown in the XRD pattern in Figure 7. The peaks ranging from 746 to 794 • C with a maximum at 776 • C could be associated with the reduction of the Ni-Mo-O phase [27,69] and some thermally stable NiMoO 4 and CaMoO 4 phases. The prevalence of more thermally stable phases in the catalysts increased as the calcination temperature increased from 600 to 800 • C, therefore enhancing the interaction between the catalyst and support. This occurrence of these phases helps enhance the stability and activity of NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalysts during CNTs nucleation and growth, and this in turn affects the overall performance of the catalyst to grow CNTs.
Catalysts 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 20 TPR was used to study the interaction between the Ni active phase and the support material of the catalysts prepared at different calcination temperatures, as illustrated in Figure 8. From the TPR profile, the peaks at 460 °C, 480 °C, and 484 °C for 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts respectively, could be attributed to the high-temperature reduction of the NiO species to Ni 0 due to its interaction with the support material. Again, the small crystallite size of the metal oxide could be the reason also for its high reduction temperature. It is also necessary to recall that crystallites with small size require high temperature to be reduced to their metallic form [32,68]. The profile for the 800 °C calcined catalyst shows somehow a shift to more complex peaks and a shoulder (plateau) at 631 °C, 691 °C, and 776 °C. This could be due to the presence of the larger amount of thermally stable phases present, as shown in the XRD pattern in Figure 7. The peaks ranging from 746 to 794 °C with a maximum at 776 °C could be associated with the reduction of the Ni-Mo-O phase [27,69] and some thermally stable NiMoO4 and CaMoO4 phases. The prevalence of more thermally stable phases in the catalysts increased as the calcination temperature increased from 600 to 800 °C, therefore enhancing the interaction between the catalyst and support. This occurrence of these phases helps enhance the stability and activity of NiMo/CaTiO3 catalysts during CNTs nucleation and growth, and this in turn affects the overall performance of the catalyst to grow CNTs. Evaluating the effect of different calcination temperature on the yield of MWCNTs shows that there was not much appreciable difference in the carbon yield as the calcination temperature increased from 600 to 800 °C. The carbon yield gradually increased from 43% at 600 °C to 44% at 700 °C and showed a little decline to 42% as the thermal treatment temperature was further increased to 800 °C. The decrease in carbon yield at 800 °C could be attributed to the excessive dominance of the thermally stable NiMoO4 and CaMoO4 species (as observed in the XRD pattern in Figure 7). Although their presence assisted in inhibiting the formation of large NiO particle mass, they also take up the active metal species, which are the bedrock for CNTs nucleation and growth, thereby reducing their availability for nucleation, resulting in low carbon yield [61].
The TEM micrographs of the as-produced carbon are shown in Figure 9. It could be observed that the presented filamentous hollow-core nanostructure indicates the presence of MWCNTs, although a few carbon nanofibers (CNFs) are present. The catalyst calcined at 600 °C showed long MWCNTs with large uniform outer diameter CNTs ranging from 11 to 60 nm and few surface-rugged Evaluating the effect of different calcination temperature on the yield of MWCNTs shows that there was not much appreciable difference in the carbon yield as the calcination temperature increased from 600 to 800 • C. The carbon yield gradually increased from 43% at 600 • C to 44% at 700 • C and showed a little decline to 42% as the thermal treatment temperature was further increased to 800 • C. The decrease in carbon yield at 800 • C could be attributed to the excessive dominance of the thermally stable NiMoO 4 and CaMoO 4 species (as observed in the XRD pattern in Figure 7). Although their presence assisted in inhibiting the formation of large NiO particle mass, they also take up the active metal species, which are the bedrock for CNTs nucleation and growth, thereby reducing their availability for nucleation, resulting in low carbon yield [61].
The TEM micrographs of the as-produced carbon are shown in Figure 9. It could be observed that the presented filamentous hollow-core nanostructure indicates the presence of MWCNTs, although a few carbon nanofibers (CNFs) are present. The catalyst calcined at 600 • C showed long MWCNTs with large uniform outer diameter CNTs ranging from 11 to 60 nm and few surface-rugged CNTs. The catalyst calcined at 800 • C produced short structured MWCNTs with an outer diameter in the range of 14-32 nm. The obtained short length MWCNTs could be a result of its large NiO crystallite size, as observed in Table 2. Studies in the literature have reported that increasing the calcination temperature of catalysts results in the loss of their porosity [50,68]. This is true as shown in the BET surface area and pore volume, as presented in Table 1. It is also evident that at high calcination temperature, NiO particles are prone to agglomerate, which could reduce the mobility of active species on the support, resulting in a reduction of carbon yield and/or reduction of the number of reducible NiO present in the bulk catalyst [43]. However, this study reveals that although the interaction of the NiO species could be strong, the good stability of the catalyst material still resulted in the growth of small diameter CNTs.
Catalysts 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 12 of 20 CNTs. The catalyst calcined at 800 °C produced short structured MWCNTs with an outer diameter in the range of 14-32 nm. The obtained short length MWCNTs could be a result of its large NiO crystallite size, as observed in Table 2. Studies in the literature have reported that increasing the calcination temperature of catalysts results in the loss of their porosity [50,68]. This is true as shown in the BET surface area and pore volume, as presented in Table 1. It is also evident that at high calcination temperature, NiO particles are prone to agglomerate, which could reduce the mobility of active species on the support, resulting in a reduction of carbon yield and/or reduction of the number of reducible NiO present in the bulk catalyst [43]. However, this study reveals that although the interaction of the NiO species could be strong, the good stability of the catalyst material still resulted in the growth of small diameter CNTs. The Raman spectra of as-grown CNTs deposited on NiMo/CaTiO3 catalyst prepared at various calcination temperatures are shown in Figure 10. The appearance of three major peaks (D-band, Gband, and G' or 2D-bands) could be seen on the spectrum for each CNT sample. The intensity ratios IG/ID of 1.00, 1.12, and 1.03 were obtained from CNTs deposited over 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts, respectively. The intensity ratio IG/ID is an indicator of the quality of CNTs [63]. Therefore, the relatively high IG/ID ratio of 1.12 for CNTs obtained over a 700 °C-treated catalyst indicates less defects or amorphous carbon within the graphite layer, unlike CNTs deposited on 600 °C and 800 °C calcined catalysts with a lower IG/ID ratio. Consequently, the 700 °C thermally treated catalyst showed less defective and higher quality and structurally ordered MWCNTs than 600 °C and The Raman spectra of as-grown CNTs deposited on NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalyst prepared at various calcination temperatures are shown in Figure 10. The appearance of three major peaks (D-band, G-band, and G' or 2D-bands) could be seen on the spectrum for each CNT sample. The intensity ratios I G /I D of 1.00, 1.12, and 1.03 were obtained from CNTs deposited over 600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C calcined catalysts, respectively. The intensity ratio I G /I D is an indicator of the quality of CNTs [63]. Therefore, the relatively high I G /I D ratio of 1.12 for CNTs obtained over a 700 • C-treated catalyst indicates less defects or amorphous carbon within the graphite layer, unlike CNTs deposited on 600 • C and 800 • C calcined catalysts with a lower I G /I D ratio. Consequently, the 700 • C thermally treated catalyst showed less defective and higher quality and structurally ordered MWCNTs than 600 • C and 800 • C catalysts. This result suggests that CNTs deposited on a 700 • C thermally-treated catalyst had more of an sp 2 hybridized in-plane graphitic structure than CNTs obtained on 600 • C and 800 • C calcined catalysts. The result from Raman spectra was in agreement with those of thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and TEM. This is an indication of the high quality of CNTs obtained over a bimetallic NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalyst mix, irrespective of their degree of thermal treatment.
Catalysts 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 13 of 20 800 °C catalysts. This result suggests that CNTs deposited on a 700 °C thermally-treated catalyst had more of an sp 2 hybridized in-plane graphitic structure than CNTs obtained on 600 °C and 800 °C calcined catalysts. The result from Raman spectra was in agreement with those of thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and TEM. This is an indication of the high quality of CNTs obtained over a bimetallic NiMo-supported CaTiO3 catalyst mix, irrespective of their degree of thermal treatment. Typically, model CNTs and graphite are reported to oxidize and decompose under O2 and inert environment at temperatures above 500 °C and 600 °C, respectively [70]. For all as-grown CNTs over 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts, weight loss started above 600 °C and 500 °C under inert and oxidizing environments, as indicated in Figure 11a,b, respectively. Weight losses were calculated to be 76.7%, 83.2%, and 75.0% for all CNTs deposited over 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts, respectively. However, the catalyst calcined at 600 °C produced the least thermally stable CNTs.  Typically, model CNTs and graphite are reported to oxidize and decompose under O 2 and inert environment at temperatures above 500 • C and 600 • C, respectively [70]. For all as-grown CNTs over 600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C calcined catalysts, weight loss started above 600 • C and 500 • C under inert and oxidizing environments, as indicated in Figure 11a,b, respectively. Weight losses were calculated to be 76.7%, 83.2%, and 75.0% for all CNTs deposited over 600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C calcined catalysts, respectively. However, the catalyst calcined at 600 • C produced the least thermally stable CNTs.
Catalysts 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 13 of 20 800 °C catalysts. This result suggests that CNTs deposited on a 700 °C thermally-treated catalyst had more of an sp 2 hybridized in-plane graphitic structure than CNTs obtained on 600 °C and 800 °C calcined catalysts. The result from Raman spectra was in agreement with those of thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and TEM. This is an indication of the high quality of CNTs obtained over a bimetallic NiMo-supported CaTiO3 catalyst mix, irrespective of their degree of thermal treatment. Typically, model CNTs and graphite are reported to oxidize and decompose under O2 and inert environment at temperatures above 500 °C and 600 °C, respectively [70]. For all as-grown CNTs over 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts, weight loss started above 600 °C and 500 °C under inert and oxidizing environments, as indicated in Figure 11a and 11b, respectively. Weight losses were calculated to be 76.7%, 83.2%, and 75.0% for all CNTs deposited over 600 °C, 700 °C, and 800 °C calcined catalysts, respectively. However, the catalyst calcined at 600 °C produced the least thermally stable CNTs.

Materials and Catalyst Preparation
Nickel (II) nitrate hexahydrate, ammonium molybdate tetrahydrate, and calcium carbonate (supplied by Associated Chemical Enterprises (PTY) LTD); titanium (IV) isopropoxide (TTIP) (Sigma-Aldrich, Johannesburg, South Africa), additive-citric acid (supplied by Rochelle Chemicals and Laboratory equipment company, Johannesburg, South Africa); ethanol solvents, and deionized water were used in the synthesis. All supplied chemicals were used without further purification. The sol-gel method was used to prepare bimetallic NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalysts with the parent catalyst (metal content) composition Ni-Mo maintained at a molar ratio of 4:1. The support (CaTiO 3 ) content was varied (while still maintaining a Ca/Ti molar ratio at 1:1 in both catalysts), resulting in two catalysts of different support content; NiMo/CaTiO 3 (molar ratio 4:1:2) and NiMo/CaTiO 3 (molar ratio 4:1:4).
CaO precursor was dissolved in ethanol, and 1.7 M of TTIP was drop-wisely added to the Ca-ethanol solution while vigorously stirred using a magnetic stirrer at 80 • C at a pH = 9.0. The entire mixture was allowed to stir under the same conditions for 5 h. Thereafter, the calculated amount of Ni and Mo salt precursors was dissolved in deionized water, and the mixture added to the Ca-TTIP solution while still vigorously stirred. Again, 4.0 g of citric acid was also added to the mixture until pH = 4.0, and the entire content aged overnight. The resultant gel was oven-dried for 6 h at 100 • C to remove the remaining solvents. The obtained solid chunk was crushed to powder using an agate mortar and calcined in air at 700 • C for 3 h to obtain the fresh catalyst. The final catalysts were denoted as NMC412 and NMC414 for NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalysts with molar ratios of 4:1:2 and 4:1:4, respectively.

Production of CNTs from Waste PP
The waste PP (food package container) used for this work was obtained from the University of Johannesburg refuse deposition/collection center, washed, air-dried, and cut into tiny pieces (1-4 mm) using a Retsch SM 200 (Retsch GmbH, Haan, Germany) jaw crusher. The experimental setup used in the production of CNTs from waste PP was similar to that described elsewhere by Mishra et al. [65] with some modifications. Briefly, a single-stage CVD setup was utilized to grow CNTs from waste PP. The system consisted of a horizontal tubular furnace and a quartz tube reactor (110 cm length and 50 mm I.D.), as well as a gas supplying system with a flow meter and exhaust gas bubbler at the end.
Two sets of experiments were carried out in this study to determine the effect of different catalyst support contents (NMC412 and NMC414) on the yield and quality of CNTs, as well as the influence of different calcination temperatures (600 • C, 700 • C, and 800 • C) on the quality and morphology of CNTs. Typically, 0.5 g of catalyst was packed evenly on a quartz boat situated at the center of the reactor and heated to 700 • C at a ramp rate of 10 • C/min. When the set temperature was achieved, the catalyst was reduced in situ for 20 min under the flow of 5 vol.% H 2 /95 vol.% Ar gas mixtures at a flow rate of 100 mL/min. At the end of the treatment, the 5 vol.% H 2 /95 vol.% Ar gas mixture was switched to N 2 , maintaining the flow at 100 mL/min; then, the ceramic boat housing 1.0 g of waste PP was introduced for the continuous decomposition and growth of carbon nanomaterial at a dwelling time of 30 min, after which the reactor was cooled down overnight in a N 2 atmosphere at a flow rate of 100 mL/min. The experiment was repeated to assure the reliability and repeatability of the results. The obtained black material was further purified using mild acid treatment (0.1 M HCl) and subsequently washed with hot and cold DI water until the pH was around 7. The CNT yield was estimated with respect to the mass of feedstock (waste PP) used according to Equation (1) where, Mass of CNTs = Mass of carbon deposit before purification-Mass of catalyst used.

Morphological Analysis
A surface morphological study of catalysts was performed using VEGA 3 TESCAN (TESCAN, Brno, Czech Republic) scanning electron microscope (SEM) operated at 10 kV, which was coupled to an energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS).

Microstructure Analysis
The morphology of the catalysts and microstructure of deposited carbon as well as the diameters of catalyst metal particles was carried out with a JEM-2100 transmission electron microscope (TEM) instrument (JEOL, Tokyo, Japan) operating at 200 kV. A small amount of sample was dispersed and sonicated in ethanol for 10 min; 2 drops of the blend were dispersed onto carbon-coated copper grid, dried, and photographed.

X-Ray Diffraction
The different crystalline phases present on the surface of NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalysts of different contents were determined out by X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) using Rigaku Ultima IV X-Ray Diffractometer (RIGAKU Corporation, Tokyo, Japan). The samples were scanned in the 2θ range of 10 • to 90 • with a step width of 0.01 • operating at 40 kV and 30 mA with Cu Kα (λ = 1.54 Å) radiation. XRD data analysis was undertaken using PDXL software.

Surface Area and Pore Volume Measurement
The textural properties of the prepared catalysts were determined by nitrogen physisorption analysis at −196 • C using Micromeritics ASAP 2020 (Micromeritics, Atlanta, GA, USA) surface area and a particle analyzer. During the analysis, 200 mg of catalyst was degassed under vacuum using a Micromeritics flow Prep 060 sample degas system at 300 • C for 3 h. The adsorption isotherm was used to estimate the specific surface area, while the Barrett-Joyner-Halenda (BJH) method was used to estimate the pore volumes of the catalysts.

Temperature-Programmed Reduction (TPR)
The TPR technique was used to study the reduction behavior of the catalysts using a Quantachrome TPR-Win instrument (Quantachrome, Boynton Beach, FL, USA); about 100 mg of the fresh catalyst was dried at 300 • C for 1 h under Ar flow and then cooled to room temperature. Afterwards, 5 vol.% H 2 /95 vol.% Ar gas mixture with a flow rate of 30 mL/min was passed through the catalyst. The catalyst was heated to 800 • C at a heating rate of 10 • C/min for 2 h. A thermal conductivity detector (TCD) was used to monitor the H 2 consumption by the metallic oxide part of the catalyst.
3.3.6. Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) TGA analysis was employed to examine the thermal stability of the as-produced carbon nanomaterial using a HITACHI STA-7200RV thermal analysis system (HITACHI, Tokyo, Japan). The analysis was carried out in two different environments: N 2 and air atmosphere. During the analysis, the sample was heated under N 2 and synthetic air at a gas flow rate of 20 mL/min with a ramp rate of 10 • C/min from 30 to 900 • C.

Raman Spectroscopy
The purity and graphitization degree of as-produced CNTs were determined using WITec focus innovations Raman spectrometer (WITec Wissenschaftliche Instrumente and Technologie GmbH, Ulm, Germany) operating at a wavelength of 532 nm with Raman shift in the range of 500 to 3000 cm −1 .

Conclusions
The yield, quality, and morphology of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) obtained from waste PP is greatly influenced by the amount of catalyst support in the catalyst. In this study, bimetallic NiMo-supported CaTiO 3 catalysts with excellent stability and superior activity for the synthesis of CNTs from waste PP were successfully synthesized and tested. The strong interaction between metal and support resulted in a higher yield for both catalysts with different supports (CaTiO 3 ) content. This can be attributed to the presence of thermally stable species in the catalysts that inhibited the agglomeration of metal particles resulting in the formation of small metal particles and the resultant high yield and small diameter CNTs. The low CaTiO 3 content in the NiMo catalyst (denoted as NMC412) gave the highest CNTs yield and quality. However, increasing the calcination temperature from 600 to 800 • C resulted in a shift in CNTs morphology to a shorter length and larger diameter CNTs at 800 • C and a drop in CNTs yield. The maximum CNTs quality and a yield of 44% was obtained over the NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalyst with a molar ratio of 4:1:2 calcined at 700 • C. Therefore, the excellent thermal stability of the NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalyst plays a more determining role in the catalytic decomposition of PP toward CNTs growth in a single stage CVD setup. Therefore, this work presents the feasibility of growing CNTs from waste PP using an efficient NiMo/CaTiO 3 catalyst in a single-stage CVD method. Thus, it highlights the potential of this approach for the large-scale production of CNTs from wastes.

Conflicts of Interest:
The authors declare no conflict of interest.