An Approach to Progress Learning Outcomes: International Graduate Students’ Engagement in Reﬂective Practice and Reﬂective Journal Writing during Pandemic

: Reﬂective practice (RP) and reﬂective journal writing (RJW) are considered the most important ways to enhance students’ learning progress. During the pandemic, ofﬂine learning has replaced online learning to keep students safe and healthy. This research solely examined reﬂective practice during online learning, which is signiﬁcant as online education is less effective and students carry the full study load. However, this study’s core purpose was to determine international graduate students’ perceptions regarding RP and RJW during online learning in the pandemic period. It also investigated whether student engagement in RP enhances their critical reﬂection and learning progress. The mixed-method (QUAN-QUAL) approach was utilized in this study. The sample consisted of 123 international graduate students who were enrolled in various disciplines and majors in China and at least attended two consecutive semesters (24 weeks) online. The survey questionnaire was based on 28 items to collect the quantitative data. The questionnaire was categorized into four variables: self-education, learning progress, critical reﬂection, and engagement. While semi-structured interviews were conducted with 5 participants for qualitative data collection, the quantitative results indicated that all of the statements received good ranks and could be used to study how reﬂective journals helped students improve their self-education, critical reﬂection, writing skills, learning progress, and engagement. In addition, the results revealed a statistically signiﬁcant beneﬁcial association between engagement, self-education, critical reﬂection, and learning progress. Qualitative ﬁndings corroborated the quantitative results that participation in RP and RJW boosted students’ critical thinking skills and facilitated their learning and development. Based on the results, this study concluded that RP or RJW enhance success ratios as well as critical reﬂection, which is effective not only in learning but also in professional and practical settings.


Introduction
Service learning in higher education is an experiential learning pedagogy that balances the needs of student and community members involved, links the service and learning through reflective processes, and, if skillfully managed, leads to positive student personal, social or citizenship, career, and intellectual development [1].Through service-learning, students learn to reflect on their experiences and develop critical-reflective skills, such as the ability to bring disparate elements of experience together in meaningful ways, to analyze information for patterns and deeper meaning, and to make evaluations and judgments [2].
Reflective practice is a serious examination of past events to conclude how to improve future outcomes [3].Moreover, it entails critically examining one's behaviors and past experiences to better oneself [4].Reflexivity and critical reflection are often discussed in relation to reflective practice [5]; reflexivity is the capacity and propensity of individuals Reflective practice is a serious examination of past events to conclude how to improve future outcomes [3].Moreover, it entails critically examining one's behaviors and past experiences to better oneself [4].Reflexivity and critical reflection are often discussed in relation to reflective practice [5]; reflexivity is the capacity and propensity of individuals to demonstrate broad self-awareness and to contemplate themselves concerning their surroundings [6].Critical reflection is an in-depth reflection that entails being aware of how your assumptions impact you and assessing your actions and obligations from moral, ethical, and social vantage points [7].In addition, with the fast growth of education technology in the 21 st century, students have been exposed to numerous information roots.Having access to millions of resources for education might lead to deeper learning.Students are expected to develop the skills necessary to become self-directed, self-reflective thinkers as part of this trend [8].Therefore, instructors are no longer only information providers; their responsibility is to support students' learning.Consequently, today's students must develop the ability to participate in reflective activities, as these abilities will aid them in being productive in their respective professional settings [9,10].
However, contemporary discourse on reflective practice encourages professionals to participate in personal introspection and larger societal criticism.For instance, RP has been conceptualized as a combination of reflection, self-awareness, and critical thinking in the Open University's Health and Social Care faculty (Figure 1) [11,12].In learning, reflection means actively keeping track of and evaluating one's formal learning and professional practice activities to find new insights that add to the person's knowledge and experience [13,14].Students are believed to develop self-and critical reflection via the usage of reflective journal writing (owing to the need of transferring thinking processes into written form) [15,16].In addition, Reflective Journal Writing, often known as RJW, is a technique that is seen as useful in various sectors, including the medical and nursing professions and clinical and professional institutions [17][18][19][20].For example, tertiary and higher-education instructors often employ reflective writing as a formative and summative evaluation tool for their students [21,22].Through reflective writing about one's own experiences, students may develop self-awareness and a sense of control while also gaining self-confidence through validating their ideas [23].It promotes independence by stressing student responsibility for learning and providing a venue for classroom-related discussions.These fundamental components of journal writing may help a student become a reflective practitioner [24,25].As aforementioned, reflective thinking is In learning, reflection means actively keeping track of and evaluating one's formal learning and professional practice activities to find new insights that add to the person's knowledge and experience [13,14].Students are believed to develop self-and critical reflection via the usage of reflective journal writing (owing to the need of transferring thinking processes into written form) [15,16].In addition, Reflective Journal Writing, often known as RJW, is a technique that is seen as useful in various sectors, including the medical and nursing professions and clinical and professional institutions [17][18][19][20].For example, tertiary and higher-education instructors often employ reflective writing as a formative and summative evaluation tool for their students [21,22].Through reflective writing about one's own experiences, students may develop self-awareness and a sense of control while also gaining self-confidence through validating their ideas [23].It promotes independence by stressing student responsibility for learning and providing a venue for classroom-related discussions.These fundamental components of journal writing may help a student become a reflective practitioner [24,25].As aforementioned, reflective thinking is a higher-order thinking skill.This ability assesses a process after a task has been completed or when engaging in a task.When reviewing learning experiences using this technique, students may better analyze their learning processes and develop learning standards [26,27].
Throughout higher education, student involvement is considered a vital study topic concerning academic achievement [28].Student engagement was conceptualized as a mix of two aspects, the first of which focuses on the student and the second corroborates the behavioral, cognitive, and emotional dimensions of involvement proposed by scholars [29].In this context, participation in academic and social activities that lead to positive learning outcomes is referred to as "behavioral engagement" [30].
Further, critical and reflective thinking (CRT) is a set of abilities students use to evaluate their own and others' cognitive processes.It involves developing judgments based on reasoning, in which students investigate possibilities, evaluate alternatives using predetermined criteria, and draw conclusions [31].Furthermore, it encompasses various thinking abilities that lead to desired results, while reflective thinking focuses on evaluating past events.However, reflective thinking is particularly crucial for promoting learning in complex problem-solving circumstances because it enables learners to consider how they solve issues and why a particular set of problem-solving strategies is optimal for achieving their goals [32].
Moreover, during the pandemic, online learning has been introduced around the globe [33].Furthermore, offline education shifted to online education [34].Students are encouraged to attend online classes to make them safe and healthy.Most of the studies have been conducted during the pandemic on the barriers to online learning, technology, the internet, electricity, and instructional obstacles [35].In addition, fewer studies have focused on reflective practice during online classes.Nevertheless, this study only looked at reflective practice during online learning in the pandemic period, which is significant because the online learning is considered less productive and students bear the entire study burden [36,37].However, reflective practice and journal writing are helpful studentcentered activities that offer self-education opportunities to enhance critical reflection and learning outcomes.The present study was conducted in the academic year of 2020/2021.The study aimed to take the perceptions of international graduate students (about their engagement in reflective practice) pursuing higher education in China from different universities and disciplines and experienced online classes and reflective journal writing (RJW) for at least two consecutive semesters during the pandemic.To fulfill the study's aim, the following three research questions were formulated.

1.
What are the perceptions and understanding of reflective practice among international graduate students during online learning?2.
How do students' engagement in reflective practice enhance critical thinking and learning outcomes of international graduate students during online learning?3.
Are there statistically significance relationships of engagement between self-education, learning progress, and critical reflection?

Theoretical Underpinning
Several conceptions of reflection have been developed in various professional practices and educational contexts.Researchers argue that these notions vary in their degrees of preparation, clarification, criticality, and reflexivity, but they all stress reflection as basically retrospective.There are many theories behind reflective thinking and reflective practice.Most models are beyond this course's scope, and many types of models are available.One of Boud's models (Figure 2) can be seen as the simplest.Reflection leads to further learning according to this cyclic model.Even though it captures the essence (learning comes from experience and reflection), it falls short of delivering the whole picture [38].According to Morris [39], reflection is a crucial aspect of learning, and successful learning cannot occur without it.However, Finlay [40] contends that they often entail three key processes: (1) retrospection (the process of reflecting on or analyzing previous events or circumstances), (2) self-evaluation (the actions and feelings involved in the experience need to be critically analyzed and evaluated); (3) reorientation (applying selfevaluation results to similar situations or experiences in the future).As indicated by Adeani and Febriani [41], Gibbs' Reflective Cycle (Figure 3) was based on the idea that theory and practice are mutually beneficial.Professional education has embraced this cycle as a strategy to foster reflection.The reflecting cycle of Gibbs divides into further steps.It admits that your sentiments have influenced how you think on the topic.It expands on Boud's model, which divides reflection into event evaluation and analysis, and there is a strong connection between experience-based learning and future practice [42].By implementing Gibbs' reflective series, reflective experts can analyze and assess their practices and improve them as needed.The six components of reflective writing are as follows: a detailed description of the situation, an examination of how you felt about it, an evaluation of the experience, analysis to make sense of it, a conclusion, and, finally, an examination of what you would do differently if the same condition arose again through an "action plan" [43][44][45][46].

Literature Review
Many studies have explored how reflective practice and journal writing can enhance learning.It can teach reflective thinking skills and facilitate reflective activity among According to Morris [39], reflection is a crucial aspect of learning, and successful learning cannot occur without it.However, Finlay [40] contends that they often entail three key processes: (1) retrospection (the process of reflecting on or analyzing previous events or circumstances), ( 2) self-evaluation (the actions and feelings involved in the experience need to be critically analyzed and evaluated); ( 3) reorientation (applying self-evaluation results to similar situations or experiences in the future).As indicated by Adeani and Febriani [41], Gibbs' Reflective Cycle (Figure 3) was based on the idea that theory and practice are mutually beneficial.Professional education has embraced this cycle as a strategy to foster reflection.According to Morris [39], reflection is a crucial aspect of learning, and successful learning cannot occur without it.However, Finlay [40] contends that they often entail three key processes: (1) retrospection (the process of reflecting on or analyzing previous events or circumstances), ( 2) self-evaluation (the actions and feelings involved in the experience need to be critically analyzed and evaluated); ( 3) reorientation (applying selfevaluation results to similar situations or experiences in the future).As indicated by Adeani and Febriani [41], Gibbs' Reflective Cycle (Figure 3) was based on the idea that theory and practice are mutually beneficial.Professional education has embraced this cycle as a strategy to foster reflection.The reflecting cycle of Gibbs divides into further steps.It admits that your sentiments have influenced how you think on the topic.It expands on Boud's model, which divides reflection into event evaluation and analysis, and there is a strong connection between experience-based learning and future practice [42].By implementing Gibbs' reflective series, reflective experts can analyze and assess their practices and improve them as needed.The six components of reflective writing are as follows: a detailed description of the situation, an examination of how you felt about it, an evaluation of the experience, analysis to make sense of it, a conclusion, and, finally, an examination of what you would do differently if the same condition arose again through an "action plan" [43][44][45][46].

Literature Review
Many studies have explored how reflective practice and journal writing can enhance learning.It can teach reflective thinking skills and facilitate reflective activity among The reflecting cycle of Gibbs divides into further steps.It admits that your sentiments have influenced how you think on the topic.It expands on Boud's model, which divides reflection into event evaluation and analysis, and there is a strong connection between experience-based learning and future practice [42].By implementing Gibbs' reflective series, reflective experts can analyze and assess their practices and improve them as needed.The six components of reflective writing are as follows: a detailed description of the situation, an examination of how you felt about it, an evaluation of the experience, analysis to make sense of it, a conclusion, and, finally, an examination of what you would do differently if the same condition arose again through an "action plan" [43][44][45][46].

Literature Review
Many studies have explored how reflective practice and journal writing can enhance learning.It can teach reflective thinking skills and facilitate reflective activity among learners [47].RJW is an effective instructional tool for assessing student learning.For instance, RJW has been used to assess learners' ability to reflect [48,49].Despite the increase in student and instructor workload, journal writing increased reflective capacities.In addition, RJW has considerably enhanced teacher-student interaction, initiating a productive learning environment [50].Researchers have found that reflective journal writing positively impacted students' learning process in several studies.
Similarly, Knapp [51] utilized RJW to investigate her students' educational practices and, as a result, she gained a deeper understanding of the theories and concepts offered in her college classes.Knapp said that journal writing allowed instructors to be more supportive of student teaching experiences and helped students reflect on what she termed "apprenticeships of experience." In addition, Davis [52] analyzed the reflective journals of twenty-five pre-service teachers to determine how they applied the theoretical information gained in university training to their teaching practice.Davis discovered that RJW gave university professors insight into the mental processes of pre-service teachers.
Cheng and Chan [53] examined the advantages of the RJW for encouraging students to reflect on their learning and improve their writing abilities.In a similar vein, Pintrich [54] said that teachers might use students' replies to help pupils articulate linkages between new material and what they already know.Wong and Kember [55] investigated the role of reflective journals in fostering reflection and learning among post-registration nursing students.The research indicated that student writing "may be utilized as evidence of reflective thinking's existence or absence." Lew and Schmidt [56] researched at a post-secondary school to determine the degree to which students perceive RJW to enhance their learning.They discovered that students' ideas about the value of journal writing in helping students to think and write reflectively are connected to their attitudes about boosting learning via frequent journal writing, using journal writing as an impression management tool, and as a method of providing feedback on teamwork.They found that online reflection diaries give students many chances to think about what they have learned and lets teachers see how much their students have grown.
Greiman and Covington [57] investigated student teachers' journal writing experiences to gain insight into the process of producing reflective practitioners.Student teachers were found to be quite comfortable with writing as a means of communication, and many said RJW went well.Scholars in their study identified reflective thinking as the most prevalent benefit of journal writing.The examined literature review indicates that reflective journal writing is essential for optimizing student engagement, improving motivation, fostering critical thinking, and enhancing learning outcomes.

Study Design
This research used a mixed-method approach [58], A mixed-method explanatory sequential design was chosen in which the researcher combined and utilized quantitative and qualitative approaches [59].This approach is prevalent among researchers who think that gaining information or truth can be established entirely by a single scientific technique (positivism), making access to social reality impossible (interpretivist).Combining these mindsets is, thus, required to uncover reality [60].

Participants and Sampling
One hundred and twenty-three (123) international graduate students participated in the survey questionnaires through random sampling from various Chinese highereducation institutions.Participants were undergraduate (bachelor), master, and Ph.D. students from different fields of study.Moreover, 8 participants were selected among the survey participants and interviewed.The interview participants were selected through purposive sampling.Most of the participants in this study were female and hesitant to give their perceptions through semi-structured interviews.Then, the researcher requested hesitant participants for Reflective Journal Writing (RJW) as per their experience that can be seen in quantitative result findings.

Instrumentation (Questionnaire)
For data collection, the survey questionnaire was designed for quantitative study based on a large amount of educational literature and prior research discussing this subject [61,62], then modified according to the research objective and questions.The questionnaire was categorized into four dimensions addressed in this study: self-education, with 5 items; learning progress, with 9 items; critical reflection, with 6 items; engagement, with 8 items.The data were collected on a five-point Likert scale (strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree, and strongly agree).

Validity, Reliability, and Pilot Testing of the Questionnaires
The initial survey questionnaire consisted of 30 items.Two experienced experts checked the questionnaire to ensure the questionnaire's validity.After the implementation and the opinions of the expert, two items were eliminated, and the final formulation of the survey questionnaire consisted of 28 items with 4 dimensions.To check the reliability of the survey questionnaire, Cronbach's alpha was calculated.For this purpose, the pilot test of the questionnaire was conducted for 46 participants, and the alpha value showed a high degree of internal consistency, making the questionnaire very reliable to collect formal data as suggested by the literature review.Each dimension and overall questionnaire Cronbach's Alpha values are shown in Table 1.

Quantitative Data Collection and Analysis Procedure
The quantitative survey sheets were sent to the participants through their emails for collecting quantitative data with the request to complete the survey sheets.Before sending the survey sheets to participants, consent was taken from each participant.It was also confirmed that the collected data would be kept secret and only used for study purposes.The one hundred thirty-two (132) survey sheets were mailed to participants, whereas 127 survey sheets were returned from them, and 4 sheets were excluded because they were not completed properly and had missing data.
Before conducting analysis, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was conducted to explore the data's normal distribution.According to the findings, the data had a normal distribution.According to Table 2, the value for all variables was statistically significant, indicating that the data followed a normal distribution.

Semi-Structured Interviews
For collecting qualitative data, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 8 participants enrolled in Undergraduate, Master, and Ph.D. courses at various Chinese universities.The selected participants were approached on consented days to conduct the semi-structured interviews.The 3 interviews were on calls through Wechat (a Chinese social media app), and the interviews were recorded with the consent of the participants.Each interview duration was around 45 to 60 min.Furthermore, the remaining 2 interviews were conducted face to face, and the collected data were then further transcribed, incorporated, and compared to the notes; the repetition of ideas was observed through thematic analysis.

Demographic Profile of Qualitative Respondents
The qualitative demographic profile of respondents who participated in semi-structured interviews is shown in Table 4.The respondent profile was separated into four variables, the first of which was the respondents' names, which have been presented as "Pseudonyms" to protect their privacy, and the other variables were gender, age, degree level, and discipline.The following table contains the remaining information.Table 5 indicates the mean values of each item, and the items SE5, LP2, LP3, LP5, LP8, CR1, CR2, and E8 showed the highest means values, which revealed that reflective practice is the best way to enhance learning outcomes, critical reflection, and self-education.In the meantime, item E3 ranked (M = 4.80), which means that most students were also aware of the importance of reflective practice and took it as an essential assignment to enhance their self-education and learning outcomes.The statements of each items can be seen in Appendix A. Table 6 revealed the relationship among dimensions such as self-education, learning progress, critical reflection, and engagement.The bivariate correlation analysis was conducted to determine the association among dimensions.Based on the findings, it was determined that the independent variables (Self-education, Learning Progress, and Critical Reflection) had a substantial and strong positive relationship with the dependent variable (Engagement).The findings also demonstrated that students' engagement in reflective practice might improve their self-education, learning progress, and critical reflection.

Qualitative Findings Trustworthiness of Thematic Analysis
The collected data via interviews and students' reflective journals were analyzed through thematic analysis.Thematic analysis is a technique used to examine qualitative data.It is often used in many texts, such as interviews or transcripts.The researcher meticulously analyzes the data to uncover common themes-recurring topics, concepts, and meaning patterns.This process was carried out under six steps: (1) familiarizing with the data, (2) generating initial code, (3) searching for a theme, (4) producing the report, (5) defining and naming, and (6) reviewing themes [63].After screening the data, the transcribed data were given to participants again to check the authenticity of their perceptions and if they could add something new that was not on their minds at the time of the interview.The trustworthiness process of each phase is described in Table 7.
Table 7. Trustworthiness during Each Phase of Thematic Analysis process.

Phases of Thematic Analysis Description
Familiarizing with the data

•
The first step involves the repetitive reading of collected data; for example, the researcher should be proactive in searching for designs and meaning before coding.During this phase, notes were taken, each phrase of the transcribed data was reviewed, and text was compared to the audio recording.

Generating initial code
• Initial codes are produced in phase two.The coding phase categorizes data into a meaningful set of data.Interpretive analysis occurs in this stage, relevant to the context and arguments of the study.Hence, phase two is the preparatory stage for the next phase.
Searching for a theme

•
This phase begins when all collected data have been coded initially.Then, the analysis of an extensive level of themes, instead of codes, includes arranging codes into probable themes.The mind map was used to organize the ideas piles for themes.Furthermore, the association among codes, themes, and sub-themes was considered.The sub-themes were kept purposely as the themes are yet to be finalized.
Producing the report

•
This phase starts with devising the group of identified themes for reinforcement.The themes without enough supporting details were combined as one theme, and the rest were separated.The process of refining the themes involves reviewing all codes and collected data.
Defining and naming

•
In this phase, identifying and elaborating the meaning of every theme were considered.It was carried out by looking at the data and codes collected and putting the themes in a way that made sense and gave an explanation.
Reviewing themes • Consequently, this phase exposes a coherent, brief, concise, rational, and engaging storyline about the study.Relevant research and explanations of the gathered material reinforced the themes.
After analyzing the qualitative data through each phase of thematic analysis, two themes were finalized based on research questions, interviews, and reflective journal writing (RJW): (1) journaling is a great technique for encouraging self-reflection and growth; (2) students' continuous engagement in reflective journal writing enhances their critical reflection and learning progress.

Theme 1-Journaling Is a Great Technique for Encouraging Self-Reflection and Growth
Reflecting on practice may assist learners in shifting from a level where they may be primarily directed by instinct, intuition, or habit to one where they are guided by selfreflection [64].Previous studies claimed that to be as effective as possible, RP encourages contemplation of why things are as they are and how we can control our actions and behavior through thoughtful preparation based on experience and theory [65,66].On the awareness of reflective practice, one response revealed that: I was not aware of reflective practice and journal writing.But in online classes, the most learning burden is considered on the learner.So, after experiences, I concluded that reflective practice is the best way to enhance self-learning.(P2) I do not understand what "Reflective practice" is theoretically and conceptually.Nonetheless, my self-education depends entirely on carefully considering previously attended lessons.Then I find it refreshing to record my thoughts.(P5) Russell* [67] went further and defined two processes: reflection-in-action and reflectionon-action.The distinction between examining thoughts and behaviors as they occur is to make changes in the present and looking back and gaining insight from past experiences to modify future behavior.Respondents added: I was already aware of the term reflective practice, and I strongly recommend to every student adopt it because it enhances the ability to use new knowledge in practice and also the way to promote skills to analyze and evaluate things.It is significant not only in the learning process but also in professional life.(P4) Recently, educators and academics have shown a renewed interest in the role of reflection in education.It is because scholars have pointed out that it could help students develop professional values or skills by encouraging them to think about themselves [68].Even though the definitions of self-reflection are diverse, they all advocate for enhancing student learning.In the current investigation, these interpretations impact self-reflection.Although self-reflection may be understood in many ways, its ultimate goal remains to improve education.These meanings have an effect on introspection in the present study.It refers to the processes a learner goes through to reflect on their earlier learning experiences and what they did to assist learning (self-reflection on how learning happened), as well as the identification of connections between the taught knowledge and the student's views about it (self-reflection on what was acquired).In these two semesters, I observed clearly that I will neither pass the semester nor improve my self-learning and reflection level without proper adopting reflective journal writing and its practice.I also discovered in online learning that most professors did not help impart the necessary information during class.They had presented their scheduled lectures so often that I would beg them to provide something challenging to help us grasp, but they never did.(P3) Nonetheless, RJW also influences behavior, as revealed.During the reflection phase, learners review their work and determine whether the objective has been met.In response to this evaluation, they adjust their behavior concerning future learning activities.Consequently, the result of a former learning event influences a later learning process [69][70][71][72].

Theme 2-Students' Continuous Engagement in Reflective Journal Writing Enhances Their Critical Reflection and Learning Progress
The capability to reflect on one's own learning is fundamental to lifelong learning [73].As a result, encouraging learners to participate in RP has been identified as a vital aim in higher education for preparing students for future professional experiences.An essential purpose of education is to produce learning experiences that are useful beyond the original learning setting [74,75].
Moreover, critical reflection, reflective practice, reflective thinking, and reflexivity all use similar meanings in education [76].However, the scholars contend that not all reflection is critical and that critical reflection may be a more complex kind of reflection that is challenging for both students and instructors [77,78].One of the respondents shared their experience regarding the understanding of critical reflection; I can understand the meaning of critical reflection.It covered our experience and utilized it in the future.Our coursework also covers this topic, but only a few professors discussed its importance in learning outcomes during the online semester.(P2) Nonetheless, the CR encourages the student to continue gaining knowledge through experience, bridge the gap between theory and practice, and become successful [79,80].Based on this idea, Brown and Slater [81] claimed that reflection should be regarded as a prerequisite for transferring information and skills between the classroom and the workplace and that including a reflection tool in the training method might assist this transfer.
Moreover, critical and profound reflection is difficult.Few students (and teachers) instinctively understand how to use this skill [82,83].Students must possess personal insight and be amenable to altering their ideas or core beliefs.It is simpler to write about events than it is to write about applications or links and provide critical reflections.Some students will be attracted to the easy path of journal writing and may want assistance in order to write profoundly [84].Added by the respondent: Essentially, reflective journal writing (RJW) is a technique to promote critical reflection and learning outcomes; thus, we analyze after each lesson, what we've learned in a certain area and where we need to work harder; therefore, we can say that it's a kind of daily self-evaluation.(P4) Furthermore, as highlighted in the literature, students approach the journal writing with varied degrees of expertise [85].Some students may have maintained diaries for different courses, others in their personal life, and some may have never kept a journal [86].Likewise, several researchers have emphasized the significance of critical reflection in the learning process and emphasized its crucial function as a facilitator of meaning-making.
Previous studies have acknowledged the potential benefits of RJW in raising students' levels of metacognitive awareness [87].The assumption is that metacognition is essential for optimal learning and finds a substantial increase in learning outcomes when regulatory abilities are included into classroom exercise as reflective practice [39,88,89].The results of this study are consistent with the arguments of previous research [90][91][92][93].

Limitations of This Study and Future Work
The study also encountered limitations; first, the sample size was relatively small, from 123 international graduate students who belong to three disciplines for quantitative data collection.Future studies can be performed to enhance sample size and disciplines.Secondly, for qualitative data collection, only five students were interviewed.Thus, future research can be focused on interviewing professors to study this phenomenon in depth.

Conclusions
The present study examined the enhancement of learning outcomes of graduate students through reflective practice and journal writing.Based on the results of this study, RP or RJW enhance success ratios as well as critical reflection, which is not only effective in learning but also in professional and practical settings.As a result, RP and RJW are critical for students in today's complex educational setting, where they must accommodate a diverse range of students from various cultural and social backgrounds, each with its own set of demands.In such a rigorous educational environment, rather than relying on an acknowledged body of information, it is firmly believed that students should engage in reflective activities in order to become successful and productive students.Because reflective practice is seen as the essence of learners' growth, professional development, and improved learning, it is anticipated that successful teaching will emerge from learners' professional development via reflection.Therefore, it is proposed that instructors embrace reflective journal writing in the classroom in order to evaluate and classify students according to their commitment to a certain subject.In addition, it might be beneficial for professors to organize instructional techniques for graduate students from various environments.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Competencies supporting the idea of reflective practice.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Competencies supporting the idea of reflective practice.
As per my perception, Reflective journal writing is the way to judge what we have learned in class and on which part we need to improve.It also indicate the one's strength and weakness.(P1)

Table 1 .
Reliability Analysis of each dimension and overall questionnaire.

Table 3 .
Demographic Characteristics of quantitative Participants.

Table 4 .
Profile of participants who took part in semi-structured interviews.

Table 5 .
Means and standard deviation values of each item.

Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable. Informed Consent Statement:
Informed consent had been taken from all participants involved in this study.The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Table A1 .
Survey Questionnaires.the ability to find and use the information.SE2 RP creates skills to analyze, evaluate the alternatives.SE3 RP encourages to think logically and arrange the problem solution way.SE4 RP stays orientate in unexpected situations.SE5 RP helps to find new approaches to non-standard problems solving.Learning Progress LP1 Reflective Practice supports to develop my way of learning.LP2 RP helps me to make better understand the lecture that I study in the class LP3 RP increases interest in my learning.LP4 RP supports to improve my ability to work more efficiently.LP5 RP encourages to find out new strategies to improve learning.LP6 RP gives more knowledge to improve my learning ability.LP7 RP gives more experience to improve my learning skills.LP8 RP supports to know my learning strengths.LP9 RP supports to know about my weaknesses.Critical Reflection CR1 Reflective Practice changed the way I look at myself.CR2 RP provides me opportunity to judge my behavior towards learning.CR3 RP changed my normal way of doing things.CR4 RP helps to discover my faults which previously considered to be right.CR5 Because of RP I can understand better between theory and practice.CR6 RP enhances my ability to examine things critically.

Table A3 .
Collected data description.