Cationic and Biocompatible Polymer/Lipid Nanoparticles as Immunoadjuvants

Nanostructures have been of paramount importance for developing immunoadjuvants. They must be cationic and non-cytotoxic, easily assembling with usually oppositely charged antigens such as proteins, haptens or nucleic acids for use in vaccines. We obtained optimal hybrid nanoparticles (NPs) from the biocompatible polymer poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and the cationic lipid dioctadecyl dimethyl ammonium bromide (DODAB) by emulsion polymerization of methyl methacrylate (MMA) in the presence of DODAB. NPs adsorbed ovalbumin (OVA) as a model antigen and we determined their adjuvant properties. Interestingly, they elicited high double immune responses of the cellular and humoral types overcoming the poor biocompatibility of DODAB-based adjuvants of the bilayer type. The results suggested that the novel adjuvant would be possibly of use in a variety of vaccines.

The synthesis of PMMA/DODAB NPs was carried out by polymerizing MMA (emulsion polymerization) in the presence of DODAB and AIBN initiator [16,19,43]. In the tubes containing the dry DODAB films or DODAB bilayer fragments (BF), MMA (0.1 to 0.56 M), 0.036 g AIBN and 1 mM NaCl solution were added to a final volume of 10 mL and placed in a water bath at 70-80 • C for 1 h with periodic vortexing before exhaustive dialysis for eliminating unreacted monomer (4 L water, 6 times change, 72 h/Milli-Q water).

Determining Physical Properties of NPs by Dynamic Light-Scattering (DLS)
Dispersions were diluted 20 times for zeta-average diameter (Dz), zeta-potential (ζ) and polydispersity (P) DLS measurements using a Zeta-Plus Zeta-Potential Analyzer (Brookhaven Instruments Corporation, Holtsville, NY, USA), which was equipped with a 677 nm laser and dynamic light-scattering (DLS) at 90 • for particle sizing. From fluctuations of scattered light intensity, the decay times of the fluctuations can be related to the diffusion constants and, therefore, to the sizes of the particles. Small particles moving rapidly cause faster decaying fluctuations than large particles moving slowly. The decay times of these fluctuations are determined in the time domain using a correlator. The fluctuating signal is processed by forming the autocorrelation function which decays exponentially with time so that the relaxation of the fluctuations is directly related to the decay constant (Γ). The decay constant is given by Equation (1): where q depends on the scattering angle, the wavelength of the laser light and refractive index of the suspending liquid and D is the translational diffusion coefficient. Hydrodynamic particle diameter (Dz) is inversely related to D by the Stokes-Einstein Equation (2): where k is the Boltzmann's constant, T is temperature in Kelvin, η is the viscosity of the suspending liquid, and D is the diffusion coefficient. Mean diameters were obtained by fitting data to log-normal size distributions that do not discriminate between one, two, or more different populations and always consider all scattering particles as belonging to one single Gaussian population. For the size distribution data, fitting was performed by the apparatus software using the non-negatively constrained least-squares (NNLS) algorithm, which is a model-independent technique allowing multimodal distributions to be achieved [44]. In order to define a relative width of size distributions, the polydispersity P is given by Equation (3): where µ 2 is proportional to the variance of the "intensity" weighted diffusion coefficient distribution and carries information on the width of the size distribution. Polydispersity (P) has no units. It is close to zero (0.000 to 0.020) for monodisperse or nearly monodisperse samples, small (0.020 to 0.080) for narrow distributions and larger for broader distributions. ζ was determined from electrophoretic mobility (µ) in 1 mM NaCl and the Smoluchowski equation (Equation (4)): where η is the medium viscosity and ε the medium dielectric constant. DODAB differs from surfactants by being a lipid.

Determination of Solid Content and DODAB Concentration in NPs
Solid contents (mg/mL) in the dispersions were quantified by weighing 1 mL NPs dispersions before and after lyophilization as previously described [16,17,19,45]. Centrifuging dispersions (1 h/10,000 rpm) and pelleting NPs allowed the determination of DODAB concentration in the supernatant from halide microtitration [46]. DODAB concentration in NPs was obtained by subtracting DODAB concentration in the supernatant from DODAB concentration used for NPs synthesis [21,45].
2.5. Determination of Interaction of PMMA/DODAB NPs (20 mg/mL PMMA and 1.6 mM DODAB) and OVA After washing out DODAB in the supernatant of a PMMA/DODAB NPs dispersion by centrifuging and re-suspending the initial dispersion three times in pure water, an aliquot (2) DODAB LV at 10 mM DODAB in DODAB dispersions obtained by vortexing the DODAB powder in 1 mM NaCl solution above 47 • C [41]; (3) DODAB BF at 10 mM DODAB obtained by sonication in 1 mM NaCl with a macro-probe. Aliquots of each stock dispersion of adjuvants were mixed with cells' culture media over a range of DODAB concentrations (0.04, 0.08, 0.12, 0.16 mM DODAB for each adjuvant type). Thereafter 0.1 mL of each adjuvant type and concentration in culture medium were added to subconfluent layers of L929 fibroblasts or J774A.1 macrophages (American Type Culture Collection).

Immunization Protocol
Animals were immunized subcutaneously according to four groups with five BALB/c male mice each. They were injected with 0.1 mL of solution or dispersion on the base of the tail at two separate sites with 0.1 mL each (0.2 mL per animal in total). The composition of solutions or dispersions used for immunization is in Table 1. Animals received a booster with the same priming dose on day 21 after immunization.

OVA-Specific IgG1 and IgG2a Production by ELISA in Immunized Mice
Animals' blood was collected from the ophthalmic plexus at days 14, 21 and 28 postimmunization for serum individual analysis by indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Microtiter plates (Costar Corning Inc., Kennebunk, ME, USA) were incubated overnight at 4 • C with 0.1 mL OVA solution at 0.010 mg/mL in 0.01 M PBS, pH 7.2. Gelatin 3% in PBS blocked the wells for 2 h before adding serially diluted serum and further incubating the microplates for 1 h at 37 • C. 0.100 mL of goat anti-mouse biotin-conjugated IgG1 (1:1000) or IgG2a (1:500) (Southern Biotechnology Associates, Birmingham, AL, USA) were added per well for incubation (1 h/37 • C). Thereafter, peroxidase-labeled streptavidin (0.100 mL/diluted 1:3000) was added and incubated for 1 h at 37 • C. Three-times washing was performed after each incubation step with PBS containing 0.05% Tween 20 (PBST). An amount of 0.1 mL of ortho-phenilenediamine dihydrochloride (OPD) substrate solution at 1 mg/mL and H 2 O 2 (1 µL/mL) in 0.1 M citrate-phosphate at pH 5.0) were added per well for 15 min incubation at 25 • C. An amount of 0.050 mL of a H 2 SO 4 solution (2 M) terminated the reaction. Optical density at 492 nm was read in an ELISA apparatus (Multiskan Ex, Thermo Electron Corporation, Waltham, MA, USA). Samples were diluted to fit inside the 0-1 absorbance range and data were shown. The results were expressed for diluted serum samples as the mean values ± standard deviation. For IgG1 dilution of 1:1024 corresponded to the primary response and 1/512,000, to the secondary one. For IgG2a, primary and secondary responses were present at 1:32 and 1:512 dilutions.

Determination of Delayed-Type Hypersensitivity Reaction (DTH)
DTH associated with cell-mediated immune response was evaluated from footpad swelling in mice [7,11,38,48]. At day 5 postimmunization, mice received injections of denaturated OVA in saline solution (0.030 mL of a 2 mg/mL OVA) at the left-hind footpad. Negative control was 0.030 mL of saline injected at the right-hind footpad of each animal. Footpad swelling at 24 h after injection was measured with a Mitutoyo digital micrometer. The difference between swelling of left and right hind footpads of a given 24 h after injection was taken as the individual footpad swelling. The mean footpad swelling ± standard deviation could be calculated considering all five animals in each group.

Statistics Tests
The significance of results for different groups was evaluated using a two-way ANOVA variance analysis and the multiple comparisons Tukey's test. p < 0.05 meant significant differences between results. The software for statistical analysis was provided by the Origin 2018 program available from the Origin Lab Corporation, Northampton, MA, USA.

Synthesis of Nanoparticles (NP), NPs Physical Properties and Cytotoxicity against Cultured Cells
The background for synthesizing PMMA/DODAB NPs has been the high miscibility of DODAB and PMMA due to weak but numerous intermolecular interactions [40]. The hybrid coatings using PMMA/DODAB materials joined the high biocompatibility of PMMA [21,50,51] with the antimicrobial activity of the quaternary ammonium moiety of DODAB [52][53][54][55]. Here we take advantage of PMMA biocompatibility and DODAB activity as immunoadjuvant to obtain hybrid NPs of PMMA/DODAB. One should also recall the high surface potential of DODAB nanostructures, bilayer fragments and bilayer vesicles [56] favoring the adsorption of oppositely charged antigens, an essential property for combining antigen and adjuvant. The main physical properties of PMMA/DODAB NPs hybrid coatings using PMMA/DODAB materials joined the high biocompatibility of PMMA [21,50,51] with the antimicrobial activity of the quaternary ammonium moiety of DODAB [52][53][54][55]. Here we take advantage of PMMA biocompatibility and DODAB activity as immunoadjuvant to obtain hybrid NPs of PMMA/DODAB. One should also recall the high surface potential of DODAB nanostructures, bilayer fragments and bilayer vesicles [56] favoring the adsorption of oppositely charged antigens, an essential property for combining antigen and adjuvant. The main physical properties of PMMA/DODAB NPs obtained by emulsion polymerization of MMA in the presence of DODAB were on Figure 1.   Regarding the use of DODAB films for NPs synthesis, no signicant difference in zeta-potential and polydispersity was observed, but sizes tended to be always larger than the ones for NPs obtained from DODAB BF (Figure 1a-c).
At 0.3 M MMA, BFs confirmed their suitability to yield NPs sizes below 100 nm; DODAB films yielded always larger NPs (Figure 1d). This had already been observed on Figure 1a, where films yielded always larger NPs than those prepared in the presence of DODAB BF. Again, nanometric size (50-80 nm) was mainly achieved using the DODAB BF during NPs synthesis over a range of MMA concentrations (Figure 1d). DODAB BF emulsified MMA better than DODAB films casted on the bottom of glass tubes. Possibly, Pharmaceutics 2021, 13, 1859 7 of 17 DODAB BF present in the aqueous reaction medium organized the growing chains of PMMA in the core of the bilayer fragments at early stages of the polymerization. The high miscibility between PMMA and DODAB led to hybrid NPs where DODAB could be localized both in the polymer matrix and on the NP surface. Curiously, DODAB affinity for PMMA has been shown to be higher than the one for cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB): whereas DODAB remains in the polymer matrix, CTAB diffuses through the polymer network reaching the outer water medium [19,40,57]. The initial study determining the optimal molar ratio for MMA/DODAB during polymerization, namely 0.3:0.0015 MMA:DODAB, suggested this ratio for synthesizing the NPs to be evaluated as antigen presenters. The concentrations used for NPs synthesis in the next experiments were 0.3 M MMA and 0.0020 M DODAB, considering that the cationic DODAB usually adsorbs onto all glass [58] or plastic containers [33]. In other words, we synthesized the NPs under a slight excess of DODAB, even though complete removal of DODAB by centrifuging, discarding the supernatant and resuspending in pure water was routinely done. For the final NPs, [DODAB]p was 1.62 mM.
In the presence of PMMA/DODAB NPs, DODAB BF and DODAB LV, determination of the viability of macrophages or fibroblasts in culture pointed out that DODAB concentration at 0.08 mM barely affected the macrophages and the fibroblasts after a period of 24 h interaction (Figure 3). In contrast with DODAB BF or DODAB LV, the PMMA/DODAB NPs resulted much less cytotoxic against the macrophages (Figure 3b  From a certain MMA concentration it was not possible to disperse all PMMA as NPs due to lack of DODAB emulsifier; polymerization proceeded anyway yielding precipitated polymeric masses in the reaction mixtures; this occurred mainly over a range of [MMA] above 0.3 M (Figure 2a). Thus there is a need of establishing the saturation of PMMA with DODAB at a given concentration of MMA. For example, until 0.3 M MMA there was a linear dependence of DODAB incorporation from BF into PMMA/DODAB NPs (Figure 2a). However, it was observed that above 0.3 M MMA there were nonemulsified, precipitated polymer masses at the bottom of the assay tubes after NPs synthesis. For DODAB from films, the emulsification was even more hampered due to a lower availability of DODAB molecules to diffuse into the reaction mixture; at least for BF, the previous step of dispersing DODAB by sonication placed DODAB in a more suitable position as emulsifier for obtaining well dispersed polymeric NPs (Figure 2a,b). DODAB incorporation in NPs was always higher for polymerizations in the presence of BF than those in the presence of films ( Figure 2). Furthermore, from DODAB added as BF, at 0.3 M MMA, there was a linear dependence of DODAB incorporation with the total DODAB concentration added to the reaction mixture, at least up to 1.5 mM DODAB (Figure 2b). In addition, all DODAB added could become incorporated in the NPs (Figure 2b). Above 1.5 mM DODAB added not all DODAB became part of the NPs meaning that the maximal DODAB incorporation had been achieved at a certain proportion of MMA/DODAB, namely 0.3 M MMA and 1.5 mM DODAB (Figure 2b).
The initial study determining the optimal molar ratio for MMA/DODAB during polymerization, namely 0.3:0.0015 MMA:DODAB, suggested this ratio for synthesizing the NPs to be evaluated as antigen presenters. The concentrations used for NPs synthesis in the next experiments were 0.3 M MMA and 0.0020 M DODAB, considering that the cationic DODAB usually adsorbs onto all glass [58] or plastic containers [33]. In other words, we synthesized the NPs under a slight excess of DODAB, even though complete removal of DODAB by centrifuging, discarding the supernatant and resuspending in pure water was routinely done. For the final NPs, [DODAB] p was 1.62 mM.
In the presence of PMMA/DODAB NPs, DODAB BF and DODAB LV, determination of the viability of macrophages or fibroblasts in culture pointed out that DODAB concentration at 0.08 mM barely affected the macrophages and the fibroblasts after a period of 24 h interaction ( Figure 3). In contrast with DODAB BF or DODAB LV, the PMMA/DODAB NPs resulted much less cytotoxic against the macrophages (Figure 3b)

Ovalbumin Adsorption onto NPs, NPs/OVA Physical Properties and Colloidal Stability, and NPs/FITC-OVA Internalization in Macrophages
OVA adsorption onto PMMA/DODAB NPs was determined at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA over a range of added OVA concentrations. The reason for choosing this PMMA concentration was the possibility of comparing later on, the adjuvant effects of PMMA/DODAB with the previously described effects for PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs as adjuvants at this same concentration [21].
The oppositely charged OVA adsorbed onto PMMA/DODAB NPs at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA over a range of [OVA] yielding the macroscopic features shown on Figure 4a. Upon charge neutralization and zeta-potentials around zero, there was precipitation and loss of colloidal stability around 0.100-0.125 mg/mL of OVA (Figure 4a,d).  (Figure 3c,d). This result agrees with previous data on fibroblasts cell death in the presence of DODAB BF showing significant DODAB cytotoxicity only above 0.5 mM DODAB [59]. In summary, the use of DODAB mixed as a hybrid material with a biocompatible polymer such as PMMA advantageously reduced DODAB toxicity against the macrophages.

Ovalbumin Adsorption onto NPs, NPs/OVA Physical Properties and Colloidal Stability, and NPs/FITC-OVA Internalization in Macrophages
OVA adsorption onto PMMA/DODAB NPs was determined at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA over a range of added OVA concentrations. The reason for choosing this PMMA concentration was the possibility of comparing later on, the adjuvant effects of PMMA/DODAB with the previously described effects for PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs as adjuvants at this same concentration [21].
The oppositely charged OVA adsorbed onto PMMA/DODAB NPs at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA over a range of [OVA] yielding the macroscopic features shown on Figure 4a. Upon charge neutralization and zeta-potentials around zero, there was precipitation and loss of colloidal stability around 0.100-0.125 mg/mL of OVA (Figure 4a,d).
This behavior is usually obtained for interaction between NPs and oppositely charged molecules such as silica/DODAB [37], and polystyrene sulfate NPs/DODAB [15,33]. Around neutralization, large aggregates precipitate and polydispersity increases substantially; basically, it is not possible to use the DLS technique due to the absence of colloids in dispersion. The determination of colloidal stability was important to define OVA concentration to be combined with 0.5 mg/mL PMMA. To obtain positively charged NPs, their concentrations should be smaller than 0.1 mg/mL; furthermore, at 0.1 mg/mL OVA, aggregation and precipitation hampered the use of this OVA concentration. The OVA concentration chosen was 0.05 mg/mL in combination with 0.5 mg/mL PMMA/DODAB NPs. The reason for choosing 0.5 mg/mL PMMA/DODAB NPs was to compare later on the adjuvant effect with the one induced by PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs described previously at this same concentration [21].
The red point on Figure 4c-e showing the physical properties of NPs/OVA were obtained from a 1 mg/mL OVA stock solution. As compared to NPs/OVA obtained from a 10 mg/mL OVA stock solution (black points), sizes and polydispersities were smaller for the NPs obtained from the 1 mg/mL OVA. This was observed previously for concentrated OVA stock solutions and attributed to OVA-OVA interactions leading to OVA aggregation in the stock solution that remains to a certain extent after further dilution [60]. Thus, the stock OVA solution used was the one at 1 mg/mL OVA (red points in Figure 4c-e).
The OVA adsorption onto PMMA/DODAB NPs at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA increased linearly with added OVA concentration up to 0.1 mg/mL of added OVA (Figure 4b). Above this concentration NPs became saturated with OVA and further adsorption was substantially reduced. Therefore, 0.05 mg/mL of added OVA was suitable to ensure that all OVA added was adsorbed onto the NPs, no free OVA remained in solution.
In comparison with PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs (zeta-potentials around 70 mV), the present system with PMMA/DODAB NPs exhibited smaller zeta-potentials (around 30 mV) but maximal OVA adsorption was similarly around 0.10-0.12 mg/mL for both systems [21]. This can be better understood from the compared sizes for both NPs. PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs (Dz = 217 nm) were larger than PMMA/DODAB NPs (Dz = 81 nm). At 0.5 mg/mL PMMA for both NPs, the total surface area available for OVA adsorption is larger for the smaller NPs explaining why the lower zeta-potential resulted in similar adsorption to the one obtained with the PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs with higher zeta-potential. Small sizes compensated for the lower zeta-potentials.
OVA stock solutions and attributed to OVA-OVA interactions leading to OVA aggregation in the stock solution that remains to a certain extent after further dilution [60]. Thus, the stock OVA solution used was the one at 1 mg/mL OVA (red points in Figure 4ce). The OVA adsorption onto PMMA/DODAB NPs at 0.5 mg/mL PMMA increased linearly with added OVA concentration up to 0.1 mg/mL of added OVA (Figure 4b). Above this concentration NPs became saturated with OVA and further adsorption was substantially reduced. Therefore, 0.05 mg/mL of added OVA was suitable to ensure that all OVA added was adsorbed onto the NPs, no free OVA remained in solution.
In comparison with PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs (zeta-potentials around 70 mV), the present system with PMMA/DODAB NPs exhibited smaller zeta-potentials (around 30 mV) but maximal OVA adsorption was similarly around 0.10-0.12 mg/mL for both systems [21]. This can be better understood from the compared sizes for both NPs. The stock solution of OVA used was 10 mg/mL whereas the red dot indicates properties of dispersions obtained from a 1 mg/mL OVA stock solution. The immunology tests were performed using the last stock solution of OVA. The red rectangle corresponds to the OVA concentration region of poor colloidal stability, meaning that DLS measurments could not be performed due to precipitation in the tubes.

Immune Response of NPs/OVA In Vivo: Improved Production of IgG1 and IgG2a
IgG1 and IgG2a OVA-specific antibodies production was enhanced substantially using NPs/OVA for immunization ( Figure 5). Furthermore, NPs were as efficient as Al(OH) 3 as adjuvants inducing the IgG1 primary response on days 14 and 21 but surpassed alum regarding the secondary response on day 28 (Figure 5a). IgG2a production induced by NPs/OVA was substantially superior to the one induced by alum both for the primary and the secondary response, suggesting and important role of the novel NPs in promoting cellular immune response (Figure 5b). Similar NPs made of the biocompatible PMMA and a cationic polymer were previously used as adjuvants also yielding improved humoral response [21,43]. Emulsion polymerization of methyl methacrylate (MMA), producing poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), is well described in the literature [61][62][63]. We have been studying the effect of adding cationic lipid, surfactant or polymer to obtain cationic PMMA NPs useful as immunoadjuvants. Adding a cationic polymer to obtain PMMA/cationic polymer NPs, the IgG1 production was about four times higher than the one induced by alum [21] whereas in the present work, adding the cationic lipid DODAB to obtain PMMA/cationic lipid NPs, the IgG1 production was similar to the one induced by alum (Figure 5a). Production of IgG2a induced by PMMA/cationic lipid (Figure 5b) was four times higher than the one induced by PMMA/cationic polymer [21]. The cationic polymer PDDA was shown to enhance humoral response at levels superior to those attributed to polyethyleneimine (PEI) or cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) adsorbed to gold nanorods [64]. production induced by NPs/OVA was substantially superior to the one induced by alum both for the primary and the secondary response, suggesting and important role of the novel NPs in promoting cellular immune response (Figure 5b). Similar NPs made of the biocompatible PMMA and a cationic polymer were previously used as adjuvants also yielding improved humoral response [21,43]. Emulsion polymerization of methyl methacrylate (MMA), producing poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), is well described in the literature [61][62][63]. We have been studying the effect of adding cationic lipid, surfactant or polymer to obtain cationic PMMA NPs useful as immunoadjuvants. Adding a cationic polymer to obtain PMMA/cationic polymer NPs, the IgG1 production was about four times higher than the one induced by alum [21] whereas in the present work, adding the cationic lipid DODAB to obtain PMMA/cationic lipid NPs, the IgG1 production was similar to the one induced by alum (Figure 5a). Production of IgG2a induced by PMMA/cationic lipid (Figure 5b) was four times higher than the one induced by PMMA/cationic polymer [21]. The cationic polymer PDDA was shown to enhance humoral response at levels superior to those attributed to polyethyleneimine (PEI) or cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) adsorbed to gold nanorods [64]. Figure 5. Antibody production in sera on days 14, 21 and 28 after immunization as induced by ovalbumin (OVA), Al(OH) 3 /OVA and NPs/OVA. The mean absorbance measured at 492 nm ± standard deviation was relative to the production of OVA-specific IgG1 (a) or IgG2a (b). Serum dilution to present IgG1 primary response was 1/1024 and IgG2a primary response was showed at 1/32. Secondary response of IgG1 was displayed at 1/512,000 whereas IgG2a secondary response was presented at 1/512. p < 0.05 compared to the naive group (#), p < 0.05 compared to the OVA group (*), p < 0.05 compared to the Al(OH) 3 /OVA group (∆).
In order to obtain more quantitative data on IgG1 and IgG2a antibodies production, the endpoint titers were obtained in both cases and shown on Table 2. The qualitative data described on Figure 5 were reconfirmed by the titers' determination. PMMA/DODAB NPs induced indeed a mixed Th1-Th2 response in contrast to OVA alone or alum as adjuvant. Although OVA alone induced a certain production of IgG1, the production of IgG2a was basically neglectable (Table 2). In summary, the NP structure determines the magnitude of both humoral and cellular responses when used as adjuvants. The cationic component as the outermost layer imparts high surface potential to the NPs and is seen by the immune system as a foreign body. The hybrid cationic lipid/PMMA NPs exhibit a lower surface potential due to uniform distribution of the cationic lipid in the polymer matrix and are not seen as so foreigner by the immune system. Figure 6 shows the footpad swelling (FS) in mm for PMMA/DODAB NPs as compared to alum. The FS was 0.7 mm ( Figure 6) and lower than the one previously determined for DODAB BF/OVA by Rozenfeld and coworkers, which was 1.3 mm [11]. Whereas the zeta-potential for PMMA/DODAB/OVA in this work is about 34 mV (Figure 4d), the zeta-potential for DODAB BF/OVA was determined as 21 mV [11]. The less charged nanostructure apparently induced the larger cellular response.
In order to obtain more quantitative data on IgG1 and IgG2a antibodies production, the endpoint titers were obtained in both cases and shown on Table 2. The qualitative data described on Figure 5 were reconfirmed by the titers' determination. PMMA/DODAB NPs induced indeed a mixed Th1-Th2 response in contrast to OVA alone or alum as adjuvant. Although OVA alone induced a certain production of IgG1, the production of IgG2a was basically neglectable (Table 2). In summary, the NP structure determines the magnitude of both humoral and cellular responses when used as adjuvants. The cationic component as the outermost layer imparts high surface potential to the NPs and is seen by the immune system as a foreign body. The hybrid cationic lipid/PMMA NPs exhibit a lower surface potential due to uniform distribution of the cationic lipid in the polymer matrix and are not seen as so foreigner by the immune system. Figure 6 shows the footpad swelling (FS) in mm for PMMA/DODAB NPs as compared to alum. The FS was 0.7 mm ( Figure 6) and lower than the one previously determined for DODAB BF/OVA by Rozenfeld and coworkers, which was 1.3 mm [11]. Whereas the zeta-potential for PMMA/DODAB/OVA in this work is about 34 mV ( Figure  4d), the zeta-potential for DODAB BF/OVA was determined as 21 mV [11]. The less charged nanostructure apparently induced the larger cellular response.  Some cytokines elicited by medium (negative control), OVA or concanavalin-A in cultured spleen cells of animals previously immunized with water (naive), OVA, Al(OH) 3 /OVA or PMMA/DODAB/OVA NPs allowed to reconfirm the intensity of humoral and cellular immune responses (Figure 7). Whereas IL-4 enhancement means improved humoral response ( Figure 7a) and IL-10 enhancement relates to both humoral and cellular responses (Figure 7b), IL-2 ( Figure 7c) and IFN-γ are typically produced in enhanced cellular immune response (Figure 7d). This profile perfectly agrees with previous results reported in this work where significant enhancements in both cellular (Figures 5b and 6) and humoral immune responses were indeed described (Figure 5a). IL-10 enhancement means a regulatory response against the pro-inflammatory effect of NPs/OVA in mice.
improved humoral response (Figure 7a) and IL-10 enhancement relates to both humoral and cellular responses (Figure 7b), IL-2 ( Figure 7c) and IFN-γ are typically produced in enhanced cellular immune response (Figure 7d). This profile perfectly agrees with previous results reported in this work where significant enhancements in both cellular (Figures 5b and 6) and humoral immune responses were indeed described (Figure 5a). IL-10 enhancement means a regulatory response against the pro-inflammatory effect of NPs/OVA in mice. In the presence of DODAB and poly(diallyl dimethylammonium chloride) (PDDA), emulsion polymerization of MMA yielded PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs [21,43,45]. These hybrid, PMMA-based NPs predominantly contained PMMA, a biocompatible polymer, displaying absence of cytotoxicity when tiny amounts of cationic components were used, as shown in this work. The comparison between PMMA/DODAB NPs (this work) and PMMA/DODAB/PDDA [21] showed some differences in the type of immune response. The former NPs induced preferentially a Th-1 response (higher IgG2a, IFN-γ and lower IL-10 for down regulation of inflammatory response induced by the PMMA/DODAB NP) as compared to the PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs that generated higher Th-2 response In the presence of DODAB and poly(diallyl dimethylammonium chloride) (PDDA), emulsion polymerization of MMA yielded PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs [21,43,45]. These hybrid, PMMA-based NPs predominantly contained PMMA, a biocompatible polymer, displaying absence of cytotoxicity when tiny amounts of cationic components were used, as shown in this work. The comparison between PMMA/DODAB NPs (this work) and PMMA/DODAB/PDDA [21] showed some differences in the type of immune response. The former NPs induced preferentially a Th-1 response (higher IgG2a, IFN-γ and lower IL-10 for down regulation of inflammatory response induced by the PMMA/DODAB NP) as compared to the PMMA/DODAB/PDDA NPs that generated higher Th-2 response (lower IgG2a, IFN-γ and higher IL-10 attempting to reduce the NPs induced inflammatory effect).
The comparison between PMMA/DODAB NPs and DODAB bilayer fragments (BF) regarding the DTH response measured as footpad swelling (FS) also showed the mild inflammatory effect of the PMMA/DODAB NPs (FS = 0.70 mm) in comparison to DODAB BF (FS = 1.3). Figure 8 shows schematically four different cationic nanostructures and their immune responses as studied in our group over the last 25 years. effect).
The comparison between PMMA/DODAB NPs and DODAB bilayer fragments (BF) regarding the DTH response measured as footpad swelling (FS) also showed the mild inflammatory effect of the PMMA/DODAB NPs (FS = 0.70 mm) in comparison to DODAB BF (FS = 1.3). Figure 8 shows schematically four different cationic nanostructures and their immune responses as studied in our group over the last 25 years.

Conclusions
PMMA/DODAB NPs with nanometric sizes, high zeta-potential and narrow size distribution were obtained by emulsion polymerization of MMA in the presence of DODAB (at 0.3 M MMA and 2.0 mM DODAB). From DODAB films for NPs synthesis sizes were always larger than the ones for NPs obtained from DODAB BF. PMMA/DODAB NPs exhibited functional behavior as immunoadjuvants. They were non cytotoxic against macrophages and fibroblasts in culture, combined well with OVA, as model antigen, were nanometric, showing high zeta-potential, low polydispersity and high colloidal stability in water dispersions. NPs/OVA induced high production of OVAspecific IgG1 and IgG2a in immunized mice, high delayed type hypersensitivity reaction, high production of IFN-γ, regulatory cytokine IL-10, IL-2 and IL-4. Quantitative determination of IgG1 and IgG2a titers reconfirmed the induction of a mixed Th1-Th2 response induced by the PMMA/DODAB/OVA NPs. In summary, there was enhanced humoral and cellular responses against OVA carried by the novel biocompatible adjuvant.

Conclusions
PMMA/DODAB NPs with nanometric sizes, high zeta-potential and narrow size distribution were obtained by emulsion polymerization of MMA in the presence of DODAB (at 0.3 M MMA and 2.0 mM DODAB). From DODAB films for NPs synthesis sizes were always larger than the ones for NPs obtained from DODAB BF. PMMA/DODAB NPs exhibited functional behavior as immunoadjuvants. They were non cytotoxic against macrophages and fibroblasts in culture, combined well with OVA, as model antigen, were nanometric, showing high zeta-potential, low polydispersity and high colloidal stability in water dispersions. NPs/OVA induced high production of OVA-specific IgG1 and IgG2a in immunized mice, high delayed type hypersensitivity reaction, high production of IFN-γ, regulatory cytokine IL-10, IL-2 and IL-4. Quantitative determination of IgG1 and IgG2a titers reconfirmed the induction of a mixed Th1-Th2 response induced by the PMMA/DODAB/OVA NPs. In summary, there was enhanced humoral and cellular responses against OVA carried by the novel biocompatible adjuvant.