Evaluation of the Foliar Damage That Threatens a Millennial-Age Tree, Araucaria araucana (Molina) K. Koch, Using Leaf Waxes

A. araucana is an endemic species of the temperate forests from Chile and Argentina; protected in both countries and categorized as in danger of extinction. Individuals of this species have begun to show foliar damage (i.e., discoloration) in branches and upper parts. The discoloration begins from the base to the top and from the trunk to the branches with necrotic rings appearing; in some cases causing death; and is currently attributed to an as yet unknown disease. This study focuses on the first protective layer of plants against environmental stress and pathogens; known as leaf waxes. The abundance and distribution of three classes of leaf waxes (long chain fatty acids; alkanes and alcohols) were measured in healthy individuals of A. araucana from different sites and individuals that present foliar damage (sick individuals). In the case of sick individuals; their leaf waxes were measured considering the level of leaf damage; that is; leaves without; medium and full foliar damage. The most abundant class of leaf wax in both sick and healthy individuals was fatty acids; followed by alkanes and then alcohols; with common dominant chains; C28 fatty acid; C29 alkane and C24 alcohol. Sick individuals have higher abundances of alkanes and alcohols than healthy individuals. The leaves of sick individuals have lower values of distribution indices (the carbon preference index of fatty acids and average chain length of alkanes) as foliar damage increases that are interpreted as a reduction of in vivo biosynthesis of waxes. This is the first evidence of A. araucana response to a still unknown disease that is killing individuals of this endemic species.


Introduction
The Araucaria araucana forest is found in the temperate forests of South America [1], where species like A. araucana and Nothofagus dominate, forming mixed stands with a dense understory dominated by Chusquea bamboos [2]. The temperate forests have high endemism, and over time, the natural distribution of A. araucana forest has been reduced despite significant interest in conservation. Today, A. araucana forests are distributed between the Chilean and Argentinian slopes of the Andean Cordillera and two unconnected populations in the Coastal Cordillera of Chile. The main causes of the reduction of A. araucana forests and specifically of the A. araucana species, has been human-induced fires [3,4], utilization of seeds as a food supply [5], and introduction of exotic species [6][7][8][9]. The above are among the reasons why A. araucana is considered of high conservation value and protected on both sides of the Andean Mountains [10]. Indeed, it has been declared a natural monument since 1990 in Chile [11], with the population of the Andean Cordillera categorized as vulnerable and the population of Nahuelbuta Coastal ridge in danger of extinction [12].
Forests 2020, 11,59 3 of 17 associated with the diseased A. araucana. The alteration of lipid homeostasis has also been associated with various diseases [46]. Therefore, a study of the cuticular waxes of A. araucana is timely considering the current situation.
There are very few investigations of cuticle waxes from A. araucana [30,47] and only in healthy individuals; there is no information on leaf waxes from sick or leaf-damaged individuals to date. This study quantifies and compares the abundance and distribution (ACL and CPI) of leaf waxes among healthy individuals of A. araucana collected from four riparian sites of A. araucana forest in the Región de la Araucanía (Chile). The main compounds avoiding leaf water loss are very long chain of alkanes and alcohols derivate from fatty acids [24]. Then, we expect an increase in abundance and distribution of leaf waxes in sick individuals of A. araucana, with high variability among healthy individuals located in different sites. The study also compares waxes between healthy and sick individuals found on a specific site of the Parque Nacional Tolhuaca (Tolhuaca National Park-PNT), evaluating three levels of visual foliar damage (without, medium, and full foliar damage [or discoloration]) in sick individuals.

Study Site
The study was carried out in the Región de la Araucanía in south-central Chile, specifically in protected zones in the riparian zones of Laguna Verde Tolhuaca (Site 1; 38 •

Sampling Protocol
Leaves of A. araucana individuals were collected in two sampling campaigns. Sampling sites were chosen according to their accessibility, avoiding trails and easy human access to minimize anthropogenic disturbances [49]. In January 2017, leaves from only healthy individuals at four sites were collected because no sick individuals were observed at the sites ( Figure 1). In December 2017, sick individuals were found only in Site 1 (PNT) and therefore leaves were collected.
Forests 2020, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 18 with various diseases [46]. Therefore, a study of the cuticular waxes of A. araucana is timely considering the current situation.
There are very few investigations of cuticle waxes from A. araucana [30,47] and only in healthy individuals; there is no information on leaf waxes from sick or leaf-damaged individuals to date. This study quantifies and compares the abundance and distribution (ACL and CPI) of leaf waxes among healthy individuals of A. araucana collected from four riparian sites of A. araucana forest in the Región de la Araucanía (Chile). The main compounds avoiding leaf water loss are very long chain of alkanes and alcohols derivate from fatty acids [24]. Then, we expect an increase in abundance and distribution of leaf waxes in sick individuals of A. araucana, with high variability among healthy individuals located in different sites. The study also compares waxes between healthy and sick individuals found on a specific site of the Parque Nacional Tolhuaca (Tolhuaca National Park-PNT), evaluating three levels of visual foliar damage (without, medium, and full foliar damage [or discoloration]) in sick individuals.

Study Site
The study was carried out in the Región de la Araucanía in south-central Chile, specifically in protected zones in the riparian zones of Laguna Verde

Sampling Protocol
Leaves of A. araucana individuals were collected in two sampling campaigns. Sampling sites were chosen according to their accessibility, avoiding trails and easy human access to minimize anthropogenic disturbances [49]. In January 2017, leaves from only healthy individuals at four sites were collected because no sick individuals were observed at the sites ( Figure 1). In December 2017, sick individuals were found only in Site 1 (PNT) and therefore leaves were collected.   Leaves of 3 healthy individuals were collected per site (n = 4; total n = 12) and leaves of 5 sick individuals were collected at Site 1, considering 3 levels of visual foliar damage: leaves without damage (green), leaves with medium damage (discolored with green and brown) and full foliar damage (totally discolored) (see Figures 2 and 3). Leaves of 3 healthy individuals were collected per site (n = 4; total n = 12) and leaves of 5 sick individuals were collected at Site 1, considering 3 levels of visual foliar damage: leaves without damage (green), leaves with medium damage (discolored with green and brown) and full foliar damage (totally discolored) (see Figures 2 and 3).  To ensure similar environmental conditions at the same site (i.e., light regime, vertical location in the dossal), trees were preferably chosen far away from other trees, with leaves exposed to the sun but under the dossal, collecting those leaves without obvious herbivory damage [50]. All the individuals were adults ca. 10 meters tall, to avoid the different states of ontogeny [51]. The samples  Leaves of 3 healthy individuals were collected per site (n = 4; total n = 12) and leaves of 5 sick individuals were collected at Site 1, considering 3 levels of visual foliar damage: leaves without damage (green), leaves with medium damage (discolored with green and brown) and full foliar damage (totally discolored) (see Figures 2 and 3).  To ensure similar environmental conditions at the same site (i.e., light regime, vertical location in the dossal), trees were preferably chosen far away from other trees, with leaves exposed to the sun but under the dossal, collecting those leaves without obvious herbivory damage [50]. All the individuals were adults ca. 10 meters tall, to avoid the different states of ontogeny [51]. The samples To ensure similar environmental conditions at the same site (i.e., light regime, vertical location in the dossal), trees were preferably chosen far away from other trees, with leaves exposed to the sun but under the dossal, collecting those leaves without obvious herbivory damage [50]. All the individuals were adults ca. 10 meters tall, to avoid the different states of ontogeny [51]. The samples were taken at Forests 2020, 11, 59 5 of 17 a greater height than 5 meters with a tree pruner. Finally, leaves were collected and stored in kraft paper bags during the field sampling. Once in the laboratory they were kept at 50 • C in an oven for 15 days (model Schutzart, Memmert GmbH, Schwabach, Germany) until dryness.

Total Lipid Separation
The TLE was separated in two fractions of different polarity (fatty acids and neutral) via solid phase extraction using aminopropyl cartridges (Clean-up ® ) following published methods [54]. The neutral fraction, containing alkanes and alcohols, was eluted with 10 mL of DCM

Derivatization
The fatty acid and alcohol fractions were derivatized prior to instrumental analysis. Fatty acids were methylated with 500 µL of boron trifluoride in methanol, generating fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs). The alcohols were silylated, generating trimethylsilyl esters, using 25 µL of pyridine and 25 µL of bis-(trimethylsilyl)-trifluoroacetamide.

Leaf Wax Identification and Quantification
The leaf waxes were identified using a capillary gas chromatograph (GC17A-Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan, column 30 m HP5, 0.25 mm id, film thickness = 0.25 µm) with helium-carrier gas at constant flow of 1.4 mL min with mass spectrometry detector (QP-5050A; Shimadzu). The GC program started at 50 • C for 1 min, increased by 10 • C/min to 130 • C, maintained for 0.1 min at 130 • C, then increased by 4 • C/min to 325 • C, and was maintained for 15 min at 325 • C. The individual wax components were identified by comparing their mass spectra and retention times with those of authentic standards.
Leaf waxes were quantified by GC with flame ionization detection (7890A, Agilent, Santa Clara, CA, USA) with a quantification standard (5α-androstane), under the same conditions as above, but with H 2 as carrier gas. Coelution of compounds of interest was occasionally observed in the alcohol fraction, therefore, the quantification was estimated in all samples by peak integration in the mass chromatograms using characteristics m/z values and correcting for response factor. Then, all leaf wax abundances were normalized by the mass of the extracted dry leaf material expressed as µg/g dry leaf.
To compare with other studies, abundance (µg) was also normalized to area of dry leaf of A. araucana where n > 22 and Cn is the concentration of a fatty acids or alkanes with n carbons [35]. The carbon preference index was calculated following Equations (2) and (3) [34]: where the concentration of carbon chains ranges from 24 to 34 for fatty acids and from 23 to 33 for alkanes.

Statistical Analysis
A variance analysis (ANOVA) was applied to determine significant differences in abundance and distribution indices (ACL and CPI) of leaf waxes between healthy individuals at the different sites as well as between states of foliar damage of sick individuals (without, medium and full foliar damage), followed by a post-hoc Tuckey analysis to determine pairwise differences. In the case of healthy and sick individuals at Site 1, a T-test was applied to determine significant differences we assume for significant effects p < 0.05. Statistical analysis was performed with Sigma Plot 12.2 software (Systat Software, San José, CA, USA). All data available as Supplementary data (Data S1).

Leaf Waxes of Healthy A. araucana
In all healthy individuals sampled (n = 12), all three identified classes of leaf wax displayed similar relative abundance patterns. Fatty acids were greatest in abundance (from 445.8 ± 308.3 to 548.4 ± 82.6 µg/g of dry leaf), followed by alkanes (from 26.1 ± 18.8 to 95.6 ± 10.8 µg/g of dry leaf) and then alcohols (from 0.1 ± 0.1 to 2.2 ± 3.5 µg/g of dry leaf) (Figure 4, Supplementary Materials Table S1). The only class of leaf wax that show significant abundance differences among sites was alkanes (F = 6.925; p < 0.05).
Forests 2020, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 of 18 The average chain length was calculated following Equation (1): ACL (fatty acids) or (alkanes) = Σ Cn x n / Σ Cn (1) where n > 22 and Cn is the concentration of a fatty acids or alkanes with n carbons [35]. The carbon preference index was calculated following Equations (2) and (3) where the concentration of carbon chains ranges from 24 to 34 for fatty acids and from 23 to 33 for alkanes.

Statistical Analysis
A variance analysis (ANOVA) was applied to determine significant differences in abundance and distribution indices (ACL and CPI) of leaf waxes between healthy individuals at the different sites as well as between states of foliar damage of sick individuals (without, medium and full foliar damage), followed by a post-hoc Tuckey analysis to determine pairwise differences. In the case of healthy and sick individuals at Site 1, a T-test was applied to determine significant differences we assume for significant effects p < 0.05. Statistical analysis was performed with Sigma Plot 12.2 software (Systat Software, San José, CA, USA). All data available as Supplementary data (Data S1).

Leaf Waxes of Healthy A. araucana
In all healthy individuals sampled (n = 12), all three identified classes of leaf wax displayed similar relative abundance patterns. Fatty acids were greatest in abundance (from 445.8 ± 308.3 to 548.4 ± 82.6 μg/g of dry leaf), followed by alkanes (from 26.1 ± 18.8 to 95.6 ± 10.8 μg/g of dry leaf) and then alcohols (from 0.1 ± 0.1 to 2.2 ± 3.5 μg/g of dry leaf) (Figure 4, Supplementary Materials Table  S1). The only class of leaf wax that show significant abundance differences among sites was alkanes (F = 6.925; p < 0.05). The distributions of fatty acids and alkanes were slightly different among sites ( Figure 5). The difference observed in the ACL index was no more than two units but the CPI difference reaches

Individuals of Site 1 (Sick and Healthy)
Considering only samples of A. araucana at Site 1, where leaves without leaf damage were obtained from sick individuals in December 2017, and comparing with individuals in healthy condition sampled previously (January 2017), we observe that the total leaf wax abundance as well as individual abundances of all three classes of were higher in sick individuals than in healthy ones ( Figure 6; Table 1). The average abundance of fatty acids in sick individuals was 22.2% higher than in healthy ones (544.8 vs. 445.8 μg/g dry leaf). The relative difference in alkanes was even greater, with a mean abundance in sick individuals that was 233.8% greater than in healthy individuals (77.1 vs. 28.9 μg/g dry leaf). Finally, alcohol relative abundance had the greatest difference between sick and healthy individuals, with 1000% higher abundance in sick individuals than healthy individuals (23.1 vs. 2.2 μg/g dry leaf). The differences found were significant in alkanes (t = 2667; p < 0.05) and alcohols (t = 2584; p < 0.05).
The ACL of fatty acids varied from 27.5 in healthy individuals to 28.1 in sick individuals; and the CPI varies from 14.3 in healthy individuals and 18.8 in sick individuals. In alkanes, the ACL varies from 28.6 (healthy) to 29.4 (sick) and the CPI has a very similar range between sick and healthy individuals. Although the distribution index values were higher in sick individuals, the differences were not statistically significant.

Individuals of Site 1 (Sick and Healthy)
Considering only samples of A. araucana at Site 1, where leaves without leaf damage were obtained from sick individuals in December 2017, and comparing with individuals in healthy condition sampled previously (January 2017), we observe that the total leaf wax abundance as well as individual abundances of all three classes of were higher in sick individuals than in healthy ones ( Figure 6; Table 1). The average abundance of fatty acids in sick individuals was 22.2% higher than in healthy ones (544.8 vs. 445.8 µg/g dry leaf). The relative difference in alkanes was even greater, with a mean abundance in sick individuals that was 233.8% greater than in healthy individuals (77.1 vs. 28.9 µg/g dry leaf). Finally, alcohol relative abundance had the greatest difference between sick and healthy individuals, with 1000% higher abundance in sick individuals than healthy individuals (23.1 vs. 2.2 µg/g dry leaf). The differences found were significant in alkanes (t = 2667; p < 0.05) and alcohols (t = 2584; p < 0.05).
The ACL of fatty acids varied from 27.5 in healthy individuals to 28.1 in sick individuals; and the CPI varies from 14.3 in healthy individuals and 18.8 in sick individuals. In alkanes, the ACL varies from 28.6 (healthy) to 29.4 (sick) and the CPI has a very similar range between sick and healthy individuals. Although the distribution index values were higher in sick individuals, the differences were not statistically significant.
Other important aspects of leaf wax distribution are the most abundant chain length and abundance of each chain. The most abundant fatty acid chain length in sick and healthy individuals was octacosanoic acid (C 28 ; Table 1; Figure 7), with similar abundance in sick (185.7 µg/g) and healthy individuals (192.9 µg/g).     Each specific alkane chain length is more abundant in sick individuals, but in both healthy and sick individuals the dominant homologue C29, with three-fold greater abundance in sick individuals than healthy ones. Finally, the dominant chain length in alcohols was C24 with six-fold greater abundance in sick compared to healthy individuals. It is also important to mention that, the range of alcohol chain lengths for sick individuals was C24 to C28 and in the healthy individuals only the C24 chain was identified, another possible indicator of the presence of this disease.

Sick Individuals At Site 1: Three Levels of Foliar Damage
Leaf waxes were identified in three states in sick individuals: without foliar damage, medium Each specific alkane chain length is more abundant in sick individuals, but in both healthy and sick individuals the dominant homologue C 29 , with three-fold greater abundance in sick individuals than healthy ones. Finally, the dominant chain length in alcohols was C 24 with six-fold greater abundance in sick compared to healthy individuals. It is also important to mention that, the range of alcohol chain lengths for sick individuals was C 24 to C 28 and in the healthy individuals only the C 24 chain was identified, another possible indicator of the presence of this disease.

Sick Individuals At Site 1: Three Levels of Foliar Damage
Leaf waxes were identified in three states in sick individuals: without foliar damage, medium foliar damage and full foliar damage. We observe a decreasing trend of total alkane abundance with increasing damage, and the opposite trend in alcohols ( Table 1).
The ACL and CPI values were higher in leaves of sick individuals without leaf damage than in leaves with some degree of foliar damage (Figure 8). The mean values of ACL of alkanes and CPI of fatty acids show a trend of decreasing values as damage increases. The differences in the trends observed between levels of damage were significant in the CPI of fatty acids (F = 11,224; p < 0.05) and in the ACL of alkanes (F = 5879; p < 0.05), differentiating the leaves without damage from those with medium and full foliar damage (Tukey p < 0.05).

Discussion
Data on abundance and distribution of leaf waxes of this millennial tree is scarce and what is available is based on very few individuals. This study reports three different classes of leaf wax in individuals of A. araucana from different sites living in their natural habitat, and compares healthy and sick individuals from the same site to evaluate the influence of different leaf damage states on leaf wax distribution and abundance. The Araucariacea family has been present since the Triassic, with the first appearance of A. araucana in the Cretaceous [55]. Since then, this family has been diminished in number of species, with only two species remaining in the Araucaria genus and only A. araucana living and adapted in temperate forests with a decreasing trend in the distribution range [56]. Today this species vulnerability and current climate change context increase the management and restoration initiatives in South America [57]. Therefore, to increase the success in management and restoration initiatives is important to gather any ecological information about tree species like chemical properties in leaf waxes that might respond to environmental changes affecting interactions between organisms [58]. The following discussion section was conducted from an ecological perspective considering different levels of organization from chemical characteristics considering species, then different populations to finally end discussing at the individual level.

Discussion
Data on abundance and distribution of leaf waxes of this millennial tree is scarce and what is available is based on very few individuals. This study reports three different classes of leaf wax in individuals of A. araucana from different sites living in their natural habitat, and compares healthy and sick individuals from the same site to evaluate the influence of different leaf damage states on leaf wax distribution and abundance. The Araucariacea family has been present since the Triassic, with the first appearance of A. araucana in the Cretaceous [55]. Since then, this family has been diminished in number of species, with only two species remaining in the Araucaria genus and only A. araucana living and adapted in temperate forests with a decreasing trend in the distribution range [56]. Today this species vulnerability and current climate change context increase the management and restoration initiatives in South America [57]. Therefore, to increase the success in management and restoration initiatives is important to gather any ecological information about tree species like chemical properties in leaf waxes that might respond to environmental changes affecting interactions between organisms [58]. The following discussion section was conducted from an ecological perspective considering different levels of organization from chemical characteristics considering species, then different populations to finally end discussing at the individual level.

A. Araucana Leaf Wax Composition
Leaf wax compounds have a long alkyl chain that is apolar (hydrophobic) and a primary functionality such as hydroxyl, carbonyl or carboxyl group (e.g., [21]), which gives alcohols and fatty acids a polar region (hydrophilic) [59]. Thus, from an ecophysiological point of view a high percentage of fatty acids in the leaf waxes of individuals of A. araucana (more than 85% of total waxes analyzed) would increase the polarity of the waxy layer, which could be associated with the need for the cuticular layer to have more affinity with the water available in the environment for survival reasons. In contrast, a greater percentage of alkanes would confer a more hydrophobic layer, which would help to avoid the loss of water from inside the leaves.
Respect to the comparison between the three leaf wax classes in A. araucana other study report results with a dominance of alkanes (91.7%) over fatty acids (5.4%) and alcohols (2.9%) [30]. The difference in the dominance of the leaf wax classes with these study may be due to differences in the methodology of extraction (e.g., [52,53,[60][61][62]), the ontogeny stage of the plants [30] or the inclusion of just one part of the leaf waxes ( [32,63,64]). Studies of other Araucarias from the same family was been conducted and found higher abundance of alkanes, followed by fatty acid and alcohol in two species (Araucaria angustifolia and Agathis australis) [53]. It is important to highlight that in all of the above studies of species from the family Araucariacea, the leaf samples were taken from young individuals (ca. 2 to 6 years) maintained in greenhouses for years [30,53,60]. In contrast, in the present study we selected adult individuals in their native natural environment, where the species has lived for millions of years.

Dominant Homologues of Leaf Waxes
This study reports for the first time the dominant leaf wax fatty acid and alcohol where C 28 , C 26 and C 30 homologues (decreasing order) dominate in fatty acids and C 24 in alcohols. We observed C 29 to be the alkane dominant homologue in all sick and healthy A. araucana individuals. Other studies report C 29 [47] and C 33 [30] as dominant alkane homologues in A. araucana, but as already mentioned Dragota and Riederer analyzed leaves in other ontogenic stages [30]. In contrast, Raffi and Dodd reported leaf wax data from A. araucana adults located in four native zones of this species (The Andes and the Nahuelbuta coastal mountains in Chile) [47], and their observations are consistent with this study.

Leaf Waxes of A. araucana from the Four Sites
Differences in leaf wax abundances in the same species from different sites such as observed in this study has been reported previously, mainly in alkanes [65][66][67][68] and specifically in Araucaria araucana populations [47]. These differences have been attributed to several causes, being the environmental variables one of the main causes pointing out [69]. Variations in climatic conditions such as temperature or precipitation affect the abundance or chain length distribution of individual plants [43,66,67,70]. The change in the composition of leaf waxes has been proposed to be by genetic adaptation [47,68] or genetic expression [71]. Indeed, there are more than 100 genes implicated in the process of biosynthesis of leaf waxes [72]. In either case, adaptation or genetic expression, the ultimate cause producing the observed differences is environmental variables that would affect the water content of the leaf [37,73,74]. Cuticular leaf waxes play pivotal physiological and ecological roles. It is advantageous for trees to change their composition and properties in order to adapt to fluctuating environmental conditions [43,52,73].

Comparison of Sick and Healthy Individuals at Site 1
Sick individuals from site 1 had a greater abundance of total waxes, as well as a greater abundance of each class of wax (fatty acids, alkanes and alcohols) compared with healthy individuals at the same site, although this difference was only significant in alkanes and alcohols. ACL values of fatty acids and alkanes were higher in sick individuals (though not significantly; Table 1), most notably in the longer chains of fatty acids (i.e., C 28 , C 30 and C 32 ; Figure 7) and the highest abundance weighting of alkanes chains in these individuals. These results reflect a change in the biosynthesis process (see [21,25,32]) were a greater abundance of long chain alkanes and alcohols in sick individuals from A. araucana could indicate that the disease is intensifying the decarboxylation and reduction of the long chain length fatty acids.
Consequently, measuring both alkanes and alcohols in a population of A. araucana without visual foliar damage might help to identify sick individuals, in which high abundances of alkanes and presence of long chain alcohols (>C 24 ) would indicate the presence of disease. Interestingly, we do not observe differences in the dominant chain length between sick and healthy A. araucana individuals in all analyzed waxes (C 28 in fatty acids, C 29 in alkanes and C 24 in alcohols). However, sick A. araucana trees showed longer chain lengths of alcohols, which could be another potential early indicator of this unknown disease.

Potential Causes: Evidence of Leaf Wax Changes from Plant Diseases or Environmental Conditions
Several studies of the role of the cuticle in sick plants have been reported (e.g., [31,75,76]) with most describing a pathogenic disease because cuticle waxes help to prevent attack from bacteria, fungi and insects [75][76][77]. Belding et al. studied fungal infection, specifically from Peltaster fructicola and Leptodontidium elatius, in epicuticular waxes of apple cultivars, although the authors found differences in the relative proportions of alkanes, the differences were not related to the severity of fungal infection [75]. Marcell and Beatti evaluated the influence of foliar cuticle waxes on bacterial colonization in leaves from four bright corn mutants (Zea mays L.), determining that bacterial colonization was facilitated by a lower density of the crystalline waxes on the leaves [78]. It has also been proposed that thickness and three-dimensional structure of leaf wax crystalloids protect the leaves and fruits of fungal pathogens (Uncinula necátor) in grape berries [79]. These and other studies mention how important cuticle waxes are for the growth and infection of pathogens in the leaves (or aerial parts of plants), suggesting that a higher density (cuticle thickness) of waxes leads to better protection [80][81][82]. This change in wax density must increase cuticular permeability, minimizing the exudation of nutrients that favor the growth of pathogens [80][81][82][83]. Based on this information, we expect that changes in the chemical composition of leaf waxes observed here alter their permeability by increasing the compounds derived from long chains of fatty acids as was suggested by Jetter and Riederer [24]. This is the first study showing evidence of changes in the chemical composition of leaf waxes associated with disease, however, more studies are needed to determine the specific influence of pathogens on waxes.
In addition, combined action of drought or water stress with pathogen infection cannot be ruled out, since as plants produce a thicker and more complex cuticular wax layer in response to drought stress it would confer increased tolerance to pathogen infection [84]. Although our results show leaf wax changes in sick individuals of A. araucana, unfortunately, the origin and causes of the disease are still unknown.

Sick Individuals: Three Levels of Foliar Damage
The evaluation of leaf waxes considering different degrees of foliar damage in sick A. araucana individuals showed significant differences in distribution (index of ACL alkane and CPI fatty acid), but not in abundance. The CPI of fatty acids was higher in leaves without foliar damage than leaves with foliar damage. Low CPI values of leaf waxes have been associated with bacterial degradation (e.g., [85]). However, leaf waxes are considered difficult to degrade with slow degradation rates (>2 years) (e.g., [86]). An alternative and more plausible explanation of low CPI values is a cessation of biosynthesis of fatty acids when foliar damage occurs, with fatty acids biosynthesis continuing only in leaves of sick individuals without foliar damage. The ACL of alkanes was significantly higher in leaves of sick individuals without foliar damage indicating a greater abundance of odd long chain alkanes in leaves without foliar damage. This result also agrees with our previous interpretation of a cessation of in vivo biosynthesis of waxes in leaves with foliar damage. The alkanes due to their high conservation in terrestrial and aquatic environments have been the most studied leaf wax so far (e.g., [52,53,60]). Even so, ACL or CPI values of alkanes in many species, including A. araucana, have not been reported, this work shows differences between levels of damage in sick individuals.

Conclusions
This study reports a high abundance of long chain fatty acids compared to alkanes and alcohols in leaf waxes of A. araucana. A. araucana individuals have similar chemical leaf wax characteristics, where the most abundant chain in fatty acids is C 28 , in alkanes is C 29 and in alcohols C 24 . Leaf waxes are potential indicators of sick individuals in the A. araucana population, where a greater abundance of long chain length alkanes and alcohols observed even present in leaves without a visual foliar damage. A decrease in leaf wax distribution indices (CPI of fatty acids and ACL of alkanes) in leaves with foliar damage is interpreted as biochemical response where individuals stop in vivo biosynthesis of waxes.
Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at http://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/11/1/59/s1, Data S1: Supplementary data of abundance of chains in micro grams per area and weight of dry leaf; Table S1: Average abundance of each chain of fatty acids, alkanes and alcohols, distribution index (ACL and CPI) and the total waxes with their respective standard deviation of A. araucana individuals.
Author Contributions: S.C. planned research; S.C. and C.C.-P. carry on the sampling, G.C. and C.C.-P. did laboratory analysis; all authors contributed to interpretation, writing and editing of the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.