Development Review of Broadband and Multi-Band Outphasing Power Amplifiers for High-Efficiency Amplification

: Outphasing power amplifiers (OPAs) can be used in wireless information and power transfer systems due to their excellent conversion efficiency. With the rapid advancement of technology, there is a strong demand for OPAs to achieve wideband and multi-band operations to enhance frequency coverage. This paper provides a comprehensive review of the research progress on the development of broadband and multi-band board-level OPAs. Firstly, the paper introduces the fundamental components of an OPA. Then, the paper delves into a detailed analysis of the load modulation of OPAs. Subsequently, previous works on the circuit topology and design methods for broadband and multi-band OPAs are discussed and compared. The paper highlights various design strategies and their respective advantages and disadvantages. Finally, the paper explores some potential design methods for broadband and multi-band OPAs, discussing emerging technologies and highlighting potential research directions.


Introduction
Outphasing power amplifiers (OPAs) are famous for their high-efficiency amplification leveraging on active load modulation [1].A simplified block diagram of a classical OPA is shown in Figure 1.The high conversion efficiency of OPAs is achieved through phase modulation between two sub-amplifiers, which work in saturation conditions [2].An efficient power amplifier (PA) solution can be adopted, such as class-E or class-F, by the two sub-amplifiers to boost the conversion efficiency [3][4][5][6].Many studies have been conducted on OPAs, including circuit topology and design methods.For OPAs, the combiner plays a critical role for high-efficiency amplification [7,8].Figure 2 shows two most popular combiners, the Chireix combiner and the non-commensurate transmission line (NCTL) combiner, for board-level OPA design.
In 1985, F. Raab conducted an analysis of the efficiency of an outphasing power amplifier (OPA) based on the Chireix combiner, revealing that the average efficiency of an OPA is determined by the shunt reactance [7].This groundbreaking research demonstrated that optimal OPA efficiency can be achieved by selecting a shunt reactance that is precisely matched to the signal, thereby laying the theoretical foundation for subsequent advances in OPA design.Drawing on the principles established in Raab's seminal work, several highefficiency OPA implementations have been successfully realized, as documented in a series of subsequent studies [9][10][11][12][13].In [12], El-Asmar proposed a simplified analysis method for the design of the Chireix OPA, which underscores the importance of precise control over the characteristic impedance and length of parallel TLs in maximizing the OPA's average efficiency.In [13], an RF-input Chireix OPA working at 2.14 GHz was designed, maintaining a drain efficiency (DE) of more than 60% over a 5.5 dB output back-off (OBO) power range.This impressive feat underscores the practical significance of the theoretical insights and design methodologies that have been painstakingly developed and refined over the years, paving the way for continued innovation and advancement in the field of high-efficiency power amplification.However, the above Chireix OPAs require the addition of two extra compensation components in parallel to ensure efficiency peaks at the power back-off point, which increases the complexity of the circuit topology [14][15][16].To solve this problem, Gerhard proposed a new type of OPA combiner that eliminates the need for parallel reactance compensation components [14,15].The new OPA combiner consists of two TLs with different electrical lengths [15], as shown in Figure 2b.The NCTL combiner can reduce circuit complexity and facilitate the practical implementation of OPAs.It has been demonstrated in many papers that the NCTL combiner has the same functions as the Chireix combiner [15][16][17].In 2017, a 2.11 GHz RF-input OPA based on the NCTL combiner was successfully implemented and extensively analyzed, exhibiting a peak output power of 43.0 dBm coupled with a remarkable DE of 73% [17].To further enhance the efficiency, a harmonic-tuned OPA based on the NCTL combiner was realized at 0.9 GHz in [6], achieving a power-added efficiency (PAE) of more than 60% over an OBO power range of 7 dB.These advancements in OPA technology have opened up new possibilities for high-efficiency power amplification in a wide range of applications, paving the way for more efficient and reliable wireless communication systems.
Notice that the two types of OPA combiner mentioned above can be applied to multiway applications [18][19][20][21][22][23].In 2014, a 2.14 GHz four-way Chireix OPA was meticulously designed [20], achieving a remarkable maximum output power of 62 W with an impressive drain efficiency (DE) of over 50% at an 8.4 dB output back-off (OBO).This underscores the effectiveness and scalability of the Chireix combiner approach in high-power amplification scenarios.Two years later, in 2016, a 2.14 GHz OPA leveraging the NCTL combiner approach was implemented [23].This groundbreaking design demonstrated exceptional performance, delivering a saturation power of 105 W while maintaining a commendable DE of over 60% across a wide 6.2 dB OBO power range.This achievement underscores the potential of the NCTL combiner to enable highly efficient power amplification even in demanding multi-way configurations.These advancements offer valuable insights for the continued evolution of OPA technology, paving the way for future innovations in wireless communication systems that demand both high power and efficiency.
Though the above analysis shows that OPAs can achieve high efficiency over a large OBO power range, it is a challenge to design broadband or multi-band OPAs due to the frequency dispersion of the combiner [24,25].Previous works have demonstrated that both the Chireix and NCTL combiners have limited bandwidth (typically less than 200 MHz).Therefore, it is interesting to conduct research on novel architectures and methods to design broadband and multi-band OPAs.Given these constraints, there is a compelling interest in exploring innovative architectures and methodologies to facilitate the design of broadband and multi-band OPAs.This paper presents an overview of recent advancements in this area, delving into the fundamental principles of OPA technology before delving into a comprehensive review of broadband OPA designs.Subsequently, a thorough examination of multi-band OPAs is presented, discussing their unique characteristics and challenges.Finally, this paper presents potential design strategies aimed at extending the frequency coverage of OPAs, thus paving the way for more versatile and adaptable power amplification solutions.
By addressing these critical research gaps, this work aims to contribute to the continued evolution of OPA technology, enabling more efficient and effective power amplification across a broader range of frequencies.This, in turn, holds profound implications for enhancing the performance and capabilities of wireless communication systems, driving forward technological innovation in this dynamic field.

Load Modulation of OPAs
This section will analyze the load modulation of OPAs based on the NCTL combiner, because it is the most useful combiner for designing board-level OPAs.Moreover, the bandwidth limitation of OPAs will be discussed.The NCTL combiner of an OPA consists of two TLs with electrical lengths of 90 • ± ∆, as inllustrated in Figure 2b.The two sub- amplifiers of an OPA can be considered as two RF voltage sources V 1 and V 2 , which can be expressed as where φ defines the phase modulation of the OPA.Traditionally, the combining impedance is Z L = R L = Z 0 /2, as depicted in Figure 2b.Then, the load admittance of the two sub-amplifiers can be calculated as Using the load admittance of the two sub-amplifiers, the efficiency of the OPA can be obtained as Considering the frequency response of the OPA combiner, Equations ( 2)-( 4) can be be re-calculated as where In ( 5)-( 8), f is the normalized frequency, normalized to the center frequency.Using the above formulas, the load modulation trajectories of an OPA are shown in Figure 3 when Z L = Z 0 /2.At the center frequency, f 0 , the two sub-amplifiers see a real load impedance at both back-off and saturation power levels, leading to an combined efficiency of 100%, as indicated in Figure 4 (the circled red line).However, as f deviates from one, the two sub-amplifiers will see a complex load impedance at the back-off power level, as shown in Figure 3b,c.When the working frequency goes higher, a positive imaginary part will be presented to the sub-amplifier of the OPA, as shown in Figure 3b, while a negative imaginary part will be presented to the sub-amplifier of the OPA when the frequency goes lower, as shown in Figure 3c.The reactive part of the load impedance presented to each sub-amplifier will decrease the combined efficiency, as shown in Figure 4. Therefore, the bandwidth of the OPA is limited by the frequency dispersion of the combiner.Output Back-off Level (dB)

Review of Broadband OPAs
As illustrated in the above section, the combiner of an OPA limits its bandwidth.Therefore, it is interesting but challenging to address the bandwidth limitation of the OPA combiner.This section will review the state-of-the-art works for broadband OPA design [24][25][26][27].In summary, there are three popular methods for extending the bandwidth of an OPA.These three methods can be named as broadband class-E OPA, broadband reconfigurable OPA and complex combined OPA.They will be discussed separately in the following parts.

Broadband Class-E OPAs
As a highly-efficient switch-mode power amplifier, class-E operation mode can be adopted by the sub-amplifier of an OPA to boost the conversion efficiency.To extend the bandwidth of an OPA, a fully analytical combiner design technique was developed for wideband class-E OPAs in [25].The design parameters of the combiner network are firstly calculated based on the boundary conditions required for high-efficiency class-E PAs.Then, the bandwidth of the OPA is extended by introducing continuous mode operation into the synthesis approach.The load impedance required by the OPA for class-E operation can be calculated using where n represents the harmonic index.Notice that the efficiency and output power are mainly affected by Z S 1 and Z S 2 [25].The factor R can be derived based on the output power level: According to the load modulation of the class-E PA, the design parameters of the OPA combiner can be derived.Based on the analytical combiner design method, a broadband class-E OPA was designed in [25], demonstrating that a DE of more than 71% can be obtained at saturation, and that more than 60% over a 6-dB OBO power range in the frequency band of 0.7-1.05GHz can be obtained.Meanwhile, the fabricated broadband OPA in [25] was also simulated using a 5 MHz wideband signal.Simulation results showed that the broadband class-E OPA achieved an adjacent channel leakage ratio of better than −41 dBc with an average efficiency of more than 56% across the frequency band of interest.

Broadband Reconfigurable OPAs
Actually, the bandwidth of an OPA will be increased if optimal load modulation can be satisfied in a wide frequency band.To fulfill this requirement, tunable elements can be used in the OPA combiner to provide the OPA with optimal load modulation.This means a reconfigurable OPA has the potential to cover a wide bandwidth.In [27], a reconfigurable class-E OPA was proposed for broadband applications.To achieve optimum efficiency of the class-E OPA at different frequency bands, a single-ended class-E PA that achieved optimal operation under load modulation conditions was first analyzed.In [27], the losses of the switch were excluded for simplicity.The circuit can be described through a design set K(q, k, d) = {K L , K C , K P , K X }, where These design sets are a function of the parameters q (q = 1/(ω √ LC)) and k, which is the slope of the switch voltage waveform V sw across the output capacitor C at V sw (t) = 0 V.Then, the nominal load R 0 is derived using In [27], the analytical solution was reported for the combination of q, k and the duty cycle d (= T ON /T 0 ).According to q = 1/(ω √ LC), we can satisfy q at a different operating frequency without modifying L or C but by simply changing the duty cycle.Notice that the reconfigurable technique in [27] can only be used in switch mode PAs and needs precise pulse width modulation.Meanwhile, the operating bandwidth of the OPA also depends on the duty cycle.In [27], a 1.8-2.2GHz class-E OPA based on a frequency reconfigurable duty cycle was constructed and measured.The peak output power was 42 dBm and varied +/− O.3 dB across the three frequency bands.The broadband class-E OPA exhibited a 6 dB back-off DE of more than 60% in the frequency band of 1.8-2.2GHz.

Complex Combining Impedance for Broadband Applications
Unlike the above works, a novel design methodology was proposed in [28] to extend the bandwidth of an NCTL-based OPA.As shown in Figure 5a, the frequency dispersion of the NCTL combiner limited the bandwidth of the OPA.To overcome this problem, a complex combining method was proposed, as shown in Figure 5b.Complex combining impedance can be used to compensate the reactive part presented to each sub-amplifier when the working frequency deviates from the center point.In this way, the two subamplifiers will see an almost purely real load impedance at the back-off power level, as shown in Figure 5b.
From ( 5) and ( 6), the load impedance of each sub-amplifier in the OPA is a function of the combining load Z L .To make sure each sub-amplifier sees a real load impedance at the back-off power level, the following equation should be satisfied: This equation means the reactive part of the load impedance presented to each subamplifier can be compensated by a specific Z L .After compensating the reactive part, the efficiency of the OPA will be recovered.Figure 6 compares the combining efficiency of an OPA at f = 0.9 when ∆ = 30 • .Compared to the real combining method, the OPA efficiency can be increased by 13.7% by using the complex combining method.Most importantly, the complex combined OPA does not need any tunable elements in the combiner.This will reduce extra power losses.Output Back-off Level (dB) Efficiency increased by 13.7% Figure 6.Calculated efficiencies of the NCTL combiner when f = 0.9.
To demonstrate the complex combining method, a high-efficiency broadband OPA operating at 1.7-2.2GHz frequency band was implemented and measured in [28].The measured saturation power and DE of the broadband OPA are 43.1-44.3dBm and respectively.At the same time, a DE of 45.4-70.4% can also be obtained at the 6 dB OBO power level.
To compare broadband high-efficiency OPAs, the performances of the recent published broadband OPAs are listed in Table 1.Correspondingly, the DE (or PAE) and output power of the broadband OPAs versus the working frequency are shown in Figure 7.

Review of Multi-Band OPAs
The above section shows some advanced techniques to extend an OPA's bandwidth.However, it is still hard for an OPA to maintain high efficiency when the fractional bandwidth exceeds 30%, as shown in Figure 7.To further extend the frequency coverage of an OPA, multi-band operation is a good candidate.Until now, only a few articles have carried out research on multi-band OPAs [29][30][31][32][33][34].Furthermore, the design methods in these articles can be divided into three categories: the reconfigurable technique based on tunable elements, multi-band matching topology based on the T or Π network and the multi-mode operation-based frequency periodicity of TLs.

Reconfigurable OPAs for Multi-Band Applications
The reconfigurable technique can be used not only to extend the bandwidth of an OPA but also to design multi-band OPAs.The load modulation trajectory of an OPA at different frequencies can be optimized by tunable elements, leading to multi-band operation.In [30], a tri-band OPA operating at 1.65, 2.1 and 2.35 GHz was realized by integrating a tunable capacitor and inductor into the Chireix combiner.The tunable capacitor and inductor were designed using varactor diode SMV1430 from SKYWORK.To support the high-voltage swing of the output signal, three varactor diodes with serial back-to-back connection were adopted by both the capacitor and inductor.In [30], the tri-band OPA obtained a DE of more than 40% over a 5-6 dB OBO power range at the targeted three frequency points.

Multi-Band Matching Topology for Multi-Band OPAs
It has been demonstrated by many multi-band PAs that Tand Π-type matching networks can be used to realize multi-band matching.Therefore, these multi-band matching topologies can be adopted by OPAs to enable multi-band operation.In [31,32], 2.6/3.5 GHz dual-band OPAs were realized based on the multi-band matching topology.
In [31], a dual-band Chireix OPA was realized using T-type matching topology.The input matching network (IMN), impedance inverter and the reactance compensation network were all realized based on T-type matching topology.A comprehensive theoretical formulation for calculating the parameters of the T-type matching topology was also given in [31].The fabricated dual-band OPA in [31] achieved saturation DEs of 71% and 64% at 2.6 and 3.5 GHz, respectively.Meanwhile, 6 dB back-off DEs of 58.4% and 50.1% were also measured at 2.6 and 3.5 GHz.
In [32], a 2.6/3.5 GHz dual-band OPA was designed based on a dual-band NCTL combiner, which was realized using stub-loaded transmission lines (SLTLs).Each subamplifier in the dual-band OPA adopted a broadband IMN.The SLTL in the NCTL combiner was constructed by integrating two T-type networks into a Π-type network.The circuit parameters of the SLTL after each sub-amplifier were calculated leveraging the ABCDmetric theory.Based on the schematic shown in [32], a dual-band OPA was simulated, fabricated and measured, exhibiting excellent performances.At 2.6 GHz, the measured average output power was 37.3 dBm and a DE of 51.2% can be achieved, respectively.At 3.5 GHz, the measured output power and efficiency were 36.9 dBm and 40.6%, respectively.

Multi-Mode Multi-Band OPAs Based on Frequency Periodicity
Normally, the phase delay of a passive network is periodic.It has been demonstrated that the frequency periodicity of a transmission line can be utilized to design multi-mode PAs that cover an ultra-wideband area, such as the PAs in [24,35].The frequency periodicity can also be adopted when designing multi-band OPAs, especially NCTL-based OPAs.
In [33], the authors demonstrated that the OPA could obtain correct load modulation by adding an additional half-wavelength transmission line to one of the branches in the NCTL combiner.It was validated in [33] that the three NCTL combiners are all suitable for OPA design.From [33], the phase delay of the transmission lines in the combiners are different.Meanwhile, for a fixed NCTL combiner, it has different electrical behaviors at different frequencies.Therefore, dual-band operation can be obtained if an NCTL combiner conforms to one of the three combiners at two different frequency points.Based on this theory, a dual-band OPA working at 2.6 and 3.5 GHz was implemented and measured in [33].The dual-band OPA in [33] achieve maximum output powers of 44.4 and 44.3 dBm with DEs of 69.5% and 69.2% at 2.6 and 3.5 GHz, respectively.Meanwhile, 6 dB back-off DEs of 62.4% and 63.5% were also obtained by the dual-band OPA at 2.6 and 3.5 GHz, respectively.
As shown in [33], the base length of transmission lines in the NCTL combiner is 90 • .Indeed, there are two solutions of base length that can be used to construct OPAs.One is 90 • and the other is 180 • , as shown in Figure 8a,b.Meanwhile, the delta length (∆ 1 and ∆ 2 in Figure 8) should be different.In [34], the authors defined these two solutions as Mode-I and Mode-II, respectively.According to the theoretical analysis in [34], the load modulation trajectories of these two operation modes are opposite to each other, as shown in Figure 9. Therefore, the OPAs operating in Mode-I and Mode-II are, respectively, named OPA and inverted OPA (IOPA).To enable a 6 dB OBO power level in each operation mode, ∆ 1 = 30 • and ∆ 2 = 60 • should be simultaneously satisfied.Figure 10 shows the phase delay requirements of the OPA and IOPA.Notice that the phase delay of the transmission lines in the IOPA combiner is twice that in the OPA combiner.As we all know, the phase delay of a transmission line changes linearly versus by frequency.Therefore, a dual-band OPA can be obtained if the higher frequency f H is two times the lower frequency ( f L ). the proposed theory.d as follows.Section II he proposed dual-mode the implementation and measurement results of n in Section IV.Finally, in Section V.
-BAND OPA inly determined by the neralized block diagram combiner of the OPA is (TLs) TL 1 and TL 2 .The us normalized frequency

B. Dual-Mode Dual-Band OPA
In this part, for simplicity, n = 1 is adopted to analysis the dual-mode dual-band OPA.Meanwhile, the combining impedance R L is set to Z 0 /2, where Z 0 is the optimal load impedance of the utilized transistors.And a 6 dB OBO power level is expected by each operation mode.
The sub-amplifiers in the OPA operate in saturation.Therefore, the two sub-amplifiers can be regarded as two RF voltage sources, as shown in Fig. 1.And Then, the relationship between the port voltages and currents of the NCTLC can be expressed as, where the ABCD matrix in ( 2) is obtained by cascading the A dual-band OPA was realized in [34] to verify the dual-mode theory.The operation frequencies were set to 1 and 2 GHz (two times), respectively.The OPA delivered a maximum output power of 42.For comparison, the measurement results of state-of-the-art dual-band OPAs are listed in Table 2. Similarly, the drain efficiency and output power of the recently published multi-band OPAs versus the working frequency are shown in Figure 11.Then, Y 1 and Y 2 in Mode-II can be obtained as, And the relationship between ∆ 2 and the OBO level β can be expressed as, Finally, using the computing method described in [18], the theoretical efficiency of both the OPA and IOPA can be expressed as, By comparing ( 6) and ( 7) with ( 10) and ( 11), the load modulation trajectories of the OPA and IOPA operation modes are the opposite of each other, as shown in Fig. 3. Compared to the OPA operation mode, a reversed load modulation trajectory is obtained by the IOPA operation mode, as shown in Fig. 3(a) and (b).In these two figures, ∆ 1 and ∆ 2 are set to 30 • and 60 • , respectively.
To enable a 6 dB OBO power level in each operation mode, ∆ 1 =30 • and ∆ 2 =60 • should be simultaneously satisfied according to (8) and (12).Therefore, the combiner parameters of the dual-mode dual-band OPA can be illustrated in Fig. 4. In this figure, the operating frequencies of the OPA and IOPA modes are set to f L and f H , respectively.It can be noted in Fig. 4 that both the base and delta lengths in IOPA mode is twice that in the OPA mode.Therefore, based on (1), f H should be two times f L .In this way, the electrical lengths of TL 1 and TL 2 in the OPA mode are 60 • and 120 • , respectively.While the electrical lengths of TL 1 and TL 2 in the IOPA mode are

III. DESIGN OF A DUAL-MO
To verify the proposed theory, a is implemented in this part.In this and 2 GHz (two times), respectiv substrate with a thickness of 20 transistors are CGH40010F from impedance Z 0 of this kind of tra drain and gate bias voltages of th to 28 and -3 V, respectively.

A. Design of a dual-mode dual-ba
Firstly, the output combiner net is constructed.The NCTLC is com TL 2 ) with a characteristic impedan Meantime, the electrical lengths of the design parameters shown in Fi the intrinsic elements of the utiliz the above analysis part.To remov elements of the utilized transistor combiner should be composed by (OMN) and the intrinsic element schematic of the composited TL 1 .W terminated with 30 Ω at two sides, are shown in Fig. 5(b).This figu    2, where the arrow represents the direction of the reference Y-axis [30][31][32][33][34].

Potential Solutions for Broadband and Multi-Band OPAs
The above two sections presented some progress of broadband and multi-band OPAs.Though there exist some promising design methods, more advanced techniques are still required to further improve the frequency coverage of OPAs.Based on previous research, the reconfigurable technique based on tunable elements is a popular method to design broadband and multi-band OPAs.However, the tunable elements will complicate the OPA design and cause additional power loss.In view of the above, the complex combining method proposed in [25] and the analytical combiner design technique proposed in [28] are two potential solutions to design broadband OPAs.For multi-band OPAs, two operation modes based on the periodicity of the transmission line were explored in [34].Indeed, more operation modes of the OPA can be further enriched by considering the frequency periodicity of the NCTL combiner.Therefore, to achieve multi-band OPAs, one potential solution is to fully utilize the periodicity of the NCTL combiner.On the other hand, the digital control technique could provide flexible input signal splitting [36][37][38][39][40].For traditional OPAs, the problem of high system complexity limits their application to some extent.With the development of the digital control technique, its introduction into the OPA system can effectively solve this problem.Through the optimization of the digital front end, the efficiency and output power of OPAs can be maximized.
Another noteworthy point is that the efficiency and linearity of OPAs are highly related to the symmetry of their two sub-amplifiers.It is very difficult to design a fully symmetrical sub-amplifier, especially for wideband operation.To realize symmetrical sub-amplifiers in an OPA, accuracy models are required by both the active and passive elements.Therefore, it is valuable to conduct research on the modeling of the transistors and passive elements, especially in integrated systems.

Conclusions
This paper gives a comprehensive review of the development of broadband and multiband OPAs for high-efficiency amplification.The OPA load modulation is studied based on an NCTL combiner.Furthermore, the bandwidth limitation of OPAs is discussed.Some promising methods for extending the bandwidth of OPAs are presented, including the analytical combiner synthesis technique, the reconfigurable technique and the complex combining technique.Subsequently, the design methods for multi-band OPAs are discussed.Finally, the potential design methods for broadband and multi-band OPAs are pointed out.In summary, this paper systematically summarizes the development of broadband and multi-band OPAs for high-efficiency amplification.These research findings provide valuable references for the design and application of high-efficiency PAs and offer direction and inspiration for future research.Based on the review in this paper, the design theories of broadband and multi-band OPAs are far from mature.Therefore, there are many aspects worth studying to improve the performances of OPAs.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4. Efficiency of the NCTL combiner versus output power at different frequency points.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. Simplified block diagram and combining methods of (a) the traditional NCTL-based OPA and (b) the complex combined OPA.

Figure 8 .
Figure 8. Block diagrams of the dual-mode OPA when it operates in (a) Mode-I and (b) Mode-II in [34].IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON CIRCUITS AND SYSTEMS II: EXPRESS BRIEFS, VOL.X, NO.X, 2023

Fig. 3 .
Fig. 3. Load modulation trajectories of the proposed dual-mode dual-band OPA in (a) Mode-I and (b) Mode-II.
8-43 dBm, a saturation DE of 58.4-62.5%, a saturation gain of 9.7-10.1 dB and a 6 dB back-off DE of 41.3-46.2%over 0.89-0.93GHz (40 MHz) in Mode-I.On the other hand, when the OPA was in Mode-II, it achieved a maximum output power of 43.7-44.3dBm, a saturation DE of 50.6-57.7%,a saturation gain of 10.8-11.5 dB and a 6 dB back-off DE of 50.1-62.3%over 1.89-1.96GHz (70 MHz).

Figure 10 .
Figure 10.Phase delay requirements of the OPA and IOPA.

Figure 11 .
Figure 11.Drain efficiency and output power of the recently published multi-band OPA versus the working frequency in Table2, where the arrow represents the direction of the reference Y-axis[30][31][32][33][34].

Table 1 .
Performance comparison of recently published broadband OPAs.

Table 2 .
Measurement results and performance comparison of recently published multi-band OPAs.