Aerodynamic Characteristics of Wind Turbines Operating under Hazard Environmental Conditions: A Review

: This paper provides a review of the aerodynamic behavior of horizontal axis wind turbines operating in hazardous environmental conditions. Over the past decade, renewable energy use has accelerated due to global warming, depleting fossil fuel reserves, and stricter environmental regulations. Among renewable options, solar and wind energy have shown economic viability and global growth. Horizontal axis wind turbines offer promising solutions for sustainable energy demand. Since wind turbines operate in an open environment, their efﬁciency depends on environmental conditions. Hazard environmental conditions, such as icing, rainfall, hailstorms, dust or sand, insects’ collisions, increased humidity, and sea spray, result in degraded aerodynamic characteristics. The outcome of most studies has been that the airfoils’ lift is degraded, and at the same time, drag is increased when wind turbines operate under these conditions. The objective of this review is to improve our comprehension of these crucial aspects so they are taken into account when designing wind turbine blades, and it offers suggestions for future research paths. It serves as a valuable resource that can inspire researchers who are dedicated to enhancing the aerodynamic characteristics of horizontal axis


Introduction
Over the past decade, the utilization of renewable energy sources (RES) has witnessed a significant acceleration in response to the escalating threats posed by global warming, the reduction in fossil fuel reservoirs, and the implementation of stricter environmental regulations in the global energy market and society [1].Among all the available renewable energy options, solar energy and wind energy have emerged as the most economically viable sources, experiencing rapid growth on a global scale [2]. Figure 1 illustrates the global distribution of operational and under construction wind farms with capacities of 10 MW or more.
After experiencing a consecutive decline over the past two years, the capacity additions for onshore wind energy are projected to witness a remarkable recovery in 2023, with an anticipated increase of 70% to reach a historic milestone of 107 GW [3].This resurgence can primarily be attributed to the successful completion of delayed projects in China that were affected by the COVID-19 restrictions imposed last year.Furthermore, accelerated expansion is expected across Europe and the USA, as the challenges faced in the supply chain have caused project commissioning to be postponed from 2022 to 2023.Conversely, the development of offshore wind energy is not projected to match the unprecedented expansion achieved two years ago, largely due to the limited number of projects currently under construction outside of China.
Two main types of wind turbines exist, categorized based on their rotor structure and position in airflow: horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) and vertical axis wind Energies 2023, 16, 7681 2 of 43 turbines (VAWTs).HAWTs have gained significant popularity in the commercial electricity generation sector, owing to a considerable amount of time and effort having been invested in their research and development, due to their higher efficiency.The present review paper primarily examines HAWTs, which enjoy a broader adoption and are commonly employed in wind farms.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 43 Two main types of wind turbines exist, categorized based on their rotor structure and position in airflow: horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) and vertical axis wind turbines (VAWTs).HAWTs have gained significant popularity in the commercial electricity generation sector, owing to a considerable amount of time and effort having been invested in their research and development, due to their higher efficiency.The present review paper primarily examines HAWTs, which enjoy a broader adoption and are commonly employed in wind farms.The efficiency of a HAWT is influenced by numerous variables, including the wind speed during operation, the length of the blades, the height of the tower, the design of the casing, and the environmental conditions in the vicinity, including weather conditions, as well as collisions with birds and insects [5].
The aerodynamics of the blade significantly impacts the performance of a HAWT.Additionally, collisions with birds and insects can disrupt the blade's aerodynamic profile, resulting in increased aerodynamic drag and a subsequent decrease in power generation of up to 50% [6][7][8].Moreover, the accumulation of ice on the surface further impacts the HAWT's performance, leading to a potential decrease in power generation ranging from 20% to 50% [6].Under normal circumstances, the performance of a HAWT is closely linked to the wind speed profile at a specific site.Any variations in wind speed profiles have a substantial impact on turbine performance.
Achieving accurate calculations of HAWT power curves is crucial for power performance testing and annual energy production (AEP) assessments..The presence of icing causes a decrease in the AEP by up to 17% and leads to a reduction in the power coefficient within the range of 20-50% [9].Rainfall has the potential to induce erosion on the surfaces of HAWT blades, leading to an increase in surface roughness, which eventually increases the aerodynamic drag of the blades [10][11][12][13][14][15].Consequently, this leads to a decline in performance and a subsequent loss of energy [10,16].It is worth noting that erosion on HAWT blades can result in AEP losses of up to 25% [17][18][19][20].Moreover, the accumulation of dirt and insects on the blade surface can result in roughness, leading to a potential decrease of up to 50% in power output [6,21,22].The effects of increased surface roughness, resulting The efficiency of a HAWT is influenced by numerous variables, including the wind speed during operation, the length of the blades, the height of the tower, the design of the casing, and the environmental conditions in the vicinity, including weather conditions, as well as collisions with birds and insects [5].
The aerodynamics of the blade significantly impacts the performance of a HAWT.Additionally, collisions with birds and insects can disrupt the blade's aerodynamic profile, resulting in increased aerodynamic drag and a subsequent decrease in power generation of up to 50% [6][7][8].Moreover, the accumulation of ice on the surface further impacts the HAWT's performance, leading to a potential decrease in power generation ranging from 20% to 50% [6].Under normal circumstances, the performance of a HAWT is closely linked to the wind speed profile at a specific site.Any variations in wind speed profiles have a substantial impact on turbine performance.
Achieving accurate calculations of HAWT power curves is crucial for power performance testing and annual energy production (AEP) assessments.The presence of icing causes a decrease in the AEP by up to 17% and leads to a reduction in the power coefficient within the range of 20-50% [9].Rainfall has the potential to induce erosion on the surfaces of HAWT blades, leading to an increase in surface roughness, which eventually increases the aerodynamic drag of the blades [10][11][12][13][14][15].Consequently, this leads to a decline in performance and a subsequent loss of energy [10,16].It is worth noting that erosion on HAWT blades can result in AEP losses of up to 25% [17][18][19][20].Moreover, the accumulation of dirt and insects on the blade surface can result in roughness, leading to a potential decrease of up to 50% in power output [6,21,22].The effects of increased surface roughness, resulting from factors such as sand or insect impacts, as well as erosion caused by rain, on the power output of HAWTs were examined in [23].
Energies 2023, 16, 7681 3 of 43 Hence, it is imperative to comprehensively examine all the variables influencing HAWT aerodynamic characteristics and discuss potential solutions.HAWTs offer a promising solution to address the growing demand for sustainable energy in the future, presenting an appealing technology for harnessing wind energy and converting it into electricity or other useful forms.This review aims to enhance our understanding of the key parameters that must be considered during HAWT blade design and provides recommendations for future research areas.

Aerodynamic Performance of Wind Turbines
The blades of the wind turbine harness the kinetic energy of the incoming wind and convert it into mechanical energy stored in the shaft.The shaft is then linked to an electrical generator, which produces electricity.The power output of a wind turbine is determined by the speed of the incoming wind, the size of the turbine, and the area it sweeps.The maximum amount of kinetic energy extractable from the wind is approximately 59.3% of the total available wind power, according to the Betz limit [24].The power generated by a wind turbine (P) is in direct proportion to the density of the air (ρ), the rotor sweep area (A), the cube of the wind velocity (u), and the aerodynamic coefficient (C p ) as shown by Equation (1) [25].
The maximum aerodynamic coefficient (C p max ) for HAWTs can be calculated by the empirical Equation (2), proposed by Wilson et al. [26]: where λ is the tip speed ratio (TSR), ranging from 4 to 20, B is the number of blades, and c L and c D are the aerodynamic coefficients of lift and drag, respectively.It is apparent that the generated power of HAWTs depends on the airfoils, from which the blades are constructed.Thus, any changes in the flow field could lead to changes in the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoils, and finally impact the power production of HAWTs.

Aerodynamic Characteristics of Wind Turbines under Hazard Environmental Conditions
The aerodynamic characteristics of airfoils and wind turbine blades when subjected to adverse environmental conditions necessitates an understanding of how these conditions influence airfoil performance and behavior.Such environmental hazards, such as icing, rainfall, and hailstorms, among others, present specific difficulties that noticeably influence the fundamental principles of airfoil and wind turbine blade aerodynamics.
Icing occurs when supercooled water droplets solidify on the surface of the blade, resulting in an augmented load and structural perturbations that can significantly impair the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil.The presence of ice on the surface causes more turbulence in the airflow, leading to increased drag.As a result, the lift generated by the blade decreases, reducing its ability to produce power.
The impact of raindrops on the airfoil surface precipitates an increase in drag and consequent influences on the lift-to-drag ratio, resulting in an overall reduction in operational efficiency and power generation.Moreover, the prolonged interaction of raindrops with the blade's surface can cause erosion, altering the aerodynamic profile and further impinging on the blade's performance.
Hailstorms can cause significant harm as well.When hailstones impact the wind turbine blades, they can cause physical damage to them.This damage includes cracks, dents, and changes in shape, which disrupt the normal airflow, leading to a decrease in performance.The occurrence of hailstorms raises concerns about the safety of both the wind turbine and its surroundings.To address these concerns, protective measures need to be taken, and strong blade design practices should be implemented.
When dust and sand are carried by the wind, they can potentially abrade the blade surface, inducing alterations in surface smoothness and shape.Furthermore, the accumulation of particles can disturb the airflow over the blade surface, increasing drag and decreasing lift as a result.
Other hazard conditions that degrade the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWTs are insects, humidity, and sea spray.Accumulated insects on blade surfaces block the airflow, causing an increase in drag.Elevated humidity levels influence air density, thus affecting the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil.The salty composition of sea spray causes corrosion and material deterioration on blade surfaces, with consequent effects on aerodynamic performance.
To comprehensively examine the various aspects of the aerodynamic characteristics of wind turbines in hazardous environmental conditions, the literature reviewed has been organized into distinct categories.This classification is intended to present readers with a well-structured framework that facilitates their comprehension of the numerous challenges and factors associated with this field.Firstly, the impact of icing on wind turbines' aerodynamic characteristics is thoroughly examined.Then, rainfall, another environmental factor significantly affecting the aerodynamic characteristic of wind turbines, is explored.Following this, hailstorms, known for presenting unique challenges to wind turbines' aerodynamic characteristics and causing damage and performance degradation, are presented.Subsequently, dust and sand are discussed, which are often ignored even though they significantly influence the wind turbines' performance and lifespan.In addition to the previously mentioned categories, additional hazard conditions are addressed, including the effects of insects, humidity, and sea spray, offering a comprehensive perspective on the broader spectrum of environmental challenges.

Icing
Many countries in cold climate regions already harness wind energy and will increasingly rely on it due to their favorable, abundant wind resources.These regions offer a naturally advantageous environment for wind energy utilization.To ensure optimal power production, HAWT manufacturers, including airfoil designers for turbine blades, must account for the challenging conditions caused by atmospheric icing events.Wind farms located in cold regions with higher altitudes are particularly promising, as wind speeds tend to increase by approximately 0.1 m•s −1 for every 100 m of altitude over the initial 1000 m [27].Additionally, colder regions benefit from a wind power potential approximately 10% greater than other areas, thanks to their higher air density.The denser cold air boosts the kinetic energy of the wind, resulting in increased power generation for HAWTs [28].Figure 2 shows the mean snow cover duration obtained across the last 23 years on an annual basis.
In cold climate regions, icing is a physical phenomenon that significantly impacts the performance of HAWTs and poses a significant challenge.There are two primary types of ice formation: glaze ice and rime ice [21].Glaze ice forms when rain freezes on cold surfaces and typically occurs near 0 • C. It appears transparent and spreads as ice sheets over large areas.On the other hand, rime ice develops when extremely cold moisture droplets in the atmosphere come into contact with a cold surface.Rime ice accumulates in temperatures below 0 • C. The presence of ice on aerodynamic surfaces negatively impacts HAWT performance and can lead to sensor failures or inaccurate readings on anemometers and wind vanes.Moreover, ice buildup can lead to rotor imbalances, impaired aerodynamic brakes, and power line disruptions, and pose a risk of falling ice hazards to personnel [21].
The formation of ice on HAWTs (Figure 3) can greatly affect the aerodynamic characteristics and power production.It has been observed that ice growth is influenced by changes in blade design, such as size and airfoil section, as well as the relative velocity The formation of ice on HAWTs (Figure 3) can greatly affect the aerodynamic characteristics and power production.It has been observed that ice growth is influenced by changes in blade design, such as size and airfoil section, as well as the relative velocity at each section of the blade.Various software codes have been developed to model and predict ice accretion on several surfaces.

•
LEWICE is a code for 2D ice accumulation created by the NASA Glenn Research Center [31].It utilizes a time-stepping procedure to forecast the shape of ice accumulation.The flow field mathematical computations are performed using the Douglas Hess-Smith 2D panel code.The obtained solution is then used to determine particle trajectories and the points at which they impinge on the object.Additionally, LEW-ICE incorporates an icing model to estimate the rate and shape of ice growth.

•
The Turbine Blade Icing Model (TURBICE) is a 2D simulation program specifically designed to anticipate ice accretion on HAWT blades [32,33].The blade's potential flow field is determined by panel methods, while droplet trajectories and impingement calculations are performed using a Lagrangian technique.Additionally, TUR-BICE has the ability to estimate the energy necessary for heating in order to prevent ice accumulation on the blade surface.

•
FENSAP-ICE represents a premier 3D in-flight icing simulation solver [34,35].It simulates the flow field, impacts of droplets, and ice shapes, and predicts anti/de-icing The formation of ice on HAWTs (Figure 3) can greatly affect the aerodynamic characteristics and power production.It has been observed that ice growth is influenced by changes in blade design, such as size and airfoil section, as well as the relative velocity at each section of the blade.Various software codes have been developed to model and predict ice accretion on several surfaces.

•
LEWICE is a code for 2D ice accumulation created by the NASA Glenn Research Center [31].It utilizes a time-stepping procedure to forecast the shape of ice accumulation.The flow field mathematical computations are performed using the Douglas Hess-Smith 2D panel code.The obtained solution is then used to determine particle trajectories and the points at which they impinge on the object.Additionally, LEW-ICE incorporates an icing model to estimate the rate and shape of ice growth.

•
The Turbine Blade Icing Model (TURBICE) is a 2D simulation program specifically designed to anticipate ice accretion on HAWT blades [32,33].The blade's potential flow field is determined by panel methods, while droplet trajectories and impingement calculations are performed using a Lagrangian technique.Additionally, TUR-BICE has the ability to estimate the energy necessary for heating in order to prevent ice accumulation on the blade surface.

•
FENSAP-ICE represents a premier 3D in-flight icing simulation solver [34,35].It simulates the flow field, impacts of droplets, and ice shapes, and predicts anti/de-icing • LEWICE is a code for 2D ice accumulation created by the NASA Glenn Research Center [31].It utilizes a time-stepping procedure to forecast the shape of ice accumulation.The flow field mathematical computations are performed using the Douglas Hess-Smith 2D panel code.The obtained solution is then used to determine particle trajectories and the points at which they impinge on the object.Additionally, LEWICE incorporates an icing model to estimate the rate and shape of ice growth.

•
The Turbine Blade Icing Model (TURBICE) is a 2D simulation program specifically designed to anticipate ice accretion on HAWT blades [32,33].The blade's potential flow field is determined by panel methods, while droplet trajectories and impingement calculations are performed using a Lagrangian technique.Additionally, TURBICE has the ability to estimate the energy necessary for heating in order to prevent ice accumulation on the blade surface.

•
FENSAP-ICE represents a premier 3D in-flight icing simulation solver [34,35].It simulates the flow field, impacts of droplets, and ice shapes, and predicts anti/deicing heat loads.FENSAP-ICE incorporates integrated computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modules to perform these calculations.The software employs 3D Navier-Stokes and energy equations to analyze the flow field, along with a 3D Eulerian model for calculating droplet behavior.
Limited efforts have been undertaken to incorporate rotational effects when simulating the 3D model of an entire HAWT blade at full scale [36][37][38].The buildup of ice on the blades (Figure 4) affects both the aerodynamic efficiency and safety.Icing can increase blade mass, alter the shape of the aerodynamic profile, cause abnormal tower vibrations, decrease torque, and result in power output losses [39,40].Even minor icing roughness on the blade surface can lead to a decrease in power output, while a severe icing event has the potential to result in a complete turbine shutdown [41].Pinar Pérez et al. [42] found that a wind farm consisting of 517 HAWTs experienced a 3% reduction in production as a result of blade icing over a period of 29 months.On the other hand, ice accumulation can lead to an increase in power output by altering the blade profile [41].
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 of 43 heat loads.FENSAP-ICE incorporates integrated computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modules to perform these calculations.The software employs 3D Navier-Stokes and energy equations to analyze the flow field, along with a 3D Eulerian model for calculating droplet behavior.
Limited efforts have been undertaken to incorporate rotational effects when simulating the 3D model of an entire HAWT blade at full scale [36][37][38].The buildup of ice on the blades (Figure 4) affects both the aerodynamic efficiency and safety.Icing can increase blade mass, alter the shape of the aerodynamic profile, cause abnormal tower vibrations, decrease torque, and result in power output losses [39,40].Even minor icing roughness on the blade surface can lead to a decrease in power output, while a severe icing event has the potential to result in a complete turbine shutdown [41].Pinar Pérez et al. [42] found that a wind farm consisting of 517 HAWTs experienced a 3% reduction in production as a result of blade icing over a period of 29 months.On the other hand, ice accumulation can lead to an increase in power output by altering the blade profile [41].Icing poses a critical challenge for HAWTs operating in cold environments, as it is impacted by multiple fluctuating factors.Ice buildup on the airfoils of turbine blades leads to a significant decline in aerodynamic performance, ultimately leading to a loss in productivity.This ice accretion causes deformation in the airfoil's geometry, leading to pronounced turbulence, especially on the suction side of the airfoil when exposed to high AOAs.Employing modeling and simulation techniques is essential to evaluate the effects of icing on HAWT operations and enhance our comprehension of this phenomenon [44].
During the winter of 1990-1991, Bose [45] closely monitored the natural icing occurrences of a HAWT with a diameter of 1.05 m, designed for battery charging.The most severe icing events were observed as glaze ice accretion, which formed due to freezing rain and drizzle.The icing process exhibited a qualitatively similar pattern at the leading edge (LE) of the blade section, resembling the formation observed on fixed airfoil sections under comparable conditions in icing wind tunnels.The rotational motion of the blades contributed to a greater accumulation of ice at the blade tips compared to the blade roots.While the pressure side of the sections was covered in ice, a significant portion of the suction side remained free of ice.
A large and growing body of literature has investigated the ice formation process on airfoils and HAWT blades [46][47][48][49][50][51][52].The accumulation of ice on HAWT blades is affected by a combination of operating factors such as temperature, velocity, mean volume Icing poses a critical challenge for HAWTs operating in cold environments, as it is impacted by multiple fluctuating factors.Ice buildup on the airfoils of turbine blades leads to a significant decline in aerodynamic performance, ultimately leading to a loss in productivity.This ice accretion causes deformation in the airfoil's geometry, leading to pronounced turbulence, especially on the suction side of the airfoil when exposed to high AOAs.Employing modeling and simulation techniques is essential to evaluate the effects of icing on HAWT operations and enhance our comprehension of this phenomenon [44].
During the winter of 1990-1991, Bose [45] closely monitored the natural icing occurrences of a HAWT with a diameter of 1.05 m, designed for battery charging.The most severe icing events were observed as glaze ice accretion, which formed due to freezing rain and drizzle.The icing process exhibited a qualitatively similar pattern at the leading edge (LE) of the blade section, resembling the formation observed on fixed airfoil sections under comparable conditions in icing wind tunnels.The rotational motion of the blades contributed to a greater accumulation of ice at the blade tips compared to the blade roots.While the pressure side of the sections was covered in ice, a significant portion of the suction side remained free of ice.
A large and growing body of literature has investigated the ice formation process on airfoils and HAWT blades [46][47][48][49][50][51][52].The accumulation of ice on HAWT blades is affected by a combination of operating factors such as temperature, velocity, mean volume diameter (MVD), and liquid water content (LWC), as well as geometric characteristics including size and shape.Varied temperatures and heat distribution across the HAWT blades result in the formation of ice with differing masses and shapes.
Seifert and Richert [53] conducted an experimental investigation on a typical airfoil used in HAWT blades, specifically, the NACA 4415 airfoil.The study examined the aerodynamic coefficients of the airfoil with and without various types of ice formations at the LE.The aerodynamic degradation was more severe when more ice accumulated on the LE.The aerodynamic data obtained from the iced airfoil were utilized as input for load and power calculation codes, and the energy loss was predicted for a typical 300 kW turbine, revealing a 6% to 19% decrease in the AEP, depending on the ice formation, after three months of operation.
Jasinski et al. [54] conducted a study to estimate the impact of rime ice on the performance of HAWTs.They used the NASA LEWICE code to predict four rime ice formations on the S809 airfoil, used for HAWT blade construction, in conditions of usual supercooled fog, prevalent in cold northern regions.Wind tunnel experiments were conducted on the resulting airfoil/ice profiles to analyze the aerodynamic characteristics of lift, drag, and pitching moment at Reynolds numbers (Re) ranging from 1 to 2 million.The obtained data were then input into the PROPID HAWT performance prediction software to evaluate the impact of rime ice on a 450 kW rated power, 28.7 m diameter HAWT operating in both stallregulated and variable-speed/variable-pitch modes.The variable-speed/variable-pitch rotor showed reduced performance of approximately 20%.On the other hand, for the stallregulated rotor, even a minor rime ice formation led to much greater performance losses.
[55] experimentally studied the NACA 63 415 airfoil under two in-fog icing conditions.The measurements encompassed the forms and sizes of the ice deposits, alongside the aerodynamic forces exerted on the ice-covered profiles.During the wet-regime testing, glaze primarily developed near the LE and on the pressure side, while also accumulating through run-off on the trailing edge (TE) of the outer portion of the blade.In the dry-regime testing, rime predominantly accreted on the LE forming horn-shaped structures.In both icing events, the presence of glaze or rime on the blade profile resulted in a reduced lift of 40% and an increased drag of about 365% for glaze and 250% for rime ice.
Zhao et al.
[56] investigated the fault mechanism of HAWT blade icing through theoretical and experimental analysis.Initially, the aerodynamic characteristics of the S830 airfoil was simulated under normal and icing conditions.The simulation results indicated that the irregular icing coverage significantly alters the airfoil's aerodynamics, leading to a decrease in the lift coefficient and an increase in the drag coefficient, consequently resulting in a direct reduction in power output.Furthermore, icing-induced mass unbalance generated an exciting force causing power frequency vibrations in the HAWT.They concluded that there are two ways to identify icing-through direct and indirect means, with decreases in power output and power frequency vibrations serving as evidence of the presence of icing or similar conditions.
Homola et al. [57] conducted a numerical study to investigate the impact of fluctuations in atmospheric temperature and droplet size on the rate and morphology of ice accretion, as well as the resulting flow field characteristics, for a 5 MW pitch controlled HAWT with blades constructed by the NACA 64-618 airfoil.The findings indicated that while icing leads to a reduction in lift coefficients across all scenarios, the extent of this reduction varied.Specifically, the cases yielding streamlined ice shapes resembling rime ice exhibited minimal changes in lift, whereas those resulting in horn-shaped glazed ice experienced more significant reductions in lift.These results underscore the necessity of obtaining accurate measurements of the atmospheric conditions during icing events to reliably estimate energy production losses, considering the specific shape and type of ice accretion.
Villalpando et al. [58] examined the influence of ice accretion on the aerodynamic coefficients of a HAWT airfoil.CFD simulations were conducted at various AOAs, considering both the NACA 63-415 clean airfoil and the same airfoil with ice accumulation.The presence of ice on the airfoil significantly alters the pressure distribution (Cp).Notably, it increases the minimum Cp value, thereby diminishing the suction effect on the suction side Energies 2023, 16, 7681 8 of 43 of the airfoil.As pressure forces are the primary contributors to lift and drag coefficients, the aerodynamic characteristics experience notable effects, resulting in reduced lift and increased drag.
Turkia et al. [30] simulated the impact of icing on power output for a typical 3 MW HAWT.Three different rime ice cases were simulated, representing various phases of an icing event: the onset of icing, a brief icing event, and a prolonged icing event.The simulations utilized the in-house code TURBICE to model the accretion of ice masses on HAWT blades.The findings demonstrated that the roughness of the turbine's surface at a small scale had a significant impact on power production.During the initial stages of an icing event, power production was observed to decrease by approximately 17% below rated wind speeds compared to the scenario without ice.With the accumulation of greater ice masses, the reduction in production reached 18% for the short icing event and 24% for the prolonged icing event.
Hudecz et al. [59] conducted experimental and numerical analyses to investigate the impact of glaze, rime, and mixed ice accretion on an NACA 64-618 airfoil at a 7 • angle of attack (AOA).The experiments were conducted in a controlled climatic wind tunnel, while the numerical analyses employed the TURBICE ice accretion model.It was observed that the lift coefficient decreased, and the drag coefficient increased as ice accreted.These effects exhibited a nearly linear relationship.Mixed ice formation resulted in the most significant reduction in lift coefficient, while rime ice led to the least reduction.They also concluded that a noticeable decrease in lift and subsequent loss in power production can be experienced within the initial hour of ice accretion.
Hu et al. [60] investigated the ice distribution and load response of various components using the NREL Phase VI HAWT.The study primarily focused on exploring the impact of different parameters on ice distribution, considering the size of dispersed water droplets.The results indicate a linear increase in both ice mass and ice thickness from the root to the tip of the blade.Furthermore, it was observed that both asymmetric icing and symmetric icing lead to a reduction in rotor thrust force, and the blade root moments.In the case of the low-speed shaft, asymmetric icing can introduce an increased imbalance shear force.The resulting asymmetric load can elevate the fatigue damage of the blade by up to 97.6% and that of the tower by up to 70.8%.
Virk et al. [61] simulated the profiles of blade icing for four HAWTs of different sizes.The findings suggest that larger HAWTs experience less severe dry rime icing in terms of both local ice mass and ice thickness.Comparisons between clean and iced profiles revealed noticeable changes in flow behavior and aerodynamic characteristics.Moreover, it was determined that the decrease in torque is more pronounced for the smaller HAWT, providing further evidence to support the hypothesis that dry rime icing has a lesser impact on larger HAWTs compared to smaller ones.
Han et al. [62] conducted CFD simulations, utilizing the dispersed multiphase (DMP) droplet model, to anticipate the development of ice along the LE of a blade tip airfoil.Once verified, their model was utilized to forecast ice formation along the LE of the NACA 64-618 airfoil and predict its aerodynamic behavior under varying environmental conditions.The BLADED software was utilized to conduct steady power computations for the NREL 5 MW HAWT.The modifications in the shape of the airfoil's LE due to ice formation resulted in a 37% reduction in lift coefficient and a 550% increase in drag coefficient.The findings also revealed that the presence of ice on the LE of the blade tip airfoil led to an approximate decrease of 8-29% in HAWT performance.
Ibrahim et al. [43] numerically investigated the forecasting of ice loads on an 80% span HAWT blade section.Simulations of air flow, droplet impingement, and ice accretion using the FENSAP-ICE software were conducted.The analysis focused on assessing the impact of varying low and high LWC conditions on blade thickness.Moreover, it examined all NREL airfoil families commonly utilized in HAWTs to analyze the influence of blade design on ice accretion.The degradation in aerodynamic characteristics resulting from ice formation was Energies 2023, 16, 7681 9 of 43 found to be 10-65% in the lift coefficient, a value significantly influenced by the specific shape of the accumulated ice.
Jin and Virk numerically investigated the phenomenon of ice accretion on HAWT blades, focusing on both symmetric and asymmetric airfoils, NACA 0012 and NACA 23012 [63], the DU96-W-180 airfoil [64], and the S826 and S832 airfoils [65].The findings indicate that the shape and dimensions of the airfoil have a notable influence on the rate and morphology of ice accretion.Specifically, streamlined ice formations were observed on the symmetric airfoil, contrasting with the structures formed on the asymmetric airfoil.In the presence of glaze ice conditions, more complex ice formations can be observed, which have a distinct impact on the aerodynamic characteristics compared to rime ice conditions (Figure 5).The analysis reveals a greater deterioration in aerodynamic characteristics under glaze ice conditions, particularly at higher AOAs.Moreover, the S832 airfoil experienced greater changes, particularly under wet ice conditions.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 43 from ice formation was found to be 10-65% in the lift coefficient, a value significantly influenced by the specific shape of the accumulated ice.Jin and Virk numerically investigated the phenomenon of ice accretion on HAWT blades, focusing on both symmetric and asymmetric airfoils, NACA 0012 and NACA 23012 [63], the DU96-W-180 airfoil [64], and the S826 and S832 airfoils [65].The findings indicate that the shape and dimensions of the airfoil have a notable influence on the rate and morphology of ice accretion.Specifically, streamlined ice formations were observed on the symmetric airfoil, contrasting with the structures formed on the asymmetric airfoil.In the presence of glaze ice conditions, more complex ice formations can be observed, which have a distinct impact on the aerodynamic characteristics compared to rime ice conditions (Figure 5).The analysis reveals a greater deterioration in aerodynamic characteristics under glaze ice conditions, particularly at higher AOAs.Moreover, the S832 airfoil experienced greater changes, particularly under wet ice conditions.Yirtici et al. [66,67] developed an ice accretion prediction tool, based on the blade element momentum (BEM) method and the Extended Messinger model, to forecast ice formations on HAWT blades and the resulting power production losses.In their next study [68], they simulated the operation of a 30 kW HAWT in different icing conditions and predicted a power loss of approximately 20% during an hour-long exposure to icing conditions.
Gao et al. [69] experimentally investigated the deterioration of the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWT blades, constructed by the DU91-W2-250 airfoil, caused by the dynamic process of ice accretion.During the ice accretion experiment, it was observed that ice structures formed rapidly on both the upper and lower surfaces of the blade model.These irregular-shaped ice formations significantly disrupted the airflow around the blade, resulting in extensive flow separations and the shedding of unsteady vortex structures from the ice-covered surface.The aerodynamic characteristics of the blade model experienced substantial degradation as a result.The extent of performance deterioration due to ice accretion was found to strongly depend on the AOA of the blade model, with more pronounced degradations occurring at lower AOAs.In the case of a 5.0° AOA, the lift force decreased to approximately 12% of its initial value after 10 min of the ice accretion experiment, while the drag force correspondingly increased by a factor of 4.5.
Jiang and Qiu [70] simulated the impact of icing on both the aerodynamic characteristics of the NACA 0012 airfoil and the power efficiency of HAWTs.They found that icing significantly influences the airflow surrounding the airfoil, resulting in the premature appearance of a flow separation vortex.Consequently, the lift coefficient decreases, while the drag coefficient increases.Notably, clear ice exhibits a more detrimental effect on the airfoil compared to frost ice.Furthermore, ice accretion on the airfoil causes a drop in the power curve, with a stall Yirtici et al. [66,67] developed an ice accretion prediction tool, based on the blade element momentum (BEM) method and the Extended Messinger model, to forecast ice formations on HAWT blades and the resulting power production losses.In their next study [68], they simulated the operation of a 30 kW HAWT in different icing conditions and predicted a power loss of approximately 20% during an hour-long exposure to icing conditions.
Gao et al. [69] experimentally investigated the deterioration of the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWT blades, constructed by the DU91-W2-250 airfoil, caused by the dynamic process of ice accretion.During the ice accretion experiment, it was observed that ice structures formed rapidly on both the upper and lower surfaces of the blade model.These irregular-shaped ice formations significantly disrupted the airflow around the blade, resulting in extensive flow separations and the shedding of unsteady vortex structures from the ice-covered surface.The aerodynamic characteristics of the blade model experienced substantial degradation as a result.The extent of performance deterioration due to ice accretion was found to strongly depend on the AOA of the blade model, with more pronounced degradations occurring at lower AOAs.In the case of a 5.0 • AOA, the lift force decreased to approximately 12% of its initial value after 10 min of the ice accretion experiment, while the drag force correspondingly increased by a factor of 4.5.
Jiang and Qiu [70] simulated the impact of icing on both the aerodynamic characteristics of the NACA 0012 airfoil and the power efficiency of HAWTs.They found that icing significantly influences the airflow surrounding the airfoil, resulting in the premature appearance of a flow separation vortex.Consequently, the lift coefficient decreases, while the drag coefficient increases.Notably, clear ice exhibits a more detrimental effect on the airfoil compared to frost ice.Furthermore, ice accretion on the airfoil causes a drop in the power curve, with a stall occurring near the rated wind speed.By analyzing the daily power generation of the HAWT, it was determined that icing results in a power generation loss of up to 4.8%.
Martini et al. [71] studied ice formation on the NACA 64-618 airfoil and estimated aerodynamic losses due to icing.Two turbulence models were used, Spalart-Allmaras and k-ω SST, and the impact of surface roughness was also examined.The results matched the experimental data for both clean and iced airfoils, showing increased drag and decreased lift on the iced airfoil.Both turbulence models worked well for the clean airfoil, but the k-ω SST model performed better for the iced airfoil.The Spalart-Allmaras model had limitations at high AOAs but was suitable for low angles.Surface roughness significantly affected ice growth and should be considered as a way to estimate the icing effects on aerodynamic characteristics.
Surface roughness on an airfoil can significantly affect ice growth by influencing the interaction between the airfoil's surface and supercooled water droplets.In regions with surface roughness, small-scale irregularities create crevices and protrusions, which promote the formation of ice.This means that in the presence of supercooled water droplets, more ice crystals can start forming on the roughened surface compared to a smooth surface.Moreover, surface roughness can influence the heat transfer rates on the airfoil.Irregularities on the airfoil's surface can lead to variations in temperature, which can affect the rate of ice growth.Specifically, heat transfer rates can be enhanced in areas with roughness, leading to variations in ice accumulation.Furthermore, surface roughness can disrupt the boundary layer flow over the airfoil, resulting in variations in pressure and temperature, which may affect the ice accretion patterns.Disruption of the boundary layer can lead to circumstances favorable for the formation of ice.
Chitransh and Kaur [72] predicted ice formation and acceleration on the NACA 4412 airfoil with the help of a numerical solution.The Extended Messinger method was employed to detect ice deposition, while various parameters relevant to HAWT analysis were also calculated.The simulation reveals that ice deposition on the airfoil has a significant impact on power generation by altering the airfoil's shape.The findings indicate a considerable decrease in the lift coefficient and an increase in the drag coefficient.
Rotich and Kollár [73] examined the influence of ice accretion on the aerodynamic behavior of an NACA 2412 airfoil under various environmental conditions.The lift and drag coefficients for the iced airfoil were calculated, considering different LWCs, AOAs, and accretion times.The results demonstrated that the lift-to-drag ratio is highest shortly after ice begins to accumulate for AOAs up to 10 • but significantly decreases with longer accretion times.
Yang et al. [74] analyzed the impact of blade rime icing on a 5 MW offshore floating HAWT with blades constructed using NACA64_A17, DU21_A17, and DU25_A17 airfoils, by using CFD.Results showed concentrated icing on the NACA64_A17 airfoil's tip.Changes in wind speed had some influence on icing, while temperature had minimal effect.Iced airfoil geometry had little impact on the lift coefficient (−34%) but significantly increased the drag coefficient (36-200%).Power production decreased by about 17% with iced airfoils compared to clean ones.Table 1 summarizes the different types of airfoils that were examined for icing.
Virk et al. [75] used CFD to analyze ice formation on an NREL 5 MW HAWT blade.Different sections of the blade were tested under various ice conditions and atmospheric temperatures.The results showed that ice formation was milder near the blade root, where the blade chord is larger and thicker.Ice growth varied along the blade, with more ice near the tip.Barber et al. [76] examined, experimentally and computationally, the ice formation effects on HAWT performance.The results show that ice at high altitudes (2330 m) can decrease the power coefficient by up to 22% and AEP by up to 2%, while extreme icing conditions can lead to 17% AEP losses.Icing at the blade tip region (95-100% span) has the strongest impact and icing at high altitudes has less impact than at lower altitudes on AEP.

Author Investigation Method Airfoil Type Main Conclusions
Seifert and Richert [53] experimental NACA 4415 More ice on the LE led to worse aerodynamic characteristics.
AEP dropped by 6% to 19% for a 300 kW turbine.

S809
The 450 kW rated power rotor with variable speed and pitch had about a 20% decrease in performance.

numerical
The stall-regulated rotor experienced higher performance losses even with a small amount of ice.Horn-shaped glazed ice led to a more significant reduction in lift than streamlined rime ice.
Accurate measurement of atmospheric conditions during icing events is crucial to estimate energy production losses, considering ice shape and type.
Villalpando et al. [58] numerical NACA 63-415 The ice on the airfoil increases the minimum pressure coefficient value, reducing the suction effect on the airfoil.
Turkia et al. [30] numerical NACA 64-618 In the early stages of ice formation, power production decreased by about 17% below rated wind speed.
As more ice accumulated, the reduction increased to 18% for a brief icing event and 24% for a prolonged one.
Hudecz et al. [59] experimental NACA 64-618 Mixed ice had the biggest impact on reducing lift, while rime ice had the smallest.
numerical Within the first hour of ice formation, there was a noticeable decrease in lift and a loss in power production.
Hu et al. [60] numerical S809 Ice mass and thickness increase linearly from the root to the tip of the blade.
Both asymmetric and symmetric icing reduce rotor thrust force and blade root moments.
Asymmetric icing on the low-speed shaft can cause an extra shear force imbalance.
This asymmetric load can lead to higher levels of blade fatigue damage by up to 97.6% and tower damage by up to 70.8%.

Virk et al. [61] numerical NACA 63-215
The decrease in torque is more significant for smaller turbines, supporting the hypothesis that dry rime icing affects them more than larger turbines.
Ice on the blade tip's LE reduced HAWT performance by about 8-29%.

Author Investigation Method Airfoil Type Main Conclusions
Jin and Virk [63] numerical NACA 0012 The airfoil's shape and dimensions affect ice formation.

NACA 23012
For the symmetric airfoil, streamlined ice formations were seen, while the asymmetric one had different structures.

Jin and Virk [64]
DU96-W-180 Glaze ice led to more complex formations that affected aerodynamic characteristics more than rime ice.
Jin and Virk [65] S826 Aerodynamic characteristics deteriorated more with glaze ice, especially at higher AOAs.

S832s
The S832 airfoil showed significant changes, especially with wet ice.

S809
The estimated quantities of rime and glaze ice, and the maximum ice thickness, exhibit variances ranging from 3% to 25% when compared to experimental data.DU93-W210 Yirtici et al. [68] numerical NACA 23012 During exposure to icing conditions for an hour, there is a reduction in power of around 20%.NACA 0012
The degree of degradation depended on the blade's AOA, with greater deterioration at lower angles.
At a 5.0 • AOA, lift force decreased to about 12% of the initial value after 10 min, while drag force increased by a factor of 4.5.
Jiang and Qiu [70] numerical NACA 0012 Icing affects airflow around the airfoil, causing flow separation vortex.
Clear ice is more harmful than frost ice.
Icing can lead to up to 4.8% power loss in HAWT.
Martini et al. [71] numerical NACA 64-618 The airfoil studied is a specific airfoil employed in the blades of the NREL 5 MW reference HAWT.
Iced airfoils experienced higher drag and lower lift.
The k-ω SST model was more effective for the iced airfoil, while the Spalart-Allmaras model had limitations at high AOAs but worked well at low angles.
Surface roughness played a significant role in ice growth and should be considered when estimating the effects of icing on aerodynamic characteristics.
Chitransh and Kaur [72] numerical NACA 4412 The presence of ice on the airfoil significantly affects power generation by modifying the shape of the airfoil.
Considerable reduction in the lift coefficient and an increase in the drag coefficient.
Rotich and Kollár [73] numerical NACA 2412 The lift-to-drag ratio reaches its peak shortly after ice accumulation begins for AOAs up to 10 • .
The ratio decreases significantly as the accretion time becomes longer.

DU21_A17
Icing reduced lift coefficient by 34% and increased drag coefficient up to 200%.

DU25_A17
HAWT power production decreased by 17% with icing.
Homola et al. [77] modeled ice accretion on an NREL 5 MW HAWT blade by using a CFD solver.The calculated power curve changes due to icing were compared with observed differences in power production for an identical turbine operating under icing conditions.The model showed a 27% decrease in power production for wind speeds ranging from 7 m•s −1 to 11 m•s −1 .These effects were less severe than the observed HAWT, possibly due to a shorter icing event in the model.Their results indicate that modeling can be useful for estimating icing effects and exploring ways to reduce them.In a following study, they suggested [78] that modifying the turbine controller could enhance power production when operating with iced blades.
Dimitrova et al. [79] employed the numerical model PROICET in a HAWT to determine the aerodynamic performance degradation, and the energy and power losses, incurred due to light icing.The findings indicate a general deterioration in aerodynamic characteristics, with lift coefficient losses not surpassing 30% and an increase in the drag coefficient of up to 140%.The aerodynamic performance degradation during light icing precipitation resulted in 3.4% power losses and less than 1% on AEP losses.
In their research, Lamraoui et al.
[80] identified the presence of glaze and rime ice on the blade to identify the areas responsible for significant power reduction.The distribution of power production and the characteristics of the accreted ice are inconsistent along the blade.When icing occurs, the aerodynamics of the blade are significantly affected by the outer section of the blade starting at a radial position of r/R = 0.8.The distribution of the freezing fraction is not uniform; rime ice forms near the root and transitions to glaze ice towards the blade's tip.Their study considers four values of LWC, defining five classes of icing severity, and the major power reduction is found to be situated at r/R ~[0.93 0.96] and the maximum power reduction reaches 40%.Regarding power loss, it is observed that, locally, the shape of the ice has a more significant impact than its thickness.However, when considering the entire blade, power degradation is mainly influenced by the ice thickness, irrespective of the ice type.
Etemaddar et al. [81] studied the impact of eight atmospheric and system parameters on the patterns of ice accretion on an NACA 64-618 airfoil, using the 2D ice accumulation software LEWICE 1.6.Among the system parameters, relative wind speed and blade thickness, along with environmental parameters such as LWC and median volume diameter (MVD), are identified as key factors influencing HAWT icing.Through aerodynamic analysis of an iced rotor, it is observed that within the linear region of the lift curve, icinginduced performance degradation primarily stems from an increase in the drag coefficient, as the lift curve undergoes minimal alteration in this particular region.At high AOAs, the discrepancies between the lift coefficients of iced and clean rotors intensify, while the discrepancies in drag coefficients diminish.
Myong [82] employed computational methods to examine the effects of atmospheric icing on the aerodynamics of HAWT blades and also explored the similarities and differences between atmospheric icing on HAWTs and in-flight icing on aircraft.Although certain distinctions exist, such as turbulent shear boundary layers and iced areas other than the LE, many characteristics of aircraft icing can be applied to atmospheric icing on HAWTs.Their findings illustrate that the thickness of ice accumulation increases from the blade root to the tip, and icing conditions, specifically relative wind velocity, significantly influence the shape of the ice buildup.Furthermore, they concluded that ice on the blade surface can cause a substantial reduction in power coefficients across all TSRs.
Reid et al. [83] presented a numerical analysis of the performance degradation of an NREL phase VI rotor operating under icing conditions.By utilizing FENSAP-ICE, simulations were conducted to examine airflow, water impact, and ice accretion.The investigation focused on four different icing conditions, revealing power losses exceeding 60% in certain cases.Simulations with rime ice conditions exhibited lower power losses than those with glaze ice conditions.The glaze ice shape that formed at the largest droplet diameter resulted in the most significant performance degradation, attributed to greater ice thickness and an enlarged contaminated area.Shu et al. [84] experimentally studied the characteristics and performance of a small HAWT and created a three-dimensional model of a HAWT covered in glaze ice for simulation purposes.An artificial climate chamber was used for the icing experiments, located in Chongqing University, with a 7.8 m diameter and 11.6 m height.The HAWT blade radius was 0.5 m and the chord length ranged from 0.03 m to 0.1 m.The output of the three-phase permanent magnet synchronous motor is 100 W under rated conditions.The findings indicate that the presence of ice considerably diminishes the rotational speed and power output of the turbine.The rate of ice accretion initially increases but then declines over time.Ice accumulates predominantly at the LE, gradually increasing from the root to the tip of the turbine.As the rotational speed decreases, the area covered by ice shifts towards the pressure side.Although a higher wind velocity and lower temperature deteriorate the impact of ice, they do not alter its shape.Ice load seems to have a larger effect on the performance of the rotor in small HAWTs compared to the degradation of aerodynamic characteristics.
The same researchers [85] conducted a study focusing on the ice formation on HAWT blades and its impact on the power performance of a 300 kW HAWT operating in a natural icing environment (Figures 6 and 7).The results indicated a significant decrease in power output at higher wind speeds following blade icing, with the severity of deterioration increasing as the ice thickness at the blade tip grows.Furthermore, it was observed that irregular and coarse ice formations have a more detrimental effect on power performance.The rotor speed of iced rotors noticeably decreases at the same wind speed as the ice thickness increases.In icing cases, both the power and moment coefficients experience a greater decline as the ice thickness increases, at the same TSR.Additionally, the maximum power and moment coefficients in icing cases occur at lower TSRs.Later, they proposed a 3D numerical simulation model to assess blade aerodynamics after icing, by employing the multiple reference frame model, Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS), and the k-ω SST turbulence model [86].The results demonstrate agreement between computational and experimental clean and rime-iced rotors within rated wind speed, but overestimation for glaze-iced rotors at high wind speed.Increasing the wind speed leads to significant decreases in rotor speed and power output under icing conditions.Ice shapes primarily impact pressure distribution at the airfoil's LE, reducing normal and tangential forces, and result in stall at the same wind speed and heightened flow separation, particularly for glaze ice.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 14 of 43 irregular and coarse ice formations have a more detrimental effect on power performance.The rotor speed of iced rotors noticeably decreases at the same wind speed as the ice thickness increases.In icing cases, both the power and moment coefficients experience a greater decline as the ice thickness increases, at the same TSR.Additionally, the maximum power and moment coefficients in icing cases occur at lower TSRs.Later, they proposed a 3D numerical simulation model to assess blade aerodynamics after icing, by employing the multiple reference frame model, Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS), and the k-ω SST turbulence model [86].The results demonstrate agreement between computational and experimental clean and rime-iced rotors within rated wind speed, but overestimation for glaze-iced rotors at high wind speed.Increasing the wind speed leads to significant decreases in rotor speed and power output under icing conditions.Ice shapes primarily impact pressure distribution at the airfoil's LE, reducing normal and tangential forces, and result in stall at the same wind speed and heightened flow separation, particularly for glaze ice.Zanon et al. [87] introduced a numerical methodology that effectively simulated the transient occurrence of ice accretion and its consequences on the performance of HAWTs.The NREL 5 MW reference HAWT was utilized to apply this approach, aiming to forecast its performance throughout and following an 8 h period of icing, and the potential enhancement in energy extraction through various operational strategies.The findings indicate that by reducing the rotational speed of the turbine and accepting a minor decline in energy conversion during the icing event, the performance can improve by up to 6% once full operation is restored, in comparison to the baseline operational strategy.Conversely, maintaining the rotational speed during the icing event can result in a subsequent 3% decrease in performance, relative to the same baseline.Zanon et al. [87] introduced a numerical methodology that effectively simulated the transient occurrence of ice accretion and its consequences on the performance of HAWTs.The NREL 5 MW reference HAWT was utilized to apply this approach, aiming to forecast its performance throughout and following an 8 h period of icing, and the potential enhancement in energy extraction through various operational strategies.The findings indicate that by reducing the rotational speed of the turbine and accepting a minor decline in energy conversion during the icing event, the performance can improve by up to 6% once Tabatabaei et al. [88] evaluated the accuracy and limitations of the BEM method in icing conditions.They investigated the aerodynamic performance of the full-scale NREL 5 MW rotor through computational simulations.Three-dimensional steady RANS simulations were employed to analyze both clean and iced blades, while 2D CFD airfoil data were used for BEM calculations.The calculated total power using the BEM method closely aligns with the 3D CFD results for the clean blade, with a deviation of 4%.However, for the iced blade, the BEM method underestimates the total power by 28%.The way the load is distributed along the span of the clean blade varies between the two methods.The 3D CFD predicts a 32% load loss in extracted power due to the presence of ice, with the main loss occurring in areas where the height of the ice horn is greater than 8% of the chord length.
Caccia and Guardone [89] conducted a simulation to analyze ice accretion on the NREL 5 MW HAWT blade, utilizing the BEM approach.To enhance accuracy in calculating ice shapes, they proposed utilizing independent time steps in a multi-step ice accretion simulation.Additionally, they investigated the impact of surface roughness on the aerodynamic characteristics of the iced sections, by considering two roughness extensions and two roughness heights for each section.By calculating the aerodynamic coefficients for each case, they evaluated whether the observed aerodynamic penalty resulted from ice, roughness, or both.The findings demonstrated that even in the presence of a complex ice shape, roughness can significantly influence the aerodynamics of an iced section when the roughness height is sufficiently significant.The extended roughness case that was studied assumed a roughness height of k s /c = 3 × 10 −3 and an extended roughness region covering 25% of chord length, specifically 0.44 m, on both airfoil surfaces and on all sections along the blade.That high-roughness case exhibited a power loss that was 50% greater than the low-roughness case.
Yirtici and Tuncer [90] conducted an aerodynamic shape optimization study conducted to minimize power production losses caused by ice on HAWT blades.Their study focused on the Aeolos-H 30 kW HAWT exposed to icing conditions for 30 min at a wind speed of 11 m/s.Through optimization, the power losses due to icing were reduced by approximately 4%.Similarly, for the larger NREL 5 MW HAWT, the optimized blade design reduced the power losses by about 1%.The study concludes that optimizing blade profiles around the LE is most efficient for low Re and small-scale HAWTs.Table 2 provides a summary of various types of HAWTs that underwent examination regarding icing.Both glaze and rime ice on the blade affect power.
Outer section from r/R = 0.8 significantly affects aerodynamics.
Freezing fraction is non-uniform, with rime ice close to the root and glaze ice towards the tip.
Major power reduction occurs around r/R ~[0.93 0.96] with a maximum reduction of 40%.
Ice shape has a bigger local impact than thickness, but blade-wide, thickness matters most for power loss, regardless of ice type.
Etemaddar et al. [81] numerical NREL 5 MW In the linear region of the lift curve, ice-induced performance degradation mainly occurs due to higher drag coefficient.
At high AOAs, the differences between the lift coefficients of iced and clean rotors become more pronounced, while the differences in drag coefficients decrease.
During icing, nearly 50% less power is produced at cut-in wind speed, and as wind speed increases, the difference diminishes.
Myong [82] numerical NREL 5 MW Many aircraft icing features can be applied to icing on HAWTs.
Ice thickness grows from the base to the tip of the blade.
Ice on the blade reduces power coefficients at all tip speeds.
Reid et al. [83] numerical NREL phase VI Some icing conditions showed power losses over 60%.
Simulations with rime ice had less power losses than glaze ice.
Glaze ice at the largest droplet size caused the greatest performance decline due to thicker ice and a larger contaminated area.
Shu et al. [84] experimental Small HAWT (with blade radius 0.5 m) The presence of ice slows down the turbine and reduces its power.
Ice builds up more at the front edge and increases from the base to the tip of the turbine.
As the speed decreases, the ice shifts to the other side.
Higher wind and lower temperature make ice less effective but do not change its shape.
Ice load affects small HAWTs more than changes in aerodynamics.Irregular and coarse ice formations have a more negative impact on power performance.
Iced rotors experience a noticeable decrease in rotor speed as ice thickness increases.
In icing conditions, power and moment coefficients decline more as ice thickness increases, at the same TSR.
Maximum power and moment coefficients in icing conditions occur at lower TSRs.
An hour of icing leads to a power loss of approximately 31.8% for wind speeds 6-7 m/s.
Shu et al. [86] numerical 300 kW HAWT (with blade radius 14.6 m) Computational and experimental results show agreement for clean and rime-iced rotors at rated wind speed, but overestimate for glaze-iced rotors at high wind speed.
Higher wind speed reduces rotor speed and power output when icing occurs.
Ice shapes primarily impact pressure distribution at the airfoil's front edge, decreasing normal and tangential forces, causing stall at the same wind speed and increased flow separation, especially with glaze ice.
Zanon et al. [87] numerical NREL 5 MW By lowering the turbine's rotational speed during icing, the performance can increase by up to 6% once normal operation resumes.
Maintaining the speed during icing can lead to a 3% decrease in performance compared to the baseline.
Tabatabaei et al. [88] numerical NREL 5 MW The BEM method agrees closely with the 3D CFD results for the clean blade (4% deviation) but underestimates the total power for the iced blade by 28%.
The 3D CFD predicts a 32% loss in extracted power due to ice, mainly when the ice horn height is over 8% of the chord length.
Caccia and Guardone [89] numerical NREL 5 MW When the ice shape is complex, roughness can greatly affect the aerodynamics of an iced area if the roughness is significant enough.
In the high-roughness case, there was a 50% higher power loss compared to the low-roughness case.
Yirtici and Tuncer [90] numerical Aeolos-H The optimization of HAWT blades reduced losses by about 4% for Aeolos-H turbine and 1% for NREL 5 MW.NREL 5 MW

Rainfall
Among the various meteorological conditions during HAWT operation that can impact their performance is rainfall, which leads to a decrease in aerodynamic lift and an increase in drag [91][92][93].Moreover, the low-pressure region above the airfoil experiences significant water vapor condensation, releasing latent heat from water droplets [93].The remaining raindrops form a thin water film on the airfoil surface, which is subsequently affected by subsequent raindrops.This interaction results in the formation of craters and an uneven film, effectively roughening the airfoil surface and causing increased drag [94].
Figure 8 shows the average precipitation globally, and it is evident that there is a necessity to study the operation of HAWTs under rainfall and hailstorm conditions.Limited investigation has taken place regarding the impact of rain on the operational efficiency of HAWTs, despite rain being a frequent occurrence in certain regions.While numerous studies have explored the effects of rain in aviation applications [95][96][97][98][99][100][101][102][103], similar investigations specifically focused on HAWTs remain scarce.Research from the airfoil and aircraft industry highlights the adverse impact of rain on drag and lift, causing a significant reduction in power generation.Consequently, there is an evident necessity for a comprehensive examination of HAWT performance in rainy conditions and the subsequent reduction in operational efficiency.
an uneven film, effectively roughening the airfoil surface and causing increased drag [94].
Figure 8 shows the average precipitation globally, and it is evident that there is a necessity to study the operation of HAWTs under rainfall and hailstorm conditions.Limited investigation has taken place regarding the impact of rain on the operational efficiency of HAWTs, despite rain being a frequent occurrence in certain regions.While numerous studies have explored the effects of rain in aviation applications [95][96][97][98][99][100][101][102][103], similar investigations specifically focused on HAWTs remain scarce.Research from the airfoil and aircraft industry highlights the adverse impact of rain on drag and lift, causing a significant reduction in power generation.Consequently, there is an evident necessity for a comprehensive examination of HAWT performance in rainy conditions and the subsequent reduction in operational efficiency.The first systematic research about the effects of precipitation on HAWT power output was conducted by Corrigan and Demiglio [105].They experimentally studied the twobladed Mod-0 HAWT with three different rotor configurations and revealed the impact of rain on its performance.The results indicated a degradation in performance due to rain, with light rainfall leading to a decrease of up to 20% and heavy rainfall up to 30%.Furthermore, when snow was mixed with drizzle, the performance degradation reached as high as 36% in low wind speeds.Additionally, an analysis was performed to forecast the impact of rain on HAWT performance.Their analysis utilized a BEM code, incorporating adjusted airfoil characteristics to account for the rain effect.The analysis predicted a performance loss of 31% in high winds with moderate rainfall rates, and these projected results corresponded well with the experimental data.
CFD advancements over the past decades have contributed significantly to enhancing our understanding of the dynamics of two-phase flows.Rainfall can be characterized as a two-phase flow, necessitating the utilization of CFD codes to address supplementary transport equations for the second phase.Moreover, these codes facilitate the management of interaction terms encompassing mass, momentum, and energy exchanges between the phases.In the modeling of fluid-particle flows, two prevalent approaches have been extensively examined by researchers such as Valentine and Decker [106], as well as Durst et al. [107].
Following these, Luers [108] analyzed, theoretically, the aerodynamic performance of the same HAWT, and the computational results aligned well with the experimental data from Corrigan and Demiglio [105].According to Luers' [108] findings, there is a significant 25% power loss at a wind speed of 10 m/s and a rain rate of 50 mm/h.Additionally, notable performance penalties are observed even under less intense rain conditions and lower wind speeds.It has been determined that the deterioration in performance is attributed to the aerodynamic roughness caused by the impact of raindrops and the waviness of the water film on the HAWT's blades.
Cai et al. [109] developed a novel CFD model to evaluate the performance of the S809 airfoil under rainy conditions.These validated single-phase simulation results served as a reference point for quantifying the impact of rain on the HAWT's performance.By employing a coupled Lagrangian-Eulerian approach, they captured the formation of a water film over the airfoil.Through the accurate representation of the water film's shape and position, they estimated the resulting performance loss, and they concluded that heavy rain could lead to considerable performance degradation of the airfoil.
Douvi and Margaris [110] simulated the heavy rain over the NACA 0012 airfoil by employing the Discrete Phase Model (DPM) and computed lift and drag coefficients at various AOAs under both dry and wet conditions.The findings indicated that heavy rain significantly affects airfoil performance, leading to a decrease in lift and an increase in drag.The degradation is a result of water film formation on the airfoil's surface and the impactinduced cratering from raindrops.The rate of degradation is more pronounced at higher AOAs.The computational results also reveal droplet breakup near regions with severe pressure gradients, forming an "ejecta fog" near the airfoil and causing water streams to flow from the TE.Douvi et al. [92,94] studied, experimentally and computationally, the influence of different rainfall rates on the aerodynamic characteristics of the NACA 0012 airfoil operating at a low Re.To simulate various rainfall rates, they injected water droplets upstream of the airfoil model using commercial rain simulation nozzles, achieving four different LWCs, and they used a CFD code to gain further insight into the flow field.Their findings indicated that as LWC increased, the degradation of aerodynamic characteristics also increased, particularly up to the stall angle.Additionally, stall onset was delayed for all rainfall rates.The computational results revealed that larger droplets were more prone to droplet breakup, particularly in regions with severe pressure gradients near the airfoil (Figure 9).The thickness of the water film on the upper surface of the airfoil increased with higher LWC.The maximum height of the water film appeared near the TE at a 0 • AOA for all LWCs but shifted towards the LE at higher AOAs.Furthermore, as the AOA increased, less water accumulated on the upper surface of the airfoil for all LWCs.Finally, they observed that the rivulet formation point on the upper surface of the airfoil was close to the TE for low AOAs and moved towards the LE with increasing AOA.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 19 of 43 with higher LWC.The maximum height of the water film appeared near the TE at a 0° AOA for all LWCs but shifted towards the LE at higher AOAs.Furthermore, as the AOA increased, less water accumulated on the upper surface of the airfoil for all LWCs.Finally, they observed that the rivulet formation point on the upper surface of the airfoil was close to the TE for low AOAs and moved towards the LE with increasing AOA.Cohan and Arastoopour [111] enhanced the Cai et al. [109] model and developed a CFD model to investigate the influence of rainfall rate, surface tension, and surface properties on HAWT blades by employing the DPM and the Eulerian Volume of Fluid (VOF) model.They noticed that, at low rainfall rates, the airfoil's performance is highly responsive to the rainfall rate.However, when the rainfall rate becomes sufficient to form water film on the airfoil surface, further increases in rainfall do not substantially impact its performance.At higher rainfall rates, the lift coefficient is higher compared to the no-rain case but accompanied by an unfavorable increase in the drag coefficient.Arastoopour and Cohan [112] refined their previous CFD model [111] to more effectively simulate the transfer of momentum during the formation of water films on the airfoils of a HAWT.The 2D airfoil simulation demonstrated an increase in the lift coefficient with the AOA, surpassing the stall angle observed in the single-phase case.However, this favorable lift increase was accompanied by a higher drag coefficient, particularly at larger AOAs.Furthermore, they examined the impact of rainwater films on the turbine performance using the 3D NREL Phase VI HAWT as a case model and concluded that the accumulation and flow of rain film on the turbine airfoil surface led to a reduction in power output by up to 25% at a wind speed of 7 m/s and a rainfall rate of 40 mm/h.Wu et al. [113,114] presented a hybrid method designed to analyze the dynamic characteristics of HAWTs operating under wind-rain conditions, which utilizes a Eulerian Cohan and Arastoopour [111] enhanced the Cai et al. [109] model and developed a CFD model to investigate the influence of rainfall rate, surface tension, and surface properties on HAWT blades by employing the DPM and the Eulerian Volume of Fluid (VOF) model.They noticed that, at low rainfall rates, the airfoil's performance is highly responsive to the rainfall rate.However, when the rainfall rate becomes sufficient to form water film on the airfoil surface, further increases in rainfall do not substantially impact its performance.At higher rainfall rates, the lift coefficient is higher compared to the no-rain case but accompanied by an unfavorable increase in the drag coefficient.
Arastoopour and Cohan [112] refined their previous CFD model [111] to more effectively simulate the transfer of momentum during the formation of water films on the airfoils of a HAWT.The 2D airfoil simulation demonstrated an increase in the lift coefficient with the AOA, surpassing the stall angle observed in the single-phase case.However, this favorable lift increase was accompanied by a higher drag coefficient, particularly at larger AOAs.Furthermore, they examined the impact of rainwater films on the turbine performance using the 3D NREL Phase VI HAWT as a case model and concluded that the accumulation and flow of rain film on the turbine airfoil surface led to a reduction in power output by up to 25% at a wind speed of 7 m/s and a rainfall rate of 40 mm/h.Wu et al. [113,114] presented a hybrid method designed to analyze the dynamic characteristics of HAWTs operating under wind-rain conditions, which utilizes a Eulerian multiphase model to represent the flow of wind and rain, a single rotating frame to simulate the rotational motion of HAWTs, and collision theory to calculate the load generated by rain.Numerical simulations were conducted to investigate various scenarios involving wind speed, rotation speed, and rain intensity for a 5 MW HAWT.The results clearly indicate that the impact of rain on the HAWT is more pronounced near the blade tip during rotation, whereas free-falling rain primarily affects the region near the blade root.Moreover, the rain-induced load, in terms of thrust and torque, increases with higher rain intensity.Additionally, empirical formulae are derived from the numerical results to describe the relationship among the three influencing factors, i.e., wind speed, rotation speed, and rain intensity, and the rain-induced load coefficient.
Barfknecht et al. [18] calculated and compared the AEP loss resulting from LE erosion (LEE) and from operating in an Erosion-Safe Mode (ESM) for the IEA 15 MW and NREL 5 MW offshore HAWTs.Performance evaluations were conducted under uniform and sheared inflow conditions for both turbines, with a focus on identifying trends and tradeoffs between LEE and the ESM.LEE negatively impacts power production below rated capacity, while operating in the ESM predominantly reduces performance at the turbine's rated power.The IEA 15 MW reference turbine experienced a higher performance loss due to erosion, particularly at lower wind speeds, compared to the NREL 5 MW turbine.However, the turbine design had little sensitivity to the break-even point for the ESM.
Anh and Duc [115] presented an analytical method and model that simulated the physical processes of raindrops forming on the blades of HAWTs.Their model estimated the effect of precipitation, determined optimal wetness, and subsequently evaluated power and performance, under various rainy weather conditions, considering different turbine blade geometrical shapes.They found that the wetness on HAWT blades corresponded to the impact force of rain, with an optimal wind speed minimizing both the impact force and power loss.Moreover, larger raindrop size significantly reduced power output, affecting the rotation speed of HAWT blades.In a following study, Anh and Duc [116] proposed an analytical method to study the power output of a HAWT and the operation of the pitch control system under various rainy conditions.Their model simulated the physics-based process of raindrops falling on the blades' surfaces, enabling the determination of optimal wetness levels based on the swept area's shape.Subsequently, they analyzed the power generation and performance of the HAWT in rainy conditions, and the results indicated that during rain, the pitch angles should be decreased when the wind speed exceeds the predefined threshold value.Douvi et al. [117] investigated the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWT with three blades, constructed by NACA 4418 airfoil, under three different rainy conditions.The blade geometry was optimized using the TTBEM application [118], while a commercial CFD code was employed for simulations.The study first analyzed the blade's operation in dry conditions and subsequently examined different rainfall scenarios to evaluate rain droplets' impact on the turbine's aerodynamic performance.It concluded that rain negatively affects the aerodynamic performance of the HAWT, specifically causing a decrease in the power coefficient as the LWC and droplet diameter increase.A significant decline in aerodynamic efficiency compared to the single-phase flow was observed: reductions of 11.84%, 16.87%, and 23.9% were identified for rain densities of 10 g/m 3 , 30 g/m 3 , and 60 g/m 3 , respectively.Notably, the maximum water film thickness was observed near the hub, where the blade's chord length is greater, while a smaller amount of water accumulated near the blade tip due to centrifugal force removing the water from the blade.Additionally, under a two-phase flow with an LWC of 30 g/m 3 , power coefficient reductions of 15.33%, 16.87%, and 17.99% were observed for raindrop diameters of 0.5 mm, 1 mm, and 2 mm, respectively.Table 3 shows the different types of airfoils and HAWTs that have been tested in the literature for rainfall.When snow mixed with drizzle, performance dropped by as much as 36% in low winds.
A 31% performance loss occurs in high winds with moderate rainfall, which aligned with the experimental data.
Luers [108] theoretical two-bladed Mod-0 HAWT A 25% power loss occurs at a wind speed of 10 m/s and a rain rate of 50 mm/h.
Even under lighter rain and lower wind speeds, noticeable performance issues are seen.
The decrease in performance is due to the roughness caused by raindrops and the waviness of the water film on the HAWT's blades.

Cai et al. [109] numerical S809 airfoil
They observed water forming on the airfoil and estimated how it affected performance.
Heavy rain can significantly degrade the airfoil's performance.

Douvi and Margaris [110] numerical NACA 0012 airfoil
Heavy rain affects airfoil performance, reducing lift and increasing drag, due to water film formation on the airfoil's surface and impact-induced cratering from raindrops.
The degradation is more significant at higher AOAs.
Droplets break up near areas with severe pressure gradients, creating an "ejecta fog" near the airfoil and causing water streams to flow from the TE.
Rainfall delays stall onset.Larger droplets break up more in areas with pressure gradients near the airfoil.
Higher LWC increases water film thickness on the upper airfoil surface.
The maximum water film height near TE occurs at 0 • angle, shifting towards LE at higher angles.
With higher AOAs, less water accumulates on the upper surface.
Rivulet formation point on upper surface moves from TE to LE with increasing AOA.
Cohan and Arastoopour [111] numerical S809 airfoil At low rainfall rates, the airfoil's performance is affected by rainfall.
When the rainfall rate is enough to form a water film on the airfoil surface, further increases in rainfall do not significantly affect performance.
Higher rainfall rates increase the lift coefficient, but are also detrimental to the drag coefficient.The results show that rain affects the HAWT differently at the blade tip and root.
Rain intensity increases the impact.
Empirical formulae describe the relationship between wind speed, rotation speed, rain intensity, and the load caused by rain.
Barfknecht et al. [18] numerical IEA 15 MW and NREL 5 MW offshore HAWTs The IEA 15 MW turbine had higher erosion-related performance loss at lower wind speeds compared to the NREL 5 MW turbine.
Turbine design had little sensitivity to the Erosion-Safe Mode break-even point.
Anh and Duc [115] numerical --- The wetness on turbine blades correlates with the impact force of rain.
The optimum wind speed reduces both the impact force and power loss.
Larger raindrops lower power output and affect blade rotation.
Anh and Duc [116] numerical ---Optimal wetness levels based on the blade shape were determined.
Pitch angles should decrease when wind speed exceeds a set threshold during rain.
The power output reduced under rainfall of about 7%, for wind speeds 8-12 m/s.

Douvi et al. [117] numerical
Optimized three-bladed HAWT, with blades constructed by NACA 4418 airfoil Rain has a detrimental impact on HAWT aerodynamics, causing a decrease in power coefficient as raindrop size and LWC increase.
The thickest water film accumulated near the hub, where the blade chord is longest, while less water collected near the blade tip due to centrifugal force.

Hailstorms
Hailstorms are less frequent than rainfalls, but they can cause significant damages to infrastructures, resulting in financial and insured damages [119].Unlike rain, the solid particles that prevail in hailstorms include a wide range of shapes and sizes.Hailstones, for instance, are larger than 5 mm, and no upper limit exists; some of the largest hailstones ever recorded reached a diameter of approximately 20 cm [120].In the Midwest of the USA, where numerous HAWTs operate, hail is a common phenomenon [121].However, there is a lack of similar data on hail events in the North Sea region.Europe, on the other hand, experiences fewer hail occurrences when compared to the USA, although they constitute a significant meteorological risk as well [119].
Fiore et al. [122] investigated, numerically, the damage caused by raindrops and hailstones over a HAWT blade.The trajectory of the particles hitting the blades was analyzed using a numerical code, the areas of the blade surface that were subjected to damage were estimated, and it was found that they depend on the airfoil type, the AOA, and the particle mass.More raindrops and hailstones were captured by the blade section constructed by thinner airfoils.Notably, the hailstones generated significant impact forces at the LE of the blade due to the angle of their trajectory in relation to the blade surface.On the other hand, raindrops are more sensitive to the flow field around the blade compared to hailstones.This sensitivity is reflected in the impact force's dependence on the blade's AOA.The erosion rate resulting from raindrop impact is found to be proportional to the cube of the blade's relative wind velocity, while the impact force exhibits a power-law relationship with the square of the wind velocity.Douvi et al. examined, computationally, the impact of hailstorm conditions on the aerodynamic characteristics of the S809 [123] and the NACA 0012 [124] airfoils.The results confirmed that hailstorm conditions have a significant effect on the aerodynamic characteristics of both airfoils, resulting in a decrease in the lift coefficient and an increase in the drag coefficient when compared to normal airflow.When operating under hailstorm conditions, discrepancies between the hailstorm and air flow contours were observed primarily at the TE and LE of the airfoils.Furthermore, the analysis of hailstone and water droplet distribution around the airfoils revealed that both particles impact the airfoils, breaking up into smaller particles.Shadow zones were also apparent, and it was concluded that an increased AOA leads to a wider distribution of smaller hailstones across the upper surface of the airfoil and a higher concentration of hailstones below the airfoil.Ultimately, the prediction of the power coefficient for a three-bladed HAWT indicated a decrease in power coefficient during hailstorm conditions.Douvi and Douvi [125] expanded their research to study the pressure coefficient and wall film height, both on the upper and lower surfaces of the S809 airfoil, while operating in hailstorm conditions.A significant finding of this study was that the upper surface of the airfoil near the LE displayed the highest wall film height for all AOAs.These findings support the notion that particles contribute to the deterioration of airfoil aerodynamics due to the roughness of the LE.The wavy nature of these curves reflected the shape of the water film on the airfoils.Increasing the AOA resulted in reduced water accumulation on the upper surface and increased water presence on the lower surface of the airfoil.Lastly, the prediction of the power coefficient for a three-bladed HAWT using the S809 airfoil profile indicated a decrease in the power coefficient during hailstorm conditions for various TSRs, ranging from 0.87% to 1.35% for TSRs ranging from 5 to 8. Douvi et al. [126] conducted a novel computational study investigating the aerodynamic performance of an optimal three-bladed HAWT during hailstorm conditions when hailstones and raindrops are present.This study explored not only the power output of a HAWT operating under hailstorm conditions but also comprehensively analyzed the entire flow field, providing valuable information about the regions on the blade susceptible to erosion and offering insights into the wake development downwind of the HAWT rotor (Figure 10).The findings indicate that the HAWT's aerodynamic performance declines due to particle impact and breakup on the blade.Table 4 provides several airfoils and HAWT types studied in the literature for operating under hailstorm conditions.Hailstones generated significant impact forces at the blade's LE due to their trajectory angle.
Raindrops were more influenced by the blade's flow field and AOA, affecting their impact force.
Raindrop erosion rate correlated with the cube of the blade's relative wind velocity, while impact force followed a power-law relationship with wind velocity squared.Hailstones and water droplets impacting the airfoils fragmented into smaller particles, and shadow zones were observed.
Increasing the AOA resulted in a wider distribution of smaller hailstones on the airfoil's upper surface and a higher concentration on the lower surface.
The power coefficient prediction for a three-bladed HAWT indicated a decrease during hailstorm conditions.

Douvi and Douvi [125] numerical S809 airfoil
The airfoil's upper surface near the LE consistently had the highest wall film height, suggesting that particle accumulation contributes to airfoil aerodynamic deterioration, especially at the LE.
The shape of wall film curves implies the water film's wavy shape on the airfoils.
Increasing the AOA led to reduced water accumulation on the upper surface and more on the lower surface of the airfoil.
Decrease in power coefficient of a three-bladed HAWT using the S809 airfoil profile during hailstorm conditions, ranging from 0.87% to 1.35%, across different TSRs.

Douvi et al. [126] numerical
Optimized three-bladed HAWT with blades constructed by S809 airfoil The turbine's power decreases by 6.4% at a wind speed of 10 m/s and by 3.0% at 15 m/s under hailstorm conditions.
Hailstorms create rings of varying speeds and diameters in the wake, weakening the wake.
Particles are concentrated on the pressure side and mainly on 50% of the blade near the hub.
With increased air velocity, particles move closer to the hub and appear on the upper surface, causing erosion.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 23 of 43 profile indicated a decrease in the power coefficient during hailstorm conditions for various TSRs, ranging from 0.87% to 1.35% for TSRs ranging from 5 to 8. Douvi et al. [126] conducted a novel computational study investigating the aerodynamic performance of an optimal three-bladed HAWT during hailstorm conditions when hailstones and raindrops are present.This study explored not only the power output of a HAWT operating under hailstorm conditions but also comprehensively analyzed the entire flow field, providing valuable information about the regions on the blade susceptible to erosion and offering insights into the wake development downwind of the HAWT rotor (Figure 10).The findings indicate that the HAWT's aerodynamic performance declines due to particle impact and breakup on the blade.Table 4 provides several airfoils and HAWT types studied in the literature for operating under hailstorm conditions.

Dust and Sand
In regions with warm and dry climates, sand and dust often represent prevalent airborne particles, which potentially result in LE erosion concerns (Figure 11).However, in greener and wetter environments, this problem might not exist.Additionally, coastal areas may face significant threats from sand erosion.In general, dust accumulation on the blade surface can increase drag force and reduce lift force, ultimately reducing power output.
The first serious discussions and analyses of blade surface roughness caused by dust accumulation on HAWT performance emerged in 2007 with Khalfallah and Koliub [127].Their experimental investigation focused on a stall-regulated, 300 kW HAWT, analyzing the mechanism of dust buildup and accumulation on the blade surface over the turbine's operational period.Furthermore, the research evaluated the impact of dust on the performance of a pitch-regulated 100 kW HAWT and compared these findings with those of the 100 kW stall-regulated HAWT.They concluded that the effect of dust on HAWTs depends on various factors, including rotor speed and specifications, nacelle height from the ground, power-regulation type, and wind farm site conditions.
Khakpour et al. [128] examined the way that sand particles impact the performance of the primary airfoil in a HAWT.They compared the flow pattern and pressure distribution in dusty conditions to those in uniform flow, considering different AOAs.The findings demonstrate that introducing sand particles reduces the pressure coefficient on the airfoil, leading to lower drag coefficients.This effect is more pronounced with fine sand particles and diminishes gradually as the particles become coarser.The lift coefficient shows little sensitivity to changes in sand particles, except at high AOAs.At high AOAs, small particles result in the highest erosion rate, while coarse particles cause maximum erosion at zero AOA.Their study also investigated the effects of different sand-to-air drift velocities.The results indicate that larger drift velocities yield more noticeable changes.Furthermore, when examining various sand-to-air mass flow rate ratios, it becomes evident that the discrete phase formulation is inaccurate as it fails to consider the effects of particle collisions.However, the findings regarding pressure distribution demonstrate that increasing particle mass flow rate ultimately decreases the pressure coefficient, particularly in the downstream region.
Energies 2023, 16, x FOR PEER REVIEW 25 of 43 operational period.Furthermore, the research evaluated the impact of dust on the performance of a pitch-regulated 100 kW HAWT and compared these findings with those of the 100 kW stall-regulated HAWT.They concluded that the effect of dust on HAWTs depends on various factors, including rotor speed and specifications, nacelle height from the ground, power-regulation type, and wind farm site conditions.Khakpour et al. [128] examined the way that sand particles impact the performance of the primary airfoil in a HAWT.They compared the flow pattern and pressure distribution in dusty conditions to those in uniform flow, considering different AOAs.The findings demonstrate that introducing sand particles reduces the pressure coefficient on the airfoil, leading to lower drag coefficients.This effect is more pronounced with fine sand particles and diminishes gradually as the particles become coarser.The lift coefficient shows little sensitivity to changes in sand particles, except at high AOAs.At high AOAs, small particles result in the highest erosion rate, while coarse particles cause maximum erosion at zero AOA.Their study also investigated the effects of different sand-to-air drift velocities.The results indicate that larger drift velocities yield more noticeable changes.Furthermore, when examining various sand-to-air mass flow rate ratios, it becomes evident that the discrete phase formulation is inaccurate as it fails to consider the effects of particle collisions.However, the findings regarding pressure distribution demonstrate that increasing particle mass flow rate ultimately decreases the pressure coefficient, particularly in the downstream region.Several researchers used the 2D Navier-Stokes equations and the SST k-ω turbulence model to simulate the aerodynamic characteristics of a large number of HAWT airfoils operating in a dusty environment.Ren and Ou [130] numerically studied the flow past NACA 63-430 airfoil, a common HAWT airfoil, under both clean and rough surface conditions.Lift and drag coefficients of the NACA 63-430 airfoil were computed for varying roughness heights, locations, and areas, corresponding to the buildup of dust on HAWT blade surfaces during their operation in natural environments and highlighting their role in promoting the transition to turbulence and flow separation.Critical values for roughness height, area, and location were determined.The airfoil's performance under different operational periods was simulated, leading to a recommended cleaning frequency of 3 months without rain for HAWT blade surfaces.The study revealed that airfoil performance is highly affected by small roughness height, and, particularly for the NACA 63-430 airfoil, the location of roughness within the front 50% of the chord length has a significant impact on its performance.
Li et al. [131] studied, also computationally, another airfoil used in HAWT blade construction, the DU 95-W-180 airfoil.Their study examined the impact of surface roughness on airfoil performance, including lift and drag coefficients under various roughness heights, ranging from 0.03 mm to 2 mm, and locations.Critical values for roughness height and location were identified, with critical roughness equal to 0.5 mm.On the suction surface, the critical locations are situated at 10% of the chord length, while on the pressure surface, they are located at 100% of the chord length.The study explored how lift and drag coefficients changed according to roughness height at these critical locations.It was found that for a smooth surface of up to 0.5 mm roughness height, the lift coefficient increases and the drag coefficient degreases rapidly.For a roughness height higher than 0.7 mm, the aerodynamic coefficients' change is slower.
Salem et al. [132] developed a CFD model merged with a deposition model to evaluate the performance degradation of HAWTs, with an NACA 63-215 airfoil, operating in the dusty regions of North Africa and the Middle East.Their results agreed well with the results of Ren and Ou [130] and Li et al. [131], and they proposed the same frequency of blade cleaning as Ren and Ou [130].They concluded that roughness contributes to the premature transition to a turbulent boundary layer.
Wu et al. [133] simulated the impact of the presence of contaminants on the surface of a HAWT airfoil, the FFA-W3-211 airfoil, on their aerodynamic characteristics.The airfoil surface was evenly roughened, with roughness heights ranging from 0.03 mm to 2.0 mm.By dividing the airfoil into 18 sections, the lift and drag coefficients were analyzed, as the locations of significant roughness varied.To determine the airfoil's sensitivity, the results obtained from XFOIL and CFD calculations were compared.Consequently, the areas of the airfoil surface that were most affected by surface roughness were identified, both on the suction site (at 53% and 92% distances from the chord line towards the LE) and the pressure site (at 44% and 88% distances).The presence of sensitive roughness at these locations caused a delay in the transition point.
Fiore and Selig [134,135] conducted a numerical investigation simulating collisions of sand grains on a 1.5 MW HAWT blade, constructed by DU 97-W-300, DU 96-W-212, and DU 96-W-180 airfoils along the blade.The goal of sand simulations is to ascertain the rate of surface erosion.The findings suggest that the locations where particles impact the blade sections depend on the airfoil type, the local AOA, the local freestream velocity, and the particles.Sand particles predominantly collided in the vicinity of the blade's LE and the erosion rate was highest on the low-pressure side of the HAWT blade.The erosion rate at a radial position of r/R = 0.75 exhibited an approximately tenfold increase compared to the inboard section located at r/R = 0.35.In the vicinity of the LE, steep angles of impact were observed, resulting in a minimum erosion rate.However, as the blade section moved slightly downstream, the erosion rate reached its maximum value.
Fiore and Selig [136] optimized HAWT airfoils, which are subjected to erosion due to the collision of sand grains on the LE of the rotor blades.For the optimization, a genetic algorithm was coupled with XFOIL and BugFoil.The impact of sand impingement on the blade surface generates two distinct erosion peaks situated at a certain distance from the LE.These erosion peaks are susceptible to displacements influenced by factors such as the AOA, diameter of sand particles, and velocity inlet.The study also examined the impact of different airfoil shapes on erosion rates.The results revealed that a bulbous upper LE facilitates downstream movement of the erosion rate peak, whereas a flat slanted inclined lower surface of the LE allows particles to decelerate, resulting in surface impacts at nearly perpendicular angles.
Fiore and Selig [137] used a time-stepping algorithm to predict the final form of HAWT blades affected by erosion caused by sand and determined the key factors influencing blade lifespan.The most significant factor was the sand particle's diameter, with the lifespan of the blade decreasing parabolically as the particle's diameter increases.The blade's lifespan is influenced positively for higher lift coefficients and turbine hub heights.Furthermore, the longest observed lifespans were found for airfoils with bulbous and rounded LEs, along with moderately aft-cambered airfoils.
Diab et al. [138] compared the contamination sensitivity of various airfoil shapes, DU NACA, and NREL, commonly used in HAWT blades and investigated the potential application of an LE slat in an NACA airfoil to alleviate the HAWT performance deterioration due to dust.The thickness to chord ratios of the studied airfoils were ~15%, ~20%, and ~25%.The flow of particles over the airfoil section was simulated by the help of the SST k-ω turbulence model and DPM.The findings suggest that HAWT airfoils designed with low surface contamination sensitivity exhibit superior performance under dusty conditions.Additionally, the introduction of an LE slat impacts the aerodynamics of the particle-laden flow, offering a potential solution to mitigate the detrimental effects of surface contamination, which would otherwise necessitate costly frequent cleaning.
Srinivasan and Surasani [139] examined the way that surface fouling affects NREL S814 and NREL S826 airfoils, at two Reynold's numbers.Surface fouling was simulated by adding roughness at the LE of the airfoil.The research findings indicate that the transition model accurately predicts flow over clean airfoils, while the fully turbulent model provides a more precise representation of surface-fouled conditions.A comparison between normal operating conditions and surface-fouled conditions reveals that the Reynold's number does not significantly impact the aerodynamic characteristics of either airfoil.Furthermore, the S826 airfoil, which is thinner, demonstrates greater resistance to performance degradation caused by surface fouling compared to the S814 airfoil.
Jafari et al. [140] numerically studied the viscous and turbulent flow over an E387 airfoil and a turbine blade.The primary aim of their study was to explore different arrangements of roughness to minimize the negative effects caused by rough surfaces.To achieve this, sand grain roughness was evenly distributed along the suction side, the pressure side, and both sides during manufacturing.Their findings suggest that, contrary to previous research, applying roughness exclusively to the pressure side of the airfoil proves beneficial.Under this configuration, the lift coefficient increases by 8.62% compared to an airfoil with rough surfaces and by 1.2% compared to an airfoil with smooth surfaces.However, the lift coefficient of the blade with roughness on the pressure surface is slightly lower than the smooth blade, but the detrimental effects are considerably less compared to having roughness on the suction surface or on both sides.
Zidane et al. [141] examined the impact of debris flow on the efficiency of HAWT blades.The aerodynamic characteristics of an NACA 63415 airfoil is analyzed using 2D incompressible Navier-Stokes equations and the SST turbulence model, considering both clean and sandy conditions.By utilizing DPM, the study investigates the influence of sand particles on aerodynamic characteristics.Varying flow rates of sand particles are studied to determine their impact on the airfoil's pressure and lift coefficients.The airfoil's performance is evaluated at different AOAs, ranging from 0 • up to 10 • .Findings demonstrate that the blade's lift coefficient can decrease by 28% during sandstorms comparable to those experienced in the Gulf and South African countries.
Han et al. [142] quantitatively analyzed the impact of contamination and erosion on the AEP of HAWTs.Transient CFD simulations of the NACA 64-618 airfoil provided the relevant aerodynamic data, which were then applied to the tip area of the 5-MW NREL reference HAWT model to calculate the corresponding AEP losses.Blades with contaminant accumulation at the airfoil's LE experienced a decrease of up to 27% in lift coefficient and an increase of up to 159% in drag coefficient compared to a clean airfoil.On the other hand, blades affected by erosion at the LE exhibited a decrease of up to 53% in lift coefficient and an increase of up to 314% in drag coefficient.The reduction in aerodynamic characteristics was more pronounced in the section exposed to large AOAs (10 • and higher), particularly with a greater extent of surface damage at the LE.In general, the computed AEP reduction varied between 2% and 3.7%, based on the degree of damage observed at the LE.
Chen and Agarwal [143] studied, computationally, the aerodynamic characteristics of the S809 and S814 airfoils in clean and dusty air conditions.In the case of clean air, the Spalart-Allmaras and the Realizable k-ε turbulence models were employed, and the obtained results were compared with experimental data to determine the preferable model.In dusty air conditions, the Realizable k-ε model and DPM were used, considering two different dust particle concentrations, 1% and 10% per volume.The results were compared with the clean air data to demonstrate the impact of dust contamination on the airfoil's aerodynamic characteristics, and they concluded that the power degradation of HAWTs was more severe for the 10% concentration of particles.
Guo et al. [144] simulated air-particle flows over S809, NH6 MW25, and NACA 0012 airfoils.The results showed that a slight decrease in performance occurs in attached flow due to momentum loss in the boundary layer.However, when flow separation occurs, the performance degradation becomes more severe, primarily due to a more extensive separation caused by particles.In contrast to the NACA 0012 airfoil, the other two airfoils exhibit a specific AOA in the light stall region that is most sensitive to particles.At this angle, the decrease in lift and the increase in drag reach their peak values.For the S809 airfoil, the most sensitive AOA is approximately 3 • greater than the maximum lift-to-drag ratio angle.They concluded that the presence of particles has a significant impact on the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWTs.
ElMessiry et al. [145] numerically studied the impact of dust on the aerodynamic characteristics of the same airfoil families with the same thickness to chord ratios as Diab et al. [138].The results revealed that fouled airfoils generally experienced a decrease in lift coefficient, ranging from 17% to 75%, along with an increase in drag coefficient compared to the clean conditions.Most airfoils demonstrated a 40% drop in lift coefficient.Among airfoils operating in clean conditions, the DU 84-132V3 displayed the greatest performance, although it cannot guarantee the same level of performance when exposed to dusty environments, which can alter the airfoil's geometry.The NACA 63-215 airfoil demonstrated the least sensitivity to dust accumulation, exhibiting excellent performance across different AOAs and only experiencing a minor decrease in aerodynamic characteristics compared to other airfoils.Douvi et al. numerically investigated the aerodynamic characteristics of the S809 [146,147] and NACA 0012 [148,149] airfoils within a Reynolds number range of 1 × 10 6 to 3 × 10 6 while considering different concentrations of sand particles in the airflow.The findings revealed that irrespective of the airfoil type and Re, an increase in AOA and sand particle concentration leads to elevated degradation of performance.Based on the examination of a three-bladed HAWT with blades utilizing these airfoils, it has been observed that the inclusion of sand particles leads to a reduction in the power coefficient, influenced by both the twist angle of the blades and the concentration of sand particles in the airflow.Moreover, the concentration of sand particles suggested a tendency for particle accumulation predominantly on the upper surface and in the region extending from the LE to the central area of the lower surface, particularly at small angles of attack.As the AOA increases, particle concentration narrows down to a smaller section of the airfoil.Douvi et al. [150] studied the aerodynamic efficiency of a HAWT operating in a dusty environment with varying dust concentrations in the airflow.An optimized rotor for a three-bladed HAWT, constructed with S809 airfoil blades, was calculated using the userfriendly TTBEM application [118] and designed by QBlade [151].Additionally, numerical simulation was carried out, with the MRF model accounting for blade rotation and the DPM model handling dust injection into the flow field.The results of this investigation confirmed that the aerodynamic performance of a HAWT is negatively affected when operating in dusty environments.Depending on the conditions, the power output of the HAWT was found to decrease by between 1.24% and 9.04%.The illustration of the flow field revealed that as the concentration of sand particles in the air increased, the wake became weaker and the minimum velocity values decreased.At higher wind speeds, the velocity distribution pattern remained consistent, but the range of values increased, and the wake dissipated more rapidly.Furthermore, sand particles tended to accumulate more towards the hub, and as the concentration and wind speed increased, the particles on the rotor became more abundant (Figure 12).Moreover, it was observed that the particles were mainly dissipated near the LE along the blade and on the pressure surface, where static pressure reached its highest values.Moving towards the hub, the particles concentrated over a larger area on the blade's pressure surface, negatively impacting the power produced by the HAWT.The regions with the highest dissipation rate of sand coincided with those with the highest erosion rate (Figure 13).
Zare et al. [152] used numerical methods to examine the performance of the NREL Phase VI HAWT, operating under clean and dusty air.They investigated how the aerodynamic performance of the turbine is affected by variables such as wind speed (from 5 to 25 m/s), particle diameter (from 0.025 to 0.9 mm), and AOA (from 0 • to 44 • ).Their findings reveal that the HAWT's performance declines in dusty conditions, particularly for particle diameters larger than 0.1 mm and when it is in a post-stall state.The power generated decreases on average by 4.3% and 13.3% for air with particles of 0.05 mm and 0.9 mm diameter, respectively.The presence of particles significantly alters the flow field, resulting in a reduced pressure difference between the suction and pressure sides of the blade, an increased separation of the boundary layer, and strengthened recirculation zones.Various airfoil and HAWT types tested under sand conditions are compiled in Table 5.

Insects
In high winds, the presence of flying insects around turbines is infrequent, ensuring that HAWTs operating under steady high-wind conditions stay free from contamination, thereby maintaining constant power levels.However, during high winds, the angle formed between the airflow and the blades increases, causing the aerodynamic suction peak to shift towards the LE.If the LE is already covered with deceased insects from a prior low-wind period, the resulting power output will decrease.The level of contamination at the suction peak directly affects blade stall and lift loss.Consequently, after each low-wind period, the amount of insect contamination may vary, leading to different power levels being produced in high winds [7]. Figure 14 shows a close view of the contamination of insects on a HAWT blade.
In recent times, the impact of insect contamination on HAWT performance has gained recognition, although it was not previously regarded as a significant cause of power loss.Observations at wind farms in California [7,153] revealed varying power levels among different turbines operating under the same wind speed.

Author Investigation Method HAWT or Airfoil Type Main Conclusions
Khalfallah and Koliub [127] experimental Nordtank 300 kW HAWT The impact of dust on HAWTs depends on rotor speed, specifications, nacelle height, power regulation, and wind farm site conditions.
Fine sand particles have a stronger effect than coarse particles.
Lift remains mostly unaffected by sand, except at high AOAs.
Small particles erode the most at high AOA, while coarse particles erode the most at 0 • .
Increasing particle mass flow rate lowers pressure coefficient in the downstream region.
Ren and Ou [130] numerical NACA 63-430 airfoil HAWT blade performance is greatly influenced by small roughness height.
Roughness located in the front 50% of the chord length significantly affects performance.
The lift coefficient reduces by up to 30%, depending on roughness locations.
It is recommended to clean the blades every 3 months if there is no rain.
Li et al. [131] numerical DU 95-W-180 airfoil For a smooth surface with roughness heights up to 0.5 mm, the lift coefficient increased, while the drag coefficient decreased significantly.
For roughness heights greater than 0.7 mm, the changes in aerodynamic coefficients were more gradual.
Roughness leads to an early shift to turbulent boundary layer.
Wu et al. [133] numerical FFA-W3-211 airfoil The rough areas on the airfoil surface were at the suction site (53% and 92% from the chord line towards the LE) and the pressure site (44% and 88% distances).
These rough areas caused a delay in the transition point.
Energies 2023, 16, 7681 and DU 96-W-180 airfoils along the blade The blade sections where particles hit depend on the type of airfoil, AOA, freestream velocity, and particles themselves.
Sand particles mostly collide near the blade's front edge, causing the highest erosion rate on the low-pressure side.
At a radial position of r/R = 0.75, the erosion rate increased tenfold compared to the inboard section at r/R = 0.35.
Steep impact angles were seen near the front edge, minimizing erosion.
Moving slightly downstream, the erosion rate reached its maximum.The erosion from sand impacts creates two peaks on the blade surface, which can shift due to AOA, particle size, and inlet velocity.
A rounded upper edge helps the erosion peak move downstream, while a flat inclined lower edge causes particles to slow down, resulting in impacts at nearly perpendicular angles.
Higher lift coefficients and turbine hub heights increase lifespan.
Airfoils with bulbous and rounded LEs, as well as moderately aft-cambered airfoils, have the longest observed lifespans.Eroded blades at the LE had 53% less lift and 314% more drag.
The impact was worse at high angles (10 • and above) and the damaged area was wider at the LE.
Energy production dropped by 2% to 3.7%, depending on the level of damage at the LE.
Chen and Agarwal [143] numerical S809 and S814 airfoils 10% dust concentration caused more severe power degradation for HAWTs.Unlike the NACA 0012 airfoil, the other two airfoils have a specific AOA in the light stall region that is highly influenced by particles.
For the S809 airfoil, the most sensitive AOA is about 3 • higher than the angle for maximum lift-to-drag ratio.
The DU 84-132V3 airfoil performed well under clean conditions, but its performance was uncertain in dusty environments due to changes in the airfoil's geometry.
The NACA 63-215 airfoil was the least affected by dust accumulation and maintained good performance at different AOAs with only a minor decrease.The power output of the HAWT decreases by 1.24% to 9.04% depending on conditions.
As sand particle concentration in the air increases, the wake becomes weaker and minimum velocity decreases.
Sand particles tend to gather more at the hub, and as concentration and wind speed rise, the particles on the rotor become more abundant.
Approaching the hub, particles gather over a larger area on the pressure surface, negatively impacting power production.
The areas with the highest sand dissipation rate correlate with the highest erosion rate.
Zare et al. [152] numerical NREL Phase VI HAWT The HAWT's performance decreases in dusty conditions, especially when it is in a post-stall state and for particle diameters > 0.1 mm.
The average power generated decreases by 4.3% and 13.3% for particles with diameters of 0.05 mm and 0.9 mm, respectively.
Particles significantly change the flow, reducing the pressure difference between the blade's suction and pressure sides, increasing the separation of the boundary layer, and strengthening recirculation zones.

Insects
In high winds, the presence of flying insects around turbines is infrequent, ensuring that HAWTs operating under steady high-wind conditions stay free from contamination, thereby maintaining constant power levels.However, during high winds, the angle formed between the airflow and the blades increases, causing the aerodynamic suction peak to shift towards the LE.If the LE is already covered with deceased insects from a prior low-wind period, the resulting power output will decrease.The level of contamination at the suction peak directly affects blade stall and lift loss.Consequently, after each low-wind period, the amount of insect contamination may vary, leading to different power levels being produced in high winds [7]. Figure 14 shows a close view of the contamination of insects on a HAWT blade.
In recent times, the impact of insect contamination on HAWT performance has gained recognition, although it was not previously regarded as a significant cause of power loss.Observations at wind farms in California [7,153] revealed varying power levels among different turbines operating under the same wind speed.To investigate this phenomenon, Corten and Veldkamp [153] proposed and experimentally tested multiple hypotheses.Among these, they confirmed the plausibility of insect accretion on HAWT blades, primarily occurring during low-speed winds when insects are capable of flight.At such speeds, the roughness caused by insects has a negligible effect on power production.However, at higher wind speeds, there is a notable decline in power output due to the increased surface roughness resulting from insect contamination.Furthermore, the level of contamination is found to rely on atmospheric conditions during insect flight, particularly when the temperature is above 10 °C and there is no rain.Additionally, insect density decreases rapidly from ground level to an altitude of 150 m [155].Insect-free environments are more prevalent in very low temperatures and low humidity [156].The conditions conducive to insect contamination are illustrated in Figure 15.The observed increase in the power curve is attributed to the cleaning effect of rainfall on the turbine blades.To investigate this phenomenon, Corten and Veldkamp [153] proposed and experimentally tested multiple hypotheses.Among these, they confirmed the plausibility of insect accretion on HAWT blades, primarily occurring during low-speed winds when insects are capable of flight.At such speeds, the roughness caused by insects has a negligible effect on power production.However, at higher wind speeds, there is a notable decline in power output due to the increased surface roughness resulting from insect contamination.Furthermore, the level of contamination is found to rely on atmospheric conditions during insect flight, particularly when the temperature is above 10 • C and there is no rain.Additionally, insect density decreases rapidly from ground level to an altitude of 150 m [155].Insect-free environments are more prevalent in very low temperatures and low humidity [156].The conditions conducive to insect contamination are illustrated in Figure 15.The observed increase in the power curve is attributed to the cleaning effect of rainfall on the turbine blades.
To ascertain the validity of the hypothesis, an experimental investigation was conducted utilizing two adjacent HAWTs situated within the same wind park.The initial HAWT, designated as the clean HAWT, underwent natural exposure to insect contamination, while an artificial surface roughness was intentionally introduced to the second HAWT.Throughout the experiment, the power outputs of both HAWTs were periodically documented.Initially, the first HAWT exhibited greater power output compared to the second one.However, as the contamination level gradually escalated, the power output of the first HAWT progressively declined, eventually aligning with the power production of the second one, which means that the accumulation of natural contamination resulted in a degree of surface roughness equivalent to that of the second HAWT.These findings effectively confirm the hypothesis that the accumulation of insects on the blade surface, by augmenting its roughness, results in a reduction in power output [153].
Janiszewska et al. [157,158] experimentally studied the LS(1)-0417MOD and S814 airfoils under clean and rough conditions.Field measurements on the LE area of a HAWT blade uncovered that the average grain size of the typical roughness resulting from insect contamination on HAWT blades ranged from 0.5 mm to 0.9 mm.The density of these rough elements varied from 1.25 to 5 particles per cm 2 .The roughness design was based on the measurements from the HAWT, leading to a 41% and 24% decline in maximum lift coefficient and a 36% and 60% increase in minimum drag coefficient, for the LS(1)-0417MOD airfoil and the S814 airfoil, respectively.Similar wind tunnel experiments were performed on the NACA 4415, S801, S809, and S813 airfoils [159][160][161][162] using the same roughness design as Janiszewska et al. [158].The results indicated reductions of up to 20%, 12%, 19%, and 12% in the maximum lift coefficient for the NACA 4415, S801, S809, and S813 airfoils, respectively, and an increase greater than 50% for all airfoils tested.To investigate this phenomenon, Corten and Veldkamp [153] proposed and experimentally tested multiple hypotheses.Among these, they confirmed the plausibility of insect accretion on HAWT blades, primarily occurring during low-speed winds when insects are capable of flight.At such speeds, the roughness caused by insects has a negligible effect on power production.However, at higher wind speeds, there is a notable decline in power output due to the increased surface roughness resulting from insect contamination.Furthermore, the level of contamination is found to rely on atmospheric conditions during insect flight, particularly when the temperature is above 10 °C and there is no rain.Additionally, insect density decreases rapidly from ground level to an altitude of 150 m [155].Insect-free environments are more prevalent in very low temperatures and low humidity [156].The conditions conducive to insect contamination are illustrated in Figure 15.The observed increase in the power curve is attributed to the cleaning effect of rainfall on the turbine blades.Ferrer and Munduate [163] conducted CFD analyses to determine S814 airfoil performance under clean and rough surfaces, by simulating contamination during the operational lifespan of HAWTs.The roughness pattern for the S814 tests was a molded insect pattern sourced from an actual HAWT in the field and the results agreed with the corresponding data from Janiszewska et al. [158].The results indicate that contamination-induced roughness has a more detrimental impact on the aerodynamic behavior of the airfoil than boundary layer transition.The aerodynamic degradation reached 60% for the lift-to-drag ratio for moderate AOAs.
Wilcox et al. [164] developed a simulation code to establish the connection between airfoil type, insect collision areas, and roughness sensitivity.They determined representative insect collection patterns for various airfoil shapes and used these data to simulate roughness on an NREL S814 airfoil, which was tested, experimentally, at various Reynolds numbers.The obtained results were compared to the results of Ehrmann [165] for the NACA 63 3 -418 airfoil.The analysis revealed that increasing roughness density and height led to a reduction in the maximum lift, lift-to-drag ratio, and lift curve slope.It was pointed out that the S814 airfoil exhibited heightened sensitivity to roughness in comparison to the NACA 63 3 -418 airfoil.To quantify the AEP losses, blade element momentum analysis was employed.It was determined that an NACA 63 3 -418 HAWT experienced a 4.9% decrease in energy production, while an S814 HAWT encountered a slightly higher reduction of 6.8%.
Fiore and Selig [134,135] numerically studied, in addition to the sand grains, the collisions of insects on a 1.5 MW HAWT blade.The debris thickness on the blade was estimated through insect simulations.The findings suggest that the locations of particle impact on the blade sections are influenced by factors such as the airfoil type, the local AOA, the local freestream velocity, and the particles.Collisions between insects and sand grains were predominantly observed near the LE of the blade.The highest volume of insect debris per unit span was found at r/R = 0.75.
3.6.Other Aspects 3.6.1.Humidity In recent years, there has been a rise in the installation of large offshore HAWTs to harness the considerable potential of wind energy.Although offshore wind resources are plentiful, stronger, and more consistent compared to those on land, offshore HAWTs typically operate in environments with high humidity.Consequently, the measurement of the HAWT power curve based on the IEC standard is conducted onshore, often in environments with lower to moderate humidity.
When the air contains a significant amount of moisture, it can lead to condensation on the surface of the rotating blades.This condensation, especially during winter weather, can result in reduced blade performance due to contamination or the formation of ice.Additionally, in the mornings, foggy or rainy conditions are frequent around offshore wind farms.These conditions cause tiny water droplets to mix with the air, and when they collide with the rotating blades, it increases drag and negatively affects turbine performance.Offshore HAWTs are more prone to corrosion due to exposure to seawater and high humidity.Consequently, they need to be designed with greater durability to minimize maintenance, mainly because the transportation of maintenance crews and replacement parts to and from offshore wind plant sites incurs high costs.
Yu et al. [166,167] simulated the effects of different humidity levels on airfoil/blade aerodynamics and the impact of water condensation on HAWT blades.Their analysis revealed that high humidity significantly affects density under high-temperature conditions but has minimal impact on airfoil/blade aerodynamics.Additionally, water vapor condensation occurs on the airfoil or blade surfaces, primarily around the LE and TEs.This phenomenon leads to blade contamination, particularly in dirty environments with dust and insects, or during winter and low-temperature conditions conducive to icing.When contamination occurs, the performance of the HAWT can be considerably degraded.Their study also found that on foggy days, water droplets in humid air contaminate on the airfoil surface, forming a water film that alters the flow of the boundary layer, leading to increased drag and diminished performance.The findings from these studies are confirmed by similar findings of performance losses on rainy days.

Sea Spray
The impact of sea spray on offshore HAWTs is a significant concern, specifically regarding the LE of the HAWT blades.The effects of sea spray on the blades are expected to resemble those of rain, involving forces, pressures, and discrete impact events.In certain cases, the blades can be quickly affected by larger amounts of seawater spray.Another aspect to consider when dealing with the impact of particles is the existence of sea salt crystals within the spray.Airborne sea salt crystals pose a challenge in various offshore applications, primarily leading to their accumulation on components.The problem of salt-contaminated blades was considered during the study of lightning protection measures for HAWTs [168][169][170].Moreover, since seawater typically contains 3-3.5% NaCl [171], corrosion becomes a significant concern for metallic elements.Consequently, the accumulation of salt crystals on the LE of the blade results in deterioration in aerodynamic characteristics and potentially in corrosive damage.Despite its significance, limited research has been conducted on this subject thus far.

Conclusions
The escalating effects of global climate change, including the rise in greenhouse gas concentrations and the depletion of fossil fuel reservoirs, have spurred a substantial surge in the demand for alternative energy sources.Among these, wind energy stands out as a highly promising solution due to its comparatively lower cost and minimal environmental impact.It is crucial to examine the impact of various meteorological phenomena on the performance of typical HAWTs as this knowledge is essential for enhancing their design and overall efficiency.
The aim of the present research was to examine the changes in the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWTs operating under hazard environmental conditions.Various conditions were reviewed, such as icing, rainfall, hailstorms, high concentrations of dust, humidity, insect collisions, and sea spray.
All of the studies reviewed here support the hypothesis that when HAWTs operate under these conditions, they experience a decrease in lift and a simultaneous increase in drag, which leads to aerodynamic characteristics' degradation.Since the aerodynamic performance is directly connected to the power output of HAWTs, efforts should be implemented to mitigate these losses.
Researchers have dedicated significant attention to the study of ice accumulation and its impact on the aerodynamic characteristics of airfoils and blades.The research on this topic is popular in cold regions, such as Norway and Canada.More extensive research has been conducted involving ice due to the convenient observation of ice formation on blades in such locations, allowing for experimental study of its effects.Consequently, computational simulation of ice conditions was relatively uncomplicated, as the study involved altering the geometry while assuming the presence of formed ice.
Conversely to ice, there is a scarcity of experimental research in the literature concerning the performance of HAWTs in rainy conditions.When HAWTs are subjected to rainy conditions, rain droplets accumulate on the surfaces of the blades or airfoils, subsequently causing a decline in aerodynamic performance.
To perform a thorough examination of HAWT performance under various operating and environmental conditions, the DPM, which is available in CFD codes, is highly suitable for delivering accurate and intricate insights into turbine performance.This method obviates the need for expensive experimental setups at different scales by offering comprehensive and reliable information.The data obtained through the CFD approach can be utilized to optimize HAWT design, operations, and scale-up processes.This model has been used extensively to simulate the rainfall, the hailstorms, and the dust over a HAWT blade.The degradation of the aerodynamic characteristics of a HAWT is more pronounced when faced with heavier and larger raindrops, hailstones, and sand particles, as well as a higher LWC and sand concentration in the air.However, a comprehensive understanding of the aerodynamic characteristics of offshore HAWTs in high humidity environments and in regions with sea salt remains lacking.
Countries with the most operational wind farms exhibit a notable inclination towards HAWT operation under hazard conditions, as evident from the map in Figure 16.Moreover, several airfoil types were studied, and the most popular was the S809 airfoil followed by NACA 0012 and NACA 64-618 (Figure 17).The aim of the present research was to examine the changes in the aerodynamic characteristics of HAWTs operating under hazard environmental conditions.Various conditions were reviewed, such as icing, rainfall, hailstorms, high concentrations of dust, humidity, insect collisions, and sea spray.
All of the studies reviewed here support the hypothesis that when HAWTs operate under these conditions, they experience a decrease in lift and a simultaneous increase in drag, which leads to aerodynamic characteristics' degradation.Since the aerodynamic performance is directly connected to the power output of HAWTs, efforts should be implemented to mitigate these losses.
Researchers have dedicated significant attention to the study of ice accumulation and its impact on the aerodynamic characteristics of airfoils and blades.The research on this topic is popular in cold regions, such as Norway and Canada.More extensive research has been conducted involving ice due to the convenient observation of ice formation on blades in such locations, allowing for experimental study of its effects.Consequently, computational simulation of ice conditions was relatively uncomplicated, as the study involved altering the geometry while assuming the presence of formed ice.
Conversely to ice, there is a scarcity of experimental research in the literature concerning the performance of HAWTs in rainy conditions.When HAWTs are subjected to rainy conditions, rain droplets accumulate on the surfaces of the blades or airfoils, subsequently causing a decline in aerodynamic performance.
To perform a thorough examination of HAWT performance under various operating and environmental conditions, the DPM, which is available in CFD codes, is highly suitable for delivering accurate and intricate insights into turbine performance.This method obviates the need for expensive experimental setups at different scales by offering comprehensive and reliable information.The data obtained through the CFD approach can be utilized to optimize HAWT design, operations, and scale-up processes.This model has been used extensively to simulate the rainfall, the hailstorms, and the dust over a HAWT blade.The degradation of the aerodynamic characteristics of a HAWT is more pronounced when faced with heavier and larger raindrops, hailstones, and sand particles, as well as a higher LWC and sand concentration in the air.However, a comprehensive understanding of the aerodynamic characteristics of offshore HAWTs in high humidity environments and in regions with sea salt remains lacking.
Countries with the most operational wind farms exhibit a notable inclination towards HAWT operation under hazard conditions, as evident from the map in Figure 16.Moreover, several airfoil types were studied, and the most popular was the S809 airfoil followed by NACA 0012 and NACA 64-618 (Figure 17).In the field of the operation of HAWTs under hazardous conditions, several unresolved issues remain and need further investigation in the near future.Some of these include:

•
The operation of HAWTs in various hailstorm conditions and in environments with sea spray; • The design and analysis of additional airfoils and HAWT blades, aiming to optimize their performance across hazard environmental conditions; • Employing user-defined functions (UDFs) to introduce particles of varying shape and size, facilitating the study of multiphase flows; • Investigating the impact of these multiphase flows in wind farms, specifically in conjunction with terrain; this case would necessitate significant computational power.In the field of the operation of HAWTs under hazardous conditions, several unresolved issues remain and need further investigation in the near future.Some of these include:

•
The operation of HAWTs in various hailstorm conditions and in environments with sea spray; • The design and analysis of additional airfoils and HAWT blades, aiming to optimize their performance across hazard environmental conditions; • Employing user-defined functions (UDFs) to introduce particles of varying shape and size, facilitating the study of multiphase flows; • Investigating the impact of these multiphase flows in wind farms, specifically in conjunction with terrain; this case would necessitate significant computational power.
Funding: This research received no external funding.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Worldwide map showing the operating (green) and under construction (yellow) wind farms with capacities equal to or exceeding 10 MW [4].

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Worldwide map showing the operating (green) and under construction (yellow) wind farms with capacities equal to or exceeding 10 MW [4].

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Photos of ice accretion on blade tip under various icing conditions, from light icing (case 1) to severe icing (case 6).Reproduced with permission from [85], Elsevier, 2018.Figure 6. Photos of ice accretion on blade tip under various icing conditions, from light icing (case 1) to severe icing (case 6).Reproduced with permission from [85], Elsevier, 2018.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Photos of ice accretion on blade tip under various icing conditions, from light icing (case 1) to severe icing (case 6).Reproduced with permission from [85], Elsevier, 2018.Figure 6. Photos of ice accretion on blade tip under various icing conditions, from light icing (case 1) to severe icing (case 6).Reproduced with permission from [85], Elsevier, 2018.

Figure 8 .
Figure 8.Average precipitation in 2020 globally.Precipitation is the water that falls from clouds in either liquid or solid form [104].

Figure 11 .
Figure 11.View of the Shagaya wind farm from the control building, 150 m away from the nearest turbine, during a severe storm on 26 April 2018.Reproduced with permission from [129], Elsevier, 2018.Several researchers used the 2D Navier-Stokes equations and the SST k-ω turbulence model to simulate the aerodynamic characteristics of a large number of HAWT airfoils operating in a dusty environment.Ren and Ou [130] numerically studied the flow past NACA 63-430 airfoil, a common HAWT airfoil, under both clean and rough surface conditions.Lift and drag coefficients of the NACA 63-430 airfoil were computed for varying

Figure 11 .
Figure 11.View of the Shagaya wind farm from the control building, 150 m away from the nearest turbine, during a severe storm on 26 April 2018.Reproduced with permission from [129], Elsevier, 2018.

Figure 16 .
Figure 16.Institutions globally that have studied the operation of HAWTs under hazard conditions.Figure 16.Institutions globally that have studied the operation of HAWTs under hazard conditions.

Figure 16 .
Figure 16.Institutions globally that have studied the operation of HAWTs under hazard conditions.Figure 16.Institutions globally that have studied the operation of HAWTs under hazard conditions.

Figure 17 .
Figure 17.Airfoils used for the construction of HAWT blades investigated operating under hazard conditions.

Figure 17 .
Figure 17.Airfoils used for the construction of HAWT blades investigated operating under hazard conditions.

Table 1 .
Various airfoil types tested in bibliography for icing.

Table 2 .
Various HAWT types tested in bibliography for icing.

Table 3 .
Various airfoil and HAWT types tested in bibliography for rainfall.

Table 4 .
Various airfoil and HAWT types tested in bibliography for hailstorm conditions.
These effects were particularly notable at the airfoil's TE and LE.

Table 5 .
Various airfoil and HAWT types tested in bibliography for sand conditions.