Design and Implementation of a STATCOM Based on a Multilevel FHB Converter with Delta-Connected Configuration for Unbalanced Load Compensation

A delta-connected STATCOM with cascade multilevel full H-bridge (FHB) converter has been applied for phase balancing and power factor correction of unbalanced load in a three-phase, three-wire power distribution system. In this paper, a feedforward compensation formula is presented for the STATCOM by using the symmetrical components method to compensate unbalanced load. Computer simulation is performed for preliminary verification. Accordingly, a hardware prototype employing a TMS320F2812 DSP-based system is built for final verification test. Experimental results show that the proposed STATCOM is very effective for real-time unbalanced load compensation.


Introduction
A large unbalanced capacity load, such as a single-phase electrical railway system, in a three-phase, three-wire electric power distribution system can absorb undesired negative-sequence currents and reactive power.The negative-sequence current and reactive power cause additional losses in the power distribution system and produce an unbalanced voltage drop on the distribution line, which should be improved to ensure satisfactory power quality.Voltage fluctuations caused by large inductive loads such as electric arc furnace can induce light flicker.Therefore, unbalanced load compensation, including phase balancing and power factor correction, is very important in electric power distribution systems.
Thyristor-controlled reactor with thyristor-switched capacitor (TCR-TSC) type static var compensators (SVCs) with delta-connected configuration and individual-phase control are applied in power distribution systems for real-time unbalanced load compensation and voltage regulation [1][2][3][4][5][6].In recent years, the static synchronous compensator (STATCOM) has been recognized as the next-generation compensator [7][8][9][10].Properly designed STATCOMs can be used for real-time unbalanced load compensation.Compared to SVCs, STATCOMs have compact structures, faster response times, they demand less space, and generate lower noise.Many types of converter/inverter are employed to construct the main circuit of a STATCOM, such as cascade multilevel full H-bridge (FHB) converter, diode-clamped converter, and flying-capacitor converter [11][12][13][14].Among them, the STATCOM using cascade multilevel FHB converter as main circuit has the advantages of a modular structure and ease of redundant operation, which is suitable for high-voltage and high-power applications.
STATCOMs using cascade multilevel full H-bridge (FHB) converters can be connected in a Y configuration [15][16][17][18][19], which is also known as a single-star bridge-cells (SSBCs)-based STATCOM [20].The SSBCs-based STATCOM can provide reactive power compensation and voltage support in balance operations.However, using the SSBCs-based STATCOM to compensate unbalanced load causes voltage shifting at neutral point of main circuit, which is not suitable for unbalanced load compensation [20,21].Cascade FHBs-based STATCOM can also be connected as a delta configuration [22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29].This type of STATCOM is also known as single delta bridge cells (SDBCs)-based STATCOM, which not only can compensate the negative-sequence current of unbalanced loads to achieve a balanced operation, but also perform unity power factor correction.In [26], a delta-connected STATCOM with multilevel optimal modulation strategy is proposed to reduce harmonic distortion.Furthermore, using a special switching patterns swapping maintains dc-link voltages in balanced operation.However, the delta-connected STATCOM is only used in balanced operation.A control method based on instantaneous power theory for SDBCs-based STATCOM is employed to compensate positive-sequence and negative-sequence reactive powers in [28].In [29], a hybrid multilevel FHB based, delta-connected STATCOM is proposed, which synthesizes voltage waveforms by using two modulation frequencies.In each STATCOM arm, the high-voltage FHB cell uses step modulation and the low-voltage FHB uses 5 kHz pulse width modulation (PWM) technique at the same time.This modulation technique can not only improve efficiency and output waveform, but also compensate reactive power and negative-sequence currents.In [28][29][30], zero-sequence circulating current in the delta-connected main circuit of the SDBCs-based STATCOM is employed to construct the compensation current for unbalanced load compensation.However, all the above mentioned STATCOMs need complicated calculations and high frequency PWM techniques.The use of PWM techniques in the STATCOMs reduces the main circuit efficiency, which is not suitable for STATCOMs in high power application if they want to compete with the existing SVCs in the industry.In [25], a current-regulated DSTATCOM based on cascade multilevel FHB converter is proposed for unbalanced load compensation.Use of reactive parts of load currents calculates the compensation currents.
In this paper, a delta-connected, transformerless STATCOM with cascade multilevel FHB converter and step modulation is introduced for real-time unbalanced load compensation in three-phase, three-wire distribution systems.A systematic design approach regarding the load demand, the sizing of the STATCOM, and the power source response is proposed.To meet the fast response requirements, a feedforward compensation formula is derived for the STATCOM.Use of step modulation in the STATCOM main circuit achieves high efficiency operation.The MatLab/Simulink program is used in simulation for preliminary verification.A hardware prototype is built for a final verification test.Experimental results are presented for functioning verification.This paper introduces a very suitable transition of technology from existing SVC to new-generation STATCOM in high power application.

Operation of the STATCOM Main Circuit
Figure 1 shows the studied system, which is a three-phase power distribution system with unbalanced load and the proposed transformerless, delta-connected STATCOM.In Figure 1a, a cascade 7-level FHB converter is used to construct the STATCOM main circuit arms.Individual phase control of the three STATCOM arms is available for unbalanced load compensation like a traditional SVC.Each arm of the STATCOM consists of three FHB cells and a reactor X ST connected in series.Every FHB cell in each STATCOM arm has its own dc-link capacitor.
Mostly, STATCOMs are controlled on the synchronous q-d reference frame.The dc-link voltage of the STATCOM is controlled on the d-axis.At the same time, the reactive power or current is regulated on the q-axis [11][12][13][14][15][16][17]26,28].This control scheme can be implemented by using PWM techniques, but the power efficiency is sacrificed, which is not suitable for high power applications.Another control scheme is to directly regulate the STATCOM internal angle for reactive power control, which achieves high efficiency operation [31].Hence, this paper uses the internal phase angle control for the STATCOM.The STATCOM controller regulates the internal phase angle δ ST for different reactive power demands.In this paper, the STATCOM is equivalent as reactive power load like an SVC.The realization and operation of the STATCOM will be easy to field engineers.
Equations ( 1) and (2) express the active and reactive power inputs of each STATCOM arm in Figure 1a.In steady state, the internal angle δ ST is nearly kept at zero.For the need of capacitive reactive power, the STATCOM controller regulates the internal angle δ ST to a negative value to absorb active power according to Equation (1), which charges the capacitors in the dc-links and boosts their voltages equally.When the dc-link voltages increase, the synthesized STATCOM internal voltage V ST rises.The STATCOM absorbs capacitive reactive power with the regulation according to Equation (2).When the reactive power input reaches the desired value, the internal angle goes back to near zero: Figure 1b shows the current and voltage waveforms of the STATCOM arm a-b in Figure 1a.With the control of the switching angles, θ 1 , θ 2 , and θ 3 , each FHB cell generates three output voltages, +V DC , 0, and −V DC , which synthesize the STATCOM internal voltage v ST (v T S = v ST ab1 + v ST ab2 + v ST ab3 ) as a stepped waveform.The STATCOM controller dynamically regulates the internal angle δ ST for obtaining the needed reactive power input.The switching angles, θ 1 , θ 2 , and θ 3 , should be properly selected for minimizing the harmonics generated.

The Proposed Compensation Formula
Figure 2 shows the studied system for deriving the feedforward compensation formula.The studied system is a three-phase, three-wire electric power distribution system feeding an unbalanced inductive load.The STATCOM executes the on-site load compensation.The steady-state symmetrical components method has been widely used for deriving SVCs' real-time unbalanced load compensation schemes [2][3][4].In the paper, the method is employed for deriving the needed feedforward compensation formula for the STATCOM.The feedforward compensation formula detects the load power parameters and sends three reactive power control commands to the STATCOM main circuit arms.With the commands, the three STATCOM arms regulate their reactive power inputs, independently.As a result, the synthesized STATCOM line current compensates the imaginary part of positive-sequence component and overall negative-sequence component of the load current.Hence, the three-phase source currents are compensated to be balanced and unity power factor.
In Figure 2, the line-to-line voltages of the load bus are assumed to be balanced, as shown in Equation (6).In Equation ( 6), V L is the effective (rms) value of the line-to-line voltage.Equation (7) gives the three-arm currents of the STATCOM, in which the relationship of V * I = P − jQ is used.
The synthesized line currents of the STATCOM are calculated by using Equation (8).Use of the symmetrical components transformation in Equation ( 9) obtains the symmetrical components of the STATCOM line current in terms of reactive power inputs of the three STATCOM arms, as shown in Equation (10).Equation (10) is the rectangular form of Equation (9).For a delta-connected STATCOM, the zero-sequence component in Equation ( 9) is zero: Use of the two-wattmeter method for the unbalanced load obtains the symmetrical components of the load current.Equation (11) is the line-to-line powers flowing to the load.From Equation (11), the symmetrical components of the load current are shown in Equation ( 12): where, (V From the two-wattmeter method, use of Equation ( 13) calculates the three-phase active and reactive powers to the load.The three-phase powers from the power source can be obtained by a similar calculation.The symmetrical components of the load current in Equation ( 12) are rearranged as a rectangular form, as shown in Equation (14).For unbalanced load compensation, the STATCOM should eliminate the imaginary part of the positive-sequence component and total negative-sequence component of the load current, as shown in Equation ( 15): Im Finally, combining Equations ( 10), ( 14) and (15) gives the needed reactive power of each STATCOM arm for real-time load compensation, as shown in Equation (16).The load compensation formula in Equation ( 16) is very compact and suitable for the delta-connected STATCOM.The sizing of the STATCOM is easy by using Equation (16).With only few power transducers, the compensation formula is implemented easily: With the STATCOM compensation, the source current only contains real part of the positive-sequence load current, as shown in Equation (17).As a result, the source current is balanced with unity power factor, as shown in Equation (18).A systematic design approach regarding the load demand, the sizing of the STATCOM, and the power source response is completed by using Equations ( 13), ( 16) and ( 18):  A fast powers detection method is needed for the real-time compensation scheme in Figure 3a. Figure 4 shows the fast active and reactive powers calculation block for the STATCOM controller by using the single-phase α − β reference frame method [34].With the fast calculation method, the needed load powers for Equation ( 16) and the reactive power inputs of the three STATCOM arms are calculated in real-time.This accelerates the response of the STATCOM.During the STATCOM operation, the switching signals θ 1 ~θ3 for the three FHB cells in each STATCOM arm are swapped in each period of fundamental frequency, as shown in Figure 3b.The alternate swapping control of the switching signals can balance the dc-link voltages of FHB cells in each STATCOM arm without using additional dc voltage feedback control [35].Furthermore, using step modulation in Figure 3b significantly reduces switching losses, and the switching devices mainly have conducting loss.Therefore, the operation efficiency of the STATCOM main circuit can reach 99%, which is much higher than other types of multilevel STATCOMs using high frequency switching techniques [36].With the proposed controller in Figure 3, the STATCOM regulates reactive power inputs of its three arms independently for real-time load compensation.

Simulation Results
Figure 5 depicts the STATCOM simulation system constructed in the MatLab/Simulink program.The STATCOM main circuit is a transformerless, delta-connected configuration, as shown in Figure 1a.A single-phase load controlled by a switch creates unbalanced operation, which tests the transient and steady state compensation effects of the STATCOM.The sampling time of the STATCOM controller is set at 0.52 ms, which is equivalent to 32 sampling points in a period of fundamental frequency (60 Hz).The parameters of the three PID controllers in Figure 3a are designed on-line using a sequential approach with three steps to optimize the system step response, starting with the proportional, integral and derivative gains set to zero: (1) Increase the proportional gain K P to get a stable response with a steady-state error; (2) Then, the integral gain K I is increased gradually for eliminating the steady-state error; (3) Finally, careful choice of the derivative gain K D improves the transient response performance.Another useful on-line designing approach for PID controller cab be seen in [37].Use of the assigned sampling time (0.52 ms) digitizes the parameters of the three analog PID controllers for the STATCOM in the simulation.Furthermore, the design results are also used as reference in the hardware implementation.The parameters selection of the two power components, the reactor X ST and the dc-link capacitor, significantly affects the transient response characteristics of the STATCOM.For example, decreasing the capacitance of the dc-link capacitor accelerates the response time of the STATCOM; however, this also amplifies the dc-link voltage ripple and increases the ac side harmonic current in steady-state operation.Reducing the inductance of the reactor X ST can also accelerate the response time, but the STATCOM control tends to be unstable.A trade-off procedure obtains the parameters of the two power components.In the paper, the capacitance is set at 3300 µF and the inductance is selected as 5 mH, respectively.Appendix A lists the system parameters in Figure 5.
Figures 6-8 show the simulation results in detail.Figure 6a is the three-phase load current.At the beginning, the load current is balanced with lagging power factor.The switch is then closed to create unbalanced operation.With the STATCOM compensation, the source current is compensated to balance, as shown in Figure 6b. Figure 6c shows the phase-a load voltage v L a and the source current i S a .Figure 6b,c shows that source current is maintained in unity power factor after the change of load.Figure 6d presents the synthesized STATCOM line current.By using the harmonics minimizing method in Equation ( 5), the synthesized line current contains little harmonics.In practical application, adequate filters should be employed to meet harmonics control standards.Figure 7a is the internal voltages response of the STATCOM.The STATCOM changes to unbalanced operation after the load change.It is observed in Figure 7b that the three STATCOM arms produce harmonic current during the operation.Increasing the cascaded numbers of the FHB cells can significantly reduce the harmonic currents generated.Figure 7c shows the transient response of the current and voltage, v ST ab and i ST ab , in the arm a-b of the STATCOM.According to the compensation formula, the arm a-b absorbs capacitive reactive power after the change of load.Similarly, the arms b-c and c-a absorb inductive and capacitive reactive powers at the same time, respectively.Figure 7d illustrates the dc-link voltages responses of the STATCOM for reference.Figure 8 shows the controller responses of the STATCOM in the simulation.Figure 8a presents the calculated compensation commands, Q ST * ab , Q ST * bc , and Q ST * ca , for each STATCOM arm.In Figure 8b, according to the commands, the STATCOM regulates its reactive power inputs, Q ST ab , Q ST bc , and Q ST ca .Figure 8c shows the dynamic responses of the internal angle commands, δ ST * ab , δ ST * bc , and δ ST * ca .When the three arms' reactive power inputs reach their desired values, the three internal angle commands go back to near zero, independently.According to the internal angle commands, the active power inputs of the three STATCOM arms, P ST ab , P ST bc , and P ST ca , are responded independently, as shown in Figure 8d.The simulation results preliminarily confirm the function of the STATCOM for real-time load compensation.Table 1 lists the three-phase source, load and STATCOM currents with the STATCOM compensation.The phase-a is used as phase angle reference.Use of a current unbalance ratio,I UR2 (%) = (I 2 /I 1 ) × 100%, evaluates the compensation effect.The current unbalance ratio I L UR2 (%) of the load is 45.2%.With the STATCOM compensation, the I S UR2 (%) of the source is improved to 0.7%.At the same time, the power factor of the source is nearly compensated to unity.Table 2 shows the harmonics analysis results of the three STATCOM arm currents and synthesized line currents in the simulation when the system goes to a steady-state operation.The 5th and 7th orders harmonic components are eliminated by using Equation ( 5).Other higher order harmonic components are limited by the reactors X ST .The THDs of the source currents are within 6%, and the THDs of the load bus voltages are within 1%, which meet the IEEE-519 harmonic control standard [38].Table 2 also shows that 3th order (zero sequence) harmonic currents circulate among the delta-connected main circuit.Due to te unbalanced operation of the STATCOM arms, circulating currents (zero sequence of triple order harmonic currents) do not completely circulate in the delta-connected main circuit loop.Unbalanced operation of the STATCOM generates different amount of 3th order harmonic current in each arm.Residual 3th order harmonic currents appear in the line currents.Increasing the numbers of the FHB cells in each STATCOM arm and incorporating the 3th order harmonic in the harmonic minimizing method can effectively solve this problem.

Hardware Test Results
Figure 9 shows the hardware test system.Appendix B lists the parameters used in the hardware system.A Y-connected inductive load is connected in parallel with a single-phase load for testing.The STATCOM main circuit is a transformerless configuration with delta connection.Insulation gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) is used as switching elements in the STATCOM main circuit.The controller of the STATCOM is a TMS320F2812 DSP-based system, in which the sampling time is set at 0.52 ms to digitize the three PID controllers in the DSP.The real-time control program is firstly developed in the host PC and then downloaded to the DSP-based controller via a JTAG data link.Two eight-channel digital scopes are employed to measure the transient responses of the STATCOM.
Figures 10 and 11 present the experimental results.Figure 10 shows the current responses of the system with the STATCOM compensation.At the beginning of the test, the load is balanced with lagging power factor.Then, the close of the single-phase load creates an unbalanced operation, as shown in Figure 10a.The calculated unbalance ratio of the load current is 45%.With the compensation of the STATCOM, the source current is corrected very quickly to nearly balanced, as shown in Figure 10b.The source current unbalance ratio is improved to 2%. Figure 10c shows the phase-a load bus voltage v L a and the source current i S a , in which the source current is maintained in unity power factor after the load change.Figure 10d is the transient response of the synthesized STATCOM line current.Figure 11 shows other responses of the STATCOM for reference, which are quite agreed with the simulation results.A comparison between Figures 10d and 11b shows that uses of the minimizing method and the delta-connected STATCOM main circuit significantly eliminate the harmonic components generated in the three STATCOM arms.The compensation speed of the STATCOM is quite fast.Although the compensation formula used in the STATCOM is very simple, the compensation effect is satisfactory.The experimental results verify that the proposed STATCOM is suitable for real-time load balancing and power factor correction.
quite agreed with the simulation results.A comparison between Figures 10d and 11b shows that uses of the harmonics minimizing method and the delta-connected STATCOM main circuit significantly eliminate the harmonic components generated in the three STATCOM arms.The compensation speed of the STATCOM is quite fast.Although the compensation formula used in the STATCOM is very simple, the compensation effect is satisfactory.The experimental results verify that the proposed STATCOM is suitable for real-time load balancing and power factor correction.The proposed phase angle control and step modulation scheme also shows a limitation in the STATCOM operation.Since the dc-link capacitor voltages need to be regulated frequently for different needs of reactive power compensations in the unbalanced load compensations.The charging and discharging of these dc-link capacitors need more time comparing to STATCOMs using high frequency PWM techniques.As a result, the response time of the proposed STATCOM is slower than STATCOMs using PWM controls.However, a high power-efficiency operation can be expected by using phase angle control and step modulation scheme for a STATCOM.In the planning stage of STATCOM, a trade-off between response time and power efficiency should be made.

Conclusions
A delta-connected, transformerless STATCOM with cascade multilevel FHB converter for real-time unbalanced load compensation has been studied in the paper.A feedforward compensation formula derived by using the symmetrical components method in the phasor domain is proposed for the STATCOM.Both the computer simulation and experimental results show that the proposed STATCOM is very suitable for real-time load compensation.Although the harmonic components in the line current of the STATCOM are not so obvious in the paper, in practical applications, it should be eliminated properly to avoid polluting the power system.The PID controller dominates the transient response time of the STATCOM.Further study shows that use of other types of controller, such as adaptive controller based on dynamic STATCOM models, can improve the transient response time in load compensation.Additional functions of the STATCOM, such as voltage support and damping enhancement of system, can be implemented with properly tuned auxiliary controllers.This paper introduces a very suitable transition of technology from existing SVC to new-generation STATCOM in high power application.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.The studied system (a) three-phase unbalanced load and the proposed STATCOM; (b) Current and voltage waveforms of the STATCOM arm a-b (charging mode, δ ST < 0).

Figure 3a presents the
Figure 3a presents the architecture of the proposed STATCOM controller.Use of Equation (16) calculates the reactive power commands of the three STATCOM arms, Q ST * ab , Q ST * bc , and Q ST * ca , in real-time.First, the controller detects the line currents (i L a , i L c ) and line-to-line voltages (v L ab , v L cb ) of the unbalanced load to obtain the active and reactive powers (P L ab , Q L ab , P L cb , Q L cb ) to the load.A DSP-based power data detector is employed in the calculation.Three proportional-integral-derivative (PID) feedback controllers regulate the reactive power of the three STATCOM arms, independently.For example, the actual reactive power input Q ST ab of the STATCOM arm a-b is detected and then compared with the needed reactive power Q ST * ab .With the compared result, the PID controller generates the internal angle command δ ST * ab .For prevention of over-current operation during system faults, internal angle limiters are installed in the outputs of the PID controllers.Finally, the internal angle command δ ST * ab produces the switching signals for the FHB cells according to Figure 1b.Three phase-locked loops (PLLs) generate reference signals for synchronizing switching patterns to FHB cells of each STATCOM arm, respectively.

Figure 3 .
Figure 3.The proposed STATCOM controller and gating sequence (a) The STATCOM controller; (b) Alternate swapping of switching patterns for dc-link voltages balancing.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4.The fast power calculation block.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Compensation effect of STATCOM (a) Load current (i L a,b,c ; (b) Source current (i S a,b,c ); (c) Phase-a load bus voltage and source current (v L a , i S a ); (d) STATCOM line current (i ST a,b,c ).

Figure 10 .
Figure 10.Transient responses with the STATCOM compensation (a) Load current (i L a,b,c ; (b) Source current (i S a,b,c ); (c) Phase-a load bus voltage and source current (v L a , i S a ); (d) Line current of the STATCOM (i ST a,b,c ).

Table 2 .
Harmonics analysis of the STATCOM phases and synthesized lines currents.