Overexpression of the Arabidopsis MACPF Protein AtMACP2 Promotes Pathogen Resistance by Activating SA Signaling

Immune response in plants is tightly regulated by the coordination of the cell surface and intracellular receptors. In animals, the membrane attack complex/perforin-like (MACPF) protein superfamily creates oligomeric pore structures on the cell surface during pathogen infection. However, the function and molecular mechanism of MACPF proteins in plant pathogen responses remain largely unclear. In this study, we identified an Arabidopsis MACP2 and investigated the responsiveness of this protein during both bacterial and fungal pathogens. We suggest that MACP2 induces programmed cell death, bacterial pathogen resistance, and necrotrophic fungal pathogen sensitivity by activating the biosynthesis of tryptophan-derived indole glucosinolates and the salicylic acid signaling pathway dependent on the activity of enhanced disease susceptibility 1 (EDS1). Moreover, the response of MACP2 mRNA isoforms upon pathogen attack is differentially regulated by a posttranscriptional mechanism: alternative splicing. In comparison to previously reported MACPFs in Arabidopsis, MACP2 shares a redundant but nonoverlapping role in plant immunity. Thus, our findings provide novel insights and genetic tools for the MACPF family in maintaining SA accumulation in response to pathogens in Arabidopsis.


Introduction
As sessile organisms, plants have evolved sophisticated mechanisms to communicate with surrounding microorganisms, including beneficial and pathogenic interaction. Plant pathogens secrete effector proteins to suppress host immune responses during their colonization [1,2]. Thus, plant cells are equipped with a variety of cell surface or intracellularly localized receptor proteins that can recognize microorganisms and initiate downstream immune responses to restrict pathogen proliferation [3]. In particular, cell surface receptors, also known as pattern recognition receptors (PRRs), function in the recognition of conserved pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) and are able to trigger PAMPtriggered immunity (PTI) responses during plant interactions with either nonpathogenic or pathogenic microbes [3,4]. For example, PAMP receptors such as PRR FLAGELLIN SENSING 2 (FLS2), chitin elicitor receptor kinase 1 (CERK1), and EF-Tu receptor (EFR) recognize conserved microbial effectors, flagellin (or the minimal epitope flg22), fungal chitin, and elongation factor thermo unstable (EF-Tu), respectively, in Arabidopsis [3,5]. Furthermore, PAMP receptors form heterocomplexes with coreceptors such as Brassinosteroid insensitive 1-associated kinase 1 (BAK1) to activate downstream responses under pathway and linking PAMP-induced PCD to antimicrobial metabolism upon pathogen attack [4,30].
A total of four MACPF proteins have been identified in Arabidopsis; however, in addition to CAD1 and NSL1, the other two MACPFs have not been studied well. To this end, we isolated two independent mutants of AtMACP2 (At4g24290) from Arabidopsis. Phenotypic and genetic analysis suggested that MACP2 is involved in the SA-mediated PCD response during pathogen infection and that the activation of SA signaling may result from altered metabolism of tryptophan (Trp)-derived indole glucosinolates. Further analysis indicated that MACP2 undergoes posttranscriptional regulation by alternative splicing (AS), and the three spliced isoforms detected based on the database information differentially respond to treatment with bacterial and fungal pathogens, implying distinct responsive pathways derived from plant immunity.

Characterization of T-DNA Insertional Mutants and Transgenic Overexpression Lines in MACP2
In Arabidopsis thaliana, besides the two reported proteins, NSL1 and CAD1, the function of the other two MACPF-containing proteins, MACP1 (encoded by At1g14780) and MACP2 (encoded by At4g24290), remain unknown. To explore the role of the MACP2 in Arabidopsis thaliana, we bought two T-DNA insertional mutants ( Figure 1A, B) of this gene from TAIR and identified homozygotes. Amplification with primer pairs containing the T-DNA fragment LBa1 showed obvious bands but showed a blank with primer pairs for full-length MACP2 in mutants, which indicated that the mutants were exactly homozygous T-DNA insertion mutants. RT-PCR showed that no full-length transcripts were present in the corresponding KO-1 and KO-2 mutants ( Figure 1C), indicating that these lines are knockout mutants. Subsequently, transgenic lines introducing the MACP2-YFP construct into the wild-type were generated at the same time. Clear bands of the vector contained fragment amplification results ( Figure 1D) and higher relative expression levels of MACP2 ( Figure 1E); specific YFP-tagged MACP2 detection in MACP2-YFP(OE) plants via Western blot analysis ( Figure 1F) showed the correct MACP2-overexpression transgenic plants we obtained.

Overexpression of MACP2-Accelerated Cell Death in Rosettes
To investigate whether disruption or overexpression of MACP2 shows linkage to SA, ROS accumulation, and constitutive cell death, we examined the rosettes of 4-, 5-, and 6week-old wild-type, KO mutants, and OE transgenic plants using diaminobenzidine (DAB) and trypan blue staining. Interestingly, as shown in Figure 2, trypan blue-stained lesions displayed no significant differences at the fourth week and were apparently more severe in the leaves of OE transgenic plants than in the wild-type, whereas this was reversed in the KO mutants at the fifth and sixth weeks ( Figure 2A). Meanwhile, OE leaves generated higher levels of H 2 O 2 at the fifth and sixth weeks. This was indicated by the brown color upon DAB staining compared with the wild-type control rather than the lower level of H 2 O 2 in the KO mutants than wild-type plants in the same period ( Figure 2B). These results suggest that MACP2 promotes natural continuous cell death and ROS eruptions during leaf senescence.

MACP2-Strengthened Plant Resistance to Bacterial Pathogens Relying on the SA Pathway
To address whether the overexpression of MACP2 affects the plant defense response to bacterial pathogens, we conducted Pst DC3000 inoculation assays on four-week-old wildtype, MACP2-KO mutants, and MACP2-OE plants. According to the results, the OE plants showed a more tolerant phenotype than the wild-type when responding to Pst DC3000 infection ( Figure 3A) and significantly repressed the bacterial population ( Figure 3B), while the KO mutants showed a more sensitive phenotype than the wild-type ( Figure 3A

Overexpression of MACP2-Accelerated Cell Death in Rosettes
To investigate whether disruption or overexpression of MACP2 shows linkage to SA ROS accumulation, and constitutive cell death, we examined the rosettes of 4-, 5-, and 6 week-old wild-type, KO mutants, and OE transgenic plants using diaminobenzidin (DAB) and trypan blue staining. Interestingly, as shown in Figure 2, trypan blue-stained lesions displayed no significant differences at the fourth week and were apparently mor severe in the leaves of OE transgenic plants than in the wild-type, whereas this was re versed in the KO mutants at the fifth and sixth weeks ( Figure 2A). Meanwhile, OE leave The full-length MACP2 was amplified with primer pair XS2591 and XS2592. The length-contained T-DNA sequence was amplified via primer pair LBa1 and XS2592 in KO-1, and KO-2. (C) Semiquantitative PCR of MACP2 in WT and MACP2-KOs. The full-length MACP2 was amplified with primer pair XS2591 and XS2592. The ACTIN2 was amplified with primer pair ACTIN2-F and ACTIN2-R. (D) Identification in DNA level of MACP2-YFP transgenic plants. MACP2 CDS was cloned into pFGC-RCS binary vector then the expression cassette of MACP2-YFP was inserted into the Arabidopsis genome. UBQ10 and XS2489 were derived from the pFGC-RCS plasmid and MACP2 CDS, respectively. (E) Identification in RNA level of MACP2-YFP transgenic plants. Transcriptional level of MACP2 in MACP2-OE-1 and MACP2-OE-2 upregulated 3-5 times as that in wild-type. The data represent means from three independent repeats. Statistical differences were identified using Student's t test. ** p < 0.01. (F) Identification in protein level of MACP2-YFP transgenic plants. Anti-GFP was used to recognize the specific YFP tag. CBB represented Coomassie blue staining. lower level of H2O2 in the KO mutants than wild-type plants in the same period ( Figure  2B). These results suggest that MACP2 promotes natural continuous cell death and ROS eruptions during leaf senescence.

MACP2-Strengthened Plant Resistance to Bacterial Pathogens Relying on the SA Pathway
To address whether the overexpression of MACP2 affects the plant defense response to bacterial pathogens, we conducted Pst DC3000 inoculation assays on four-week-old wild-type, MACP2-KO mutants, and MACP2-OE plants. According to the results, the OE plants showed a more tolerant phenotype than the wild-type when responding to Pst DC3000 infection ( Figure 3A) and significantly repressed the bacterial population ( Figure  3B), while the KO mutants showed a more sensitive phenotype than the wild-type ( Figure  3A, B). In addition, we measured the endogenous SA levels in wild-type, KO mutants, and OE transgenic lines during pathogen infection using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. As shown in Figure 3C, in the CK group, the contents of SA and SAG were higher in the OE plants but lower in the KO plants than in the wild-type (WT) plants. After Pst DC3000 treatment, although the SA content increased sharply in general, the SA and SAG contents in OEs were significantly higher than those in the wild-type. In contrast, a reverse trend of their content variation in response to Pst DC3000 treatment was found in the KOs.
On the basis of MACP2 promoting SA accumulation in response to bacterial pathogens, we selected enhanced disease susceptibility 1 (EDS1), forming heterodimers with phytoalexin deficient 4 (PAD4) to promote SA accumulation [31], and to generate OE eds1-22 plants to further define the connection of the pathogen response and SA accumulation in MACP2-OE plants. Then, we conducted Pst DC3000 inoculation assays in four-week-old rosettes among different genotypes, including wild-type, OE, eds1-22, and OE eds1-22. Disrupting the SA signaling pathway EDS1 suppressed the resistance phenotype to Pst DC3000 in OE plants ( Figure 3D,E). These results suggest that MACP2 strengthened plant resistance to bacterial pathogens depending on the SA pathway in Arabidopsis.

MACP2-Weakened Plant Resistance Depending on the SA Pathway to Necrotrophic Fungal Pathogens
To explore whether the accumulation of SA in OE plants affected the response to necrotrophic fungal pathogens, we conducted B. cinerea inoculation assays on four-weekold wild-type, KO mutant, and OE plants. OE plants were hypersensitive to B. cinerea infection compared to wild-type plants ( Figure 4A,B), as confirmed by the larger lesion size in OE plants instead of the resistant phenotype, and the smaller lesion size in KO plants ( Figure 4A, B). Naturally, we also tested the contents of SA and SAG that were also induced during fungal infection and accumulated in OEs ( Figure 4C). B. cinerea infection experiments were also carried out on OE eds1-22 plants and revealed that the absence of the SA signal pathway EDS1 crippled the sensitive phenotype to B. cinerea in OE plants ( Figure 4D,E). These results suggest that MACP2 operates differentially in response to bacterial and necrotrophic fungal pathogens. The data represent means from three independent repeats. Statistically significant differences were identified using Student's t test. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
In addition, we measured the endogenous SA levels in wild-type, KO mutants, and OE transgenic lines during pathogen infection using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. As shown in Figure 3C, in the CK group, the contents of SA and SAG were higher in the OE plants but lower in the KO plants than in the wild-type (WT) plants. After Pst DC3000 treatment, although the SA content increased sharply in general, the SA and   To further investigate the difference between bacterial and fungal immunity caused by MACP2 overexpression, we detected the expression of genes related to SA-associated defense responses, including PR1, PR5, ST1, and EDR2 [32][33][34], and JA-associated defense responses, including PDF1.2a, PDF1.2b, VPS1, and VPS2 [35] in rosettes. Consistent with the phenotype resistant to bacterial pathogen in OE plants, the transcript levels of SA-associated responsive genes in OE plants (with the exception of EDR2) showed a sharply upregulated trend compared with the wild-type but displayed a significantly downregulated trend in KO mutants. On the contrary, an inverse trend was observed for JA-related responsive genes ( Figure 5A), manifesting in significant upregulation in KO mutants but downregulation in OEs. With the necrotrophic fungal pathogen (B. cinerea), the OEs displayed downregulation of JA-responsive genes, and KOs showed fiercely higher expression than the wild-type. In addition, SA-responsive genes were also induced slightly by B. cinerea and maintained a higher expression level in OEs, resulting in a fungus-sensitive phenotype based on the antagonizing role of SA and JA. Our results suggest that overexpression of MACP2 may contribute to accelerated SA accumulation, thus activating the SA signaling pathway in response to pathogen invasion. To further investigate the difference between bacterial and fungal immunity caused by MACP2 overexpression, we detected the expression of genes related to SA-associated defense responses, including PR1, PR5, ST1, and EDR2 [32][33][34], and JA-associated defense responses, including PDF1.2a, PDF1.2b, VPS1, and VPS2 [35] in rosettes. Consistent with the phenotype resistant to bacterial pathogen in OE plants, the transcript levels of SAassociated responsive genes in OE plants (with the exception of EDR2) showed a sharply upregulated trend compared with the wild-type but displayed a significantly downregulated trend in KO mutants. On the contrary, an inverse trend was observed for JA-related responsive genes ( Figure 5A), manifesting in significant upregulation in KO mutants but downregulation in OEs. With the necrotrophic fungal pathogen (B. cinerea), the OEs displayed downregulation of JA-responsive genes, and KOs showed fiercely higher expression than the wild-type. In addition, SA-responsive genes were also induced slightly by B. cinerea and maintained a higher expression level in OEs, resulting in a fungus-sensitive phenotype based on the antagonizing role of SA and JA. Our results suggest that overexpression of MACP2 may contribute to accelerated SA accumulation, thus activating the SA signaling pathway in response to pathogen invasion.

Alternatively Spliced Isoforms of MACP2 Are Differentially Expressed under Pathogen Treatment
To investigate the relationship between AS regulation of MACP2 and pathogen resistance, we designed isoform-specific primers to explore the expression levels of these isoforms either under normal conditions or treatment with Pst DC3000 or B. cinerea (Figure 6A). A total of three mRNAs can be detected for MACP2, named MACP2-1, MACP2-2, and MACP2-3. Expression analysis using semiquantitative and real-time quantitative PCR indicated that MACP2-1 and MACP2-3 were highly expressed in four-week-old rosettes of the wild-type before any treatments ( Figure 6B, C). Interestingly, Pst DC3000 induced the expression of the MACP2 locus, particularly through the transcription of MACP2-1, but not the other two mRNA isoforms. In contrast, the transcript abundance of MACP2 was reduced in response to B. cinerea inoculation. Isoform-specific expression

Alternatively Spliced Isoforms of MACP2 Are Differentially Expressed under Pathogen Treatment
To investigate the relationship between AS regulation of MACP2 and pathogen resistance, we designed isoform-specific primers to explore the expression levels of these isoforms either under normal conditions or treatment with Pst DC3000 or B. cinerea ( Figure 6A). A total of three mRNAs can be detected for MACP2, named MACP2-1, MACP2-2, and MACP2-3. Expression analysis using semiquantitative and real-time quantitative PCR indicated that MACP2-1 and MACP2-3 were highly expressed in four-week-old rosettes of the wild-type before any treatments ( Figure 6B, C). Interestingly, Pst DC3000 induced the expression of the MACP2 locus, particularly through the transcription of MACP2-1, but not the other two mRNA isoforms. In contrast, the transcript abundance of MACP2 was reduced in response to B. cinerea inoculation. Isoform-specific expression analysis suggested that MACP2-1 and MACP2-2 contribute to this reduction, whereas MACP2-3 was elevated in comparison to untreated controls. Thus, the underlying mechanism of this differential expression of MACP2 isoforms in response to different pathogens remains to be further investigated.
analysis suggested that MACP2-1 and MACP2-2 contribute to this reduction, whereas MACP2-3 was elevated in comparison to untreated controls. Thus, the underlying mechanism of this differential expression of MACP2 isoforms in response to different pathogens remains to be further investigated. The common sequence of three AS was amplified with primer pair MACP2-F and MACP2-R. The specific sequences of AS were amplified with primer pair mentioned in (B). The ACTIN2 was amplified with primer pair ACTIN2-F and ACTIN2-R. Asterisks indicate significant differences from the wild-type. ** p < 0.01 by Student's t test. (D) qRT-PCR detection of AS responding to Pst DC3000 and B. cinerea after 3 days of infection on 4-week-old rosettes of wild-type. Asterisks indicate significant differences from the wild-type. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 by Student's t test.  and specific sequence of each AS (T1, T2, T3) in 4-week-old rosettes of wild-type. The common sequence of three AS was amplified with primer pair MACP2-F and MACP2-R. The specific sequences of AS were amplified with primer pair mentioned in (B). The ACTIN2 was amplified with primer pair ACTIN2-F and ACTIN2-R. Asterisks indicate significant differences from the wild-type. ** p < 0.01 by Student's t test. (D) qRT-PCR detection of AS responding to Pst DC3000 and B. cinerea after 3 days of infection on 4-week-old rosettes of wild-type. Asterisks indicate significant differences from the wild-type. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01 by Student's t test. Pst DC3000 infection were significantly elevated in OE plants but significantly reduced in KO mutants (with the exception of MYB51) compared to the wild-type ( Figure 7A, B). In contrast, the transcriptional level of aliphatic GS synthesis regulators (MYB28, MYB29, and MYB76) and the levels of aliphatic GSs, including 4-MOSB, 5-MSOP, and 8-MSOO, were not significantly altered in OEs, while those related to aliphatic GSs and the levels of aliphatic GSs increased in response to Pst DC3000 infection in general (Supplementary Figure S1). These findings indicate that MACP2 responds to pathogen infection in a tryptophan (Trp)-derived indole glucosinolate-activated SA-dependent manner.

Pleiotropic Function of MACPF Proteins in Plant Immunity and Programmed Cell Death
An orthologue search indicated that there are four MACPF proteins in Arabidopsis, and two of them have been extensively studied in the past twenty years [19]. In this study, we demonstrated that macp2 knockout mutants and MACP2-OEs display altered sensitivity to bacterial and fungal pathogens (Figures 3 and 4), suggesting that MACP2 participates in plant immunity responses to external pathogens. Interestingly, the knockout mutant of CAD1 showed similar lesion mimic phenotypes [10,15,36], suggesting the activation of immune responses in this knockout mutant. Previous genetic and physiological studies have demonstrated that the cad1-1 mutant is resistant to the virulent bacterial pathogen Pst DC3000 [15]. Similarly, the MACP2-OEs had a similar phenotype (Figure 3), showing fewer lesions in comparison to the wild-type. The MACP2 shared 52.1% and 43.9% identity with NSL1 and CAD1, respectively [15]. The underlying mechanism of phenotypic variation among these three MACPFs remains to be further investigated. One hypothesis that has been proposed previously is that nonoverlapping functions of NSL1 and CAD1 may be related to downstream defense-related R proteins [30]. At the molecular level, the cad1-5 mutant has been found to elevate PR1 gene expression, the marker of plant immunity [15]. However, this hypothesis needs direct experimental evidence for further investigation.

Pleiotropic Function of MACPF Proteins in Plant Immunity and Programmed Cell Death
An orthologue search indicated that there are four MACPF proteins in Arabidopsis, and two of them have been extensively studied in the past twenty years [19]. In this study, we demonstrated that macp2 knockout mutants and MACP2-OEs display altered sensitivity to bacterial and fungal pathogens (Figures 3 and 4), suggesting that MACP2 participates in plant immunity responses to external pathogens. Interestingly, the knockout mutant of CAD1 showed similar lesion mimic phenotypes [10,15,36], suggesting the activation of immune responses in this knockout mutant. Previous genetic and physiological studies have demonstrated that the cad1-1 mutant is resistant to the virulent bacterial pathogen Pst DC3000 [15]. Similarly, the MACP2-OEs had a similar phenotype (Figure 3), showing fewer lesions in comparison to the wild-type. The MACP2 shared 52.1% and 43.9% identity with NSL1 and CAD1, respectively [15]. The underlying mechanism of phenotypic variation among these three MACPFs remains to be further investigated. One hypothesis that has been proposed previously is that nonoverlapping functions of NSL1 and CAD1 may be related to downstream defense-related R proteins [30]. At the molecular level, the cad1-5 mutant has been found to elevate PR1 gene expression, the marker of plant immunity [15]. However, this hypothesis needs direct experimental evidence for further investigation.
Furthermore, the expression of NSL1 and CAD1 is not induced by biotic stress treatments but is altered under abiotic stress conditions, suggesting that constitutive defense responses of these Arabidopsis mutant lines may not be the primary function of these MACPF proteins [30]. Indeed, the massive production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) through oxidative bursts during plant-pathogen interactions will trigger PCD in plants [37]. NSL1 has been proposed to disturb ROS production, thus impairing PCD during plantdisease responses [30], whereas overexpression of MACP2 caused higher levels of H 2 O 2 and profound cell death in rosette leaves (Figure 2).
In mammals, to form a transmembrane pore structure, MACPF domain-containing proteins require the assisted assembly of other complement proteins [38,39]. However, no se-cretory peptide signal could be detected in the protein sequence of Arabidopsis MACPFs [15]. A previous study of NSL1 suggested that the metabolic imbalance detected in the nsl1 mutant may be the result of improper assembly of these pore structures [30]. By using 35S-and native promoter-driven constructs, NSL1 was found to localize at the plasma membrane in Arabidopsis. Similarly, the subcellular localization of CAD1 has been confirmed by fractionation and confocal microscopy approaches [15]. In this study, MACP2 is a membrane-localized protein (Supplemental Figure S2), indicating that all three MACPFs can be deployed by the plant immune system to the entry site as a defense mechanism during host-microbe interactions. Unfortunately, there is little hard experimental evidence to prove the formation of protein complexes by these MACPFs in plants. Our previous study characterized MACPF genes in plants and revealed that several of those in Poaceae participated in plant vegetative growth and environmental stress adaptation [18]. In addition, nonredundant phenotypes of CAD1 and NSL1 suggested that plant MACPFs may function differently from their animal counterparts by assembling heteromeric complexes themselves to create pore structures on cell membranes [15]. Furthermore, although NSL1 is localized at the cell membrane, it did not kill pathogens at the entry site, suggesting that NSL1 has a differential mechanism in comparison to their animal orthologues. However, further molecular and biochemical experiments are required to unravel the underlying mechanism of plant MACPFs.

Plant Hormonal Signaling Is Critical to Influence MACP2-Mediated Disease Resistance
Plant hormones are important for all aspects of plant growth and physiology [40][41][42][43]. To unravel the molecular mechanism of MACP2-mediated PCD in plant immune responses, the relationship between plant defense hormones and MACP2 were evaluated. Genetic analysis of transgenic plants suggested that MACP2-mediated PCD is dependent on the plant hormone SA (Figure 3), which is similar to the molecular mechanism of CAD1 [15]. It has long been reported that the elimination of SA content could inhibit the expression of PR genes and thus lower resistance to pathogen infection [44]. The cad1-1 mutant has a higher level of SA content than the wild-types, and the introduction of the bacterial enzyme NahG for SA degradation could rescue the PCD phenotype of cad1-1 [15]. Meanwhile, the SA content increased significantly after treatment with both bacterial (Pst DC3000) and fungal pathogens (B. cinerea).
Furthermore, NSL1-mediated PCD triggered by flg22 has been considered a potential PAMP response and is characterized by the accumulation of SA and ROS, which are typical MTI outputs in response to pathogen attacks [4,45]. In contrast, CAD1 has been proposed to induce HR-related cell death by activating NLR signaling [36,46]. In this article, subsequent analysis indicated that EDS1 is downstream of MACP2 to confer plant immune responses (Figures 3 and 4). Similarly, most of the phenotypic and biochemical changes among CAD1 transgenic lines are proposed to be dependent on EDS1-mediated signaling [15], and approximately 90% of SA biosynthesis in plants is affected by EDS1-PAD4 signaling in the cytosol and nucleus [47,48]. EDS1 is a nucleocytoplasmic lipase-like protein that is classified as a member of the NLR-TNL signaling pathway by forming heterodimers with either phytoalexin deficient 4 (PAD4) or SAG101 [12,13]. Furthermore, the nsl1-3 pad4 double mutant did not show a hyperactive immunity phenotype, indicating that NSL1 is guarded by NLR-TNL signaling [4]. In addition to SA biosynthesis activation, the EDS1-PAD4 complex is able to induce the expression of genes involved in the cell death response, such as PR1. In this study, the expression of PR1 and PR5 among transgenic Arabidopsis MACP2-OEs correlated with SA levels, further validating that EDS1 is responsible for MACP2-mediated PCD. Nevertheless, except for EDS1, downstream signaling of MACPFs in response to plant pathogens remains to be further investigated.
Intriguingly, a recent report demonstrated that the EDS1-PAD4 pair participates in sphingolipid metabolism to trigger cell death in response to the fungal pathogen B. cinerea [13]. The involvement of sphingolipids, especially long-chain ceramides, in the MACP2-mediated PCD response is valuable for study. Furthermore, SA resists the biotrophic pathogens living and reproducing on live host cells, whereas jasmonic acid (JA) acts on necrotrophic pathogens that kill host cells for nutrition and reproduction. Both of them play important but antagonistic signaling roles in pathogen responses [49]. EDS1-PAD4 signaling has been reported to play a negative role in response to B. cinerea, a necrotrophic fungal pathogen that can activate the JA pathway in plants [50]. Thus, the phenotypes of MACP2 in response to B. cinerea could be explained (Figure 4), suggesting that the repression of cell death in Arabidopsis effectively confers plant resistance to B. cinerea. Similarly, JA accumulated in the cad1 mutant, and the JA/ethylene-induced gene PDF1.2 was altered compared to wild-types [10]. Specifically, PDF1.2a and PDF1.2b were differentially expressed in MACP2 transgenic lines in response to bacterial and fungal pathogens ( Figure 5), suggesting crosstalk between multiple plant hormonal signaling pathways downstream of MACP2. Finally, different splice isoforms responded to bacterial or fungal inoculation (Figure 6), indicating that the distinct response mechanism of MACP2 to bacterial and fungal pathogens can be controlled by posttranscriptional regulation, i.e., alternative splicing [51][52][53][54][55].

Glucosinolates Are Crucial Signal Messengers That Transduce Immunity-Triggered PCD Downstream of MACPF Proteins
Previously identified EDS1-PAD4 signaling has been documented as a universal regulator of plant immunity, which also regulates multiple metabolic pathways of plant hormones, phytoalexins (camalexin), and other secondary metabolisms (tocopherols and Nhydroxypipecolic acid) [56]. In the study of NSL1, glucosinolates (GSs), an unsuspected role of tryptophan-derived secondary metabolites, are pivotal messengers to initiate PCD by activating SA biosynthesis in Arabidopsis [4]. Glucosinolates (sulfur-and nitrogen-containing thioglucosides) show broad activity against insect herbivores and plant pathogens [57] and are classified into three subcategories: aromatic GSs, methionine-derived aliphatic GSs (AGSs), and tryptophan-derived indole GSs (IGSs) [58].
A pathogen-inducible myrosinase, penetration 2 (PEN2) involved in the bioconversion of indole glucosinolates (IGSs) [59], plays an important role in PAMP-triggered PCD in the absence of NSL1 [4]. PEN2 is responsible for releasing bioactive molecules (e.g., isothiocyanates) with a wide range of toxicity to insects and plant pathogens [60]. In particular, 4-methoxyindol-3-ylmethylglucosinolate (4MI3G, IGS against a broad spectrum of fungal pathogens) is accumulated [61] under pathogen infection via PEN2 activity. In our study, indolic GS species (I3M and 1-MOI3M) were highly accumulated in MACP2-OEs and were less accumulated in MACP2-KOs in comparison to the levels of these compounds in the wild-type plants (Figure 7), implying that IGs may function similarly as signal molecules to connect MACP2 and downstream PCD responses. Furthermore, the conversion of I3G to 4MI3G has been proposed to be tightly regulated by the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK)-transcription factor (TF) cascade. The MPK3/MPK6-MYB34/51/122 cascade has been suggested to participate in this regulation [62]. Here, the transcript abundance of three R2R3-MYB TFs, MYB34, MYB51, and MYB122, was tested, showing a high correlation with the content of I3M and 1-MOI3M in MACP2-KOs and MACP2-OEs (Figure 7). However, the mechanism by which the EDS1-PAD4 pair triggers IGS biosynthesis remains elusive. Further study of signal transduction downstream and the assembly mechanism of MACP2 will be informative because this is the general defense mechanism that plants possess to restrict pathogen infection.

Plant Material, Growth Condition, and Treatment
Arabidopsis thaliana accession Columbia-0 (Col-0) was used as the wild-type line in this study. MACP2-KO-1 (SALK_040186) and MACP2-KO-2 (SALK_052845C) were obtained from The Arabidopsis Biological Resource Center (ABRC, USA, http://www.arabidopsis. org, accessed on 24 April 2015). The eds1-22 mutant used in this study has been described previously [63]. For genetic analysis, the eds1-22 mutant was crossed with MACP2-OE to generate OE eds1-22. For the seed germination assay, the Arabidopsis seeds were surface sterilized with 20% bleach containing 0.1% Tween 20 (Sigma, P2287, St. Louis, MI, USA) for 15 min, washed with distilled water 6 times, and then plated on 1/2 MS (Sigma, M5519, USA) agar with 1% sucrose. The plates were incubated at 4 • C for 2 days and then transferred to a greenhouse under a 16 h light/8 h dark photoperiod at 20 • C for 7 days according to a previous study [64].

Plasmid Construction and Transgenic Plant Generation
All constructs were generated using the ClonExpress II One Step Cloning Kit (Vazyme, C112, China). The gene-specific primers with 15 bp extensions homologous to the corresponding vectors are listed in Supplemental Table S1.
To generate stable transgenic plants, MACP2 CDS was cloned into pUC119-YFP to construct the expression cassette MACP2-YFP, which was cloned into the binary vector pFGC-RCS via the same AscI digestion site between the two vectors [65,66]. The expression cassettes were subsequently introduced into wild-type Arabidopsis (Col-0) by Agrobacterium tumefaciens-medium transformation via the floral dip method [67] to generate MACP2-YFP transgenic plants.

Pathogen Infection
Pathogen inoculation was carried out as previously described [69][70][71] with minor modifications. The fungal pathogen Botrytis cinerea was maintained on V8 juice agar medium at 25 • C in the dark for 10 days. Spore masses were collected and suspended in Vogel buffer composed of 50 mM sucrose (Guangzhou Chemical Reagent Factory, China), 20 mM K 2 HPO 4 (Damao Chemical Reagent Factory, China), 10 mM sodium citrate, 20 mM (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 , 1 mM MgSO 4 and 10 mM CaCl 2 (pH 5.0). More than 9 mature rosettes per genotype from different 4-week-old plants were placed in petri dishes containing 0.6% (w/v) agar. Each leaf was inoculated with 5 µL droplets containing 1.6 × 10 6 spores/mL of B. cinerea suspension, incubated in the dark for 36 h, and then cultivated in a greenhouse with a 16 h light/8 h dark photoperiod at 20 • C. The lesion diameter (mm) was calculated using ImageJ software.
The bacterial pathogen P. syringae pv. tomato (Pst DC3000) was cultivated at 28 • C and 200 rpm in King's medium B [70] containing rifampicin (New Probe, 50 mg/L, China). Then, Pst DC3000 was collected by centrifugation and resuspended in 10 mM MgCl 2 at A 600 = 0.2. Bacteria were then diluted 10 times to approximately 107 colony-forming units/mL in 10 mM MgCl 2 and 0.02% Silwet L-77 (New Probe, P001374, China) for inoculation. After inoculation, the plants were kept in high humidity. To calculate the bacterial populations, leaf discs (0.6 cm diameter) were collected from infected leaves, washed three times with sterile water, and homogenized in 10 mM MgCl 2 , followed by applying appropriate dilutions on solid King's B medium with rifampicin. All experiments were repeated three times with similar results.

SA Measurements
SA was extracted and measured as described previously [72,73]. Approximately 150 mg powdered tissue was weighed in a 2 mL centrifuge tube and extracted with 800 µL of extraction buffer of 2-propanol/water/concentrated HCl (2:1:0.005, v/v/v) with internal standards of 10 ng d4-SA (Sigma-Aldrich, USA). The mixtures were shaken mildly for 30 min at 4 • C, followed by adding 1 mL dichloromethane and shaking for an additional 30 min at 4 • C. The samples were then centrifuged at 13,000× g and 4 • C for 10 min. Solvent (1 mL) from the lower phase was collected and dried using a nitrogen evaporator with nitrogen flow. The samples were dissolved in a 200 µL mixture of 60% methanol (Mreda, M042749, China) and 40% sterile ultrapure water. Quantitative analysis of SA was performed via a chromatography (Shimadzu, Japan)-mass spectrometry (Triple TOF 5600, AB SCIEX, USA) system according to Chen et al. [72].

RNA Extraction and RT-qPCR
Total RNA was extracted from 5-and 6-week-old Arabidopsis leaves referring to a previous study [35]. Two milligrams of total RNA were extracted by HiPure Plant RNA Mini kit (Magen, China) and converted into cDNA with the HiScript II QRT Super Mix kit with gDNA Wiper (Vazyme). RT-qPCR assays (10 µL reaction volumes with gene-specific primers, Supplemental Materials Table S1) were performed on a StepOne Plus Real-time PCR System (Applied Biosystems) using ChamQ SYBR Color qPCR Master Mix (Vazyme, China) and the following protocol: 95 • C for 5 min followed by 40 cycles of 95 • C for 15 s, 55 • C for 15 s, and 72 • C for 30 s.
Primers for RT-PCR were described in both a previous publication and qPrimer DB (https://biodb.swu.edu.cn/qprimerdb/, accessed on 24 April 2015, [74]). Primers for specific AS were designed in exon-exon junction, for which specificity was verified via Primer-Blast software and amplified in restricted extension time to tule out genomic DNA contribution. The efficiency of each primer pair was not evaluated and only comparisons for each particular mRNA isoform under normal conditions or pathogen treatment were compared to draw further conclusions. For calculation of relative transcription levels, the delta of threshold cycle (∆Ct) values was calculated by subtracting the arithmetic mean Ct values of the target genes from the normalizing ACTIN2. The relative transcription level (2ˆ∆∆Ct) was calculated from three independent experiments. The fold change values were visualized, illustrated, and standardized in a heatmap generated by the TBtools package [75]. In the heatmap, the color represents the fold change value. The closer it is to pink, the greater the fold change value.

GS Measurements
GSs were extracted and detected as described previously [35,76] with minor modifications. Frozen leaf samples (120 mg) were ground with a glass rod in 1.2 mL ice-cold MeOH/H 2 O (70:30, v/v) and incubated at 80 • C for 15 min. The homogenate was centrifuged at 3500× g and 4 • C for 10 min, and the supernatant was filtered through a 0.22 µm filter for analysis. Chromatography (Shimadzu, Japan)-mass spectrometry (Triple TOF 5600, AB SCIEX, USA) was used to detect and analyze the GS contents according to Liao et al. [35]. Quantification was performed using three technical replicates. Experiments were repeated three times with similar results, and five plants of each genotype were collected for one technical replicate.

Protein Isolation and Immunoblot Analysis
For total protein extraction, 4-week-old Arabidopsis seedlings grown in soil were ground in liquid nitrogen and homogenized in ice-cold protein extraction buffer of 50 mM sodium phosphate (pH 7.0), 200 mM NaCl, 10 mM MgCl 2 , 0.2% β-mercaptoethanol (Westgene, WG0482, China), and 10% glycerol, and supplemented with protease inhibitor cocktail (Roche, 04693132001) according to Xia et al. [77]. The samples were placed on ice for 30 min and centrifuged at 4 • C at 12,000× g for 10 min. The supernatant was transferred to a new microfuge tube before electrophoresis.

Statistical Analysis
The significance of the difference between 2 groups was determined using Student's t test. The level of statistical significance is indicated by asterisks (* p < 0.05 and ** p < 0.01). The numbers of samples are indicated in the figure legends.

Conclusions
Collectively, this study reveals the molecular mechanism of the Arabidopsis MACPF domain-containing protein MACP2 in the plant immune response. The natural PCD, bacterial pathogen resistance and necrotrophic fungal pathogen sensitivity observed in MACP2-OEs is possibly mediated by the activation of IGSs and endogenous SA biosynthesis through the EDS1 signaling pathway. These findings provide a genetic framework and knowledge base to study the biochemical function of plant MACPF proteins in future works.