Development of Heterocycle-Substituted and Fused Azulenes in the Last Decade (2010–2020)

Azulene derivatives with heterocyclic moieties in the molecule have been synthesized for applications in materials science by taking advantage of their unique properties. These derivatives have been prepared by various methods, involving electrophilic substitution, condensation, cyclization, and transition metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions. Herein, we present the development of the synthetic methods, reactivities, and physical properties for the heterocycle-substituted and heterocycle-fused azulenes reported in the last decade.


Introduction
Azulene (1) is one of the 10π-electron non-benzenoid aromatic hydrocarbons having a fused structure of 5-and 7-membered rings. Azulene (1) is one of the structural isomers of naphthalene, however, the color of these isomers differ greatly from each other. Despite the fact that naphthalene is a colorless compound, azulene (1) shows a beautiful blue color. The name "azulene" derives from the Arabic word "azur" and the Spanish word "azul" which both mean "blue". Azulene (1) has the contribution of the cyclopentadienide and tropylium substructures as shown in Scheme 1. Hence, despite being a hydrocarbon, azulene (1) shows a relatively large dipole moment (1.08 debye). Furthermore, electrophilic substitution reaction of azulene (1) proceeds at 1-, 3-, 5-, and 7-positions, while nucleophilic addition reaction takes place at 4-, 6-, and 8-positions. Some azulene derivatives have pharmacological activity, and azulene sulfonic acid derivatives are especially used as anti-inflammatory drugs [1][2][3]. In recent years, azulene derivatives have also been reported to exhibit anti-tumor activity [4][5][6][7]. Due to their unique optical and electrochemical properties, heterocycle-substituted and heterocycle-fused azulene derivatives are expected to be applied to organic materials such as organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), organic field effect transistors (OFETs), solar cells, and biosensors.
Lewis and co-workers demonstrated the preparation of 1-heteroarylazulenes by the cross-coupling reaction of aryl boronic acids with 1-azulenylsulfonium salt 37, instead of the 1-haloazulenes [29]. In this procedure, the reaction of the 1-azulenylsulfonium salt 37 with the boronic acids or acid esters of the heterocycles in the presence of a palladium/XPhos catalyst affords the corresponding 1-heteroarylazulenes 38 and 39 (Scheme 13). This method is also applicable to the synthesis of 1-(2-thienyl)azulenes. Details of the synthesis of these derivatives are described later. In 2016, Nica et al. reported the multistep synthesis of 2,2 :6 ,2 -terpyridine-substituted azulene derivatives under the Kröhnke-type reaction conditions (Scheme 14) [30]. Condensation of 40 with 2-acetylpyridine under grinding conditions leads to the corresponding azulene-substituted chalcone 41 in 72% yield. Compound 41 is subjected to further reaction with 2-acetylpyridine under the same conditions, then the microwave (MW) irradiation in the presence of ammonium acetate to form 4-(1-azulenyl)terpyridine 42 in 42% yield.

Azulene Derivatives with O-Containing 6-Membered Heterocycles
Several examples of azulene derivatives, which are substituted or fused by oxygen-containing (O-containing) 6-membered heterocycles, have been reported. The synthesis of these derivatives is mainly established by the intermolecular or intramolecular cyclization reactions.
In  . This reaction also allows synthesis of the corresponding furan or hydropyridine derivatives by using an aldehyde or aniline derivatives instead of 4-hydroxycoumarin.

Scheme 17.
Synthesis of tricyclic compound 52 connected with 3-aminoguaiazulene by the multicomponent reaction.
The AlCl 3 -mediated cyclization reaction of 2-hydroxyazulenes 53a and 53b with activated methylene compounds gives pyrone-fused azulene derivatives (azulenopyranones 54a-54c) in low to moderate yields (Scheme 18) [34]. The reaction of 54a with N-bromosuccinimide (NBS) results in conversion into the bromides 55 and 56. When one equivalent of NBS is used, 55 is obtained in 42% yield along with 56 in 31% yield. While, the dibromo derivative 56 is selectively generated in excellent yield (91%), when two equivalents of NBS is employed. Compounds 55 and 56 can be further functionalized by the palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction. Intramolecular cyclization of alkyne 57 in the presence of trifluoroacetic acid produces isocoumarin derivative 59a in excellent yield (Scheme 19) [35], whereas iodocyclization of alkyne 57 with N-iodosuccinimide (NIS) gives the corresponding 4-iodoisocoumarin 59b in moderate yield. Similarly, alkyne 58 having two azulenyl moieties is treated with trifluoroacetic acid in a mixed solvent of THF and water to give pyrone-fused azulene 60 in 90% yield [36].  Thiophene, TTF, and the other sulfur-containing heterocycles are expected to be applied in the field of organic electronic materials such as organic semiconductors. For this reason, many efforts have been focused on the incorporation of such heterocycles into azulene derivatives by cross-coupling, cycloaddition, and condensation reactions.
Preparation of bis(6-azulenylethynyl)thiophene 62, terthiophene 63, and dithienothiophene 64 is examined by the palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction of 6-ethynylazulene 61 with diiodothiophene and the corresponding diiodides under Sonogashira-Hagihara conditions (Scheme 20) [37]. The absorption band of these compounds in their UV/Vis spectra spreads into the near-infrared region due to the decrement of HOMO-LUMO energy gap basis on the expansion of the π-conjugated system.
Synthesis and reactivity of azulenopentathiepin 65 were reported by Sato and his co-workers. Azulenopentathiepin 65 is prepared by the reaction of azulene (1) with elemental sulfur in pyridine under reflux conditions. The azulene derivatives, such as 66a and 66b, are prepared by the reaction of electrophiles such as iodomethane, methyl chloroformate, N,N -carbonyldiimidazole and N,N -thiocarbonyldiimidazole, with the bis(thiolate) obtained by the treatment of 65 with LiAlH 4 (Scheme 21) [38]. PPh 3 -mediated desulfuration of pentathiepin 65, followed by the reaction with DMAD produces azuleno-1,4-dithiin 68 in 56% yield. The reaction of 65 with Pd(PPh 3 ) 4 gives the extremely unstable palladium complex 69 (6%), which is immediately converted to a binuclear complex. Starting from the dithiocarbonate derivative 66a, which was obtained by the reaction described above, the synthesis of azulene-fused TTFs 70a and 70b was achieved by the same group (Scheme 22) [39]. The condensation reaction of dithiocarbonate 66a with vinylene trithiocarbonate or ethylenedithio derivative in triethyl phosphite generates azulene-fused TTFs 70a and 70b in moderate yields (22% and 49%, respectively). The redox behavior of the azulene-fused TTFs was also investigated by cyclic voltammetry (CV).
Synthesis of the donor-acceptor-type extended TTFs 73 incorporated into cross-conjugated systems is achieved by the sequential [2 + 2] cycloaddition-retroelectrocyclization reaction of electron-rich butadiyne with tetracyanoethylene followed by TTF (Scheme 23) [40]. Butadiyne 71 gives tetracyanobutadiene 72 by the reaction with tetracyanoethylene, which is then converted to 73 by the cycloaddition with TTF. The UV/Vis spectrum of 73 shows a strong and broad absorption band in the visible region (λ max = 471) owing to the overlapping of the charge-transfer (CT) absorption bands arising from both azulene and 1,2-bis(1,3-dithiol-2-ylidene)ethane donors to the tetracyanobutadiene acceptor unit. In the electrochemical analysis of 73, a reversible one-stage two-electron oxidation wave and a two-stage reduction wave are observed in CV.
Cross-coupling by the palladium-catalyzed C-H bond activation applies to the preparation of azulene-substituted TTFs (Scheme 24). 2-Chloroazulene derivative 74 reacts with TTF in the presence of Pd(OAc) 2 and P(t-Bu) 3 ·HBF 4 as a ligand to generate tetra(2-azulenyl)TTF 75 (57%), along with tri(2-azulenyl)TTF 76 (9%) [41]. Although parent TTF exhibits a two-stage reversible oxidation wave, the CV experiments on 75 display one quasi-reversible wave under the electrochemical oxidation conditions owing to the overlapping of the first wave with the following irreversible waves. The spectroelectrochemical measurements of 75 exhibit significant spectral changes under the electrochemical reduction conditions.
Thiophene-fused azulenes sometimes exhibit a different reactivity from that of usual azulene derivatives.
Thiophene-fused 1,1 -biazulene derivative 78 is obtained by the reaction of azuleno [1,2-b]thiophene (77) with NIS, instead of the presumed iodoazulene derivative (Scheme 25) [42]. NIS is commonly known as an iodination reagent, but it may act as an oxidant in this case. Although the longest absorption band of 78 displayed larger absorption coefficients than that of 77, the absorption maxima are observed at almost the same wavelength region. The similarity of the absorption maxima of 77 and 78 suggests less effective conjugation due to the low planarity of the two azulene rings of 78. Compound 77 undergoes a sequential cycloaddition-reverse electron cyclization with DMAD under high temperature reaction conditions (200 • C) to give thiophene-fused heptalene 79 in 60% yield [43]. The presence of bond alternation and the nonaromatic nature of 79 are revealed by single-crystal X-ray crystallographic analysis. Photochromism is a phenomenon that is attracting a lot of attention in the field of materials science. Construction of an azulene-based photochromic system was reported by Uchida and co-workers (Scheme 26) [44]. The synthesis of 81 is accomplished by Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction of 80 with a 3-thienylboronic acid ester. The light irradiation from excitation of 81 at λ ex = 313 nm generates new absorption bands at λ max = 495 nm and at around λ max = 700 nm owing to the formation of the ring-closed system 82.
The synthesis of photochromic 1-(2-thienyl)azulene-based diarylethene derivatives 92a and 92b has been achieved by Nica and co-workers utilizing Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction (Scheme 30) [48]. Compound 93 was also synthesized via deformylation by the treatment with pyrrole in acetic acid using 92b as a starting material. Photocyclization of compounds 92a, 92b, and 93 in CH 2 Cl 2 takes place by irradiating the light at λ ex = 405 nm with the color change of the solution from greenish-yellow to blue-purple due to form ring-closing derivatives 94a-94c. Scheme 30. Photoinduced ring-closure reaction of dithienylethenes 92a, 92b, and 93.
Hawker et al. reported the Stille cross-coupling reaction of 4,7-dibromoazulene 95 with 2-thienyltin reagents under the microwave irradiation conditions to give 4,7-di(2-thienyl)azulene derivatives 96a-96c (Scheme 31) [49,50]. In the UV/Vis spectrum of these 4,7-di(2-thienyl)azulene derivatives, a weak absorption band arising from the azulene skeleton is observed in CH 2 Cl 2 , while a strong absorption band is appeared at around λ max = 500 nm in CF 3 CO 2 H. Compound 96a shows a strong fluorescence at λ FL = 573 nm in CF 3 CO 2 H, which is not observed in CH 2 Cl 2 . Lewis et al. reported the preparation of azulene-containing dyes 99a and 99b and evaluated their performance as dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) [51]. The synthesis of these azulene dyes 99a and 99b was accomplished in four to five steps, including the cross-coupling reaction of 1-azulenylsulfonium salts 37 and 97 with the corresponding thiophene-2-boronic acid following Knoevenagel condensation (Scheme 32). These azulene dyes 99a and 99b are characterized as sensitizers in DSSCs concerning their electrochemical nature and crystal structure. A method for the preparation of azuleno[2,1-b]thiophene derivatives 101 with aryl substituent at the thiophene moiety was reported [52]. In this synthetic procedure, azuleno[2,1-b]thiophene derivatives 101 can be obtained in one step by the reaction of readily available azulenyl alkynes 100 with elemental sulfur (Scheme 33). The azuleno[2,1-b]thiophene 101 with a phenyl substituent is converted to 102 by decarboxylation with 100% H 3 PO 4 . Both the UV/Vis measurements and DFT calculations show that the optical properties of azuleno[2,1-b]thiophenes are significantly affected by the electronic nature of the aryl substituents on the thiophene moiety. The decarboxylated derivative 102 in CH 2 Cl 2 displays a similar absorption band in the visible region to that of the corresponding ester derivative, while the addition of CF 3 CO 2 H to the solution shows a pronounced color change, so-called halochromism, due to the protonation of the 5-membered ring of azuleno[2,1-b]thiophene to produce a tropylium ion substructure. Tsukada and co-workers have demonstrated the synthesis of (2-azulenyl)(1-aza-2-azulenyl)amines 108a-108c containing azulene and 1-azaazulene linkage via a nitrogen atom (Scheme 35) [54]. The Hartwig-Buchwald reaction of 2-aminoazulene 106 with 2-halo-1-azaazulenes 107a-107c was employed for the synthesis of 108a-108c. As a result of the investigation of several conditions, the catalytic system using PdCl 2 (dppf)/BINAP in THF provides the best results.
Vilsmeier-Haack-type reaction of azulene derivatives with 2-indolinone was conducted in the presence of Tf 2 O affords 1-(indol-2-yl)azulenes (Scheme 36) [55]. In this research, the substituent at the 6-position of the azulene ring was found to affect the reactivity, significantly. The reaction of 1 and 109 produces mono-substituted products 110a and 110c, whereas 20a gives 110b (64% yield) as the main product along with the di-substituted product 111 (13% yield).  In another method, the synthesis of 3-(guaiazulen-3-yl)pyrroles 118 has been achieved by the Paal-Knorr reaction of 3-acetyl-4-(guaiazulen-3-yl)hexane-2,5-dione (117), which is obtained by the reaction of 9, methylglyoxal, and acetylacetone in the presence of acetic acid via primary amines (Scheme 40) [59]. Both of these synthetic methods provide a facile method for the preparation of pyrrole-substituted azulene derivatives.

Azulene Derivatives with O-Containing 5-Membered Heterocycles
Although there are not many reports for the synthesis of azulene derivatives containing furans and their derivatives in the molecule, various approaches such as cross-coupling and intramolecular cyclization have been applied to the preparation of such compounds.
Wu, Ku, and their co-workers have reported the two-step synthesis of 2-(3-furyl)azulene derivatives 124a and 124b [61]. The diketone derivatives 123a and 123b are prepared by the reaction of 122a and 122b with 4 -methoxyphenacyl bromide in the presence of CaH 2 in DMF. Compounds 124a and 124b can be obtained by Paal-Knorr reaction, i.e., treatment with p-TSA in DMF, in 67% and 70% yields, respectively (Scheme 42).  [62]. This reaction provides 3-(2-furyl)guaiazulene derivatives 126 in excellent yields when the substituent R 2 on the benzoyl chloride is an electron-donating group, while the yield of the products is slightly lower when the substituent R 2 has an electron-withdrawing nature. 2-(1-Azulenyl)benzofurans 132a-132c are obtained in one pot under the Sonogashira-Hagihara reaction conditions by the reaction of 1-ethynylazulene derivatives 131a-131c, which are prepared from 1-iodoazulenes 130a-130c as starting materials, with 2-iodophenol (Scheme 45) [35]. By contrast, the reaction of 130a-130c with 2-ethynylphenol under the similar conditions affords 2,3-di(1-azulenyl)benzofurans 133a-133c along with 132a-132c as a byproduct. The structures of these compounds were clarified by single-crystal X-ray structure analysis. The reaction of 3-(1-azulenyl)propargyl alcohols 134 with tetracyanoethylene produces 2-aminofuran derivatives 135 cross-conjugated by azulene-ring in excellent yields (Scheme 46) [64]. The formation of the 2-amino furan ring is believed to derive from the [2 + 2] cycloaddition-retroelectrocyclization of alkynes with tetracyanoethylene and subsequent nucleophilic addition of the hydroxy group to one of the cyano groups. The 2-aminofuran 135 can be converted into 6-aminopentafulvenes 136 and 6,6-diaminopentafulvenes 137 in moderate to excellent yields by treatment with an excess of primary and secondary amines. Diels-Alder reaction of 135 with maleimides affords phthalimide derivatives 139 cross-conjugated with an azulene ring in one pot and without the isolation of presumed [4 + 2] cycloadducts 138 [65]. Even though 139 does not exhibit luminescence in CH 2 Cl 2 , remarkable fluorescence is observed in a mixed solvent of CH 2 Cl 2 and CF 3 CO 2 H.

Azulene Derivatives with Other Ring Heterocycles
In addition to the aforementioned, preparation of various azulene derivatives with a variety of heterocycles have been reported. An overview of the derivatives with other 5-membered ring heterocycles is given below.
Matano et al. reported the synthesis and optical properties of phosphole derivative 141 substituted with two 2-azulenyl groups (Scheme 47) [66]. The synthesis is performed under Stille cross-coupling conditions by the reaction of 2,5-bis(tributylstannyl)phosphole 140 and 2-iodoazulene (25) using Pd 2 (dba) 3 , (2-furyl) 3 P, and CuI as catalysts, giving the target compound 141 in 52% yield. Compound 141 in CH 2 Cl 2 shows an absorption wavelength maximum at λ max = 481 nm in UV/Vis spectrum, while no emission is displayed from 141 in the same way as the usual azulene derivatives. Although preparation of 2,6-diaminoazulenes has been known to be difficult, an efficient method for their synthesis by aromatic nucleophilic substitution reactions (S N Ar) was reported in 2015 (Scheme 48) [67]. The S N Ar reaction of 2-amino-6-bromoazulene derivative 142 with cyclic amines such as pyrrolidine, piperidine, and morpholine at 130 • C in a sealed tube affords the corresponding 2,6-diaminoazulene derivatives 145a-145c in excellent yields. Alternatively, the amination reaction at lower temperature is achieved by the treatment of trifluoroacetamide derivative 143, which is obtained by the reaction of 142 with trifluoroacetic anhydride, with amines at room temperature to give the corresponding 2,6-diaminoazulenes 144a-144c. The trifluoroacetamide substituent of 145a-145c is transformed into an amino group by deprotection with K 2 CO 3 in EtOH to form 145a-145c.
Similar to the aforementioned reaction, the reaction of 6-bromoazulene 146 with two ester groups with amines yields the corresponding 6-aminoazulene derivatives 147 in good to excellent yields (Scheme 49) [68,69]. The electrophilic substitution reaction of a derivative with a pyrrolidine substituent at the 6-position with bromine provides 2-bromo-6-pyrrolidinylazulene derivative 148. Since the introduction of halogen functional group at the 2-position of azulene derivatives by electrophilic substitution reactions is usually difficult, this method is one of the preferable methods for the functionalization of azulenes. The two ester groups of the 6-aminoazulene derivatives 147 can be removed by decarboxylation reaction using 100% H 3 PO 4 to afford parent 6-aminoazulenes 149 in excellent yields. Wakamiya, Scott, and their colleagues reported the synthesis and properties of extended π-electron molecules in which the oxygen-bridged triarylamines are connected to an azulene ring, for application in perovskite solar cells [71]. The precursor, 1,3,5,7-tetraborylazulene 152, is obtained by iridium-catalyzed Hartwig-Miyaura borylation of azulene (1) with bis(pinacolato)diboron with 38% as isolated yield (Scheme 51) [72]. Synthesis of the target molecule, tetrasubstituted azulene 153, is achieved by multiple Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling of 152 with mono-brominated oxygen-bridged triarylamine in 58% yield. The performance of tetrasubstituted azulene 153 as a hole transport material for perovskite solar cells (power conversion efficiency = 16.5%) was found to be superior to the current HTM standard, spiro-OMeTAD. Since the elevated concentrations of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) in living organisms are associated with a variety of diseases including cancer and cardiovascular disease, much attention has been paid to the development of methods to detect these active species in living cells. Lewis et al. reported AzuFluor 483-Bpin 157 that exhibits fluorescence upon reaction with ROS and RNS (Scheme 53) [74]. The synthesis of AzuFluor 483-Bpin 157 is accomplished by the palladium-catalyzed borylation of the corresponding 2-amino-6-bromoazulene. The staining of various living cells with compound 157 shows remarkable luminescence due to the conversion to 158 by the reaction with ROS and RNS in the cells. Therefore, compound 157 is expected to apply to the direct detection of ROS and RNS in the living cells. The same group reported the synthesis of an azulene derivative (NAz-6-Bpin 159) as a potential fluoride detection agent in water and the evaluation of its ion selectivity (Scheme 53) [75]. The synthesis of NAz-6-Bpin 159 has been achieved by the Sandmeyer reaction of 157 using TMSCl and isoamyl nitrite. Since NAz-6-Bpin 159 can be used in a mixed solvent of water and ethanol without surfactants, this compound has potential applications for the detection of fluoride in drinking water in the field.

Synthesis of Azulene-Fused Imide Derivatives
Phthalimide and other aromatic imide derivatives have attracted much interest in the fields of materials chemistry and pharmaceutical sciences so that various synthetic methods have been reported.
The same group found that conjugated polymers 166 and 167 embedded with 2,2 -biazulene diimide units act as high-performance OFETs (Scheme 55) [77]. The thermal stability of polymers 166 and 167 is examined by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and these polymers did not decompose until the temperature was raised above 400 • C. Conjugated polymers 166 and 167 represent excellent OFET performance with high-electron mobility, and especially polymer 167 was found to be one of the best unipolar n-type polymers reported to date. A novel tetraazulene-fused tetracenediimide (TA-fused TDI 170) was prepared and evaluated using various experimental measurements and theoretical calculations by Tani and co-workers (Scheme 56) [78]. The synthesis of 170 is accomplished by the Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling reaction of 43 with tetrabromonaphthalene diimide to give 169, following the Scholl reaction of 169 with DDQ at low temperature (−60 • C). Fusing azulene rings to the TDI core, 170 shows a small HOMO-LUMO gap and intramolecular CT interaction based on an effective π-electron conjugation. TA-fused TDI 170 also shows unique properties such as absorption in the near-infrared region which appeared in the absorption spectrum, a four-step reversible reduction process observed in the CV experiments, and n-type semiconductivity. These outcomes suggest that TA-fused TDI 170 has potential application in photonics as an electronic material. Recently, the synthesis of phthalimide-fused azulene derivatives 172 was accomplished by condensation of 1,2-diformylazulene derivatives with maleimides in the presence of phosphine catalysts (Scheme 57) [79]. Various phosphine catalysts and the reaction solvents were investigated to find that phthalimide-fused azulene derivatives 172 were obtained in the highest yields when triphenylphosphine was used as a catalyst in DMF as the solvent. The ester group of 172 can be removed by decarboxylation with 100% H 3 PO 4 , yielding 173 in quantitative yield. The addition of trifluoroacetic acid to the solution of 173 indicates a marked color change, so-called halochromism. Furthermore, blue-colored luminescence is observed when the acidic solution of 173 is irradiated at λ ex = 365 nm, even though no emission is observed in common organic solvents. This luminescence could be ascribed to that from the phthalimide moiety because protonation by trifluoroacetic acid produces a tropylium ion [173 + H] + , which reduces the contribution of the azulene form that may quench the emission. Scheme 57. Synthesis and protonation of phthalimide-fused azulene derivative 173.
Back-to-front [3 + 1] synthesis afforded various azuliporphyrin derivatives by taking advantage of stable azulitripyrrane. This method was adopted for the preparation of mono-, di-, and tribenzoazuliporphyrins [90]. Bicyclo[2.2.2]octadiene-fused azuliporphyrin 176 was prepared by condensation of azulitripyrrane 174 with 2,5-diformylpyrrole 175, followed by oxidation with FeCl 3 before tribenzoazuliporphyrin 177 was quantitatively obtained via retro Diels-Alder reaction (Scheme 59). Lash and co-workers reported azulichlorins via [2 + 2] condensation. Azulidipyrrane 178 and dihydrodipyrrin 179 were treated with TFA to remove the tert-butyl ester groups. After dilution with acetic acid and addition of HI, the reaction mixture was stirred at room temperature overnight. The protonated azulichlorin 180 was obtained, resulting from the cross-condensation in 17% yield (Scheme 60) [91]. In this reaction, the self-condensation products were not obtained. The NMR spectrum of 180 shows the internal CH at −2.11 ppm and meso-CHs at 7.5-9.3 ppm, which indicates that the cation 180 has a similar diamagnetic ring current to protonated azuliporphyrins due to the contribution of resonance structure of the 18π-electron system as shown in Scheme 60.
There are few ring-expanded/contracted azuliporphyrinoids while a variety of azuliporphyrins were reported (Figure 2). Lash and co-workers reported a [4 + 1] route to azulisapphyrin with a 22π-system [92]. Diazulihexaphyrin(3.3.1.3.3.1) was reported under [2 + 1] condensation between a dipyrromethane and an azulene bisacrylaldehyde, which did not show macrocyclic aromaticity [93]. Latos-Grażyński and co-workers reported dithiaethyneazuliporphyrin with a nonaromatic triphyrin(4.1.1) framework [94]. Ghosh and co-workers reported azulicorrole as the first carbacorrole except for N-confused corroles in 2019 [95,96]. Azulicorrole 184 was isolated via acid-catalyzed condensation of azulene, pyrrole and p-trifluoromethylbenzaldehyde with a molar ratio of 1.5:4.5:2.5, followed by oxidation with DDQ (Scheme 61). Although the yield was poor, free base 184 was readily converted into the Cu(III) and Au(III) complexes. The NMR spectrum of 184 shows signals of the internal CH at 3.19 ppm and NHs at 3.47 ppm, indicating that 184 has a lower diatropic ring current compared to triarylcorroles. Okujima et al. [97] and Lash et al. [98] subsequently reported azulitriphyrin with triphyrin(2.1.1) framework. Intramolecular McMurry coupling of diformyltripyrrane is a key step for the construction of the triphyrin(2.1.1) framework (Scheme 62) [99]. Tetrahydroazulitriphyrin was obtained via McMurry coupling of 185. Oxidation with DDQ and treatment with TFA afforded protonated azulitriphyrin 188 as a trifluoroacetate. The NMR spectrum of 182 shows signals of the internal CH at 2.53 ppm and NHs at 10.86 ppm, which are upfield-shifted compared to those of 187 due to global diatropic ring current. The NICS calculations also supported that azulitriphyrin 188 is a 14π-electron aromatic system.

Conclusions
In this review, we summarize the preparation, reactivity, and physical properties of heterocycle-substituted and heterocycle-fused azulene derivatives that have been reported in the last decade. There are a wide variety of methods for their synthetic approach and the physical properties of the azulene derivatives are highly dependent on the type of heterocycles and their substitution and fused positions.
1-Heteroaryl-and 1,3-bis(heteroaryl)azulene derivatives have been prepared by various methods, including electrophilic substitution, cyclization, radical coupling, and transition metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions, whereas the introduction of a heterocycle to the 2-and 6-positions of azulene ring is mostly achieved by cross-coupling reactions using the corresponding haloazulenes as a starting material because of the low reactivity of electrophiles to these sites. There is only one example of electrophilic substitution reaction by heterocyclic compound at the 2-position of the azulene ring, but in this case, a strong electron-donating group such as a dimethylamino group at the 6-position and protection at the 1,3-positions of the azulene ring are both essential. Recently, the reaction of 2H-cyclohepta[b]furan-2-one derivatives 192 with heterocycle-substituted silyl enol ethers have been reported as a new synthetic method for 2-heteroarylazulenes without using cross-coupling reactions (Scheme 64) [102]. This method is applied to the synthesis of azulenes with various heterocycles such as 2-(pyridyl-, thienyl-, furyl-, and pyrrolyl)azulenes 193, although the reaction requires high temperature (190 • C). Furthermore, the ester group of 194 can be removed by decarboxylation with 100% H 3 PO 4 . The synthesis of azulene derivatives with heterocyclic substitutions at the 4-, 5-, and 6-positions can be accomplished by a variety of methods, such as Zieglar-Hafner method, aromatic nucleophilic substitution, and cross-coupling reactions.
The synthetic methods described in this review are extremely beneficial for the preparation of novel heterocycle-substituted and heterocycle-fused azulene derivatives that have growth potential as organic electronics and pharmaceuticals.