- freely available
Appl. Sci. 2012, 2(4), 801-815; doi:10.3390/app2040801
Published: 28 November 2012
Abstract: An automatic power management system, to monitor the distribution of power to a set of load banks, is presented in this paper. The required power is generated from a laboratory-size pitch-controlled wind turbine experimental workstation. The management system is a sequence of logic expressions, based on the generated power, a profile of the banks’ states provided by the supervisor and the banks’ priorities, to obtain an optimal behavior of the system and to ensure the load requirement. A modified PI pitch angle control is proposed to regulate the generated power for tracking the power reference in order to maintain a consistent brilliance of the load’s LEDs, to reduce the activity of the pitch actuator and to deal with fluctuation problems. Experimental results are provided to show the effectiveness of the proposed automatic power management system for load banks supplied by a pitch controlled wind turbine.
In recent decades, wind energy has become the predominant viable source of renewable energy. Scientists and engineers have gained vast experience in handling small to large capacity generation system. Wind power generation is also estimated to produce 12% of the world’s electricity requirement by 2020 . Since wind is varying in nature, a wind turbine generation unit does not take into consideration the changing load power demands [2,3]. Therefore, it is very important to develop a power management system for handling power generation, to effectively match the varying load demand and increase the life of turbines. Most of the modern wind farm management systems ensure maximum yields and increased service life of wind farms. A power management system for wind power generation communicates with sophisticated control systems to respond to changing load demands. Passive stall control, variable pitch control and active stall control are the major control systems employed in regulating the power captured by the turbine rotor. But, with increasing machine size and power production capacity, the modern trend is towards using pitch control and active stall control for power regulation. [4,5,6,7]. Also, variable pitch control methods can achieve better power regulation and lower dynamic loads on wind turbines [8,9]. In a pitch regulated wind turbine, the power captured by the rotor is regulated for achieving two targets: (1) Maximize energy captured by pitching the blades at optimum angle towards the wind for above rated wind speeds; and (2) Avoid excessive power generation by pitching to feather, i.e., optimally positioning blades away from wind direction to ensure mechanical limitations are not exceeded for wind speeds above the cut-in speed of turbines.
A power management system can control the power generation at optimum levels to meet the load power demand . It can provide adequate energy based on the load demand and the availability of energy from the wind turbine. In the case of high energy production, the load demand can be completely or partially satisfied based on the supervisor request, who has the priority in making the decision by the power management system. In order to handle the situation during low energy production, load power demand management schemes have been employed by many distribution utilities , were the HVAC (heating, ventilation and air- conditioning) loads can be switched off during peak conditions or during emergency situations with limited controllability.
The power management system changes the amount of the requested and provided power during its operation. Therefore, this power must be regulated to track a power profile requested by the supervisor. The pitch angle controller can adjust the pitch setting at its optimum value to achieve power tracking [12,13,14]. A control strategy has been investigated in  to maintain balance between produced energy and load demand, and a multivariable control strategy used in  regulates the pitch angle and electrical load to control the wind turbine speed. However, the regulation of power through the pitch angle can cause high activity of the pitch actuator due to small fluctuations in the power during steady state operation, which can affect the flow of power to the load.
In this paper, a Boolean-based power management system is developed for supplying a set of load banks from wind energy sources. It is designed for an automatic switching of the banks depending on the request of a supervisor, the availability of power from wind, and the banks’ priorities. The supervisor can manually turn the banks’ ON-OFF switches, and a power reference signal is generated based on the switches being at state ON, which is used as a reference to control the wind turbine power output. A pitch angle control strategy is used to regulate the power through the pitch actuator, the only control system available in the wind turbine, as there is no power electronic interface between the generator and the load to allow controlling the wind turbine outputs.
A modified PI pitch angle control is proposed to reduce fluctuation in the power, reduce activity of the pitch actuator and maintain a consistent brilliance of the banks’ LEDs. In case of excess wind power compared to the power reference, as requested by the supervisor, the pitch actuator of the wind turbine will change the pitch angle of the blades to reduce the generated power to the reference one. For the other case, where the wind turbine cannot produce enough power to meet the demand of the supervisor, less priority loads will be automatically turned OFF by the automatic power management system. The Boolean-based method presented in this work can be applied for a small-scale network with a limited number of isolated loads and can be used in remote areas where less demand of energy is required.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows: the experimental setup (wind turbine and electronic load) is described in Section 2; the proposed power management system for automatic switching of the banks is detailed in Section 3; the modified pitch angle controller, to deal with power fluctuation, is analyzed in Section 4; And, the experimental results are presented in Section 5.
2. Description of the Wind Turbine System
2.1. Experimental Setup
The wind turbine experimental setup consists of five-blade turbines connected to a DC generator through a gearbox with a ratio of 1:1 to change the horizontal rotation of the shaft to a vertical one as the generator is mounted vertically. The wind turbine is installed in a tunnel, and the generator is directly connected to an electronic load (circuit board with LEDs). A servo motor, used for controlling the blade pitch angle, emulates the behavior of a variable-speed hydraulic servo system [17,18] for pitch control in a real wind turbine. A variable speed blower, based on a DC motor, is installed inside the tunnel and used to emulate experimentally different wind speed profiles by controlling the speed of the motor. This system can be used in several control applications for speed, voltage and power through the pitch angle actuator, and the main purpose of this work is to develop Boolean-based software algorithm for power management applications.
The power captured from the wind by the rotor of the turbine is given by the nonlinear expression
The power produced by the generator is carried out from the measured voltage and current, and given by the following expression
The wind turbine experiment system, with major components, is presented in Figure 1.
2.2. Electronic Load Banks
The electronic load consists of 6 parallel equal banks of 20 LEDs in each bank in series with a resistance as shown in Figure 2.
3. Automatic Power Management System
3.1. Logic Development of Automatic Switching
The aim of the automatic switching system is to manage the distribution of power to the banks based on the available power from wind and the power demand by the banks. A supervisor is changing the power demand by manually turning the banks’ switches ON/OFF, and the automatic switching system will make the decision of turning the banks’ switches ON/OFF based on the generated power and some conditions related to power demand.
The design of the logic for the priorities of the banks’ automatic switching is based on the following conditions:
(1) The number of banks turned ON will be determined by the power generated from the wind turbine.
(2) A bank is considered to be ON if it is illuminated without flickering and with minor power fluctuation.
(3) Based on the amount of generated power, the banks are ranked by priority from the left to the right in the load (Bank 1, Bank 2, … and Bank 6). However, the priorities can be assigned to different banks by switching wires into the multiplexer.
(4) A supervisor can manually turn ON/OFF any bank (i.e., if Bank 3 is manually turned OFF, less power should be required to turn Bank 4 ON than if Bank 3 is also ON). In this case, the priority of automatic switching will be based on the captured power from wind and the required power, which will be regulated to follow a power reference by changing the pitch angle of the blades through the pitch actuator and a pitch angle controller.
The signal of the power reference is built based on the state of the manual switches given by the supervisor. The Boolean expressions of the priorities of the banks’ automatic switching are given as follows:
Prn (n = 1:6) is the priority of bank n, which automatically turns it ON/OFF. A, B, C, D, E and F: conditions of the manual switches for the banks (1, …, 6) respectively. –: symbol of the logic NOT. Q, R, S, T, U and V: conditions of the generated power (Pgen) given in the following table.
|Table 1. Conditions of the generated power.|
|Conditions||Generated power (Pgen)|
Table of generated power conditions has been built based on experimentation and observation. Depending on the manual switching of the banks, it is observed that for each bank a power of 0.1 W is required to illuminate the bank’s LEDs and remain bright enough to be considered ON.
3.2. Power Error-Tolerance
The measured power fluctuates around the power reference because of various factors such as random variation of wind speed, noise measurement in sensors and the continuous activity of the pitch actuator. The logic of the automatic switching system is based on constant step changes of the power reference following the supervisor’s request. Therefore, without any power error tolerance around the power reference, the banks will switch ON and OFF each time there is an error between the measured power and reference one as shown in Table 2.
|Table 2. Switch’s states based on the power error.|
It can be seen from Table 2 that the bank’s switch will automatically go OFF when the available power is smaller than the reference one, which is practically incorrect for a small error because there is sufficient power to illuminate the bank.
In order to overcome this problem, an error-dependent threshold for automatic bank switches can be added to the logic of the automatic switching system. The appropriate power threshold Ptr is the lower end of acceptable power for the number of manually switched ON banks. The added logic subtracts the programmed allowable error from the original threshold as
The acceptable power range Pa for the number of banks ON is given by
Therefore, if the generated power Pgen is changing in the range of Pa, the automatic switch(s) is (are) considered ON and the bank(s) is (are) illuminated.
4. Modified Pitch Angle Controller for Power Regulation
The profile of the power reference is generated based on the banks’ switches, manually turned ON by the supervisor, or the available power from wind. Therefore, the power must be regulated to track the power reference. In the experimental wind turbine, used in this work, adjustment of the pitch angle of the blades is the only way to regulate the power required for each bank or a combination of banks, and is done by the pitch servo-motor as shown in Figure 1.
In a basic control strategy, the controlled power is compared with its reference and the error signal is sent to a PI controller to produce the optimum pitch angle
Using such a controller, the pitch angle is continuously changing, which can damage the pitch actuator, as it is in high activity. Moreover the pitch actuators have the limitation of influencing the power regulation performance of the wind turbine . In this work, a control strategy is proposed to maintain the pitch angle at a constant during steady state operation in order to reduce the activity of the pitch actuator.
The power management system is developed for step changes in the profile of the power reference based on banks’ switching states and the available power. Therefore, the operation of the system is based on the power error compared to the error-tolerance ε. If the power error is outside the error band ± ε, the operation is considered transient, and when it is inside ± ε, it is considered steady state. Following the behavior of the generated power, two cases of operation can be observed:
(1) A change between two steps, as shown in Figure 4, due to a change in the power demand from the supervisor or the available power from wind.
(2) A change in the power while the reference is constant, as shown in Figure 4, due to disturbance, fluctuation and the undesirable behavior of the system.
The modified pitch angle controller is based on the variation of the power error. If the power error is outside the error band ± ε, a PI controller is applied to have the turbine track the power reference provided by the supervisor. Meanwhile, the value of the optimum pitch angle is continuously saved in a memory, and when it is inside ± ε, the last value of the optimum pitch angle from the PI controller saved in memory, is held constant and used as a reference for the pitch actuator. The proposed pitch angle controller and its flow chart are shown in Figure 5 and Figure 6, respectively.
5. Experimental Results and Discussion
Experimentation is carried out to validate the performance of the proposed power management system and the pitch angle fluctuation controller. Algorithms and I/O data acquisition are implemented in Matlab/Simulink/QUARC. QUARC generates real-time code directly from the Simulink model and runs the generated code in real-time on the Windows target—all on the same PC. The Data Acquisition Board Q2 seamlessly interfaces with Simulink using Hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) blocks provided in the QUARC Targets Library .
The choice of the proportional gain KP and integral gain KI of the PI controller is determined by trial and error method, so that the controller is tuned to achieve good performance. The value of the error tolerance ε is 0.03 W. Theoretically, reducing the value of this parameter will improve the behavior of the controller. However, its choice depends on the performance of the PI controller in transient operation. The wind speed pattern is artificially and randomly generated by the blower motor.
Initially, one bank must be turned ON in order to connect the generator to the load. Also, the banks can be manually turned ON/OFF by the supervisor before running the system. Then, the automatic switching will change the states of the banks depending on the generated power from the wind turbine and the bank’s priority.
The power reference is generated based on the state of the bank’s switches, manually chosen by the supervisor and the available power from wind. The pitch angle controller adjusts the pitch angle in order for the generated power to track the reference one as shown in Figure 7. The banks are automatically switched ON/OFF, based on the Boolean expressions in (3) of the automatic switching system, as shown in Figure 8, where 1 ≡ ON and 0 ≡ OFF. The red dashed line represents the banks’ switching states following the power reference, and the black line represents the automatic switching based on the actual power. It can be observed that the wind turbine starts to provide power after 8 s, due to its inertia, and the bank 2, turned ON by the supervisor, will automatically turn OFF, as the generated power did not reach the power reference before 8 s. In this application, where only four banks are used, the performances of the automatic switching system and the power tracking are good. However, the pitch angle is continuously changing and fluctuating around a constant value due to the power error, as shown in Figure 7.
The result of the modified PI pitch angle controller for the same application is shown in Figure 9, where the pitch angle is held constant during the power step, which reduces the activity of the pitch actuator. Less fluctuation in the power is observed during steady state operation compared to the result of the standard PI controller, which provides a consistent brilliance of the lights. However, some side effects occur in the automatic switching (Figure 10), as banks 2, 3 and 4 turn OFF during a short time of about 1~2 s, but not seen by the eye, due to undesirable changes in the power out of the error band and wind speed variation.
In Figure 11, a new profile for the power reference, including the six banks, is provided to check the effectiveness of the proposed system for another scenario. It is observed that the power tracking is still good under the PI pitch angle controller. Due to the transition from one step to another, the power is insufficient to turn ON the following bank, which is noticeable in banks 4, 5 and 6 of Figure 12. In Figure 13, the power is smooth, compared to the result in Figure 11, due to the constant pitch angle of the modified PI controller. However, with the implementation of the modified PI controller, the occurrence of multiple switching ON/OFF in banks 2, 3, 4 and 5, and more noticeable in bank 6 between 200 and 220 s in Figure 14, is attributed to insufficient power generation due to the switching between the PI controller and the memory, and low wind speed. But still, the controller operates to find an optimum pitch angle leading to mild variations in pitch angle. It can be observed that the overall performance of the modified pitch angle controller is good, as the main purpose of this controller is to reduce the activity of the pitch actuator.
The proposed system aims to distribute the generated power from wind turbine to LED electronic load banks, and a Boolean-based power management system for automatic switching of load banks has been implemented in this work. The logic expressions have been developed based on the generated power from the wind turbine, the profile of the banks’ states provided by the supervisor and the sequence of priorities. The generated power has been controlled to track the power reference profile by a PI controller-based pitch angle control strategy. A modified PI controller-based pitch angle control has been developed and implemented to reduce the activity of the pitch actuator and maintain a consistent brilliance of the LEDs’ light. From the experimental results, the switching system changes the state of the banks’ switches based on the available power and the modified PI controller, and the based pitch angle control system reduces the activity of the pitch actuator by providing a smooth change in pitch angle.
This work was supported in part by the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research (FGSR) at Saint Mary’s University under FGSR Grant.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Wind Force; European Wind Energy Association: Brussels, Belgium, 2002.
- Keshav, S.; Rosenberg, C. Direct Adaptive Control of Electricity Demand; CS Technical Report CS-2010-17; University of Waterloo: Waterloo, ON, Canada, 2010.
- Liu, C.-X.; Zeng, Q.-A.; Liu, Y. A dynamic load control scheme for smart grid systems. Energy Procedia 2011, 12, 200–205.
- Garcia-Sanz, M.; Houpis, C.H. Wind Energy Systems: Control Engineering Design; Taylor & Francis: Boca Raton, Florida, USA, 2011.
- Wind Energy Siting Handbook; American Wind Energy Association: Washington, DC, USA, 2008.
- Burton, T.; Sharpe, D.; Jenkins, N.; Bossanyi, E. Wind Energy Handbook; Wiley: London, UK, 2001.
- Hau, E. Wind Turbines: Fundamentals, Technologies, Application, Economics, 2nd ed.; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 2006.
- Freris, L.L. Wind Energy Conversion Systems; Prentice Hall: London, UK, 1990.
- Ma, X. Adaptive extremum control and wind turbine control. Ph.D. Thesis, Technical University of Denmark, Lyngby, Denmark, May 1997.
- Minh, H.Q.; Frederic, N.; Najib, E.; Abdelaziz, H. Power Management of a Variable Speed Wind Turbine for Stand-Alone System Using Fuzzy Logic. In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems, Taipei, Taiwan, June 2011; pp. 1404–1410.
- Camacho, E.F.; Samad, T.; Garcia-Sanz, M.; Hiskens, I. Control for Renewable Energy and Smart Grids. 2011. Available online: http://ieeecss.org/sites/ieeecss.org/files/documents/IoCT-Part1-06RESG.pdf (accessed on 10 September 2012).
- Muljadi, E. Pitch-controlled variable-speed wind turbine generator. IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 2001, 37, 240–246, doi:10.1109/28.903156.
- Musyafa, A.; Harika, A.; Negara, I.M.Y.; Roband, I. Pitch angle control of variable low rated speed wind turbine using fuzzy logic controller. Int. J. Eng. Technol. 2010, 10, 21–24.
- El-Tous, Y. Pitch angle control of variable speed wind turbine. Am. J. Eng. Appl. Sci. 2008, 1, 118–120, doi:10.3844/ajeassp.2008.118.120.
- Achraf, A.; Krichen, L. New strategy of pitch angle control for energy management of a wind farm. Energy 2011, 36, 1470–1479, doi:10.1016/j.energy.2011.01.021.
- Rocha, R. A multivariable H∞ Control for Wind Energy Conversion System. In Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Control Applications, Istanbul, Turkey, 23-25 June 2003; pp. 206–211.
- Chiang, M-H. A novel pitch control system for a wind turbine driven by a variable-speed pump-controlled hydraulic servo system. Mechatronics 2011, 21, 753–761, doi:10.1016/j.mechatronics.2011.01.003.
- Chiang, M.-H.; Wang, C.-S.; Chen, C.-S. Intelligent pitch control for a 2 MW wind turbine. Int. J. Fuzzy Syst. 2012, 14, 89–96.
- Wind Turbine Experiment, Quick-Start Guide; Quanser Inc.: Markham, ON, Canada, 2010.
- Bianchi, F.D.; Mantz, R.J.; Christiansen, C.F. Power regulation in pitch-controlled variable speed WECS above rated wind speed. Renew. Energy 2004, 29, 1911–1922, doi:10.1016/j.renene.2004.02.009.
Wind turbine: Blade Radius = 14 cm, ρ = 1.14 kg/m3, Number of blades = 5, Pitch angle [−1° 15°], DC generator: R = 2.47 Ω, L = 500 μH, Kb = 7.05 mV/rpm, Ki = 0.015 A/mN, J = 110 g/cm2.
© 2012 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).