Antioxidant Activity of Hawaiian Marine Algae

Marine algae are known to contain a wide variety of bioactive compounds, many of which have commercial applications in pharmaceutical, medical, cosmetic, nutraceutical, food and agricultural industries. Natural antioxidants, found in many algae, are important bioactive compounds that play an important role against various diseases and ageing processes through protection of cells from oxidative damage. In this respect, relatively little is known about the bioactivity of Hawaiian algae that could be a potential natural source of such antioxidants. The total antioxidant activity of organic extracts of 37 algal samples, comprising of 30 species of Hawaiian algae from 27 different genera was determined. The activity was determined by employing the FRAP (Ferric Reducing Antioxidant Power) assays. Of the algae tested, the extract of Turbinaria ornata was found to be the most active. Bioassay-guided fractionation of this extract led to the isolation of a variety of different carotenoids as the active principles. The major bioactive antioxidant compound was identified as the carotenoid fucoxanthin. These results show, for the first time, that numerous Hawaiian algae exhibit significant antioxidant activity, a property that could lead to their application in one of many useful healthcare or related products as well as in chemoprevention of a variety of diseases including cancer.

antimicrobial activity. Beyond this finding, there is no published information on the antioxidant activity of Hawaiian algae. It is expected that additional Hawaiian algae contain very effective antioxidant systems, as they are exposed to prolonged intense ultraviolet (UV) radiation in their tropical environment. In fact, it has been observed that UV radiation stimulates antioxidant defense in algae [11].
In light of the potential commercial uses of algal antioxidant compounds in the medicine, food, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industries [11], we saw the need to ascertain whether Hawaiian algae could be a natural source of such compounds. Therefore, the present study was conducted to quantify the antioxidant activity of extracts from 37 samples of algae, comprising 30 species of Hawaiian algae from 27 different genera (Table 1) using the ferric reducing antioxidant power (FRAP) assay. Furthermore, we used bioassay-guided fractionation to isolate and identify the major antioxidant compound from the species of algae whose extract was found to have the highest activity.
A one-way ANOVA test revealed that the antioxidant activity varied significantly among algae (P << 0.001). The brown algae as a group had the highest mean antioxidant activity among Hawaiian algae with a mean FRAP value of 3.55 ± 3.16 µM/µg extract, followed by the green algae with a mean FRAP value of 2.29 ± 2.34 µM/µg extract. The red algae assessed had the lowest mean antioxidant activity with a FRAP value of 1.59 ± 1.17 µM/µg extract. A one-way analysis of variance comparing the antioxidant activity of the different algal groups revealed that the differences in antioxidant activity of the brown, green, and red algae were statistically significant (P < 0.01). However, post hoc comparisons indicated that the significance in the antioxidant activity of the different algal groups was due to the difference between the brown and red algae (P < 0.001). However, there was no statistical difference between the antioxidant activity of the brown and green algae (P = 0.067), nor between the green and red algae (P = 0.283).
Although differences in antioxidant activities were found among algae collected during different years, there was no significant correlation between samples' ages (i.e., the length of time between collection and analysis) and their antioxidant activities (R 2 = 0.059).
A comparison between the antioxidant activities of algae collected from different depths revealed that those from shallow waters (0-3 m) were more active than those from depths in excess of 70 m (one-way ANOVA, P < 0.001), with mean FRAP values of 2.26 ± 2.29 and 0.21 ± 0.13 µM/µg extract, respectively.
Both  Error bars ± SD. The different colors represent the different algal groups. In cases where there are more than one sample of the same species collected at a different date or location (see Table 1), the date and/or location code was added. Hilo for Richardson's Ocean Park; Ninole,for Punaluu Beach Park; Four-mile for Four-mile Beach Park; King's, for King's Landing. In an attempt to determine the component(s) responsible for the activity of the most active extract, Turbinaria ornata, collected from Waikoloa in 2011, was chosen for bioassay-guided fractionation. HPLC fractionation of the active extract ( Figure 2a) yielded a number of fractions with varying antioxidant activities (Figure 2b), fraction 18 being found to be the most active. This fraction was further purified (>98%) and analyzed by 1 H and 13 C NMR and ESI-MS ([M + Na] + of 682 m/z), which showed it to be a carotenoid with a molecular weight of 659 amu. The only known carotenoid with this molecular weight is fucoxanthin. Further examination of our spectroscopic data, molecular weight, structural elements determined from 1 H and 13 C NMR, and its UV-Vis spectrum (Figure 2c), as well as comparisons made with an authentic sample confirmed the compound to indeed be fucoxanthin ( Figure 2d).

Figure 2.
Bioassay-guided fractionation of Turbinaria ornata and the isolation of fucoxanthin as the active antioxidant: (a) Preperative HPLC chromatogram of T. ornata methanol extract; relative absorbance at 254 nm is presented. The peak that correlates to fraction 18 is indicated; (b) Total antioxidant activity of fractions collected from the preperative HPLC of T. ornata extract, presented as mean FRAP value in µM. Error bars ± SD; (c) The UV-visible absorbance spectrum corresponding to the HPLC peak of purified fraction 18. λ max at 264 and 449 nm are indicated; and, (d) Chemical structure of fucoxanthin, the major antioxidant component of T. ornata extract.

Phaeophyta
Turbinaria ornata samples collected in 2004 from Richardson's Ocean Park, near Hilo, and in 2011 from Waikoloa (both on the island of Hawaii), exhibited the highest antioxidant activity of all the Hawaiian algae tested in this study (Figure 1). Turbinaria conoides and T. ornata from India have also been shown to possess significant antioxidant activity [16,17]. Crude and purified sulfated polysaccharides from T. ornata and T. conoides, respectively, have been shown to be excellent antioxidants, and have been suggested as natural antioxidant agents for use in the food industry or in the management of oxidative stress [17,18]. In recent years, sulfated polysaccharides have been shown to possess a wide range of bioactive properties, including antiviral, anticancer, anti-inflammatory, anticoagulant, and antioxidant activity [18]. The sulfated polysaccharides responsible for T. conoides' antioxidant activity have been isolated and identified as fucoidan, laminaran, and alginate [18]. In the present study, the major antioxidant isolated and identified from the Hawaiian specimen of T. ornata was shown to be the carotenoid fucoxanthin ( Figure 2).
More than 750 different carotenoids have been identified from nature [19], where fucoxanthin is structurally unique due to the presence of the somewhat unusual allenic moiety (C=C=C) [19,20]. Nevertheless, fucoxanthin is one of the most abundant carotenoids known and with remarkable biological activities [20]. In a very recent review [20], the biological activities and metabolism of fucoxanthin were described in detail. This unique carotenoid was found to possess potent anti-inflammatory, anticancer, anti-obese, anti-diabetic, anti-angiogenic, anti-malarial, and antioxidant activities, as well as protective effects on the liver, blood vessels of the brain, bones, skin, and eyes, including chemoprevention of a variety of diseases including cancer [20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27]. Fucoxanthin was shown to have a much higher antioxidant activity than other antioxidants, including tocopherols, and this higher activity is assumed to be due to the presence of the allenic moiety [26]. Fucoxanthin has been isolated primarily from brown algae and diatoms [19,20]. From brown algae, fucoxanthin has been isolated from 14 different genera, including Alaria, Cladosiphon, Cystoseira, Eisenia, Fucus, Hijikia, Ishige, Kjellmaniella, Laminaria, Myagropsis, Padina, Petalonia, Sargassum, and Undaria [20]. Our present study is the first report on the isolation of fucoxanthin from Turbinaria ornata, and could prove as a new resource of this important carotenoid.
The Hawaiian brown macroalgae, Hydroclathrus clathratus, Sargassum echinocarpum, and Colpomenia sinuosa also exhibited relatively high antioxidant activity (Figure 1). Heo et al. [28] found that H. clathratus and C. sinuosa from Jeju Island, Korea possessed similar antioxidant activity. However, our results could not be directly compared with these data due to differences in units and assay methods. In another study, extracts of H. clathratus inhibited the growth of human and monkey cancer cells, suppressed tumors, and demonstrated antioxidant activity [29]. Algae of the genus Sargassum have been well-studied, and extracts of many species shown to have high antioxidant activity [11]. Kang el al. [30] have shown that polyphenols are the major antioxidants in several species of Korean brown algae. The current study presents the first screening of the antioxidant activity of S. echinocarpum, a species endemic to Hawaii with significant cultural importance. Although the compounds responsible for the observed antioxidant activity are still to be isolated, it is not unlikely that its extract could have pharmaceutical and medicinal applications, as already evidenced by extracts of non-Hawaiian species being reported to ameliorate oxidative stress and reverse endothelial dysfunction in diabetic rats [31].

Chlorophyta
Gayralia oxysperma and Chaetomorpha antennina demonstrated the highest level of antioxidant activity of the tested Hawaiian green algae tested (Figure 1). This is the first report of the antioxidant activity of G. oxysperma, an alga that is consumed in Japan and known as aonori. Gayralia nitidum (formerly Monostroma nitidum) from Jeju Island, Korea has been reported to show antioxidant activity [28]. The level of antioxidant activity of G. oxysperma reported here, combined with its known antiviral and anticoagulant activities [32,33], as well as its high caloric value [14], makes it a potential valuable natural resource for the pharmaceutical, medicine, food, and aquaculture industries worthy of further research.
The significant antioxidant activity of Chaetomorpha antennina reported in the current study is in agreement with that reported by Premalatha and colleagues [34]. Their screening of extracts of this species revealed the presence of antioxidant compounds such as phenolics, tannins, and glycosides. In light of its antioxidant activity it is another local species that is being considered for further investigation.
The large disparity in antioxidant activity between the different samples of Gayralia oxysperma and Chaetomorpha antennina may be attributed to their different collection sites and/or dates. The samples of G. oxysperma were collected from the same site during different years, while the C. antennina samples were collected from different sites during different years (Table 1, Figure 1). For both species, the more recent samples exhibited higher antioxidant activity than the older ones. The fact that the samples with the lowest antioxidant activity were five years older than the more active samples could indicate long term storage as an important variable to be considered when measuring antioxidant activity. The deduction is not too surprising as loss of antioxidant activity for some frozen vegetables over eight months of storage has been reported [35]. Clearly, further research is needed in this area to determine the effects of long-term storage on the bioactivity and antioxidant activity of frozen algal samples.
The sample of Chaetomorpha antennina with the higher antioxidant activity was collected from Richardson's Ocean Park on the eastern, windward coast of Hawaii Island near Hilo, while the less active sample was collected from Punaluu Beach Park on the southern shore near Ninole (Figure 1). The observed variation in antioxidant activity for these two samples could be due to slight differences in prevailing extrinsic factors, such as herbivory, light levels, depth, salinity, and nutrient levels [11]. Since these samples were also collected in different years, and different times of year, it is possible that the algae were in different growth or reproductive stages, variables known to affect compound levels in various algal species [11].

Rhodophyta
Of the red algae tested, Polysiphonia howei exhibited the highest antioxidant activity (Figure 1). Other studies on P. urceolata and P. morrowii have shown their extracts to have antioxidant activity [11,36]. In the current study, P. howei showed higher antioxidant activity than all tested species of Laurencia from the same order, Ceramiales. This observation is in accordance with previous studies, in which Laurencia spp., although a good source of biologically active secondary metabolites, do not exhibit high antioxidant activity [11]. Considering the broad spectrum of bioactivity of Polysiphonia extracts [10], it should be considered a promising source of not only natural antioxidants, but also a wide range of bioactive compounds.
Extracts of samples of Ahnfeltiopsis concinna and Pterocladiella capillacea, two of the most common intertidal red algae in the Hawaiian Islands, also showed relatively high antioxidant activity among the tested red algae (Figure 1). Neither species has been tested previously for antioxidant activity, even though extracts of A. flabelliformis have been found to exhibit antioxidant activity [37]. A. devoniensis extracts found to contain mycosporine-like amino-acids were also shown to have antioxidant activity [38]. The antioxidant activity of A. concinna is especially relevant in the Hawaiian Islands where it is known as limu 'aki'aki, and eaten raw with limpets or baked with other foods [39].
The differences in antioxidant activity for the samples of Ahnfeltiopsis concinna (A. concinna) are probably attributable to the samples' originating from different collection sites. The sample showing the highest antioxidant activity was collected from Richardson's Ocean Park, while the other two were collected from Four-mile Beach Park and Leleiwi Beach Park. Each sample was collected in 2009. While all three samples were collected from high intertidal regions, it is possible that the A. concinna from Richardson's Ocean Park was growing in a more stressful environment than those of the other samples, and consequently produced more antioxidant compounds in response to factors such as high light levels, large temperature fluctuations, and desiccation.
In a general sense, this study has demonstrated the potential of Hawaiian algae as sources of useful antioxidants and shown the need for further and more detailed studies in this area.

Macroalgae Collection
During 2003, 2004, and 2009-2011, marine algae were collected in approximate 0.5-1 kg wet weight quantities from various locations around the islands of Hawaii, Oahu, and on Penguin Bank, off Molokai (Table 1), and transported in cooled insulated containers to our laboratory at the University of Hawaii at Hilo. Species from the groupings traditionally known as Chlorophyta, Phaeophyta, and Rhodophyta were selected for collection based on their potential to contain bioactive compounds, as indicated by the results of past research of related species in the same genera, such as Laurencia, Sargassum, Codium, Chondrus, Porphyra, Portieria, Acanthophora, Ahnfeltiopsis, Caulerpa, Ulva, and Lobophora. Algal samples were identified to genus and species levels when possible based on their morphology and anatomy, and by using taxonomic references [12,13,39]. Voucher specimens were prepared as dried specimens or slides and deposited in the Bishop Museum Herbarium in Honolulu (BISH).

Sample Preparation
Within six hours of collection, fresh algae were thoroughly rinsed three times with filtered seawater. Samples were then divided into 50-200 g portions, spun in a salad spinner for 30 s, weighed, frozen and then freeze-dried. Dry samples were weighed and the weight recorded.

Extractions
Samples were extracted with methanol (2 × 150 mL), first for approximately two hours and then for a further 24 h with occasional mixing at room temperature (25 °C). Resultant extracts were filtered and solvent removed under reduced pressure to yield dry material. Extracts' weights were recorded. For the antioxidant activity assays a sample of each extract was prepared to give a final test concentration of 10 mg/mL in DMSO. All samples were stored at 4 °C until used.

Antioxidant Activity Assay
Antioxidant activity of algal extracts was determined using the ferric reducing antioxidant power (FRAP) assay, modified from the Benzie and Strain protocol [40,41]. The working FRAP reagent was made by mixing 300 mM acetate buffer (pH 3.6), 10 mM 2,4,6-tripyridyl-S-triazine (TPTZ) solution, and 20 mM FeCl 3 ·6H 2 O in a 10:1:1 ratio and heated to 37 °C prior to use. The 300 mM acetate buffer was prepared by mixing 3.1 g of sodium acetate trihydrate (NaOAc·3H 2 O) with 16 mL glacial acetic acid and made to 1 L with ddH 2 O. The TPTZ solution was prepared by mixing equal volumes of 10 mM TPTZ with 40 mM HCl.
For the actual assays, 150 µL of FRAP reagent was added to each well of a 96-well microtiter plate. A blank reading was taken at 595 nm using a Bio-Rad (Hercules, CA, USA) microtiter plate reader. To each well 20 µL of sample in triplicate was then added, incubated for 8 min at room temperature and read at 595 nm. Triplicate standards of known Fe II concentrations were run simultaneously using concentrations between 50 and 1000 µM of FeSO 4 ·7H 2 O. A standard curve was plotted and FRAP values, in µM, determined. Since results may vary between plates, a new standard curve was prepared for each plate.

Bioassay-Guided Fractionation, Isolation, and Identification of the Active Principle
Preliminary investigations indicated that the extract of Turbinaria ornata had the highest antioxidant activity among the algae investigated. In order to determine the active component of this species, 960 mg of extract was subjected to bioassay-guided fractionation, using the FRAP antioxidant activity assay as a guide throughout the purification process.
A Shimadzu (Columbia, MD, USA) Prominence HPLC system, consisting of a photodiode array (PDA) detector, fraction collector and LC Solution software, was used for all HPLC separations and analyses. For preparative HPLC, a Restek (Bellefonte, PA, USA) 250 × 21.2 mm, 5 μm Ultra II reverse-phase C-18 column was used, employing gradient elution from 20% MeOH:H 2 O to 100% MeOH in 30 min, and then 90 min of elution with 100% MeOH. Flow rate was set to 5 mL/min. For analytical HPLC, a Restek 150 × 4.6 mm, 5 μm Ultra II reverse-phase C-18 column was used, employing gradient elution from 5% MeOH:H 2 O to 100% MeOH in 20 min, and then 40 min of elution with 100% MeOH. Injection volume was 10 μL, flow rate of 1 mL/min, and a controlled column oven temperature of 25 °C.
For the identification of the active principles various analytical methods were used, and compared to spectral data reported in the literature. 1 H NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) and 13 C NMR spectra were recorded in CD 3 OD (Cambridge Isotopes Laboratories, Andover, MA, USA) with a Bruker (Billerica, MA, USA) Avance 400 MHz NMR spectrometer. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) was performed on a Varian (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) 500-MS IT mass spectrometer. High-resolution MS was measured with an Agilent Technologies 6530 Accurate-Mass Q-TOF LC/MS. UV/Vis spectral data were taken from the PDA information part of the HPLC recording system (see above).
A reference sample of fucoxanthin (95%, Product No. F6932) was purchased from the Sigma-Aldrich Corp. (St. Louis, MO, USA). The identity of this reference sample was verified by 1 H NMR and MS as an authentic sample of fucoxanthin employing our routine method for testing of sample purity and authenticity.

Statistics
All data are expressed as means ± SD. Data were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) tests, as well as post hoc tests. A significant difference was considered at the level of P < 0.05.

Conclusions
The results presented in this study represent the first significant assessment of the antioxidant activity of Hawaiian algae. Using the FRAP assay, it was determined that all 30 species of Hawaiian algae tested showed antioxidant activity, and of these the brown algae were statistically the most active. Certain individual species, especially Turbinaria ornata, Gayralia oxysperma, and Chaetomorpha antennina, were found to have significant antioxidant activity. T. ornata exhibited the highest overall antioxidant activity, with the carotenoid fucoxanthin being identified as the major component responsible for the majority of this activity. It is apparent from the findings of this study that further investigations are required to assess many of the issues raised in this investigation relating to time and location of collection, as well as, to do with long-term sample storage. Moreover, detailed studies need to be undertaken with individual species that consider the effects of herbivory, light levels, depth, salinity, nutrient levels, type, age, and reproductive stage on observed antioxidant activity. Thus, the antioxidant activity of Hawaiian algae could become the subject of a large intraspecific variation study. Additionally, future studies need to investigate the use of standardized methodologies to enable result comparisons with other studies. This will be a challenge as there are very few if any accepted norms for this type of research. Despite these challenges, the present study stands as the first extensive screening of antioxidant activity of Hawaiian algae, and sets the stage for further research, including the isolation of the antioxidant components present in the most active of the tested algae.