- freely available
Sensors 2009, 9(05), 3337-3356; doi:10.3390/s90503337
Published: 6 May 2009
Abstract: Current production and emerging NOx sensors based on optical and nanomaterials technologies are reviewed. In view of their potential applications in mechatronics, we compared the performance of: i) Quantum cascade lasers (QCL) based photoacoustic (PA) systems; ii) gold nanoparticles as catalytically active materials in field-effect transistor (FET) sensors, and iii) functionalized III-V semiconductor based devices. QCL-based PA sensors for NOx show a detection limit in the sub part-per-million range and are characterized by high selectivity and compact set-up. Electrochemically synthesized gold-nanoparticle FET sensors are able to monitor NOx in a concentration range from 50 to 200 parts per million and are suitable for miniaturization. Porphyrin-functionalized III-V semiconductor materials can be used for the fabrication of a reliable NOx sensor platform characterized by high conductivity, corrosion resistance, and strong surface state coupling.
Monitoring and controlling combustion-related emissions are key issues for applications in mechatronics. The exhaust gas from an internal combustion engine, besides water (H2O) and carbon dioxide (CO2), also contains unburned and partially-oxidized hydrocarbons (HCs), carbon monoxide (CO) and particulate matter (PM). During combustion, the temperature is so high that the endothermic equilibrium between nitrogen and oxygen to form nitrogen oxide (NO) is established, according to the following scheme:
Subsequent rapid cooling and ejection of combusted gases into the exhaust system freeze this equilibrium, so exhaust gases also contain significant levels of NO, NO2 and N2O (generally referred to as NOx).
Vehicle exhaust emissions are undesirable and can cause serious pollution products due to complex photo-initiated reactions between NO, HCs and O2, resulting in the production of ozone and other reactive oxygen species causing the photochemical smog that is plaguing many major cities. Controlling the HCs and NOx vehicles' emissions can have a direct impact on the effective reduction of the urban photochemical smog formation.
The US regulations signed in Dec. 2000, introduced very stringent NOx emission standards for all in-use vehicles. In Japan, diesel emission standards require that in-use on-road light commercial vehicles should meet NOx emission of 0.25 g/km starting from the end of 2005 and achieve full implementation by 2011 . The European Commission has also introduced a series of regulations, the so called EURO Emission directives: from Euro I in 1991, to tighter limitations in 2009 (Euro V 80 g/km) and 2014 (Euro VI 0.08 g/Km), to meet the air quality standards stated by the international agencies . Figure 1 illustrates the progression of the Euro and USA emission standard regulations in order to stepwise tighten the limit NOx values.
Extensive research and development efforts have focused on the fabrication of NOx sensors. While the world production of vehicles is presently suffering from the current economic crisis and will presumably reach saturation by 2010, the automotive exhaust gas sensors market is still predicted to grow and reach the level of over 100 million sensors per year in the next few years. High sensitivity, reliability to degradation in harsh environments, and fast response and recovery times are some of the desirable features of such devices. The objective of the present paper is to provide an up-to-date overview of current production and emerging state-of the-art NOx sensors based on optical and nanomaterials technologies. The objective of the present paper is to provide an up-to-date overview of current production and emerging state-of the-art NOx sensors based on optical and nanomaterial technologies.
1.1. State of art NOx sensors: achievements and open issues
The key step in controlling car exhaust emissions was the introduction of ‘autocatalysts’ roughly twenty-five years ago. Initially, a platinum-based (Pt) oxidation catalyst was used with an air pump which provided excess air in the exhaust gas to oxidize HCs and CO to less harmful CO2 and H2O . By the early 1980s, it had been discovered that CO and HCs could be oxidized and NOx reduced simultaneously over a single ‘three-way catalyst’ (TWC) containing Pt and Rh . The correct operating TWC conditions require: i) the total absence of lead in gasoline, which would poison the catalyst; ii) the gaseous mixture has to be set precisely at the stoichiometric value (air/fuel weight ratio equal to 14.6).
The latter requirement can be matched using an oxygen gauge, located in the exhaust gas. The signal delivered by this gauge, also called the lambda gauge, measures the stoichiometry of the emission mixture and determines whether the combustion products are oxygen rich or lean.
Lambda gauges for stoichiometric engines are based on ceramic type metal oxides, usually yttrium stabilized zirconia (YSZ). The YSZ is compacted into a dense ceramic and relies on the generation of mobile oxygen ions (O2-) at the elevated temperatures within the tailpipe, typically in excess of 400 °C. The device is fabricated using a pair of high temperature electrodes, such as noble metals (platinum, gold, or palladium) or other metal oxides, is placed onto the surface of the device and an electrical signal, such as the change in voltage or current, is measured as a function of NOx concentration. NOx is reduced at the cathode and the pumped oxygen ion current is a measure for the amount of NOx . The current designs of such NOx sensors are using two pumping cells and chambers. At the first pumping cell, free oxygen is eliminated from the gas by using an oxygen selective electrode. In the second adjacent chamber, NOx is dissociated at a highly catalytic second electrode. The very low amount of NOx (typically < 100 ppm) downstream of a catalyst competes with a high amount of free oxygen. This necessitates careful removal of oxygen from the first chamber without dissociation of NOx at the same time. With high sophisticated electrode materials and a controlled pumping voltage, it is possible to linearly measure 50 ppm NOx in air.
To decrease both fuel consumption and carbon dioxide production and thus contribute to reducing the greenhouse effect, new engines with an excess of air versus the stoichiometric ratio have been developed. As TWC does not operate efficiently when the emission mixture departs from stoichiometry, different solutions have been proposed by car manufacturers . They include either a continuous catalytic reduction of NOx or a chemical trap with periodic regeneration times. Application of a NOx sensor would control the catalyst's operation and monitor the combustion efficiency of the engine. The requirements for such sensors are similar to those of lambda oxygen sensors presently mounted in stoichiometric engines showed that they function reliably, withstand vibrations, are economical, operate at high temperatures, possess low detection limits and are able to operate in harsh environments, such as the corrosive environment within the engine, containing oxygen with water vapor in the range 3 – 8 %.
Current NOx sensor research and development is focused on either optical or electronic methods for detection. NOx optical sensor technology is among the fastest growing for mechatronic applications, as a result of its versatility, ease of use, high speed, accuracy, and capability for integration in high performance automated inspection systems. A wide range of optical sensors based on different operating principles does in fact already exist. Semiconductor laser based sensors are characterized by important properties such as high sensitivity, reliability, possibility of miniaturization, and fabrication that is compatible with mass production. Further development of optical sensors will begin a new era for online inspection of production processes providing the potential for increased productivity and quality. Some key factors still need to be improved in order to reach a wide market, e.g., beam quality, power, wall plug efficiency, wavelength range, tunability, and maximum operating temperature. Electronic metal oxide devices, on the other hand, offer the advantages of low cost, low cross sensitivity to humidity and an output signal which is easy to be read and process. Disadvantages, however, include limitations for operating at high temperatures, signal drift over time, limited selectivity or sensitivity as well as high power consumption. For these reasons, the use of novel materials such as innovative nanostructures, in place of metal-oxides, is being widely investigated in chemiresistors and transistor based device structures. Improvements have been seen for selectivity but operation at high temperature is still an open issue [7-9]. In the following, a brief review of both optical and electronic NOx sensors is reported.
2. Optical Sensors
Infrared laser absorption spectroscopy is a powerful tool for sensitive and selective trace gas detection for mechatronic applications. Up to now sensitivities in the range of the parts per million/trillion by volume (ppmv/pptv) have been demonstrated .
In the absence of optical saturation and particulate-related scattering, the intensity of light I(x) propagating in a homogeneous gas of sample length L is described by:where I0(λ) represents the initial optical intensity, I(λ) the intensity of the radiation after it passes a gas sample of length L where the species to be measured is present at the concentration c, σ(λ) is the absorption cross-section.
In the mid-infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum (2–14 μm) most molecular species exhibit a unique spectral signature, i.e. a characteristic series of fundamental absorption lines due to transitions between rotational-vibrational states, characterized by very large cross-sections. Hence, mid-infrared spectroscopy is in principle the best choice for the qualitative and quantitative measurements of molecular species in air. Very recently, the development of mid-ir detection techniques have received a significant boost from the invention and development of efficient mid-infrared semiconductor laser sources which promise to substitute optical methods based on the study of overtones and combination of lines falling in the near-infrared spectral region where the absorption cross sections drop by orders of magnitudes.
Among the absorption techniques, direct absorption spectroscopy  and cavity enhancement approaches  take advantage of long optical path length absorption in multi-pass cells and high finesse optical cavities, respectively. However, in spite of the high sensitivities, these techniques need sophisticated and cumbersome equipments not suitable in mechatronic applications which require compact and transportable sensors.
These limitations can be overcome by fully exploiting the advantages offered by photoacoustic (PA) spectroscopy, which is one of the most effective tools for exhaust gas detection, due to the high sensitivity (parts per billion, ppbv, detection limits), compact set-up, fast response time and portability. PA sensors are based on the generation of an acoustic wave in a specially designed gas cell that arises from the absorption of modulated light of appropriate wavelength by a selected target compound. The amplitude of this sound wave is directly proportional to the gas concentration and can be detected using a sensitive microphone if the laser beam is modulated in the audio frequency range.
In recent years, the development of new mid infrared laser sources has given a new impulse to infrared laser-based trace gas sensors. In particular, single mode quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) have become very attractive for mid-infrared gas sensing techniques thanks to single-frequency operation, narrow linewidth, high powers at mid-IR wavelengths (3 to 24 μm), room temperature and continuous wave (CW) operation . They overcome some of the major drawbacks of other traditional mid-IR laser sources, i.e. lack of continuous wavelength tunability and large size and weight of gas lasers (e.g. CO and CO2), large size and cooling requirement of lead salt diode lasers, complexity and low power of nonlinear optical sources.
Recently quantum cascade lasers, working in the 5 – 8 μm range, have been largely used for the spectroscopic detection of NOx with measured high sensitivities in the ppbv range. In the following section, we report on a quantum cascade laser-based photoacustic sensor for the detection of nitric oxide, showing a detection limit of 450 ppbv.
2.1. NO photoacoustic sensor
The PA sensor consists of a resonant photoacoustic cell, an amplitude modulated single mode QCL and a signal acquisition and processing equipment. Figure 2 shows a schematic diagram of the trace gas sensor.
The resonant PA cell is a cylindrical stainless steel resonator of 120 mm length and 4 mm radius with λ/4 buffer volumes on each side used as acoustic filters for background signal due to the heating of the two ZnSe windows which close the cell at its ends. The resonator is designed to operate in the first longitudinal mode at 1,380 Hz and is equipped with four electret microphones (Knowles EK 3,024, 20 mV/Pa, 0.5 μV/Hz-1), placed on the antinode of the acoustic mode to increase the sensitivity. The electrical signals of the microphones are preamplified and then measured by a digital lock-in amplifier (EG&G Instruments) with a 10 s integration time constant.
The light source is a distributed feedback quantum cascade (QC-DFB) laser, supplied by Alpes Laser (Switzerland) and operated in pulsed mode at a wavelength around 5.3 μm (pulse duration of 42 ns and a duty cycle of 1.4%). The laser is mounted in a Peltier cooled aluminum housing to hold the laser device at a constant temperature chosen between -35 °C and +65 °C. Its light is collected with an AR coated ZnSe lens (2.54 cm focal length, f/1) and collimated by a beam condenser to reduce its diameter in order to avoid the interaction of QCL radiation with the cell walls. The laser beam intensity was modulated by a mechanical chopper at the first longitudinal resonance frequency of the photoacoustic cell. The PA signal was measured by tuning the laser emission over the P(1.5) NO lines located at 1,871.051 – 1,871.066 cm-1 and with a maximum intensity of 0.8 × 10-20 cm/molecule.
Figure 3 shows the measured PA signal corrected for in-phase component of the signal, mainly due to the periodical heating of the PA cell windows and walls and measured by filling the PA cell with pure nitrogen. The blue line is a linear fit of the background-corrected data and shows a good linear relationship between the PA signal and the NO concentration. The detection limit C for NO diluted in N2 was calculated considering a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of 3 from the following equation:where σ is the standard deviation of the linear fit and a the slope of the calibration curve (calibration factor). A detection limit of 450 ppbv was found.
Sensor performance can be described also by the minimum detectable absorption coefficient, normalized to power and detection bandwidth:where αmin is the minimum detectable absorption coefficient at a SNR=3, P0 the average laser optical power and Δf the equivalent noise detection bandwidth. In this case, considering αmin = 3.8 × 10-7 cm-1, P0 = 2 mW and Δf = 0.017 Hz (τint = 10 s, 12-dB/octave digital filter) we obtained a detection sensitivity of D = 5.9 × 10×9 W·cm×1Hz×1/2. Table 1 summarizes the state of art PA sensor performances for NOx detection, in terms of detection limit and normalized detection limit. We report the detection limit normalized to the laser optical power (ppbv per Watt), considering that the QCLs optical power has been steadily improved in last few years and now there are commercial sources with optical power up to 80mW [13,14], and prototype laser emitting up to few Watts .
3. Electronic sensors
3.1. Si-Field Effect Gas Sensor
Recent investigations have demonstrated the large potential of monolayer-protected nanoparticles for gas sensing applications . Several studies have been focused on the use of gold-nanoparticle (Au-NP) based gas sensor for the detection of NOx. The central thread at the basis is the proven good affinity of NOx with gold surface, as evidenced by Lu and co-workers .
Thermally evaporated gold thin film has been used for the monitoring of NOx, with little or negligible sensor response towards other interfering gases, such as H2 and CO . A straightforward relationship between the grain size of the gold catalytically layer and the sensing response has been envisaged in recent studies, focused on the size-dependent sensor response of Au-NP based sensors . Au-doped micro-porous silicon layers have been employed for NOx monitoring, showing comparable responses toward both NO2 and NO species . In 2001, Steffes et al. demonstrated the improvement in the sensing behavior of In2O3 towards NO2, after doping with Au-NPs .
Subsequently, Langmuir-Schaeffer deposited thiol encapsulated Au-NP films were proposed as sensing material for the detection of NO2 down to concentration levels of 0.5 ppm; sensing response was proven to be affected by the chemical composition of the capping molecule and the particle size . Furthermore, Parthangal and co-workers assembled an hybrid system comprising nanostructured gold and zinc oxides nanowires, that allowed the detection of both reducing (methanol) and oxidizing (nitrogen dioxide) gasses at high temperatures .
In our laboratories, we have recently employed electrochemically synthesized Au-NPs as catalytically active materials in field-effect transistor (FET) sensors for NOx monitoring. The synthesis of nanostructured gold was carried out according to the so-called Sacrificial Anode Electrolysis (SAE), first reported in 1994 in a seminal study by M.T. Reetz . Au-NPs with a core-shell structure were electrosynthesized in presence of quaternary ammonium chloride dissolved in THF/acetonitrile mixed solution (mixing ratio 1:3). In this process, the ammonium salt acts as both the supporting electrolyte and the NP stabilizer, forming the particle shell and thus giving rise to a stable Au-NPs colloidal solution. In similar systems, it has been proven that the thickness of the NP outer shell approximately corresponds to the length of the surfactant alkyl chains . Before the use as a gate material in FET sensors, Au-NPs were subjected to a thermal treatment at 200 °C for 1 hour, to increase the nanomaterial conductivity and enhance its stability. The material, after heating, was still nanostructured, with a spherical morphology, although a moderate increase in the NP mean core diameter could be detected (up to 50 nm, see Figure 4 for a Scanning Electron Microscopy micrograph, SEM, of annealed Au-NPs) with respect to the pristine materials (5 nm) .
X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) was used for the surface chemical characterization of both pristine and annealed materials. Carbon (92.3 ± 0.3%atomic), nitrogen (3.9 ± 0.3%atomic), and chlorine (2.4 ± 0.3%atomic), were the most abundant elements detected on the surface of the pristine materials, due to the high amount of surfactant present in the electrolytic environment. Gold (0.1 ± 0.1%atomic), and oxygen (1.3 ± 0.3%atomic), were present at lower concentration and the carbon to gold elemental ratio was close to 103. After annealing, a higher surface concentration of gold was detected. Indeed, Au, C, N, atomic concentrations were respectively equal to 1.3 ± 0.1%, 34.6 ± 0.3%, 3.2 ± 0.3%, and the C/Au surface atomic ratio was 102. Moreover, the surface of annealed materials showed a significant abundance of signals due to the silicon substrate (Si and O atomic concentrations were equal to 24.7 ± 0.3% and 36.2 ± 0.3%, respectively), which is in agreement with the morphology shown in Figure 4, outlining the presence of holes in the NP active layer, exposing the surface of the underlying SiO2 substrate.
High-resolution XP spectra of pristine and annealed Au-NPs films are shown in Figure 5. The Au4f region of the pristine material (top-left panel) is composed by two doublets, relevant to two chemical states.
The doublet falling at lower Binding Energy (BE; BEAu4f7/2 = 83.0 ± 0.1 eV) values is attributed to nano-sized Au(0) [31-33]. The second doublet (BEAu4f7/2=84.5 ± 0.1 eV) is attributed to (NR4)AuCl2 species [34-36]. The relative abundance of these chemical environments showed a certain sample-to-sample variation. After the thermal annealing, the Au4f region changed significantly and only the nano-Au(0) doublet (BEAu4f7/2 = 83.7 ± 0.1 eV) was detected. Noteworthy, the slight BE increase observed for this feature is in agreement with the microscopy results, showing a NP size increase upon annealing.
The C1s region of both pristine and annealed nano-films showed the presence of two chemical states, the most abundant one (BE = 284.8 ± 0.1 eV) is due to aliphatic carbon, while the second one (BE = 286.2 ± 0.2 eV) to carbon bound to nitrogen. Both the signals were due to the tetra-alkyl-ammonium salt, used for the Au-NPs preparation. The N1s region was composed by two chemical environments: the first one (BE = 401.8 ± 0.1 eV) is attributed to quaternary nitrogen, while the second one (BE = 399.0 ± 0.2 eV) is attributed to amine species formed by the Hofmann's degradation of the quaternary ammonium during the electrolysis. Sample heating favored further degradation of NR4+ into lower amines (NR3, NHR2, etc.), too, and the latter became the main chemical environment in annealed films.
The capacitive FET sensor devices employed consisted of p-doped Si as the semiconductor with a thermally grown SiO2 as the insulator. The ohmic backside contact consisted of evaporated, annealed Al. Bonding pads of evaporated Cr/Au were then deposited on the insulator. The sensor chip, a ceramic heater, and a Pt-100 element for temperature control, were mounted on a 16-pin holder and electric contacts made from the sensor to the pins with gold bonding.
A fixed volume (0,5 μL) of the colloidal gold solution was drop-cast on the SiO2 surface of the capacitor, partially overlapping the bonding pad and subjected to the thermal heating. Figure 6 shows the schematic diagram of the device.
Then, the 16-pin holders were mounted in aluminum blocks connected to a gas line, with a computer-controlled gas mixing system used to regulate the concentration of gases flowed over the sensor surface. Au-NPs-based gas sensors were exposed to NO or NO2 gases, in a nitrogen/oxygen carrier gas flow.
A typical calibration curve, recorded in the case of NO2 at 175 °C is shown in the panel a) of Figure 7. The sensor showed similar responses in presence of NO. Au-NP sensors were able to detect NOx in a concentration range comprised between 50 and 200 ppm. After the NOx pulse, the sensor was not able to fully recover back to the initial baseline, since some irreversible interaction takes place at the nanoparticle surface between NOx and the nanostructured gold. Similar evidences were reported in several other studies and were explained in light of strong interactions between NOx and gold-based nanoparticles. For instance, these evidences can be found in a study by Filippini et al., who used un-stabilized Au islands , and in a paper by Hanwell et al., who used thiol-capped AuNPs . Furthermore, a high response and recovery time was observed by Steffes et al. with a working temperature below 350 °C in a gold-modified In2O3 film ; similar results were also reported by Penza et al. with WO3 thin films activated by gold .
Moreover, Vitale et al. found spectroscopic evidences of NOx coordination to organometallic Pd(II)/thiol-gold nanoparticles hybrids , while Koel studied the absorption or bonding geometries of NxOy species, i.e., nitrogen dioxide (NO2), dinitrogen trioxide (N2O3), and dinitrogen tetroxide (N2O4), on Au(111) by means of infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy .
Finally, in the above-cited work of Lu and al. a theoretical investigation by means of ab-initio and density functional calculations supported the stability of several gold-NO2 complexes is also reported. .
In the panel b) of Figure 7, a typical experiment aiming to quantify the NO2/interferent response ratio is reported. The sensor was exposed to different gases: CO, H2, NH3, C3H6 and NO2.
It is noteworthy that the system used in Figure 7, although less sensitive to NOx than other ones (see for details Table 2, summarizing the state of art Au-based sensor performances for NOx detection, in terms of detection limit), proved to be extremely selective, as no response at all was detected in case of CO, and hydrocarbons. Small signals were recorded in case of NH3 and H2.
4. III-V Semiconductor Based Sensor
III-V compound semiconductors, such as GaAs, have been chemically functionalized with porphyirins molecules and proposed as a method of for selective detection of NO . Among the various porphyrin compounds, hemin (Fe-porphyrin) has been shown to be ideal for sensing NO due to the strong binding affinity it has to this small molecule [43,44]. Generally, there are a host of porphyrin compounds available with distinctly unique properties, and specificity to various gas molecules, that can be exploited for sensor applications. Of scientific interest is the integration of an organic compound, such as the porphyrin molecules, with an inorganic material and the capability for engineered sensor attributes.
The III-V compounds are especially interesting as transduction platforms for reasons of chemical inertness and wide ranging electronic properties. Detection of NO by way of hemin functionalized to GaAs has been shown to decrease its surface potential, which caused an increase in current throughout the GaAs device . As such, another favorable property of these semiconductors is its sensitivity to adsorbates.
In recent years, the authors have evaluated InAs and AlGaN/GaN HFET structures functionalized with hemin to study chemical bonding state and associated sensor function when exposed to various analytes including NO. The important aspect of n-InAs is its characteristic surface accumulation layer which is modified based on changes in surfaces states due to adsorption of analyte molecules. Similarly, the buried 2-dimensional electron gas in AlGaN/GaN heterojunction field effect transistor (HFET) structures is also coupled to surface charge states and sensitive to modifications in charge carrier concentration upon analyte capture. We have used surface-sensitive techniques in our work, such as spectroscopic ellipsometry, to determine the thickness and/or coverage of the functionalizing layer; x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, to reveal the hemin/semiconductor binding chemistry; and atomic force microscopy (AFM) to evaluate surface topology of the III-V compounds functionalized by hemin . Herein, we present an overview of surface chemistry and sensor function results for hemin functionalized surfaces and its response to NO. The approach we devised for obtaining electrical data for NO gas detection is based on the established four-contact van der Pauw (VDP) method for characterizing sheet resistivity [47, 48]. This methodology differs from current chemical sensors in a variety of ways. One such differentiation is the enhanced accuracy of the four point probe averaging technique reducing the effects due to contact resistance. Another benefit is the relative simplicity of the device and ease of manufacture.
Hemin chloride was acquired from Frontier Scientific, Inc. and 1–2 mM concentrations in dimethylformamide were used. InAs (001) and AlGaN/GaN(0001) surfaces were immersed into the hemin solution for 1–3 h. The samples were subsequently rinsed with a 5% by volume chloroform/hexane solution and dried with N2 gas. The goal of this procedure was to obtain a uniform monolayer of dispersed hemin molecules chemically attached onto the sample surface. The presence and efficacy of the procedure was evaluated by XPS and some typical data are seen in Figure 8. One notable feature of the C 1s core level XPS scan is a peak at ∼ 284 eV observed for the functionalization chemistries, which is attributed to C=N bonding within the porphyrin molecule . Furthermore, for hemin-functionalized InAs surfaces, a strong N1s peak from the hemin molecule seen for the functionalized surface provides evidence for the semiconductor hemin functionalization. Interestingly, this work also revealed chemical bonding of the carboxylic acid ligands on the hemin to the anion of the semiconductor. The AFM images of InAs and GaN functionalized with hemin are shown in Fig. 9. The 500×500 nm2 images show the appearance of grain-like features whose size and density increases with the increase of hemin concentration from 1 to 2 mM. Those features are due to hemin aggregates , which are inactive from the sensing perspective and therefore, their formation has to be avoided. AFM and ellipsometry data have been used to perfect the functionalization chemistry procedure and determined an optimal concentration <1mM to yield homogeneous porphyrinated monolayers with a thickness of 17 Å .
The sheet resistivity response of a hemin functionalized AlGaN/GaN HFET structure is shown in Figure 10. These early, initial results show that the functionalized samples show significant changes in sheet resistivity when exposed to 70 ppm of NO in argon. The plot shows attempts to purge the NO gas from the sensor environment for evaluating reversibility and response times. Upon exposure to NO there is a response with an easily measured change in sheet resistivity. The removal of the sample from the sample cell, exposure to dry nitrogen and then reinsertion into the cell did decrease the sheet resistivity to near its initial value. The re-exposure of the structure to NO again changed the sheet resistivity to near its previous NO exposed value. The resistivity response of functionalized InAs to NO and NO2 is shown in Figure 11 in terms of the normalized sheet resistivity response ((Rsh – R0)/R0). The graphic depicts increasing levels of both gases exposed to the sensor followed by decreasing levels of NO and NO2 (10 to 80 ppm).
The resistivity response of porphyrinated InAs to NO and NO2 generally shows an exponential increase with analyte exposure and decrease with diminishing concentrations, eventually reaching a constant level. This exponential behavior is attributed to Langmuir adsorption kinetics common in semiconductors with responsive surface space-charge regions . Adsorption of NO by the porphyrin molecule tethered to the III-V semiconductor causes conductivity changes through polarization induced bond formation or through van der Waals interaction leading to valence band-bending and/or charge transfer. The InAs surface accumulation layer, with its Fermi level above the conduction band minimum (CBM) balances its highly mobile free-electron concentration with positive surface states . During the adsorption of NO and NO2, the space charge region at the InAs surface is affected and has a direct impact on the conductivity change because as the electrons are depleted from the accumulation layer .
Strict emission regulations and deeper environmental awareness have led to intense research into emissions reduction by various engine manufacturers and research institutes. Under these circumstances, NOx detection is becoming a key aspect, and several sensing and transduction mechanisms have been investigated in the recent literature. In the present study, quantum cascade laser based photoacoustic (QCL-PA) detectors, gold nanoparticle-based field-effect transistor sensors (Au-NP-FET) and functionalized III-V semiconductor based devices have been developed, characterized and explored, in terms of sensitivity and selectivity. In Table 3 the sensing properties of the reported NOx sensors have been summarized and compared with commercial YSZ lambda gauges.
The QCL-based PA sensor consists of an amplitude modulated QCL, a PA cell, and a signal acquisition and processing equipment. A resonant configuration of the PA cell, excited in its first longitudinal mode, has been chosen in order to increase the sensitivity, with a detection limit of 450 ppb (SNR =3). The actual device scheme makes the reported PA sensor more suitable for stationary exhaust gas testing than for on-line applications. Future developments will be the implementation in the device scheme of: i) a QC laser operating at room temperature in continuous mode, in order to avoid the thermal chirping of pulsed operation, thus increasing the selectivity; ii) optical microphone, characterized by high sensibility (5 V/Pa) to minimize the electromagnetic noise; iii) fiber coupling with collimating system between the QC laser and the PA cell to take rid of any optical alignment issue and thus obtaining a more compact, robust and portable PA sensor.
Metal Insulator Semiconductor field effect devices used as gas sensors can be of different types: transistors, Schottky diodes or capacitors, with transistors being preferred for commercial devices. The gas sensing principle for field effect sensors is based on molecules adsorbing and dissociating on a catalytically active gate material on the sensor. These interactions create a change in the electric charges on the semiconductor surface, which in turn results in a shift in the sensor output voltage.
The interactions of the gas molecules with the gate material depend on the operating temperature and the morphology and chemical characteristics of the gate material. Electrochemically synthesized gold-nanoparticles, were used as catalytically active materials in field-effect transistor (FET) sensors capable to monitor NOx in the concentration range comprised between 50 and 200 parts per million. The use of nanostructured films as gate material has the potential to give sensors with increased sensitivity, and faster response and recovery due to the larger surface area available for interaction with the gas molecules, as compared to conventional thin film sensing layers. These sensors displayed an appreciable selectivity towards NOx, providing small responses to NH3 and H2 and not responding at all to CO and C3H6.
Reliable NO sensor could be fabricated with a porphyrin as the functional group and a GaN-based HFET as the semiconductor material. Among the various porphirins, hemin was proposed for the detection of NO because of its chemical affinity, affording for a preferential binding to NO, when exposed to a mixture of gases such as NO, O2, and CO. The reported sensing results represent initial data for porphyrinated III-V semiconductor based sensors and show (i) unambiguous response to NO and NO2, (ii) proof of Langmuir –type adsorption operative in the sensor function, and (iii) the reversibility and sensitivity of the sensors. Analyte selectivity experiments are underway, but our proof-of-concept devices showed obvious selectivity to NO,compared to O2, CO2, N2, using hemin porphyrin. We have to underlined that InAs and AlGaN/GaN porphyrins functionalized sensors represent completely new systems, that is no previous study on this type of systems have been reported so far. Only GaAs functionalized with hemin based sensor have been reported in literatore as NO sensor. And even in that case the system was neither optimized from functionalization or mechanism point of views.
Further studies are in progress for the optimization of the InAs and AlGaN/GaN porphyrins sensors with respect to sensitivity and selectivity. Nevertheless, since their novelty and promising results they are worth of consideration.
We acknowledge partial financial support from Regione Puglia – Project DM01 related with the Apulian Technological District on Mechatronics – MEDIS.
References and Notes
- National Ambient Air Quality Standards. Available online: http://www.epa.gov/air/criteria.html . Accessed January, 2009.
- Transport & Environment. Available online: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/air/transport/-road.htm . Accessed January, 2009.
- Menil, F.; Coillard, V.; Lucat, C. Critical review of nitrogen monoxide sensors for exhaust gases of lean burn engines. Sens. Actuat. B 2000, 67, 1–23.
- Fleming, W.J. Overview of the automotive sensors. IEEE Sens. J. 2001, 1, 296–308.
- Riegel, J.; Neumann, H.; Wiedenmann, H.M. Exhaust gas sensors for automotive emission control. Solid State Ionics 2002, 152, 783–800.
- Twigg, M.V. Critical topics in exhaust gas aftertreatment. Platinum Metal. Rev. 2003. 47, 1, 15–19.
- Persaud, K.C. Polymers for chemical sensing. Mater. Today 2005, 8, 38–44.
- Wilson, D.M.; Hoyt, S.; Janata, J.; Booksh, K.; Obando, L. Chemical sensors for portable hand-held field instruments. IEEE Sens. J. 2001, 1, 256–274.
- Janata, J.; Josowicz, M. Conducting polymers in electronic chemical sensors. Nature 2003, 2, 19–24.
- Tittel, F.K.; Richter, D.; Fried, A. Mid-Infrared laser applications in spectroscopy. In Solid State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources; Sorokina, I.T., Vodopyanov, K.L., Eds.; Springer Verlag: New York, NY, USA, 2003; Volume 89, pp. 445–510.
- Berden, G.; Peeters, R.; Meijer, G. Cavity ring-down spectroscopy: Experimental schemes and applications. Int. Rev. Phys. Chem. 2000, 19, 565–607.
- Troccoli, M.; Diehl, L.; Bour, D.P.; Corzine, S.W.; Yu, N.; Wang, C.Y.; Belkin, M.A.; Höfler, G.; Lewicki, R.; Wysocki, G.; Tittel, F.K.; Capasso, F. High-performance quantum cascade lasers grown by metal-organic vapor phase epitaxy and their applications to trace gas sensing. J. Lightwave Thec. 2008, 26, 3534–3555.
- DFB CW Room-Temperature lasers. January 2009. Available online: http://www.alpeslasers.ch.
- Tunable Mid-IR External Cavity Lasers. January 2009. Available online: http://www.daylightsolutions.com.
- Yu, J.S.; Slivken, S.; Evans, A.; Darvish, S.R.; Nguyen, J.; Razeghi, M. High-power λ ∼ 9.5 μm quantum-cascade lasers operating above room temperature in continuous-wave mode. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2006, 88, 091113–091115.
- Elia, A.; Lugarà, P.M.; Giancaspro, C. Photoacoustic detection of nitric oxide by use of a quantum cascade laser. Opt. Lett. 2005, 30, 988–990.
- Kosterev, A.A.; Bakhirkin, Y.A.; Tittel, F.K. Ultrasensitive gas detection by quartz-enhanced photoacoustic spectroscopy in the fundamental molecular absorption bands region. Appl. Phys. B 2005, 80, 133–138.
- Lima, J.P.; Vargas, H.; Miklós, A.; Angelmahr, M.; Hess, P. Photoacoustic detection of NO2 and N2O using quantum cascade lasers. Appl. Phys. B 2006, 85, 279–284.
- Pushkarsky, M.; Tsekoun, A.; Dunayevskiy, I.G.; Go, R.; Patel, C.K.N. Sub-parts-per-billion level detection of NO2 using room-temperature quantum cascade lasers. PNAS 2006, 103, 10846–10849.
- Hanwell, M.D.; Heriot, S.Y.; Richardson, T.H.; Cowlam, N.; Ross, I.M. Gas and vapour sensing characteristics of Langmuir-Schaeffer thiol encapsulated gold nanoparticle thin films. Coll. Surf. A 2006, 284, 379–383.
- Lu, X.; Xu, X.; Wang, N.; Zhang, Q. Bonding of NO2 to the Au Atom and Au(111) Surface: A Quantum Chemical Study. J. Phys. Chem A 1999, 103. 10969 and ref. therein.
- Filippini, D.; Fraigi, L.; Aragon, R.; Weimar, U. Thick film Au-gate field-effect devices sensitive to NO2. Sens. Actuat. B 2002, 81, 296–300.
- Han, L.; Daniel, D.R.; Mayer, M.M.; Zhang, C.J. Core-Shell Nanostructured Nanoparticle Films as Chemically Sensitive Interfaces. Anal. Chem. 2001, 73, 4441–4449.
- Baratto, C.; Sberveglieri, G.; Comini, E.; Faglia, G.; Benussi, G.; La Ferrara, V.; Quercia, L.; Di Francia, G.; Guidi, V.; Vincenti, D.; Boscarino, D.; Rigato, V. Gold-catalysed porous silicon for NOx sensing. Sens. Actuat. B 2000, 68, 74–80.
- Steffes, H.; Imawan, C.; Solzbacher, F.; Obermeier, E. Enhancement of NO2 sensing properties of In2O3-based thin films using an Au or Ti surface modification. Sens. Actuat. B 2001, 78, 106–112.
- Perez-Luna, V.H.; Aslan, K.; Betala, P.; Pravin, C. Colloidal Gold. In Encyclopedia of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology; Nalwa, H.S., Ed.; American Scientific Publishers: Valencia, CA, USA, 2004; Volume 2, pp. 27–49.
- Parthangal, P.M.; Cavicchi, R.E.; Zachariah, M.R. A universal approach to electrically connecting nanowire arrays using nanoparticles – application to a novel gas sensor architecture. Nanotechnology 2006, 17, 3786–3790.
- Reetz, M.T.; Helbig, W. Size-Selective Synthesis of Nanostructured Transition Metal Clusters. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1994, 116, 7401–7402.
- Reetz, M.T.; Helbig, W.; Quaiser, S.A.; Stimming, U.; Breuer, N.; Vogel, R. Visualization of surfactants on nanostructured palladium clusters by a combination of STM and high-resolution TEM. Science 1995, 267, 367–369.
- Ieva, E.; Buchholt, K.; Colaianni, L.; Cioffi, N.; Sabbatini, L.; Capitani, G.C.; Lloyd Spetz, A.; Käll, P.O.; Torsi, L. Au nanoparticles as gate material for NOx field effect capacitive gas sensors. Sens. Lett. 2008, 6, 577–584.
- Moulder, J.F.; Stickle, W.F.; Sobol, P.E.; Bomben, K.D. Handbook of X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy; Perkin-Elmer Corporation: Eden Praire, MN, USA, 1992.
- Radnik, J.; Mohr, C.; Claus, P. On the origin of binding energy shifts of core levels of supported gold nanoparticles and dependence of pretreatment and material synthesis. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2003, 5, 172–176.
- Balamurugan, B.; Maruyama, T. Evidence of an enhanced interband absorption in Au nanoparticles: Size-dependent electronic structure and optical properties. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2005, 87, 143105.
- Vorobyova, S.A.; Sobal, N.S.; Lesnikovich, A.I. Colloidal gold, prepared by interphase reduction. Coll. Surf. A 2001, 176, 273–283.
- Kitagawa, H.; Kojima, N.; Nakajiama, H.J. Studies of mixed-valence states in three-dimensional halogen-bridged gold compounds, Cs2AuIAuIIIX6, (X = Cl, Br or I). Part 2. X-Ray photoelectron spectroscopic study. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1991, 61, 3121–3125.
- McNeillie, A.; Brown, D.H.; Smith, W.E.; Ginson, M.; Watson, L. Studies of mixed-valence states in three-dimensional halogen-bridged gold compounds, Cs2AuIAuIIIX6, (X = Cl, Br or I). Part 2. X-Ray photoelectron spectroscopic study. J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1980, 4, 767–770.
- Filippini, D.; Wei, T.; Aragon, R.; Weimar, U. New NO2 sensor based on Au gate field effect devices. Sens. Actuat. B 2001, 78, 195–201.
- Steffes, H.; Imawan, C.; Solzbacher, F.; Obermeier, E. Enhancement of NO2 sensing properties of In2O3-based thin film using an Au or Ti surface modification. Sens. Actuat. B 2001, 78, 106–112.
- Penza, M.; Martucci, C.; Cassano, G. NOx gas sensing characteristics of WO3 thin films activated by noble metals (Pd, Pt, Au) layers. Sens. Actuat. B 1998, 50, 52–59.
- Vitale, F.; Vitaliano, R.; Battocchio, C.; Fratoddi, I.; Giannini, C.; Piscopiello, E.; Guagliardi, A.; Cervellino, A.; Polzonetti, G.; Russo, M.V.; Tapfer, L. Synthesis and microstructural investigations of organometallic Pd(II) thiol-gold nanoparticles hybrids. Nanoscale Res. Lett. 2008, 3, 461–467.
- Wang, J; Koel, B. RAS Studies of NO2, N2O3, and N2O4 adsorbed on Au(111) surfaces and reactions with coadsorbed H2O. J. Phys.Chem A 1999, 102, 8573–8579.
- Wu, D.G.; Cahen, D.; Graf, P.; Naaman, R.; Nitzan, A.; Shvarts, D. Direct detection of low-concentration no in physiological solutions by a new gaas-based sensor. Chem. Eur. J. 2001, 7, 1743–1749.
- Feelisch, M.; Stamler, J.S. Methods in Nitric Oxide Research; Wiley: New York, NY, USA, 1996; pp. 5–115.
- Rovira, C.; Kunc, K.; Hutter, J.; Ballone, P.; Parrinello, M. Bond characterization of chromium-fischer carbene complexes: A combined study of experiment and theory. J. Phys. Chem. A 1997, 101, 8914–8925.
- Bell, G.R.; Jones, T.S.; McConville, C.F. Accumulation layer profiles at InAs polar surfaces. Appl. Phys. Lett. 1997, 71, 3688–3690.
- Ibbetson, J.P.; Fini, P.T.; Ness, K.D.; DenBaars, S.P.; Speck, J.S.; Mishra, U.K. Polarization effects, surface states, and the source of electrons in AlGaN/GaN heterostructure field effect transistors. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2000, 77, 250–252.
- Garcia, M.A.; Losurdo, M.; Wolter, S.D.; Kim, T.H.; Lampert, W.V.; Bonaventura, J.; Bruno, G.; Giangregorio, M.; Brown, A. Functionalization and characterization of InAs and InP surfaces with hemin. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 2007, 25, 1504–1508.
- Uhlrich, J.; Garcia, M.; Wolter, S.; Brown, A.S.; Kuech, T.F. Interfacial chemistry and energy band line-up of pentacene with the GaN (0001) surface. J. Cryst. Growth 2007, 300, 204–211.
- Garcia, M.A.; Losurdo, M.; Wolter, S.D.; Lampert, W.V.; Bonaventura, J.; Bruno, G.; Yi, C.; Brown, A.S. Comparison of functionalized III – V semiconductor response for nitric oxide. Sens. Lett. 2008, 6, 627–634.
- Karweik, D.H.; Winograd, N. Nitrogen charge distributions in free-base porphyrins, metalloporphyrins, and their reduced analogs observed by x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Inorg. Chem. 1976, 15, 2336–2342.
- Okada, S.; Segawa, H. Substituent-control exciton in J-aggregates of protonated water-insoluble porphyrins. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2003, 125, 2792–2796.
- Kupriyanov, L.Y. Semiconductor Sensors in Physico-Chemical Studies; Elsevier: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1996; pp. 135–190.
- Olsson, L.Ö.; Andersson, C.B.M.; Håkansson, M.C.; Kanski, J.; Ilver, L.; Karlsson, U.O. Charge Accumulation at InAs surfaces. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1996, 76, 3626–3630.
- Tsui, D.C. Electron-tunneling studies of a quantized surface accumulation layer. Phys. Rev. B 1971, 4, 4438–4449.
|Table 1. State of the art of optical spectroscopic detection of NOx by compact PA spectroscopy.|
|Reference||Chemicals||Laser source||Detection limit at SNR = 3 (ppbv)||Normalized detection limit (ppbv · W)|
|Elia et al. ||NO||Pulsed QCL5.3 μm Room temperature||450||0.9|
|Kosterev et al. ||N2O||cw QCL4.55 μm Liquid N2 cooled||12||1.2|
|Lima et al. ||N2O, NO2||Pulsed QCLs6.2 μm; 8 μm Room temperature||240||1.2|
|Pushkarsky et al. ||NO2||cw QCL (external grating cavity)6.3 μm Room temperature||1.5||0.45|
|Table 2. State of art Au-NPs based sensor performances for NOx detection.|
|Reference||Chemicals||Catalytically active material||Detection limit|
|Ieva et al. ||NO, NO2||Core-shell Au-NPs stabilized by tetraalkylammonium chloride||50 ppm @175 °C|
|Hanwell et al. ||NO2||Core-shell Au-NPs functionalised by 4-methylbenzenethiol, 1-hexanethiol or 1-dodecanethiol||0.5 ppm @22 °C|
|Filippini et al  D. Filippini, L. Fraigi, R. Aragon, U.Weimar, Thick film Au-gate field-effect devices sensitive to NO2, Sensors and Actuators B 81 (2002) 296-300.||NO2||Thermally evaporated gold thin film||15 ppm @180 °C|
|Baratto et al. ||NO, NO2||Au-doped micro-porous silicon layers||5 ppm @20 °C|
|Steffes et al. ||NO2||Au-NPs modified RF-sputtered In2O3 film||10 ppm @400 °C|
|Table 3. Detection limit and selectivity values of QCL-based PA sensors, Au-NPs FETs, Hemin-GaN HFETs and commercial YSZ lambda gauges.|
|Detection limit (ppm)||Selectivity|
|QCL-based PA sensor||0.45||HC, CO2, H2O, NO2, N2O, SOx|
|Au-NPs FET||50||NH3, H2, CO and C3H6.|
|Hemin-GaN HFET||4||O2, CO2, N2|
|YSZ lambda gauges||50||low|
© 2009 by the authors; licensee Molecular Diversity Preservation International, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).