- freely available
Sensors 2013, 13(5), 5923-5936; doi:10.3390/s130505923
Published: 10 May 2013
Abstract: This paper presents an innovative access control system, based on human detection and path analysis, to reduce false automatic door system actions while increasing the added values for security applications. The proposed system can first identify a person from the scene, and track his trajectory to predict his intention for accessing the entrance, and finally activate the door accordingly. The experimental results show that the proposed system has the advantages of high precision, safety, reliability, and can be responsive to demands, while preserving the benefits of being low cost and high added value.
Automatic entrance/exit door control is widely used in public places such as grocery stores, businesses, transportation stations, airports, and wholesale department stores to eliminate the need of manually opening and closing actions. Contemporary sensor-based automatic door control technologies include infrared, ultrasonic/radio, or other wireless sensing methods. The first can be further divided into active and passive approaches. The active process emits infrared signals from the controller and captures the reflected signals to determine if there is any object close to the door. This approach is accurate and capable of identifying the position and the speed of the object but its high cost has made it less popular. The passive approach detects the infrared signals radiated by people and is the most widely used for being simple, effective, and low cost. The ultrasonic/radio approach, on the other hand, emits ultrasonic or radio waves to scan the environment and analyzes the returned signals for door access control.
Although these techniques are all successful in detecting objects, they are not capable of understanding the type and the intention of the objects. For instance, a puppy or a passing pedestrian may accidentally trigger the door and cause a false opening action. Frequent false action is not only annoying, and results in air conditioning energy waste, but also reduces equipment lifetime. This calls for the need of an automatic door control system based on the detection and intention analysis of people.
In this paper, door control is based on the confirmation that the detected object is indeed a human and the corresponding movement trajectory also indicates that he/she has the intention to go through the entrance. Furthermore, an infrared function has been added to prevent people from being trapped by the door before they leave the passage. In addition, the captured images can also be saved for other applications such as customer analysis and crime investigation.
This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 describes the system design concept and related theoretical basis. The corresponding hardware implementation architecture and the experimental results, as well as the performance analysis and discussions, on various field tests are described in Section 3. Finally, the conclusion and future work are made in the last section.
2. Design Concept and Principal Theory
The proposed innovative door control system is mainly based on human detection and intention analysis. The first part involves face detection or contour detection that identifies whether the detected object is a person, while the latter includes trajectory tracking and statistical analysis for intention estimation. A flowchart of the control procedures is shown in Figure 1.
It is known that face detection with reasonable detection rates had been well developed in the literature and has the closest relevance to human characteristics, thus is good for people identification. In short, once a person is detected in the region of interest (ROI), the trajectory of his face can be tracked and then analyzed by a statistical analyzer to calculate the corresponding cumulative probability, and will be used as the estimation of the intention.
On the other hand, in the door-closing procedure of Figure 1, the door is closed if no object is detected in the passage on both sides of the door. Overall, processes of the state transition, human detection, intention analysis, and the theoretical performance evaluation are described in the following subsections.
2.1. State Transition
The state diagram of the proposed accessing control system, which includes opening and closing actions, is depicted in Figure 2. The door open process identifies the detect targets as human by face/contour detection, and calculate the door access intention probability, called Paccess, by analyzing the corresponding trajectory. Once the Paccess is greater than a threshold thPT, the door is opened accordingly. On the other hand, an infrared sensor is added to make sure that nobody is passing or stayed before door closing, and then activate close action when the entrance/exit is clear for safety.
2.2. Human Detection
In recent years, human detection techniques, especially those implemented by face detection strategies, have been successfully applied to many consumer products such as digital cameras, smart phones, or surveillance systems for detecting people [1,2]. In the proposed system, although both face detection and contour detection are adopted for human identification, the face detection is used as the primary solution and the contour detection based on head and shoulder shape, similar to Reference , is left as the optional solution for the application which has special privacy considerations. Thus, human detection function is represented by face detection instead of contour detection in the following text. Researches of the face detection can be categorized into four types , namely, the knowledge-based, the feature-based, the template matching-based and the appearance-based methods.
In the first method, the face is identified by face features constructed by relative locations and distances of eyes, nose, and mouth . The detection rate is strongly affected by the orientation of the face.
For feature-based approaches, face features are constructed from the statistics of the locations and the distances between the facial organs [6–9]. A face is detected by matching the regions with similar features and skin color information. The detection rate of this method is better than the previous one, but the performance may easily be influenced by the noises, shadows, and lighting conditions .
The template matching methods use predetermined facial template for matching. A face is identified once the Euclidean distance between the ROI and the template is less than a certain threshold value . This approach is easy to implement but is not versatile for various types of face geometry.
In the appearance-based methods, statistical analysis and machine learning techniques are used to find the best features of faces [11–13]. Although longer learning time and more samples are needed in the training process, these methods have high detection rate and low processing time and are more practical in real time applications  hence will be adopted in our study.
The appearance-based methods can be divided into three types: linear/nonlinear projection, neural network, and Gabor filter/Haar-like feature selection. For example, the principal component analysis (PCA) , linear discriminate analysis (LDA) , and independent component analysis (ICA)  are popular projection based methods in which features extracted from face images are projected into a lower dimensional feature space where the most significant feature vectors are selected. Thereafter, an input sample vector with distance (e.g., Euclidean distance) shorter than a given threshold will be determined as a face image. Basically, performance of this type depends mainly on appropriate distance measurement. In contrast to the projection scheme, the neural network scheme uses huge face image samples for training (such as back propagation network), and then uses the trained network as classifier to detect human faces in the input image .
The Gabor filter method constructs a Gabor feature mask from input face sample images and uses it as face discrimination criterion. Although it has high detection rate and little influence by background illumination, the high computation complexity makes it be less practical . Viola et al. proposed an Adaboost structure to overcome this drawback . They use a Haar-like mask to train the face database, and determine the spatial feature masks of the face as weak classifiers. These weak classifiers are further cascaded (boosting) as a strong classifier that becomes a good face detector. Although the training process is time consuming, the Adaboost scheme is high in both detection rate and detection speed than neural network approach [12–14] thus is much practical for implementation in embedded system hence is used in the proposed system.
2.3. Intention Analysis
The intention analysis also includes two parts: trajectory tracking and estimation of the probability to access the door. The trajectory tracking is realized by comparing the overlapping area of the face images at two consecutive time instants against a threshold value. After that, people's intention of accessing the door is estimated by analyzing the probability distribution of movement in both vertical and horizontal directions. The trajectories of movement in different directions from different locations are recorded first to establish the distribution of ROI. This probability value is then used to calculate the corresponding cumulative density function corresponding to the trajectory to determine whether or not the person has intention to access the door.
2.3.1. Face Tracking via Spatial-Temporal Property
For the commonly used frame rate greater than 15 frames/s, the overlapped part of the two face blocks at two consecutive time instants along the trajectories to the door would be large and the displacement between the block centers and is assumed to be small. Thus, algorithm 1 is used to filter out the persons who seems having no intention to access the door.
where and thd is a given threshold value which is assigned to be the width of a nominal human face Wt-1 in our research as shown in Figure 3.
2.3.2. Intention Analysis by Trajectory Statistics
If a person within the ROI has intention to access the door, either the trajectory is characterized by continuous movement toward it or the person's face persists in the ROI for a certain period of time. Thus, the intention can be modeled by first recording the 2D trajectories in front of the door then taking projections along the directions vertical and parallel (or horizontal) to the door and finally conducting curve fitting by appropriate probability density functions (pdf) for the projection curves.
A set of field recorded trajectories approaching the door is shown in Figure 4(a). Note that a person with the intention to access the door will move toward the door, the closer to the door the higher probability that the target has intention to access the door.
Vertical and horizontal projections are conducted to obtain the corresponding 1D histograms sv and sh for xc and yc respectively, and is indicated by the blue lines in Figure 4(b,c).
Note that the projection sv looks like a normal distribution while sh is similar to a non-central Chi-square-distribution as indicated by the red dotted lines in Figure 4(b,c). Thus, we have:
It is assumed, in this paper, that we have μ = 0.5 at the center point of the entrance image. It seems once a person has intention to go through the entrance, the moving trajectory is getting together toward the entrance. Thus, the width of sv increases (it means the variance σ2 of sv, increase also) in proportion to the size of door (DS). On the other hand, parameter λ of sh also increases when D, the distance between a pedestrian to the entrance, get increase. That is, σ2 and λ can be obtained by:
The associated joint probability p(xc, yc) is evaluated by means of the inclusion-exclusion principle  given in Equation (3), based on which a 3D probability table (PT) is constructed to simplify the computation as shown in Figure 4(d) for a nominal image of size 320 × 240:
To determine whether or not a person has intention to go through the specific entrance/exit we use a sequence of T images after a human face is detected in the ROI and calculate the probability of the person's intention to access the door Paccess using Equation (4):
If the face stays long enough during the time interval T, the value of Paccess will be high. An average value μPT of the joint pdf is adopted as the threshold μPT, and is defined as:
It is observed that if one go through the entrance, the accumulated probability of his trajectory in PT region (the black dotted line in Figure 4(d)) will be greater than μPT within T interval. Therefore, μPT is used, in this paper, as the threshold thPT to determine whether one has intention to go through the entrance or not. That is, if Paccess is greater than μPT, the “opening” command is activated.
2.4. System Performance Evaluation
The performance of the proposed system is evaluated by both detection rate and false rate FRtot. In this paper, the face detection is implemented, based on the Viola method , by a 10-layers cascade boosting structure. In each layer, the face detection rate is set to be greater than 0.99 at training stage. Thus, the theoretical overall face detection rate is about 0.9910 ≈ 0.9. On the other hand, the false rate FRtot can be defined by FRtot = FAR + FRR, where FAR and FRR are the false acceptance rate and the false rejection rate, respectively. In general, since a non-human face being erroneously identified as a human face will be filtered in the subsequent tracking procedure hence will not cause any false activation of the door, the FAR can be ignored and the only false rate that needs attention is FRR, or FRtot = FRR. From the experiments, it is observed that the rate of falsely activating the door is below 2 in one million times, compared with the traditional systems that assume nearly 1 out of 5 or 20% of false activation.
2.4.1. False Rejection Rate of the System
The proposed method accumulates the number of the same face images detected during time interval T to determine the intention of the target and decides positively if it is greater than thPT. Thus, the more the face images detected inside the dotted region (Figure 4(d)), the higher the probability that the target has intention to access the door and likewise for the miss. In other words, the more the missed face images, the higher the FRR. Thus, FRR can be formulated by Equation (6):
3. Experiment Results and Discussion
The proposed system can determine the user's intention and provide access to a door by detecting his position and tracking his trajectories of movement in the image sequence. To implement the system, a DSP based multimedia module, TI DM368, is selected as the hardware platform. The algorithms developed were programmed in C and executed under the Linux platform. The specifications of hardware and software are as follows: an ARM9 CPU with a speed of 900 MHz with embedded processing algorithm is used. The system prototype and the DSP platform board are shown in Figure 5(a,b). The image sensor resolution is 500 M and the test image size is 320 × 240. The other installation parameters are described as follows: the camera is installed on a wall at 2.2 m high and 30° tilt. The size of ROI is 3.11 m (width) and 4.11 m (distance to door) respectively, as shown in Figure 5(c). The width of door is 1.6 m. Thus, according to Equation 2(a,b), σ2 of sv and λ of sh can be calculated as σ2 = 0.26 and λ = 4.11, respectively. The infrared signal scanning in ROI is indicated by the red area, as shown in Figure 5(d). The scanning width and distance are 3.11 m and 1.28 m (red line to door), respectively.
In the case of single person, it is observed in Figure 6(b–d), that the cumulative probability increases if a person continues walking toward the entrance so the face is detected. Once the cumulative probability is greater than the threshold value, the opening action is triggered as shown in Figure 6(d). In the multi-persons case of Figure 7, cumulative probability values for all detected faces are calculated independently. Thus, as long as one of the cumulative probability values exceeds the threshold, the door will be opened as shown in Figure 7(d). Finally, in Figure 8, it is observed that although a person is detected in ROI, the door is not opened since the person is just passing by the entrance, thus the cumulative probability does not exceed the threshold value. To evaluate the performance of the proposed system, five different scenes including one lab and four business places are used, while the test condition includes day, night, indoor, and outdoor conditions. The four business places include two shops, one restaurant, and an office. Moreover, to illustrate the effect of the system, three of these places are recorded by a side view camera set and are shown in Figures 9 and 10.
By observing the process from the embedded camera at the lab and restaurant places which are shown in Figures 6, 7 and 8, it is also observed from Figures 9 and 10 that the door is correctly activated by the pedestrian who has intention to access, it but kept closed while he is just passing by or the image object is not a real person. Interested readers can access the recorded videos  to see the experimental process. The false rate result collected from the above places is presented in Table 1.
It is observed that the face detection function is hardly affected by the following cases such as wearing glasses, mask, hat, etc. The collected data, in 253 trials at five different locations, shows that the correct opening rate within the default 2 s is 0.996 (252/253) while the incorrect action number is only 1. It is noted that although the FAR (0.004) is slightly higher than the theoretically predicted number, for the only one failure case, however, the door is still opened but just delayed for a short time (the response time is 4 s). Moreover, an interesting phenomenon is observed that although some people with access intention are walking dejected/passing with heads down thus no face is detected, finally they stop behind the close-door and look up for something to open the door. These actions, however, reveal their faces which are detected by the camera and finally the opening action is activated after a few seconds delay. Therefore, there exists zero case when a person wanted to enter was rejected and it can reject the false opening actions for people passing, staying, and non-human cases, no matter in the day, night, indoor, or outdoor conditions.
4. Conclusions and Future Works
In this paper, an automatic door control system is implemented on a DSP platform. The system can first identify a target as person by face detection, and then analyze the path trajectory to determine whether the person has intention to access the door or not, thus to control the door accordingly. It is noted that the system has advantages of low false rate (near 0%), high correct activating rate (99.6%), and short response time (within 2 s) from detecting the target, confirming his intention, to activate the door opening. Moreover, via statistical analysis on detected face in consecutive time sequence, case of passing persons with missing face can still be confirmed within 4 s thus to activate the door correctly, as shown in Table 1.
To sum up, the proposed method builds up the statistic model of moving trajectories in ROI first, and the corresponding probability of a face at certain location can be obtained by lookup table. If the average probability of face trajectory is greater than thPT within T period, the person is said to have intention to go through the entrance. That is, region within dotted line as shown in Figure 4(d), whose pdf is greater than thPT, is viewed as key region while determining one's intention. If the face trajectory locates mostly within the key region, the person is said to have intention to go through the entrance. According to Equation (6), if thPT is set to be 0.8 (or 0.2) and T is set by 2 s, the FRtot will become 0.18 (or 6.5 × 10−8). The response time to confirm one's intention will increase when thPT increase, while lower thPT value will result more false opening actions. It is observed, by our experiments, that if thPT is set to be the average of ROI, said μPT, the FRtot is about 6.3 × 10−5 and is suitable for most application cases.
The proposed intelligent control system, compared with traditional ones, not only reduces the false action rate, but offers extra power saving benefits. For example, less false door activation reduces the energy exhaust of air conditioners as well as the door driver. Moreover, combining face recognition as well as behavior analysis algorithm into the built-in camera and DSPs module, it is possible to add disaster or crime prevention functions that thus can be applied to surveillance applications. To sum up, although the cost is somewhat higher than that of traditional systems, the proposed system should be viewed as, instead of an accessing control system only, a general purpose intelligence video surveillance (IVS) system as long as the detection function is replaced according to the related applications, for example, to detect the car, motorcycle, or detect the static object application in home healthcare  or pedestrians in a forbidden region by adopting the corresponding detection function and 3D probability model. Some of the extended functions such as plate detection, pedestrian detection, and flood detection, had been successfully examined in the proposed platform [22,23], while other functions with huge complexity, e.g., fire detection, can also be fulfilled using a similar hardware structure but replacing a faster DSP module. That is, the proposed system is designed not only as an access control system but also a watch dog in front of the entrance, thus, the CP value of the proposed system is much greater than that of the existing systems.
Conflicts of Interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Rahman, M.T.; Kehtarnavaz, N. Real-time face-priority auto focus for digital and cell-phone cameras. IEEE Trans. Consum. Electron. 2008, 54, 1506–1513. [Google Scholar]
- Zuo, F.; With, P. Real-time embedded face recognition for smart home. IEEE Trans. Consum. Electron. 2005, 51, 183–190. [Google Scholar]
- Zeng, C. Robust Head-Shoulder Detection by PCA-Based Multilevel HOG-LBP Detector for People Counting. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Pattern Recognition, Beijing, China, 23–26 August 2010; pp. 2069–2072.
- Yang, M.H.; David, J.K.; Ahuja, N. Detecting faces in image: A survey. IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell. 2002, 24, 34–58. [Google Scholar]
- Yang, G.; Huang, T.S. Human face detection in complex background. Pattern Recognit. 1994, 27, 53–63. [Google Scholar]
- Yow, K.C.; Cipolla, R. Feature-based human face detection. Image Vis. Comput. 1997, 15, 713–735. [Google Scholar]
- Dai, Y.; Nakano, Y. Face-texture model based on SGLD and its application in face detection in a color scene. Pattern Recognit. 1996, 23, 1007–1017. [Google Scholar]
- Mckenna, S.; Gong, S.; Raja, Y. Modeling facial color and identity with Gaussian mixtures. Pattern Recognit. 1998, 31, 1883–1892. [Google Scholar]
- Hsu, R.L.; Abdel-Mottaleb, M.; Jain, A.K. Face detection in color images. IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell. 2002, 24, 696–706. [Google Scholar]
- Lanitis, A.; Yaylor, C.J.; Cootes, T.F. An automatic face identification system using flexible appearance models. Image Vis. Comput. 1995, 13, 393–401. [Google Scholar]
- Rowley, H.A.; Baluja, S.; Kanade, T. Neural network-based face detection. IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell. 1998, 20, 23–38. [Google Scholar]
- Viola, P.; Jones, M.J. Robust real-time face detection. Int. J. Comput. Vis. 2004, 57, 137–154. [Google Scholar]
- Lienhart, R.; Maydt, J. An Extended Set of Haar-Like Features for Rapid Object Detection. Proceeding of 2002 International Conference on Image Processing, New York, NY, USA, 22–25 September 2002; pp. 900–903.
- Zhang, C.; Zhang, Z. A Survey of Recent Advances in Face Detection; MSR-TR-2010-66. Technical report of Microsoft Research: Redmond, WA, USA, June 2010. [Google Scholar]
- Turk, M.; Pentland, A. Eigenfaces for recognition. J. Cogn. Neurosic. 1991, 3, 71–86. [Google Scholar]
- Belhumeur, P.N.; Hespanha, J.P.; Kriegman, D.J. Eigenfaces vs. Fisherfaces: Recognition using class specific linear projection. Comput. Vis. 1996, 1064, 45–58. [Google Scholar]
- Bartlett, M.S.; Movellan, J.R.; Sejnowski, T.J. Face recognition by independent component analysis. IEEE Trans. Neural. Netw. 2002, 13, 1450–1464. [Google Scholar]
- Andrea, F.A.; Michele, N.; Daniel, R.; Gabriele, S. 2D and 3D face recognition: A survey. Pattern Recognit. Lett. 2007, 28, 1885–1906. [Google Scholar]
- Leon-Garcia, A. Probability and Random Processes for Electrical Engineering, 2nd ed.; Addison-Wesley: Boston, MA, USA, 1994; pp. 34–105. [Google Scholar]
- Intelligent Automated Door Control System. Available online: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/63713304/Atuodoor%20control%20system/autodoor_video.rar (accessed on 24 April 2013).
- Lee, Y.-S.; Chung, W.-Y. Visual sensor based abnormal event detection with moving shadow removal in home healthcare applications. Sensors 2012, 12, 573–584. [Google Scholar]
- Yang, J.-C.; Lai, C.-L. Vision Based Fire/Flood Alarm Surveillance System via Robust Detection Strategy Robust Early Fire Detection in Video Surveillance System via Multiple Features Analysis. Proceeding of IEEE International Conference on Instrumentation and Measurement Technology, British Columbia, Canada, 12–14 May 2008; pp. 12–15.
- Chen, J.-H.; Tseng, T.-H.; Lai, Ch.-L.; Hsieh, S.-T. An Intelligent Virtual Fence Security System for the Detection of People Invading. Proceedings of the 2012 9th International Conference on Ubiquitous Intelligence and Computing and 9th International Conference on Autonomic and Trusted Computing, Fukuoka, Japan, 4–7 September 2012; pp. 786–791.
|Table 1. The Experimental Results of False Rate.|
|Results/Location||No. of Persons||Failure Count||Detection Rate|
|Real Test||Electronic materials store (Banqiao city)||52||1||99.5%|
|Wine store (Yingge city)||28||0|
|Office (Yangmei city)||45||0|
|Restaurant (Xindian city)||72||0|
|Lab. Test||Lab. (Banqiao city)||56||0||100%|
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/