1. Introduction

ijms

International Journal of Molecular Sciences

Int. J. Mol. Sci.

1422-0067

Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI)

10.3390/ijms131013150

ijms-13-13150

Article

Construction and Evaluation of Normalized cDNA Libraries Enriched with Full-Length Sequences for Rapid Discovery of New Genes from Sisal (Agave sisalana Perr.) Different Developmental Stages

Zhou

Wen-Zhao

* Zhang

Yan-Mei

Jun-Ying

Jun-Feng

South Subtropical Crops Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Tropical Agricultural Science, Zhanjiang 524091, China; E-Mails: yanmeizhang2002@163.com (Y.-M.Z.); junyinglusisal@163.com (J.-Y.L.); junfeng1467@163.com (J.-F.L.)

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail: wenzhaozou@163.com; Tel.: +86-0759-2859216; Fax: +86-0759-2859124.

2012

12 10 2012

13 10 13150 13168 04 07 2012 25 09 2012 26 09 2012

2012

This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).

To provide a resource of sisal-specific expressed sequence data and facilitate this powerful approach in new gene research, the preparation of normalized cDNA libraries enriched with full-length sequences is necessary. Four libraries were produced with RNA pooled from Agave sisalana multiple tissues to increase efficiency of normalization and maximize the number of independent genes by SMART™ method and the duplex-specific nuclease (DSN). This procedure kept the proportion of full-length cDNAs in the subtracted/normalized libraries and dramatically enhanced the discovery of new genes. Sequencing of 3875 cDNA clones of libraries revealed 3320 unigenes with an average insert length about 1.2 kb, indicating that the non-redundancy of libraries was about 85.7%. These unigene functions were predicted by comparing their sequences to functional domain databases and extensively annotated with Gene Ontology (GO) terms. Comparative analysis of sisal unigenes and other plant genomes revealed that four putative MADS-box genes and knotted-like homeobox (knox) gene were obtained from a total of 1162 full-length transcripts. Furthermore, real-time PCR showed that the characteristics of their transcripts mainly depended on the tight expression regulation of a number of genes during the leaf and flower development. Analysis of individual library sequence data indicated that the pooled-tissue approach was highly effective in discovering new genes and preparing libraries for efficient deep sequencing.

sisal normalization full-length cDNA library knox gene MADS-box gene expression

1. Introduction

As an important economic crop, Agave plants had been exploited and broadly utilized in different fields [1]. The best known modern agave products are tequila and agave sugars as dietary supplements and substitutes for sugar and fats [2,3] or for the production of paper [4]. Recently, some Agave species have been regarded as bioenergy crops [5] because their exploitation for bioenergy production will not divert resources from staple food crop production, as is the case of maize when used for bioenergy production [1]. Because Agave plants have many unique and interesting biological characteristics, they have also attracted the interest of plant physiologists, notably in the field of crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) and their adaptation to arid climates, in addition to extensive studies by taxonomists [6,7]. Among the Agave species, Agave sisalana is one of the most important species in widespread cultivation and application [8].

Despite the current and potential economic importance and research interests, little basic research had been carried out on these species due to a lack of basic genetic knowledge, large genome size estimated at between 2940 and 4704 Mbp of DNA [9], and long life cycle (5–8 years), especially at the genetic and molecular levels. With comparable species such as pineapple [10], only ca. 310 sequences had been deposited for the whole Agave genus, including 82 sequences from Agave tequilana, which were mainly ribosomal genes, transposon-like sequences and chaperones. Although Simpson et al. had constructed A. tequilana cDNA libraries and got some sequence information [1], no large-scale genomic or transcriptomic sequencing data is available in Genbank.

Currently, genetic or breeding studies of intra- and interspecific crosses have been successful [11], but the conventional hybridization was at low efficiencies and high costs in terms of labor, resources and money. In vitro regeneration of most Agave species tested was relatively easy and could be achieved either by indirect organogenesis or through in vitro suspension culture [8,12]. However, the asexual propagation led to vulnerability in adverse environmental conditions or attack by pests and pathogens. Based on these reasons, exploring some functional genes will be critical for improving the physiological characterizes and breeding excellent varieties.

Construction of full-length cDNA library and sequencing of ESTs could help in rapid gene discovery, especially in non-model organisms where no prior sequencing data is available. Unfortunately, conventional cDNA libraries not only need high amounts of starting mRNA (5–100 μg), but also contain a high percentage of 5′ truncated clones due to the premature stop of reverse transcription (RT), especially large mRNAs tending to form secondary structures [13]. For these reasons, SMART™ technology for full-length enriched cDNA is very straightforward and robust and requires only 0.025–1 μg of starting mRNA [14]. This technology utilizes the property of some MMLV reverse transcriptases to add a few C residues at 3′ end of the first strand cDNA, but not at prematurely terminated reverse transcripts [15]. Moreover, the percentage of full-length clones with the SMART technique is much higher compared with other full-length enriching techniques [13,16].

Due to differences in the level of gene expression among various cell types, the construction of a normalized cDNA library is necessary in approximately equal quantities and substantially increasing the efficiency of the search for rare genes. However, most of the available approaches based on the re-association of amplified plasmid libraries are not appropriate for long cDNA normalization [17]. Interestingly, duplex-specific nuclease (DSN) from the hepatopancreas of the Kamchatka crab displays a strong preference for cleaving dsDNA and DNA in DNA-RNA hybrid duplexes compared with ssDNA and RNA, irrespective of sequence length. The use of this enzyme allows us to develop a new, simple and effective method for normalization of cDNA, enriched with full-length sequences [18].

To provide insight into transcription characteristics and rare gene functions involved in different development periods of A. sisalana, the objective of this study was to construct and characterize the normalized full-length cDNA library combining the robust SMART™ technique and DSN method. Sequences were evaluated and annotated to classify different categories. By contrast, MADS-box and Knotted1-like homeobox (KNOX) gene families were contained in our libraries. The MADS-box and knox genes had been demonstrated to regulate various aspects of development in all green plant lineages and play a key role in maintaining a pluripotent cell population, called the shoot apical meristem (SAM) [19–25]. Although only a few studies regarding these potential functional genes have been reported for Agave plants, there were no any references in A. sisalana. Here, we report on the isolation and functional analysis of one putative Asknox and four MADS-box genes positioned into three subclasses from sisal. These studies revealed that they could participate in regulating leaf formation and floral development, and helped us to understand how these proteins influence plant development.

2. Results and Discussion 2.1. Generation of the Full-Length Enriched and Normalized cDNA

By contrast, published protocols did not lead to equal representation among clones of different sizes, maintain the length of long cDNAs after hybridization, or incorporate simultaneous normalization and subtraction of cDNAs [14,15,26]. To avoid those problems related to amplification of libraries, exploring a technique to normalize and subtract cDNA before cloning was necessary. In our strategy, the first strand cDNA synthesis was performed in the presence of the SMART™ RNA oligo in the reaction. And then, the full-length selective step was carried out following cDNA synthesis. Because smaller cDNAs are more preferentially amplified than large cDNAs during PCR [13], more PCR cycles must be done on the large fractions to obtain an equivalent amount of PCR product for cloning. During our experiment operation, 14 cycles were adopted to avoid increasing redundancy and reduce errors introduced by PCR polymerase according to size fraction. By these means, large cDNAs could be amplified as efficiently as smaller ones. As a result, both the first-strand cDNA and the amplified cDNA turned out to be flanked by inverted terminal repeats, which can be applied later for both non-directional and directional cloning of cDNA libraries.

Based on the kinetics of cDNA re-association, DSN normalization differed from the other methods by a separation procedure of the normalized ss-fraction [18], and involved the denaturation and re-association of cDNA with the formation of a normalized ss-fraction and a non-target ds-fraction. In addition, DSN was a thermostable enzyme active at 70 °C, so the degradation of ds-fraction was carried out at the same temperature as the cDNA re-naturation. This helped avoid a nonspecific hybridization of cDNA during the DSN treatment, and the loss of transcripts prone to the formation of secondary structures [17]. This method has been applied to analyze mouse transcriptomes and demonstrated successful performance [27]. Normalization led to a 250-fold decrease in the representation of the high-abundant genes and brought the ca. 65%–70% frequency of full-length sequences [15].

2.2. Characterization of <italic>A. sisalana</italic> cDNA Libraries

To rapidly discover some novel genes related to plant development, four normalized and full-length enriched cDNA libraries were constructed from different developing periods of A. sisalana tissues. The lengths and fullness ratios of cDNA inserts were investigated by PCR to assess the quality of those full-length enriched cDNA libraries [28]. As expected, most of the cDNA insert sizes ranged from 1 to 2 kb with an average length of 1.2 kb from normalized libraries (Figure 1a), which reflected the size distribution of the first-strand cDNAs (Figure 1b). However, no cDNAs longer than 3 kb were found in these samples. BlastX analysis of the sequences revealed that 35% (1162 out of 3320 unigenes) of the clones could potentially encode for full-length genes with an average length of 1.8 kb (Table 1). Redundancy rates were calculated in a clustering analysis of all ESTs generated from the normalized library using the program Megalign (Lasergene, DNAstar, Inc., Madison, WI, USA). In fact, the rate of recovery of unigenes in this study was about 85.6%, which is much higher than the 30% to 40% reported from non-normalized cDNA libraries [29,30]. This normalization will greatly help to enrich the library for rare genes, and increase the rate recovery of unigenes and reduce the cost of sequencing by avoiding redundant clones.

From four normalized and full-length enriched cDNA libraries, 4500 clones were randomly selected from the selection medium and sequenced using M13 reverse primer. Successful sequences were 3875. Those clones containing vector backbone and additional sequences that were added during cDNA synthesis were removed. The sequencing results were compared to genes in the non-redundant (nr) protein database using a BlastX search to determine the fullness ratios of the library (Table 1). Of these 3320 sequences, 2158 (65%) matched known genes, and 67% of the clones of classified known genes were predicted to contain a putative ATG translation initiation codon [13,16]. A total of 3320 putative novel transcripts included a large proportion of singletons (80.64%) and a small percentage of contigs (13.36%), which had no significant hits to the non-redundant (nr) protein databases of the NCBI. As expected, our libraries were abundant in several non-redundant and full-length sequences, which could be used for efficient deep sequencing in order to explore several rare genes.

2.3. Gene Ontology Annotation and Bioinformatics Analysis

In our study, contig assembly was done to remove the redundant ESTs and produce a set of unique, high-fidelity virtual transcripts (unigenes). The partial full-length unigenes were compared to these protein sequences published in the databases using the Blastx program (Table 2). Based on comparation and pfam annotations, A. sisalana unigenes were further annotated for each unigene with Gene Ontology (GO) terms. A total of 3320 unigenes were assigned in the biological process category, molecular function category and cellular component category (Figure 2). Most of the terms in which the E-value showed significance were enriched in our unique sequences. This classification provided information on the percentage of unigenes involved in the signal transduction, anabolism, catabolism, reproduction etc. Based on their function in different cellular compartments and anatomical structures, the majority of the unigenes were grouped under “other intra-cellular components”, “unknown cellular components”, and “other cytoplasmic components”, which accounted for about 63% of the unigenes (Figure 2a).

In contrast to their biological functions, the unigenes were then classified into nine different metabolism processes and an unknown item. The larger part of the unigenes were divided into “other cellular process”, “other biological process”, “other metabolic process” and “unknown biological processes” accounting for 8.1%, 10.8%, 16.9% and 29.1%, respectively (Figure 2b). In addition, a large number of A. sisalana unigenes appeared to be involved in plant molecular functions, such as transporter activity, kinase activity, transferase activity, or nucleotide and protein binding activities (Figure 2c). Of the unique sequences, it was indicated that the normalization and identification of new functional genes from our full-length cDNAs were very efficient.

2.4. Tissue-Specific Gene Expression 2.4.1. <italic>Asknox</italic> Expression Characteristics Related to Organogenesis

Plant leaves develop as flat lateral organs from SAM, and the establishment of polarity along three-dimensional axes (the proximodistal, mediolateral and adaxial-abaxial axes) is crucial for the growth of normal leaves [20], especially for sisal. In our study, a knotted-like homeobox (knox) gene (Asknox, 1074 bp) encoded homeodomain-containing transcription factor was obtained from the early developmental cDNA library of A. sisalana. Homology comparison, AsKNOX protein sequence shares 57% with A. thaliana KNAT2 and KNAT6 (ID: NP850951), 53% identity with Solanum lycopersicum TKN (ID: Q9ZRC0), and 51% with closely-related monocot genes, O. sativa OSH6 (ID: BAA79224). As with other species, AsKNOX possesses all three highly conserved domains typical to the KNOX proteins: the MEINOX domain that is subdivided into KNOX1 and KNOX2 (Figure 3a), the ELK domain and the homeodomain (Figure 3b). AsKNOX also contained a GSE domain between the MEINOX and ELK domains, similar to previous reports [31]. It is therefore reasonable to assume that AsKNOX protein possesses DNA-binding activity via its homeodomain, dimerization activity via its MEINOX domain, a nuclear localization signal via its ELK domain, and a protein degradation signal via its GSE domain [31,32].

A phylogenetic comparison of class I KNOX proteins, including that of A. sisalana, using amino acid sequences covering the MEINOX-HD region, enables the subdivision of the protein family into two main clades, namely Classes Ia and Ib (Figure 3c). The global tree topology reveals that KNOX protein sequences from diverse species positioned AsKNOX with class Ib KNOX proteins. Though monocots and dicots are all found in two subclasses, distinct boundaries can be distinguished between them (Figure 3c). On the basis of these relationships, it can be postulated that at least one duplication in the ancestral class I gene occurred before the monocot-eudicot split, leading to the divergence of class Ia and class Ib groups of genes [33].

To understand transcription characteristics of Asknox, real-time PCR was performed in different development stages of leaf and flower. Asknox transcripts were mainly expressed in the vegetative shoot apex containing the single SAM and also in the developing inflorescence (Figure 4). Interestingly, Asknox was strongly expressed in the apical meristem and at relative low levels in leaf tissues, and could not be detected in grown-up leaves with analogous expression reports of KNOX family genes in other species [20,22]. However, the transcription expression is still detectable in early developing leaves (Figure 4a). It was postulated that Class I Asknox expression might correlate with sisal leaf shape, like simple-leafed species, such as A. thaliana and maize [34,35]. Ten years after knox overexpression was first shown to increase tomato leaf complexity, genetic evidence was provided that KNOX activity was necessary and sufficient for leaflet formation in C. hirsuta [36]. A similar explanation had been offered for the variable leaf phenotypes observed in transgenic tobacco plants constitutively expressing the tobacco konx genes, TKN1 and TKN2 [37]. Loss-of-function and over-expression of knox genes had serious effects on shapes and sizes of leaves. The reason is that KNOX proteins may regulate hormone levels and repress the transcription of the IAA and GA-synthetic genes, and have impressive effects on leaf morphology [38,39]. These results suggested that knox transcription factors drive leaf development in various ways in different species by controlling the temporal action of cellular growth and differentiation pathways during early stages of the leaf.

In addition, Asknox transcripts were also readily detectable in early developing floral buds with high levels in pistil and androecium, but barely detectable in torus and perianth (Figure 4b). Asknox expression was increased 2-fold in developing floral buds with early initiating petal-spur primordial (Figure 4c), and supports the hypothesis that Asknox may also have a role in keeping normal patterning in these tissues. This hypothesis was identified by analysis of transgenic plants in Arabidopsis and strawberry, where defects in flower form, petal abscission, fruit set, and fertility were observed [25]. Thus along with leaf development, Asknox plays a significant role in floral architecture and function, consistent with it relatively high level of expression in these tissues.

2.4.2. Expression Characteristics of <italic>MADS-Box</italic> Gene Family Related to Floral Development

A search for gene sequences in the A. sisalana transcriptome database, four potentially distinct MADS genes (AsMADS-box1, 2, 5 and 6) including the putative complete open reading frames were determined. The alignment analysis showed that AsMADS-box1, 2, 5 and 6 shared with amino acid identities of 90%, 84%, 82% and 91% to MADS-box1 (AEX92976), MADS-box2 (AEX92975), MADS-box5 (AEX92969) and MADS-box6 (AEX92972) from A. tequilana, respectively (Supplementary data, Figure S1). As most plant MADS-box sequences, four homology proteins from A. sisalana fell into the stereotypical type II category on the basis of the full-length amino acid sequences. Further analysis showed that four genes belonged to three subfamilies, such as AGL2, STMADS11 and DEF, respectively (Table 3, Figure 5a). Highly conserved amino-acid consensus sequences were also found in their MADS-box domains (Figure 5b). A coiled-coil structure (K domain) also appeared. In addition, the MADS-box and K domains were separated by a weakly conserved intervening domain (I domain) (data not shown). It had been shown that the I and K domains were involved in protein-protein interactions [40].

Although the MADS-box genes had been extensively investigated and shown to be essential for inflorescence and flower development in many model plants [23,24], there was an infrequent research in A. sisalana. On the basis of protein sequence alignment, AsMADS-box1 and 2 were closely related to SEPALLATA3 (SEP3) and SEPALLATA2 (SEP2) within the E function genes, which were required for the formation of petal, stamen and carpel [19]. Interestingly, in our study, real-time PCR revealed that the parallel expression patterns showed between the AsMADS-box1 and 2, although AsMADS-box1 had more highly expressed levels compared with AsMADS-box2 (Figure 6a, b). In inflorescence tissues, the high levels of expression were observed for MADS-box1 and 2 at the initial stages of bud development and decreased during flower formation; however, no expression was detected in fully developed leaf tissue. These results were similar to SEP-like and OsMADS1-like gene expression patterns in orchid and A. tequilana, which were detected in inflorescences and developing flowers [42,43]. This was predicted that they might encode proteins of redundant functions based on homology analysis with Arabidopsis [44]. The significant fold changes of expression levels between MADS-box1 and 2 of E function genes suggested that MADS-box1 need to be further analyzed in order to demonstrate the role in the floral transition and development in A. sisalana, and may also reflect the diversity in the E group genes in various plant species during evolution.

In addition, interactions between the proteins encoded by the ABC type genes and the SEP-like genes were essential for the correct regulation of flower development. This assumption was further supported by the interaction between SEP and B, C function proteins [45]. For example, AP3 and PI had been shown to regulate petal and stamen development by interacting with SEP1, SEP2, and SEP3 [19,45,46]. This result strongly indicated that E function genes were necessary for the activities of the B and C function genes.

However, MADS-box5 showed no significant differences in expression levels between any flower organs and developmental stages (Figure 6c), because StMADS11-like genes had been shown to play an important role in the vegetative to floral transition as in the case of SVP from A. thaliana that repressed the switch from vegetative to floral growth [47,48]. The svp mutants of A. thaliana flowered earlier due to a reduced vegetative growth phase, and also passed more rapidly during the different stages of vegetative growth [49].

Based on the pattern of MADS-box6 (DEF-like) expression with similar expression profiles to AsMADS-box2 gene, it was conceivable that this gene could also exert some effect on flower formation (Figure 6d). In A. thaliana, heterodimers form between DEF and GLO proteins, which in turn interact with SEP-like proteins to form a functional unit. Similar homodimerization was also found in tulip [50], although the functionality of these complexes in specific floral organs was unclear. Sandoval et al. reported that the A. tequilana DEF-like and GLO-like genes show disproportionate changes in expression levels due to homodimerization formation of DEF-like protein [43]. In A. sisalana, whether the heterodimerization and homodimerization are produced between AsMADS and GLO-like proteins and interact with SEP-like proteins still need to be further investigated.

The data presented here show that MADS factors play different roles in the developmental pathway that finally leads to plant reproduction. Due to the complex genetic background in A. sisalana, how the MADS-box genes regulate the diverse developmental processes ranging from root to flower and fruit development is still further explored using the mutated and transgenic plants. With the gene functions elaborated in some exciting models and the novel genes discovered using the normalized cDNA library, those will considerably contribute to a better understanding of the relationship between functional genes and plant development.

3. Experimental Section 3.1. Plant Materials

Field-grown sisals (Agave sisalana Perr.) were obtained from the Sisal Field Germplasm Bank of the Southern Subtropical Crop Research Institute of CATAS (Guangdong, China). Four development stages of different tissues (SAM, root, stem, flower, and leaf) were randomly sampled from two month seedlings in the greenhouse to one, three, and seven year plants in the field. These sliced tissues of three independent plants were pooled together as one of three replications at each sampling stage. All of the tissues were immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at −80 °C before being analyzed.

3.2. Poly(A<sup>+</sup>) RNA Isolation and First-Strand cDNA Synthesis

Total RNAs isolated from different tissues using Trizol reagent (Life Technologies Inc., Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) were assessed by absorbance at 260 nm and 280 nm and agarose gel electrophoresis (1.5%), respectively. For construction of those full-length enriched cDNA libraries, SMART™ PCR cDNA Synthesis Kit (BD Biosciences Clontech, San Jose, CA, USA) was used for the synthesis of cDNA starting from 0.5 to 1 μg of poly (A⁺) RNA according to the manufacturer’s instruction. The primers were the BD Biosciences oligonucleotides SMART™ Oligo VI and CDS-3M containing the SfiI A and SfiI B recognition sequence, respectively (Supplementary data, Table S1).

3.3. Amplification of cDNA by Long-Distance Polymerase Chain Reaction

To prepare the full-length normalized cDNA, the first strand cDNA was amplified with PCR primer provided in the SMART™ PCR cDNA Synthesis Kit (Clontech). The PCR mixture (50 μL) contained 1 × Advantage 2 Polymerize mix, 1 × Advantage 2 PCR reaction buffer, 200 mM dNTPs, 0.3 mM primer and 3 ng first-strand cDNA. Fourteen PCR cycles (95 °C for 7 s, 65 °C for 20 s, and 72 °C for 3 min) were performed. The samples were used for the DSN normalization and the preparation of cDNA libraries.

3.4. First-Strand cDNA Normalization and Amplification

Upon completion of first-strand cDNA synthesis, the reaction mixture was purified using the Qia Quick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen, Tokyo, Japan), and dissolved in milliQ water to a final cDNA concentration of 100 ng/μL after precipitation with ethanol. The reaction mixture (1.5 μL aliquot, 200 mM Hepes, pH 7.5, 2 M NaCl, and 0.8 mM EDTA) was denatured at 98 °C for 3 min and allowed to hybridize at 70 °C for 5 h. After re-naturation, 5 μL of 2×DSN buffer (100 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.0, 10 mM MgCl₂, and 2 mM dithiothreitol), preliminarily preheated to 70 °C, was added to cDNA samples for 10 min. Then, 0.25 Kunitz units of DSN enzyme (Evrogen, Russia) were added to the reaction mixture for 20 min at 70 °C, and were subsequently inactivated by the addition of 10 μL of 5 mM EDTA.

To amplify the normalized ssDNA fraction after DSN treatment, PCR was carried out in a 50 μL reaction mixture using an advantage 2 PCR kit (BD Biosciences Clontech, United States) containing 2 μL of reaction mixture, 1 × Advantage 2 Polymerize mix (Clontech), 1 × Advantage 2 PCR reaction buffer (Clontech), 200 mM dNTPs and 0.3 mM CapM primer, which corresponds to the external part of the flanking cDNA adapter. To obtain amplified cDNA samples with a concentration of ca. 20 ng/μL, twenty PCR cycles (95 °C for 7 s, 65 °C for 20 s, and 72 °C for 3 min) were performed.

3.5. Construction and Quality Analysis of cDNA Library

Normalized cDNA samples digested by SfiI were cloned into the pDNR-LIB vector (Promega Corp., Madison, WI, USA) with T4 DNA liganse (MBI Ferments Inc., Vilnius, Lithuania), which were used for Escherichia coli (JM109) electro-transformation with the Gene Pulser II system (Bio-Rad company, Richmond, CA, USA) at 1500 V. After shaking for 1 h at 120 rpm and 37 °C, 200 μL of the electroporated cell were spread on Luria-Bertani (LB) agar plate containing 30 μg/mL of chloramphenicol. Frequencies of the corresponding cDNA sequences in the libraries were calculated from the number of positive colonies. For analysis of the insert size distribution, 200 colonies from each library were randomly picked, and were used for PCR with standard M13 primers (Supplementary data, Table 1). The reaction system was followed by denaturation at 94 °C for 10 min, 30 cycles (94 °C for 30 s, 52 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 2 min), and 72 °C 10 min. PCR products were visualized on a 1.2% agarose gel, following ethidium bromide (EB, 0.5 pg/mL) staining, alongside a 1 kb DNA ladder (Takara, Japan).

3.6. Sequence Processing and Analysis

Vector-derived and ambiguous sequences were eliminated using online software (vecscreen) from NCBI. The EST sequences were clustered and assembled into contiguous consensus sequences (contigs) using the program Seqman and Megalign of DNAstar software. The non-redundant sequences were searched against protein databases obtained from NCBI with a search threshold of E < 1.0 × 10⁻⁵. All similarity searches were executed using the BlastN, BlastX, and tBlastX tools. Phylogenetic trees were constructed by the Neighbor-Joining (NJ) method using the NJ algorithm implemented in the Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 5.0. The Blast results were used to obtain further information on the function and motif through the InterPro member databases [51].

3.7. Gene Expression Analysis by Real-Time PCR

Quantitative PCR was performed by using the first strand cDNA as templates on a Lightcycler (Roche Diagnostics), with the Light Cycler Fast Start Reaction Mix MasterPLUS SYBR Green according to the manufacturer’s recommendations. Cycling conditions were as follow: 95 °C for 5 min, 40 cycles at 95 °C for 10 s, 54 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 30 s. Expression of 18 s rRNA was used as an internal control to normalize the amount of mRNA. The data shown represent means of values obtained from three independent biological replicates.

4. Conclusions

Four sisal cDNA libraries enriched with full-length sequences were constructed by uniting SMART™ technique and the duplex-specific nuclease (DSN). Sequencing of 3875 cDNA clones revealed 3320 unigenes (85.7%) with an average insert length about 1.2 kb, which were extensively annotated with Gene Ontology (GO) terms. This DSN normalization greatly helped to enrich the library for rare genes and increase the rate recovery of unigenes. Furthermore, real-time PCR showed that the transcript characteristics of four putative MADS-box genes and one knotted-like homeobox (knox) gene mainly depended on the tight expression regulation of a number of genes during the flower and leaf development, respectively. Comparative analysis revealed that the pooled-tissue approach was highly effective in discovering new genes and preparing libraries for efficient deep sequencing.

Supplementary Materials

Acknowledgments

This research was supported by the earmarked fund for China Agriculture Research System (CARS-19).

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References 1

Simpson

Hernández

A.M.

Juárez

M.J.A.

Sandoval

S.D.

Villarreal

A.S.

Romero

C.C.

Genomic resources and transcriptome mining in Agave tequilana

GCB Bioenergy201132536

10.1111/j.1757-1707.2010.01079.x

Gomez

Tuohy

K.M.

Gibson

G.R.

Klinder

Costabile

In vitro evaluation of the fermentation properties and potential prebiotic activity of Agave fructans

J. Appl. Microbiol200910821142121

19941629

Leach

J.D.

Sobolik

K.D.

High dietary intake of prebiotic inulin-type fructans in the prehistoric Chihuahuan Desert

Br. J. Nutr201010315581561

10.1017/S0007114510000966

20416127

Jaouadi

Msahli

A study of the physical and mechanical properties of paper made from Agave americana L. fibers

Mater. Manuf. Process201126567572

10.1080/10426910903124878

Somerville

Youngs

Taylor

Davis

S.C.

Long

S.P.

Feedstocks for lignocellulosic biofuels

Science2010329790792

10.1126/science.1189268

20705851

Wang

Hechathorn

C.A.

Barua

Joshi

Hamilton

E.W.

Lacroix

J.J.

Effects of elevated CO₂ on the tolerance of photosynthesis to acute heat stress in C₃, C₄, and CAM species

Am. J. Bot200895165176

10.3732/ajb.95.2.165

21632342

Lujan

Lledias

Martinez

L.M.

Barreto

Cassab

G.I.

Nieto-Sotelo

Small heat-shock proteins and leaf cooling capacity account for the unusual heat tolerance of the central spike leaves in Agave tequilana var. Weber

Plant Cell Environ20093217911803

10.1111/j.1365-3040.2009.02035.x

19703117

Nikam

T.D.

Bansude

G.M.

Aneesh Kumar

K.C.

Somatic embryogenesis in sisal (Agave sisalana Perr. ex. Engelm)

Plant Cell Rep200322188194

10.1007/s00299-003-0675-9

12920563

Moreno-Salazar

S.F.

Esqueda

Martinez

Palomino

Nuclear genome size and karyotype of Agave angustifolia and A. rhodacantha from Sonora, Mexico

Rev. Fitotec. Mex2007301323 10

Antony

Taybi

Courbot

Mugford

S.T.

Smith

J.A.

Borland

A.M.

Cloning, localization and expression analysis of vacuolar sugar transporters in the CAM plant Ananas comosus (pineapple)

J. Exp. Bot20085918951908

18408220

Escobar-Guzmán

Zamudio-hernández

Gil-Vega

Simpson

Seed production and gametophyte formation in Agave tequilana and Agave Americana

Bot20088613431353

10.1139/B08-099

Flores-Benitez

Jimenez-Bremont

J.F.

Rosales-Mendoza

Arguello-Astorga

G.R.

Castillo-Collazo

Alpuche-Solis

A.G.

Genetic transformation of Agave salmiana by Agrobacterium tumefaciens and particle bombardment

Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult200791215224

10.1007/s11240-007-9287-3

Wellenreuther

Schupp

The German cDNA Consortium

Poustka

Wiemann

SMART amplification combined with cDNA size fractionation in order to obtain large full-length clones

BMC Genomics2004536

15198809

10.1186/1471-2164-5-36

Zhu

Y.Y.

Machleder

E.M.

Chenchik

Siebert

P.D.

Reverse transcriptase template switching: A SMART approach for full-length cDNA library construction

Biotechniques200130892897

11314272

Bogdanova

E.A.

Shagin

D.A.

Lukyanov

S.A.

Normalization of full-length enriched cDNA

Mol. Biosyst20084205212

10.1039/b715110c

18437263

Sugahara

Carninci

Itoh

Shibata

Konno

Endo

Muramatsu

Hayashizaki

Comparative evaluation of 5′-end-sequence quality of clones in CAP trapper and other full-length-cDNA libraries

Gene200126393102

10.1016/S0378-1119(00)00557-6

11223247

Shagina

Bogdanova

Mamedov

I.Z.

Lebedev

Lukyanov

Shagin

Normalization of genomic DNA using duplex-specific nuclease

Biotechniques201048455459

20569220

10.2144/000113422

Zhulidov

P.A.

Bogdanova

E.A.

Shcheglov

A.S.

Vagner

L.L.

Khaspekov

G.L.

Kozhemyako

V.B.

Matz

M.V.

Meleshkevitch

Moroz

L.L.

Lukyanov

S.A.

Simple cDNA normalization using kamchatka crab duplex-specific nuclease

Nucleic Acids Res200432e37

10.1093/nar/gnh031

14973331

Pelaz

Ditta

G.S.

Baumann

Wisman

Yanofsky

M.F.

B and C floral organ identity functions require SEPALLATA MADS-box genes

Nature2000405200203

10.1038/35012103

10821278

Hake

Smith

Holtan

Magnani

Mele

Ramirez

The role of KNOX genes in plant development

Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol200420125151

10.1146/annurev.cellbio.20.031803.093824

15473837

Bharathan

Goliber

T.E.

Moore

Kessler

Pham

Sinha

N.R.

Homologies in leaf form inferred from KNOXI gene expression during development

Science200229618581860

10.1126/science.1070343

12052958

Hay

Tsiantis

A KNOX family TALE

Curr. Opin. Plant Biol200912593598

10.1016/j.pbi.2009.06.006

19632142

Adamczyk

B.J.

Lehti-Shiu

M.D.

Fernandez

D.E.

The MADS domain factors AGL15 and AGL18 act redundantly as repressors of the floral transition in Arabidopsis

Plant J20075010071019

10.1111/j.1365-313X.2007.03105.x

17521410

Amasino

Floral induction and monocarpic versus polycarpic life histories

Genome Biol200910228

10.1186/gb-2009-10-7-228

19591661

Chatterjee

Bermudez-Lozano

C.L.

Clancy

M.A.

Davis

T.M.

Folta

K.M.

A strawberry KNOX gene regulates leaf, flower and meristem architecture

PLoS One20116e24752e24752

10.1371/journal.pone.0024752

21949748

Carninci

Shibata

Hayatsu

Sugahara

Shibata

Itoh

Konno

Okazaki

Muramatsu

Hayashizaki

Normalization and subtraction of cap-trapper-selected cDNAs to prepare full-length cDNA libraries for rapid discovery of new genes

Genome Res20001016171630

10.1101/gr.145100

11042159

Wells

C.A.

Ravasi

Sultana

Yagi

Carninci

Bono

Faulkner

Okazaki

Quackenbush

Hume

D.A.

Continued discovery of transcriptional units expressed in cells of the mouse mononuclear phagocyte lineage

Genome Res20031313601365

10.1101/gr.1056103

12819134

Wakimoto

B.T.

Doubling the rewards: Testis ESTs for Drosophila gene discovery and spermatogenesis expression profile analysis

Genome Res20001018411842

10.1101/gr.169400

11116081

Sakurai

Plata

Zapata

R.F.

Seki

Salcedo

Toyoda

Ishiwata

Tohme

Sakaki

Shinozaki

Sequencing analysis of 20,000 full-length cDNA clones from cassava reveals lineage specific expansions in gene families related to stress response

BMC Plant Biol2007766

10.1186/1471-2229-7-66

18096061

Wallis

J.G.

Browse

An analysis of expressed sequence tags of developing castor endosperm using a full-length cDNA library

BMC Plant Biol2007742

10.1186/1471-2229-7-42

17672910

Nagasaki

Sakamoto

Sato

Matsuoka

Functional analysis of the conserved domains of a rice KNOX homeodomain protein, OSH15

Plant Cell20011320852098

11549765

Cole

Nolte

Werr

Nuclear import of the transcription factor SHOOT MERISTEMLESS depends on heterodimerization with BLH proteins expressed in discrete sub-domains of the shoot apical meristem of Arabidopsis thaliana

Nucleic Acids Res20063412811292

10.1093/nar/gkl016

16513846

Jouannic

Collin

Vidal

Verdeil

J.L.

Tregear

J.W.

A class I KNOX gene from the palm species Elaeis uineensis (Arecaceae) is associated with meristem function and a distinct mode of leaf dissection

New Phytol2007174551568

10.1111/j.1469-8137.2007.02020.x

17447911

Cary

A.J.

Che

Howell

S.H.

Developmental events and shoot apical meristem gene expression patterns during shoot development in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plant J200232867877

10.1046/j.1365-313X.2002.01479.x

12492830

Zhang

Wong

Meng

Lemaux

P.G.

Similarity of expression patterns of knotted1 and ZmLEC1 during somatic and zygotic embryogenesis in maize (Zea mays L.)

Planta2002215191194

10.1007/s00425-002-0735-3

12029467

Hay

Barkoulas

Tsiantis

ASYMMETRIC LEAVES1 and auxin activities converge to repress BREVIPEDICELLUS expression and promote leaf development in Arabidopsis

Development200613339553961

10.1242/dev.02545

16971475

Shani

Burko

Ben-Yaakov

Berger

Amsellem

Goldshmidt

Sharon

Ori

Stage-specific regulation of Solanum lycopersicum leaf maturation by class 1 KNOTTED1-LIKE HOMEOBOX proteins

Plant Cell20092130783092

10.1105/tpc.109.068148

19820191

Sakamoto

Kamiya

Ueguchi-Tanaka

Iwahori

Matsuoka

KNOX homeodomain protein directly suppresses the expression of a gibberellin biosynthetic gene in the tobacco shoot apical meristem

Genes Dev200115581590

10.1101/gad.867901

11238378

Jasinski

Piazza

Craft

Hay

Woolley

Rieu

Phillips

Hedden

Tsiantis

KNOX action in Arabidopsis is mediated by coordinate regulation of cytokinin and gibberellin activities

Curr. Biol20061515601565 40

Yanofsky

Function and evolution of the plant MADS-box gene family

Nat. Rev. Genet20012186195

10.1038/35056041

11256070

Vandenbussche

Theissen

van de Peer

Gerats

Structural diversification and neo-functionalization during floral MADS-box gene evolution by C-terminal frameshift mutations

Nucleic Acids Res20033144014409

10.1093/nar/gkg642

12888499

Chang

Y.Y.

Chiu

Y.F.

J.W.

Yang

C.H.

Four orchid (Oncidium Gower Ramsey) AP1/AGL9-like MADS Box genes show novel expression patterns and cause different effects on floral transition and formation in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plant and Cell Physiol20095014251438

10.1093/pcp/pcp087

Delgado Sandoval

S.C.

Abraham Juárez

M.J.

Simpson

Agave tequilana MADS genes show novel expression patterns in meristems, developing bulbils and floral organs

Sex. Plant Reprod2012251126

10.1007/s00497-011-0176-x

22012076

Tzeng

T.Y

Hsiao

C.C.

Chi

P.J.

Yang

C.H.

Two lily SEPALLATA-Like genes cause different effects on floral formation and floral transition in Arabidopsis

Plant Physiol200313310911101

10.1104/pp.103.026997

14526112

Honma

Goto

Complexes of MADS-box proteins are sufficient to convert leaves into floral organs

Nature2001409525529

10.1038/35054083

11206550

Theissen

Development of floral organ identity: Stories from the MADS house

Curr. Opin. Plant Biol200147585

10.1016/S1369-5266(00)00139-4

11163172

Lee

J.H.

Yoo

S.J.

Park

S.H.

Hwang

Lee

J.S.

Ahn

J.H.

Role of SVP in the control of flowering time by ambient temperature in Arabidopsis

Genes Dev200721397402

10.1101/gad.1518407

17322399

Michaels

S.D.

Bezerra

I.C.

Amasino

R.M.

FRIGIDA-related genes are required for the winter-annual habit in Arabidopsis

Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA200410132813285

10.1073/pnas.0306778101

14973192

Hartmann

Hohmann

Nettesheim

Wisman

Saedler

Huijser

Molecular cloning of SVP: A negative regulator of the floral transition in Arabidopsis

Plant J20002351360 50

Kanno

Nakada

Akita

Hirai

Class B gene expression and the modified ABC model in nongrass monocots

The Sci. World J20077268279

10.1100/tsw.2007.86

Goujon

McWilliam

Valentin

Squizzato

Paern

Lopez

A new bioinformatics analysis tools framework at EMBL–EBI

Nucleic Acids Res201038W695W699

10.1093/nar/gkq313

20439314

Figures and Tables Figure 1

Features of normalized cDNA libraries enriched with full-length sequences. (a) Insert size distribution in normalized cDNA library; (b) Agarose gel electrophoresis of non-normalized and normalized amplified SMARTTM-prepared cDNA. Lane 1–2, normalized first-strand cDNA; lane 3–4, non-normalized cDNA; lane M, DL2000 ladder (Takara, Japan).

Figure 2

Functional categorization of unigenes with Gene Ontology (GO) terms at The Arabidopsis Information Resource (TAIR). These results in the unigenes were functionally classified under three main functional categories: cellular component (a), molecular function (b) and biological process (c) with respective GO Slim terms.

Figure 3

Sequence alignment and phylogenetic tree of the AsKNOX protein selected relatives from other plant species. (a) Schematic diagram of the AsKNOX protein structure by Position-Specific Iterated Blast; (b) Alignment of the deduced amino acid sequences of AsKNOX and KNOXs from A. thaliana (P46639), Pisum sativum (O82805) and Prunus persica (ABO28750). Identical and conserved amino acid residues were labeled in various colors, respectively. The different functional domains were indicated by black lines above the corresponding sequences. Dashes indicated gaps introduced to optimize the alignment. Sequences were aligned using the CLUSTALX program of DNAman; (c) Relationship tree of AsKNOX and its relatives in the class I KNOX group. The tree was obtained using the neighbor-joining method performed with the amino acid sequence alignment of the region comprising the MEINOX, GSE and HD domains. To assess support for the inferred relationships, 1000 bootstrap samples were generated. Sequences were designated by accession numbers and the name of organisms from the GenBank database. One Class II KNOX protein from M. truncatula was used as outgroup.

Figure 4

Real-time PCR analysis of Asknox gene expression profiles in different leaf and inflorescence development stages. (a) Analysis of the Asknox expression profiles in apical meristem and leaves during different development stages; (b) Analysis of the Asknox expression profiles in different development stages of inflorescence; (c) Analysis of the Asknox expression profiles in different organs of inflorescence; (d) Schematic diagram of different development stages and organs of inflorescence.

Figure 5

Phylogenetic tree and C-terminal domain alignment of the deduced MADS-box protein sequences from A. sisalana. The neighbor-joining tree had been constructed using a representative subset of 58 sequences from available plant MADS-box sequences (a). These 58 sequences have been selected as follows: To assess support for the inferred relationships, 1000 bootstrap replications were generated. Alignment of C-terminal amino acid domains of A. sisalana MADS proteins (b) based on motifs previously identified by Vandenbussche et al. [41]. Sequences are designated by accession numbers and organism names from GenBank database.

Figure 6

Real-time PCR analysis of AsMADS-box gene expression profiles in different tissues and inflorescence development stages. (a) AsMADS-box1 gene expression profiles; (b) AsMADS-box2 gene expression profiles; (c) AsMADS-box5 gene expression profiles; (d) AsMADS-box6 gene expression profiles.

Table 1

Summary of cDNA sisal libraries.

Description	Number
Total number of successful sequences	3875
Unique sequences	3320
5′ end unigenes	2080
3′ end unigenes	2402
Full-length genes	1162
Number of known genes	2158
Unique unknown genes	1162

Table 2

Putative functions assigned to unigenes from sisal normalized libraries.

Library ID a	Functional annotation b	E-value	Accession No.	Organism species
SF1324	Knotted1-like homeobox protein	4 × 10⁻¹¹²	CAB88029	Dendrobium nobile
SL980	NADP-dependent malic enzyme	1 × 10⁻⁹¹	ABR26037	Oryza sativa
SL712	cytochrome P450 like_TBP	3 × 10⁻⁹⁵	BAA10929	Nicotiana tabacum
SL349	ATP synthase subunit beta	6 × 10⁻¹²²	XP003627732	Medicago truncatula
SF1073	unknown protein	2 × 10⁻¹³³	ACU14517	Glycine max
SF1130	MADS-box transcription factor	4 × 10⁻¹⁵⁵	ABC70707	Asparagus virgatus
SL453	chloroplast photosystem	1 × 10⁻³⁷	ACZ54010.1	Wolffia arrhiza
SL324	Sucrose synthase	8 × 10⁻¹⁰⁴	XP003591492	Medicago truncatula
SS239	Disease resistance protein	2 × 10⁻⁴⁵	XP002275269	Vitis vinifera
SS136	UDP-glucosyltransferase	2 × 10⁻⁸⁰	NP001154307	Arabidopsis thaliana
SF201	Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase	3 × 10⁻¹⁸⁰	AFA55129	Agave schottii
SS712	Conserved hypothetical protein	2 × 10⁻¹¹⁰	BAD94036	Arabidopsis thaliana
SL506	Methionyl-tRNA synthetase	4 × 10⁻¹⁸⁹	AAC99620	Oryza sativa
SF321	Sugar transporter	2 × 10⁻⁹⁸	CAA90628	Arabidopsis thaliana
SF603	Poly(A)-binding protein	4 × 10⁻¹¹⁰	CAC01238	plumbaginifolia

: The library ID is indicated by the first letter of the designation: S, sisal and the second letter of the designation: S, stem; L, leaf; F, flower.

: Similarity gene function was conducted using the BLASTX program.

Table 3

Functional prediction of MADS-box genes from A. sisalana compared with Arabidopsis.

Gene name	Orthologous gene a	E-value	Max identity	Gene subfamily	Functional role predicted
MADS-box1	NP_564214 (SEPALLATA 3)	5 × 10⁻¹⁰⁸	67%	AGL2	E function
MADS-box2	NP_186880 (SEPALLATA 2)	1 × 10⁻⁸²	60%	AGL2	E function
MADS-box5	NP_179840 (SVP)	2 × 10⁻⁹⁰	61%	STMADS11	Control of flowering time
MADS-box6	NP_191002 (APETALA 3)	7 × 10⁻⁶⁹	51%	DEF	Class B floral homeotic gene

: The classification was based on the Arabidopsis transcription database [40].